Discussion Erase this post

[Isto]

dffsd

 

[Grandmaster Woro]

alabasta.

we have vivi, the normal version of rebecca

 

[hokageji]

Thriller Bark is my favorite... It has two of my favorite moments, Brooks revealed to be from the crew Laboon belongs. And Zoro's "nothing happened" moment.

 

[afromarco005]

I like Wano this far it could become the best arc imo.

Otherwise I think it's Shabaody archipellago introduces supernova, luffy punches the CD, Reighleig vs Kizaru, Kizaru trolling. Luffy and Crew "losing" to Kuma finally making luffy understand that his journey is not a little pirate's game. love it

 

[King Moe]

Marineford Summit War arc, not just for many fighits, touching scenes, and unexpected outcome, but also the arc I feel set the high standard of how great Oda is as a writer and artist as the arc gave him over 32 million of sales from what I heard. It was the start of Goda and set the bars higher than possibly than even Dragon Ball and feel of passing the torch from that.

 

[Takuan]

Water 7 + Enies Lobby. These two arcs combined, are my favourites.

 

[Sachsenhesse]

Thriller Bark is my favorite... It has two of my favorite moments, Brooks revealed to be from the crew Laboon belongs. And Zoro's "nothing happened" moment.

Yes. At first i really didnt liked it, but after a reread its the best one.

Yohohoho yohohoho...

 

[woefdram]

The whole stretch from Water 7 to time skip. But I'd have to say my favourite one there would be the Impel Down arc. Introducing Jinbe,Ivankov, Magellan, Shiliew + new BB crew members and the glorious return of Bon-chan

 

[Fox666]

1st - Marineford
2nd - Impel Down
3rd - Shabondy

 

[thedude]

I'm surprised at people saying Marineford and Imple down...both lacked the entire Straw Hat crew.

For my money, it's
1) Water 7 - Enies Lobby - and for me this goes all the way until they name the Thousand Sunny and flee Water 7.
2) Alabasta - and I'll cheat here and say this is everything from Reversing Mountain to Alabasta, maybe excluding Drum Island because that one really doesn't link to the entire Baroque Works/Alabasta plot. But Tiny Garden and all that other build up is part of it for me.
3) Skypia - again, I'll include the preliminary stuff here on the island with Cricket. This was pure "adventure" for the sake of it.
4) Not really one arc, but I consider everything up to Reverse Mountain to be one big arc, call it "East Blue Arc". Yes, I'm cheating huge here, lol
5) Shabondy-Marineford. I consider this all one big arc again. Shabondy is so short that it's not really a whole arc. This one loses out for me because it lacks the whole crew, but I could see putting it up as high as 3 for me...just hard to justify any higher.
6) Thriller Bark. A slight arc with some great moments. Not bad by any stretch, and I like it's brevity.

I find it hard to rank post-time skip, the pacing has been off the entire time. Right now this Wano arc is feeling more like pre-timeskip though, so this one might go up on my list above. I've liked other arcs reading in one shot, but as a week to week thing, they drag so much (also, please no more "the fight lasted 22 hours". That just feels like nonsense.)

 

[TitaniumOxide]

I like impel down to marineford arcs. I know they are distinct arcs but when I go back to reread the Marineford arc I have to reread Impel down. It almost doesn't make sense to me to just read marineford.

 

[M3J]

So far, I love the Water Seven/Enies Lobby arc. Then it's Alabasta, Thriller Bark, and Impel Down/Marineford.