Misc Attempt First Time Cleaning Attempt

[senbonzakura_17]

This is my first attempt to clean manga. I never had any experience before in manga cleaning but I guess I can give it a try. Here it is. Any comments are welcome.

RAW:

Spoiler

Cleaned:

Spoiler

 

[PitylessEnvy]

Really well done, but there are a couple parts of the image where you see to have completely gotten rid of the greys (see panels 2 and 5). Also, the little page numbers (the 42 between panels 6 and 7 in this one) are general kept on the page.

 

[hatsuharupeace]

When you're replacing grays, make sure you recheck your page before you deem it finish. 5th panel, there's gray missing which you didn't replace around the guy's face, which is highly evidient in the RAW. You also missed some gray in the bottom left corner of panel 2, so checking back on the RAW is highly important. But, for a first time clean, it's pretty darn good, have a try at getting good grays without replacing them now.

 

[Cipo]

wow, i'm impressed... really a great page.. like hatsu said you missed some things while replacing grays but the page is still fine.. it'd be cool to know how much did you take on doing it.. 1-2 hour(s)? the only thing i dislike is that borders are aliased.. better if you do them after the page is resized

 

[senbonzakura_17]

for this page it tooks me about 2-3 hours because the difficulty range between easy-medium. for a more complicated page it may takes more than 3 hours, maybe.the grays was hard though for me to get it right.

this is another page cleaned by me recently. this is the last page of bleach chapter 371. it tooks me about 2-3 hours too.

RAW:

Spoiler

Cleaned:

Spoiler