Fantasy Erza vs Mirajane

[Seven777]

The old rivals clash. Erza vs Mirajane, the Demon vs the Knight, She-Devil vs Titania. Who wins?


Round 1: Normal Erza vs Normal Mirajane. They can use whatever they have/want.

Round 2: Erza gets infinite Nakagami, Mirajane gets infinite Alegria.


Can't believe there isn't already a thread on this, or if there is I can't find it.

 

[Ramen]

Erza in RD 1

Erza in RD 2

 

[Livinbreathineatin]

Round 1: they’ll fight pretty evenly for a while. Erza in her armors and Mira in BSS and Sitri. I don’t think it’ll be a battle where Erza completely dominates Mira in every clash. Mira will get hits in.

Then they’re probably gonna bring out the big Guns. Nakagami, Armadura and Seilah and the other Tartaros demons. Macro would be a problem since it HAS worked on her before and Macro’s remote control has worked in canon. The other curses aren’t jokes either. They wrecked Fairytail’s top tiers recently. (Two years actually isn’t THAT much of a TS. The demons haven’t been powercrept).

Alegria is Mira’s trump card. One attack from it wiped out Irene’s personality enchantment. Erza possesses armors with similar strength to Mirajane’s Alegria form so it would be an all out brawl from the start to the finish. Erza probably winning. Current Mira probably can’t outlast Erza in a battle. But Macro has one shoot potential, though... never forget that.

Erza takes it with high difficulty. It’s definitely not a one sided stomp since Mira can match all of Erza’s moves. If Erza starts using strong armors, Mira will start using stronger demons etc.

Round 2: Erza for now since we haven’t seen all of Alegria’s capabilities. We didn’t even see Mirajane Alegria fly.

 

[IamtherealMirajane]

1) Mirajane macroed Erza, it works before unless Erza can counter it. It can be use remotely as per Seilah.

2) Could be either way. What im sure is we havent seen the full capabilities of Alegria. Not even its spell. It only evaporates the nearby sea. And oneshotted Irene's liutenants to the point that enchantment was lifted. Still this is feat considering they beat the Satan Soul. And tanked a bigger version of evil explosion like it was nothing. And Satan Soul is still a stronger form even in today's standard. It even tanked what Lucy consider her Trump card.

 

[Axiomus]

Round 1: Erza. She outlasts MIrajane. If Irene's dragon claw can't take out Erza permanently, then Mirajane's alegria form isn't taking her out either. Especially considering Alegria is unlikely to do more damage than Irene's dragon claw. Erza only has to survive 1 hit, and she's in the clear.

Round 2: Stalemate. This is no different than giving them both infinite magic power. At this point, it's kind of pointless to debate.

 

[Seven777]

Round 2: Stalemate. This is no different than giving them both infinite magic power. At this point, it's kind of pointless to debate.

The point was to debate which one is stronger, since they're so often compared

 

[Vis]

No way can Mirajane ever actually beat Erza at her best lol

 

[Ramen]

Bringing this one back too.

Erza stomps both rounds.

 

[Hexbend]

Yea, Erza dominates both rounds with ease

 

[Jko]

Mira. Macro GG.

 

[Ramen]

Mira. Macro GG.

You're joking right?

 

[Axiomus]

Yeah, this is a wrap for me. Erza has a devil slaying sword now. And she hits harder than Gray.

Take any point of the Erza vs Laxus fight, and replace Laxus with Gray. There isn't a single moment I can point out where replacing Gray with Laxus would have defeated Erza. Right up to the end, Erza used heaven's wheel to stalemate raiko: red lightning.

 

[Aurelius]

Is Pluto a Mira fan or not? Posts are contradictory

 

[grey matter]

Is Pluto a Mira fan or not? Posts are contradictory

Can be a fan and not be a wanker lmao

 

[sharkai]

Bringing this one back too.

Erza stomps both rounds.

Love this guy

He spotting bs from way back

 

[Ramen]

Love this guy

He spotting bs from way back

Always

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 1, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 1, 2020 ---

@sharkai I think it's time for a new dp lol

 

[Axiomus]

Macro beating Erza in 2020. Oof.

 

[Jko]

Erza got beat out by hax from Kiria in 2019 so...

 

[Mirage]

Macro works like Command T. Works on people in Mira's ballpark in terms of strength. Mira is not in Erza's ballpark in any stat.

Erza shit diffs.

 

[Jko]

Macro works like Command T. Works on people in Mira's ballpark in terms of strength. Mira is not in Erza's ballpark in any stat.

Erza shit diffs.

This is not true as a 99% dead Seilah did it on Erza and Minerva. Plus Command T isn't offset by power. The only hax stated to be determined by PL is Gemini's copy magic. Hax has been used numerous times on people far more powerful than the caster.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 1, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 1, 2020 ---

Literally stated by Mashima to break PLs lol.