Discussion Fairy Tail Power Ranking Thread

[Stormsfury]

And you call that having an effect? That didn't even faze her or do anything to her. Look at the following panels.

Spoiler

I would even go as far as to say that was just a mark. No damage there. Unless you tell me that Dimaria can heal herself, I don't know why you even bother to consider it as proof when you clearly ignored the panels after that scene. Additionally, note that Wendy had a open shot at Dimaria because she was focusing on Chelia. Yet again, another indirect help. On a real one-on-one fight, Wendy couldn't even damage her, let alone touch her as she would parry all of Wendy's attacks.

As for Lucy, I'm not arguing she is stronger than DF Wendy. They're on the same level and I believe I made that very clear. I don't think I need to repeat myself again. Like I said, Lucy doesn't have to have the same durability was DF Wendy because she can't even be touched. With the amount of celestial spirits she can summon, it would take most of Wendy's energy just to defeat all her celestial spirits and then proceed to fight Lucy.

Yes I call that having an affect, that's what bruising is man, that's how bruising is illustrated in manga, sure is minimal but she still affected her. DF Wendy and Lucy are not on the same level, I think the fact that Lucy needed an insane amount of luck, PiS, CiS and a lot of help from Natsu and others to win her fight speaks volumes, her reaction speed is shit as seen when she just stood there and prepared to tank fucking throwing knives with her arms. Base Wendy was able to dodge a sword swinging at her neck, not only did she dodge it but she also jumped over it, that's how fast Base Wendy is, DF is on a whole other level.
If Intel is known between them in a fight (which it would be) DF Wendy would probably just steal her keys, or just speed blitz her before she could even summon a spirit. Heck even if she summoned a spirit, the spirits themselves would be speed blitzed.
This is a no contest.

 

[Jko]

Calls Lucy fights PIS, CIS and a lot of help from Natsu yet Wendy's had so much plot armor that she got Grandma Ultear out of bed to save her ass but I guess we'll wipe that under the rug bcs it's Wendy .

 

[XXEliteXXAceXX]

Yes I call that having an affect, that's what bruising is man, that's how bruising is illustrated in manga, sure is minimal but she still affected her. DF Wendy and Lucy are not on the same level, I think the fact that Lucy needed an insane amount of luck, PiS, CiS and a lot of help from Natsu and others to win her fight speaks volumes, her reaction speed is shit as seen when she just stood there and prepared to tank fucking throwing knives with her arms. Base Wendy was able to dodge a sword swinging at her neck, not only did she dodge it but she also jumped over it, that's how fast Base Wendy is, DF is on a whole other level.
If Intel is known between them in a fight (which it would be) DF Wendy would probably just steal her keys, or just speed blitz her before she could even summon a spirit. Heck even if she summoned a spirit, the spirits themselves would be speed blitzed.
This is a no contest.

There is a difference between a mark and a bruise. They are purposely drawn very different. I didn't know that Mavis' clothes can be bruised because by definition, bruises form only when there is blood which clothing material obviously doesn't have...

Spoiler

The lines on Mavis' outfit are clearly marks. Now look at her face. That is bruised. Also, know that bruises are darker and take many consecutive panels for it to disappear. The panel below also shows Dimaria being bruised.

Spoiler

Now do you understand the difference? I never thought I would have to go this far just to show you the difference in manga drawings.

Spoiler

The only reason Hiro Mashima included the marks was to show the exact spot that Wendy hit her on the face. The "bruise" that you claim here didn't even last a panel. So the likeliness that it was just a mark is more probable. Dimaria obviously didn't take any damage with that hit. Dirt and debris? Maybe. But my whole point in the past few posts is that Wendy is helpless against Dimaria. You can try to twist it all you want, but that is a pretty weak argument to say that Wendy > Lucy.

Once again, Wendy dodging Dimaria's attacks says nothing. First, there was interference. Second, Dimaria was obviously toying around by slowly striking with her blade because she didn't expect Ultear to appear. Third, how do you know Lucy wouldn't be able to dodge that? Instead of speculating, show me some real feats and panels.

You expect there to be intel in a legitimate, real fight? No. On the forum threads? Maybe. And if Lucy has intel on Wendy, she'll just pick up Wendy and throw her on a boat/train/car. Congratulations, motion sickness in effect. A one-shot opportunity. Or she can toy with Wendy's mind and say she has Carla as hostage. Really, do you know how ridiculous this sounds? Let's get real.

 

[BluePegasus]

Calls Lucy fights PIS, CIS and a lot of help from Natsu yet Wendy's had so much plot armor that she got Grandma Ultear out of bed to save her ass but I guess we'll wipe that under the rug bcs it's Wendy .

Uhm yes because otherwise Di Maria can't be defeated.

 

[Cosmicstar]

I can't believe how DF Wendy is underestimated like this. Comparing her to Lucy isn't even needed since DF Wendy is a lot stronger than her. We're talking about Dragon Force, the strongest power-up from a Dragon Slayer.

Most of Lucy's Celestial Spirits are pretty weak, they're always oneshotted. The only powerful Celestial Spirit she has is Leo. It's pretty funny that people say Lucy's defense is better than Wendy's, while Lucy can only use Hologium once in a battle. Wendy already take this round since she used a barrier which blocked attacks from a God.

Defense: DF Wendy > Lucy

DF Wendy's physical power is a lot stronger than Lucy's kicks.

Physical power: DF Wendy > Lucy

Don't need to say a lot about magic power. DF Wendy's spells are a lot stronger than any Celestial Spirit spell.

Magic power: DF Wendy > Lucy

As for attack, DF Wendy landed a lot more attacks at Ezel than Lucy did to anyone.

Attack: DF Wendy > Lucy

Don't need to say anything about speed.

Speed: DF Wendy >>>>>> Lucy

I'd say their stamina is pretty much equal. DF Wendy should be able to take more damage than Lucy, but she's still too young.

Stamina: DF Wendy = Lucy

Lucy has better intelligence than Wendy.

Intelligence: Lucy > DF Wendy

I'm sorry but Lucy is no match for Dragon Force.

The fact you feel like you don't need to explain so many things is a problem especially when you don't have feats to back up you claims. You clearly are being extremely bia's towards Wendy.

Lucy has shown way better Physical feats then Wendy has. While Lucy was in her Taurus form she could easily drag people and destroy the earth. A DF punch from Wendy didn't do anything to Ezel.

Also the same way you are claiming that Wendy blocked Dimira attack, so did Horologium with Jacob attack.


Only strong spell Wendy has is Skydrill. Lucy has Urano Metria, Starshot, CSK Summoning, etc.

Lucy clearly has better Stamina then Wendy as you can go look at their performance during the Tartarous arc in which Lucy was able to do way more on her own magical reserves then Wendy was able to do after consuming a huge amount of Etherno.

 

[DemonKing888]

The fact you feel like you don't need to explain so many things is a problem especially when you don't have feats to back up you claims. You clearly are being extremely bia's towards Wendy.

Lucy has shown way better Physical feats then Wendy has. While Lucy was in her Taurus form she could easily drag people and destroy the earth. A DF punch from Wendy didn't do anything to Ezel.

Also the same way you are claiming that Wendy blocked Dimira attack, so did Horologium with Jacob attack.


Only strong spell Wendy has is Skydrill. Lucy has Urano Metria, Starshot, CSK Summoning, etc.

Lucy clearly has better Stamina then Wendy as you can go look at their performance during the Tartarous arc in which Lucy was able to do way more on her own magical reserves then Wendy was able to do after consuming a huge amount of Etherno.

I would also like to add on to this post that Lucy was always mention to have an high magic reserve, Summoning Celestial Spirits takes alot of magical power because Spirits constantly feed off their Master's magical power as explained by Loke and Virgo when Lucy had 3 gates open in her vs Tartaros arc. When the Spirit King was fighting Mard Geer he was running off of Lucy's magical energy.

Urano Metria is also a high level spell which should be stronger then Skydrill, the only difference between the two spells is that when Lucy landed Urano Metria on Angel and Jackal the fight was over. When Wendy landed Skydrill on Cherria and Ezel they both got back up and kept fighting Wendy. In less Wendy can cancel out Urano Metria she's done.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 23, 2016, Original Post Date: Apr 22, 2016 ---

I didn't think I'd ever see the day Fairytail fans would have a bias fanboyism towards Wendy. This is more heated then the Laxus vs Jellal debate.

 

[Jko]

Uhm yes because otherwise Di Maria can't be defeated.

No duh... the point of the post was to show that calling Lucy's power ups and wins BS is stupid as those same things can be brought up for Wendy also.

 

[Solitrine]

Don't really care who's stronger but Lucy isn't going to land Urano Metria on someone who's moving, so far she's only hit people who have stood still due to PiS.

 

[Mirage]

Base Dimaria is not stronger then Jacob in physicals.

Who cares? I'm talking about overall. Dimaria shits on Jacob.

That's literally what I just stated. She only truly started getting into fights after the GMG her accumulated damage is low.

It's literally every ounce of damage she took. Surely you're not dumb enough to state that Lucy has better endurance than someone who's endured this.

Well you are... you think tanking Dorma Anim little rockets is as high a durability feat when even Azuma's fodder attacks were stronger then that.

She barely got up after getting hit which is barely surviving

Spoiler

and she almost got killed/severely injured when she was about to get hit by those rockets.

Spoiler

Lucy did tank that attack as she was still conscious and ready to fight. Lucy tanked amateratsu 28 way better then Wendy tanked those rockets.

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Funny how Wendy got back up after everyone of these attacks, except the last one. That one was more her enduring it.

Where did you get that? I mean you guys do think bigger means stronger so Lucy tanked an amateratsu higher then pre-ts Laxus did.
Hades to Laxus:

Spoiler

Franmalths to Lucy (Natsu and Happy too)

Spoiler

so in no ways was his inferior.

She didn't even tank that shit.

And no, she endured Franmalth's weakened A28. Don't just show pages that benefit you, show the pages after.

Spoiler

Spoiler

Yeah, she didn't tank that. She barely endured it. xD

Torafuza was trying to kill her so if you'd think he wasn't trying to when he stated two-three times that he wanted kill her swiftly then that's on you but Jackal was sure as heck trying to kill her yet failed as she reacted and erected a barrier before his blast were able to hit her.

Spoiler

You're taking statements at face value. If you knew Torafusa, you'd know that he's modest. He's obviously lying that he was trying. If he was, he would've went all out like against Gajeel. Doesn't take a genius to figure that out.

You're pretty much implying that Lucy would actually win a fight against them when she'd get trashed real quick.

 

[Jko]

Who cares? I'm talking about overall. Dimaria shits on Jacob.

And what does that have to do with Wendy?

It's literally every ounce of damage she took. Surely you're not dumb enough to state that Lucy has better endurance than someone who's endured this.

Surely you're not dumb enough to comprehend that the accumulated damage Wendy took was low which is why she was able to endure it. Three Hits from Dorma Anima, one Tower Burst, a couple of Hades Fodder attacks, Chelia's attacks (minus her strongest one), and Ezel Base attacks... yeah her accumulative damage is very very low compared to the rest of the main cast.

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Funny how Wendy got back up after everyone of these attacks, except the last one. That one was more her enduring it.

Funny how you say I show things that only benefit me when literally your first pic is Wendy tanking and enduring jack squat.

Spoiler

Dorma Anima ain't shit so it doesn't matter if she took one to two fodder blast as they're weak. Chicken boy and Goat (Zoldeo's Subordinates) did more damage to Gajeel then Dorma Anima and they were the Seven Kin lieutenants lol.

She didn't even tank that shit.

And no, she endured Franmalth's weakened A28. Don't just show pages that benefit you, show the pages after.

Spoiler

Spoiler

Yeah, she didn't tank that. She barely endured it. xD

So you're saying Natsu didn't tank that attack either just bcs they were on the ground? They literally got attacked right after that and were getting their souls sucked out. Yeah she was barely enduring it when she literally resisted soul suck, did two forced gate closures, and devised a plan to trick Franmalth.

Spoiler

then easily got on her feet the next chapter

Spoiler

and got into to a fight with two 9Ds two chapters later. The girl definitely tanked that attack. An endurance feat is more like Erza enduring attacks from Kyouka then passing out right after which Lucy did not she was actually relatively fine.

You're taking statements at face value. If you knew Torafusa, you'd know that he's modest. He's obviously lying that he was trying. If he was, he would've went all out like against Gajeel. Doesn't take a genius to figure that out.

It doesn't take genius to figure out just because you don't go a higher form doesn't mean you aren't taking the battle serious. He tried to kill her multiple times yet kept getting held off in his Base mode.

You're pretty much implying that Lucy would actually win a fight against them when she'd get trashed real quick.

Pre-ts she'd one shot either one in a one on one battle and current Lucy would solo them both at the same time. Wendy could take one 9D pre-ts while Lucy got into fights with three 9Ds in a single day. The difference between Lucy and Wendy is clear as day.

 

[Mirage]

And what does that have to do with Wendy?

The fact that she fought a tougher opponent?

Surely you're not dumb enough to comprehend that the accumulated damage Wendy took was low which is why she was able to endure it. Three Hits from Dorma Anima, one Tower Burst, a couple of Hades Fodder attacks, Chelia's attacks (minus her strongest one), and Ezel Base attacks... yeah her accumulative damage is very very low compared to the rest of the main cast.

LOL wow, don't ever call someone a downplayer again. This post is gross. Lucy wouldn't even be able to properly tank one of these attacks. You named like several strong moves and made them seem weak. Anybody can do that. I bet if Wendy tanked Sema, it would mean Sema is weak just because Wendy is a little girl. Your logic is so bad.

Lol you're trying so hard, yet failing so miserably. It's funny to watch. You say the damage she endured is puny through Age Scratch yet you proceed to name several strong attacks.

Funny how you say I show things that only benefit me when literally your first pic is Wendy tanking and enduring jack squat.

Spoiler

Dorma Anima ain't shit so it doesn't matter if she took one to two fodder blast as they're weak. Chicken boy and Goat (Zoldeo's Subordinates) did more damage to Gajeel then Dorma Anima and they were the Seven Kin lieutenants lol.

I'm 100% convinced you're either blind or just don't know what tanking means. Can you not see Wendy smiling right there on that panel? That was her after the nukes ya jackass.

So you're saying Natsu didn't tank that attack either just bcs they were on the ground? They literally got attacked right after that and were getting their souls sucked out. Yeah she was barely enduring it when she literally resisted soul suck, did two forced gate closures, and devised a plan to trick Franmalth.

Spoiler

then easily got on her feat the next chapter

Spoiler

and got into to a fight with two 9Ds two chapters later. The girl definitely tanked that attack. An endurance feat is more like Erza enduring attacks from Kyouka then passing out right after the which Lucy did not she was actually relatively fine.

No, he didn't tank the attack. He endured it. The fact that you're asking me this just further reinforces my thinking of you not knowing what tanking means.

It doesn't take genius to figure out just because you don't go a higher form doesn't mean you aren't taking the battle serious. He tried to kill her multiple times yet kept getting held off in his Base mode.

He wasn't trying, the fact that you're actually trying to say he was is hilarious. Not only that, but you're just conveniently ignoring his personality. Come talk to me when Torafusa has a proper 1v1 with Lucy, then we'll talk.

Pre-ts she'd one shot either one in a one on one battle and current Lucy would solo them both at the same time. Wendy could one take one 9D pre-ts while Lucy got into fights with three 9Ds in a single day.

You're literally so delusional that I honestly think that you're an undercover Lucy fanboy with a Wendy avatar.

Also this post is scaring me.

Neither Wendy nor Lucy in their Pre-TS forms would one-shot Torafusa or Jackal? You're trolling me right? Current Lucy isn't any different than Tartaros Lucy. All her current feats are shit.

Yeah, she got in with 3 9DGs who weren't trying and only held them off. She couldn't shit to them.

 

[Crimson Ice]

Bad matchup? Erigor was the top guy in his guild and had wind strong enough to blow his fire away. When Natsu pushed hard he was able to deal with it. Did he easily beat Erigor in another arc? Erigor's magic and Aria's magic don't do the same thing. Aria did not stop Natsu's Fire. He stopped Natsu from punching him. Think it was Nirvana seis arc when Natsu beat up Erigor easily in a second match. It's not the power of wind or fire. It's the power of the mage using it that determines the strength. Ice will over power fire. Fire will over power ice. Water stops fire. Fire also makes water evaporate. It depends on which Mage is stronger. Erza cut throughAria's attack. Aria did not use that spell he used on Erza, nor did he use much strength against Natsu. So how does that prove anything about a bad matchup? NOTHING!

The Ajeel Laxus debate was me accusing you of stating it as fact, not probability. Ajeel said it wouldn't have killed him. That couldn't be determined so there was no end. Erza said Natsu is as strong as her or stronger, fight proved otherwise. Natsu did not have problems launching his fire. Aria jumped over it and went to Natsu. Excuses, excuses and more excuses. At least now you are giving detail why you believe it was a mismatch. Air space zetsu was all Aria used to smash Natsu. Against Erza he went full power and used airspace of death, zero. That attack wasn't just a better spell at full power, it kills, not injures. Even without using any of it he still beat the shit out of Natsu. In this argument it's you accusing me of not reading. Only now you give detail info why you believe it was a bad matchup. Which still makes no sense. I completely admit I got my source from anime until the beginning of Tartaros arc. So correct me when the anime and manga aren't the same.

Character statements don't mean anything. Erza had to fight Aria to know that he wasn't that strong. Erigor wanted to fight Erza from the start. Erza told Natsu that he has untapped potential and will be the man that surpasses her. Then against Jose she says he is as strong as her or even more.

Go check again. Natsu had his times against Gajeel. Gajeel had his too. Both roared and Gajeel got the better but not one sided. So sad when the only guy that can give me a good debate is delusional. Gajeel losing mp? Don't you think Natsu while fighting Gajeel lost mp too during the match? You haven't proven anything. "He said she said" Proof is in the fights. Not in words. Therefore your proof is lesser

They say wind magic is flat out a bad matchup for Natsu and the next time Eigor appeared it was in filler. Eigor and Aria's magic are both wind-based magic which is a bad matchup. This arc and the Wahl bots outright proved certain magics have advantages and disadvantages over each other. Wind mages are bad matchups period this was established.


The debate was you accusing me of something I didn't say because you didn't read my post correctly. Erza says Natsu is as stronger as her if not stronger even after seeing his poor performance against Aria. The manga has already said wind mages are a bad mtachup for Natsu I'm not going to repeat myself again Character statements mean a lot in the correct context you just don't want to admit because it goes against your point, it's that simple. Eigor wanting to fight Erza first is irrelvant, Erza had a better reputation that's it.

Gajeel wasn't dominating? LMAO

http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/7
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/8
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/11
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/14
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/18

Gajeel, like I said dominated the start of the match. Character statements in the right context are correct you're flat out denying this because it would mean you're wrong.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 24, 2016, Original Post Date: Apr 24, 2016 ---

I will just ignore this. In the end, all your claims are based on the fact that you're a fan from Laxus.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 16, 2016, Original Post Date: Apr 16, 2016 ---

Blitzing someone as Racer is more impressive than blitzing a Spriggan.

I'm sorry what? Just because someone like Racer focuses on speed doesn't mean he's faster than someone tiers above him. This is just nonsense.

 

[Dempsey]

They say wind magic is flat out a bad matchup for Natsu and the next time Eigor appeared it was in filler. Eigor and Aria's magic are both wind-based magic which is a bad matchup. This arc and the Wahl bots outright proved certain magics have advantages and disadvantages over each other. Wind mages are bad matchups period this was established.


The debate was you accusing me of something I didn't say because you didn't read my post correctly. Erza says Natsu is as stronger as her if not stronger even after seeing his poor performance against Aria. The manga has already said wind mages are a bad mtachup for Natsu I'm not going to repeat myself again Character statements mean a lot in the correct context you just don't want to admit because it goes against your point, it's that simple. Eigor wanting to fight Erza first is irrelvant, Erza had a better reputation that's it.

Gajeel wasn't dominating? LMAO

http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/7
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/8
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/11
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/14
http://www.mangapanda.com/fairy-tail/61/18

Gajeel, like I said dominated the start of the match. Character statements in the right context are correct you're flat out denying this because it would mean you're wrong.

People will make excuses that Gajeel was fresh and that Natsu wasn't lol

 

[Jko]

The fact that she fought a tougher opponent?

You mean she got stomped .

LOL wow, don't ever call someone a downplayer again. This post is gross. Lucy wouldn't even be able to properly tank one of these attacks. You named like several strong moves and made them seem weak. Anybody can do that. I bet if Wendy tanked Sema, it would mean Sema is weak just because Wendy is a little girl. Your logic is so bad.

Lmao you just mad Wendy got barely any durability feats. Lucy would be able to tank any of the attacks Wendy took. Amaterasu 28 >>> then any of Wendy's pre-ts tank feats. Your logic is terrible as Wendy doesn't have durability feats on Lucy level.

Lol you're trying so hard, yet failing so miserably. It's funny to watch. You say the damage she endured is puny through Age Scratch yet you proceed to name several strong attacks.

Proceed to name several fodder attacks. Dorma anima = fodder, Hades fodder attacks = everyone took them, Azuma's tower burst (that one shotted her) <<<< Jackal's explosions, and Chelia attacks <<<<<<<< Amaterasu 28. These scrub attacks wouldn't even dent Lucy lmao.

I'm 100% convinced you're either blind or just don't know what tanking means. Can you not see Wendy smiling right there on that panel? That was her after the nukes ya jackass.

Your either blind or just don't know tanking means... You can clearly see Natsu eating the attack before it even hit her and his body was in was in front of her smartass.

No, he didn't tank the attack. He endured it. The fact that you're asking me this just further reinforces my thinking of you not knowing what tanking means.

Getting up right after you get hit is being able to tank the attack. I asked because others also use the Amaterasu 28 formula as a tanking feat for Natsu as well so I wanted to see if you did too.

He wasn't trying, the fact that you're actually trying to say he was is hilarious. Not only that, but you're just conveniently ignoring his personality. Come talk to me when Torafusa has a proper 1v1 with Lucy, then we'll talk.

Lol Lucy would one shot Torafuza as well the same way she one shotted Jackal. Tell me when Wendy actually can one shot anyone beside fodder.

You're literally so delusional that I honestly think that you're an undercover Lucy fanboy with a Wendy avatar.

Lol I'm the delusional one when you think tanking two attacks from Dorma Anim is impressive. I'm just not a Wendy wanker and I know where she ranks in the FT verse.

Also this post is scaring me.

Neither Wendy nor Lucy in their Pre-TS forms would one-shot Torafusa or Jackal? You're trolling me right? Current Lucy isn't any different than Tartaros Lucy. All her current feats are shit.

Yeah, she got in with 3 9DGs who weren't trying and only held them off. She couldn't shit to them.

Seriously? You do know Pre-ts Lucy one shotted Jackal and killed him right...

Spoiler

She fought 3 9D in a single day... stalemated Torafuza, helped fight against Franmalth and was the key to their victory, summoned three spirits at the same time then summoned the CSK right after that then one shotted Jackal. Lucy feats >> Wendy feats.

 

[Laxus]

Calls Lucy fights PIS, CIS and a lot of help from Natsu yet Wendy's had so much plot armor that she got Grandma Ultear out of bed to save her ass but I guess we'll wipe that under the rug bcs it's Wendy .

Worst comparasion possible. You are talking about someone who can stop time itself.

 

[Synn]

Good guys side (updated):
Top tier:
- Natsu
- Gildarts/Jellal
- Laxus
- Erza
High Tier:
- Gods of Ishgar
- Gray/Gajeel
- TO Sheria
- Rogue/Sting
- Mirajane/Minerva
- Kagura
- Lyon/Orga
- Lucy/Wendy
- Makarov
Mid Tier:
- Rufus
- Freed
- Juvia
- Elfman
- Cana
Low Tier:
- The rest

 

[Static]

Good guys side (updated):
Top tier:
- Natsu
- Gildarts/Jellal
- Laxus
- Erza
High Tier:
- Gods of Ishgar
- Gray/Gajeel
- Mirajane
- Lucy/Wendy
- Makarov
Mid Tier:
- Freed
- Juvia
- Elfman
- Cana
Low Tier:
- The rest

Put Erza in High Tier and that's a great list.

 

[BluePegasus]

Good side

Top tier:
Jellal
Laxus
Gildarts
TO Chelia
Gods of Ishgar

High tier:
Gray
Mirajane
Natsu
Gajeel
Minerva
Kagura
Erza
DF Wendy
Makarov

Mid tier:
Sting
Rogue
Freed
Lyon
Juvia
Meredy
Lucy

Low tier:
Cana
Happy

 

[Dranzer]

Good side

Top tier:
Jellal
Laxus
Gildarts
TO Chelia
Gods of Ishgar

I pretty much completely agree with your thoughts, but other than God Serena, the Gods of Ishgar are featless and mostly a disappointment.

 

[~Charging Lightning~]

Well, since everyone else is making one for the good guys....

Top Tier:
-Laxus/Jellal
-Natsu
-Gildarts

High Tier:
-Erza
-GoI (combined)
-Gray/Gajeel
-Mirajane
-TO Cherria
-Kagura
-Minerva
-Sting/Rouge (combined)
-Freed
-Makarov
-Wendy

Mid Tier:
-Lucy
-Lyon
-Meredy/Juvia
-Cana

Low Tier:
-Fodder