Politics Fully Integrating US Prisons, good or bad idea?

miyi

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Mar 12, 2007
Messages
625
Reaction score
25
Gender
Male
Country
United States
This is probably not coincidental that just after the Gitmo ruling, this shit happens.

In the name of Civil Rights, a plan to fully integrate US prisons will be in full effect, starting this July.

Integrating schools, the army, the workplace, all of these developments, are all great.

But there comes a time when integrating something can be a BAD thing --- an example is Prison.

Perhaps we are getting ahead of ourselves here. Yes, we have progressed remarkably as far as racial equality is concerned, but that is still in a macro sense.

Realistically, and in the micro street level, racial equality is still a fantasy. There are still racial tensions, and exacerbated by gang-related rivalries and factionalism.

You'd think that segregating these racial divide to quell these tensions is a reasonable solution.......but NOOOOO....how about we extend the Civil Rights movement in Prison!?? That should force the inmates to get along together, right?

This is intuitively asinine and defies common sense and logic, and more importantly, counterproductive.

Let's hope that there isn't any race related riot that erupts from this misguided experiment.

If I was deprived of my rights and facing life time in prison, the last thing I need is to be deprived of at least the comfort of safety....and now I'd have to live with someone I may not potentially like, just because it's for Civil Rights.

Give me a break.
 

Luca Breeze

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Jun 22, 2008
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Gender
Female
Country
United States
This is probably not coincidental that just after the Gitmo ruling, this shit happens.

In the name of Civil Rights, a plan to fully integrate US prisons will be in full effect, starting this July.

Integrating schools, the army, the workplace, all of these developments, are all great.

But there comes a time when integrating something can be a BAD thing --- an example is Prison.

Perhaps we are getting ahead of ourselves here. Yes, we have progressed remarkably as far as racial equality is concerned, but that is still in a macro sense.

Realistically, and in the micro street level, racial equality is still a fantasy. There are still racial tensions, and exacerbated by gang-related rivalries and factionalism.
I agree whole-heartedly with you, but, as in saying it's a fantasy, I think it should also be pointed out that people do have hopes for it, and those with hopes act on said hopes, as to set an example they wish for others to follow. Yes, it's very hopeful, and I agree that it will be completely unattainable to have a complete racial harmony. As the song says, everybody's a little bit racist. You and I are no exceptions. Gangs have been around for ages, and bad blood never tends to die- vendettas and grudges will always be dredged up, and of all places you are absolutely correct- a prison is absolutely not the place to try this integration.

You'd think that segregating these racial divide to quell these tensions is a reasonable solution.......but NOOOOO....how about we extend the Civil Rights movement in Prison!?? That should force the inmates to get along together, right?

This is intuitively asinine and defies common sense and logic, and more importantly, counterproductive.
Granted, the CRM does get pushy, we also do have to try and think how members of said movement are thinking- 'inmates have feelings too!' I think these are the types of people who try and push veganism in the US. All joking aside, I do also agree with the statement that you're sort of putting out there that really this is childish thinking in that it is full of high expectations and hopes that more than likely won't work. I'm not saying that it can't work, but chances of it being successful in the range that they're hoping for is probably unattainable at this point in time. It sounds to me like the government and Civil Rights Activists are looking for a real life rendition of Romeo and Juliet...but I'm sorry I don't for-see a 'happy' ending for these Capulets and Montegues.

If I was deprived of my rights and facing life time in prison, the last thing I need is to be deprived of at least the comfort of safety....and now I'd have to live with someone I may not potentially like, just because it's for Civil Rights.
My idea would be that they should have people opt in to this seeing as this really, truly as you said, is an experiment. These people know of the rivalries gangwise, and racially, and if they're willing to risk it for the purpose of Civil Rights, then that's fine, but you are right, forcing this upon them is almost against what Civil Rights stands for. Yes I know that everyone should have the right to feel comfort and safe around not only people of their own race, but of other races, but we're not talking about dainty, tea-sipping upperclass people who's only task for the day is to attend the soiree down the way- we're talking about thugs, and hardcore machines who wouldn't give a second thought on injuring someone, or killing someone for the fun of it.

I think this is definitely a 'wtf were they thinking' moment. Thanks for the article.
 

Franckie

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 16, 2007
Messages
2,902
Reaction score
1,381
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
The second page of the article you provide mentions intregration occuring in Texas. Two professors studied the impact of the change, poring over 10 years of inmate-on-inmate assault data. The result: violence ultimately went down.

Also, race generally isn't the predominant factor when it comes to prison gangs. If I remember correctly, the Aryan Brotherhood and Mexican Mafia do have a history of supporting each other in order to maintain profits for the prison drug trade.

If I was deprived of my rights and facing life time in prison, the last thing I need is to be deprived of at least the comfort of safety....and now I'd have to live with someone I may not potentially like, just because it's for Civil Rights.
Although I'm not fully supportive of the idea, but if integration helps do things such as lower violence in prisons, then it may be an idea that is worth some consideration.
 
Last edited:
Top