Conditional Current Luffy vs Current Zoro

[Hibari Kyoya]

Apologies if this thread violates some rules, if so feel free to remove it, but I am curious what people's view would be on the following fight,

Combatants: Current Luffy [Post Wano] versus Zoro [Post Wano]
Location: A very large island, no vegetation, just dirt/rocky surface.
Mindset: Both have been brainwashed and will do everything possible to kill the other.
Limitations: Luffy has no Gomu Gomu no Mi abilities (Gears)/has been robbed of his Devil Fruit. Can assume he uses a more generic fighting style, say Garp-esque and is no longer susceptible to water.
Assumptions: Both are 'fresh', with no recent Haki usage. Zoro has Enma, Wado Ichimonji and Sandai Kitetsu. Any abilities or techniques which appear to be a combination of Devil Fruit & Haki are not allowed, e.g. Red Hawk/Ignition abilities.

Genuinely not a bait thread, I am curious if anyone can put forth a reasoned argument for either side, as I have my own opinion and I'm curious if it's common place.

 

[Nie Li]

Luffy with no gomu gomu? Not even gear 2 doping and just brawling? Versus a fellow advanced CoC user with his entire skill-based moveset unnerfed?

I give it to Zoro under these particular circumstances.

 

[Pirate Queen]

This is wild. Zoro Extreme diff.

Haki above all and Luffy's Haki use is far and away better than Zoro in this aspect but your dropping Luffy in a fight where he lost his signature fighting style. If he was mastered in unarmed combat without a DF than it goes to Luffy, but this is just too big of a hurdle to overcome.

Still, it would be an entertaining fight

 

[Sachsenhesse]

Without an devilfruit ability, its Zoro. Gear 5 will wreck him thou.