Editing Practice #02 - The Lesson

[shinwei]

Solutions for Editing Practice #001 have been posted:
http://mangahelpers.com/forum/index.php?topic=5452.0

Editing Practice #002

Here's another simple page for some editing practice!

http://img109.imageshack.us/img109/5627/1103gc.jpg

When attempting, please make a separate thread for yourself called:

[Nick] attempts Editing Practice #001!

Here's a checklist of things to do to the page:

• Slightly apply levels to the page.
• Rotate the page so it's nice and straight.
• Remove the text.
• Resize the image so its height is 1100 pixels.
• Typeset the page! (translation below)

Translation

Panel 1

Bulma: We've got to get ashore so I can take out a Hoi-Poi Capsule for gas, so turn into an oar, okay?

Oolong: An oar, eh?

Goku: What good's a boar?

Panel 2

Oolong: Henge (transform)!!

Panel 3

Goku: One!

Goku: Two!

SFX: BLASH BLASH

Oolong: Glaa!! Glub!!

Oolong: Gentle, dude, gentle!! I'm delicate!!

Panel 4

Goku: All tied up!

Bulma: Great!

Panel 5

Oolong: Okay, I made myself useful! Now give!

Bulma: If you think getting your head dunked a little bit is worth a pair of panties, you are DERANGED!

SFX: jrble jrble

End

Have fun!

 

[destinator]

Re: Editing Practice #002

There is already a new editing practice? Damn totally missed this one.

 

[cobra2150]

Re: Editing Practice #002

Ok as far as editing goes what exactly is it... it seems to me it is a lot of typesetting and a little cleaning... can I get a more in detail explanation of what it is.

Edit: Finally Full Member Status!!!!!!!!!!

 

[shinwei]

Re: Editing Practice #002

Finally Hero Member status!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

90% of all manga Edited Manga groups out there do NOT use magazine scans. They use volume scans instead, and therefore there is no such thing as a "cleaner" to them. Thus, they go and recruit "editors" who are expected to be able to both perform the minimal amount of cleaning AND the typesetting.

 

[gto0o]

Re: Editing Practice #002

I guess i'll give it a try

 

[Allashandra]

Re: Editing Practice #002

Finally Hero Member status!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

90% of all manga Edited Manga groups out there do NOT use magazine scans. They use volume scans instead, and therefore there is no such thing as a "cleaner" to them. Thus, they go and recruit "editors" who are expected to be able to both perform the minimal amount of cleaning AND the typesetting.

It's a little more complicated than that though I admit the cleaning part is easier overall than with magazine scans I have had some serious challeneges in recreating drawing where text once was among other things. And depending on the group and what kind of scans you use some gutter shadow can be worse than magazine scan cleaning.

 

[shinwei]

Re: Editing Practice #002

When Tanko scans are used the Editor is expected to do both the typesetting and the minimal amount of cleaning. The big things that an editor spends time on is redrawing behind text and connecting two pages in a spread.

Any group that considers themselves HQ would never use scans with gutter shadows. Scanning is always done after debinding the tankoban.

 

[Raenef]

Re: Editing Practice #002 - The Lesson

would it be accaptable to change

Panel 4
Goku: All tied up!
Bulma: Great!

the great to "OK!" cause of the small bubble?

 

[CatzCradle]

Re: Editing Practice #002 - The Lesson

The link to the RAW page appears dead.

 

[[Ju-Ni]Vicissitude]

Re: Editing Practice #002 - The Lesson

Your image link seems to have gone all 404 on you. Might want to rehost, possibly to a more stable host? Imgur, perhaps?