Discussion Garp Discussion Thread

[OP_overlord]

all we know is that garp is not as strong as he used to be (eventho he can hurl canonballs the size of a ship at ppl)

and we KNOW that grap is the same stregth if not stronger than WB cause WB may have been equal to Gol D. Roger but Garp Caught Roger

 

[Efreet]

i'd hate to see how fast he could actually throw baseballs if he could throw cannonballs the speed of real baseballs

 

[Absolutio]

all we know is that garp is not as strong as he used to be (eventho he can hurl canonballs the size of a ship at ppl)

and we KNOW that grap is the same stregth if not stronger than WB cause WB may have been equal to Gol D. Roger but Garp Caught Roger

Where does it say that Garp was the one who caught Roger?

 

[OP_overlord]

idk i think that is just implied it says that he courned roger many times

 

[Absolutio]

it also says that WhiteBeard was the only one that could fight equally with Roger.. So I dont think garp was the one to caught him.. I generally wonder how the pirate king got caught..

 

[Efreet]

it also says that WhiteBeard was the only one that could fight equally with Roger.. So I dont think garp was the one to caught him.. I generally wonder how the pirate king got caught..

how he was caught....hmm.. most likely the same way as many heroes are.. a HOSTAGE situation...

perhaps Roger's wife/daughter/son was captured and in exchange for letting them go free, Roger would have to die

 

[OP_overlord]

yeah i could see that or he was just tired of life he had everthing money, fame, power, he was ready for the next adventure

 

[Absolutio]

how he was caught....hmm.. most likely the same way as many heroes are.. a HOSTAGE situation...

perhaps Roger's wife/daughter/son was captured and in exchange for letting them go free, Roger would have to die

So what about his family if it did happen. I thought about hostage, but it seems unlikely with the likes of Roger.
I think there's something special about him being caught. Like it served him for some purpose which we don't know yet, so he intentionly let himself get caught.

 

[OP_overlord]

that is not the exact thing that i said

 

[Efreet]

maybe there's a ghostly version of the One Piece world and Roger wanted to be the King Of the Ghostly Pirates too...

he was way too calm at his execution... even Luffy tried to escape but Roger just accepted his fate...

showoff

 

[Absolutio]

maybe there's a ghostly version of the One Piece world and Roger wanted to be the King Of the Ghostly Pirates too...

he was way too calm at his execution... even Luffy tried to escape but Roger just accepted his fate...

showoff

Lol.. as I said, he probably had his intentions.. =D

 

[OP_overlord]

yeah he knew what he was doing

 

[sushi]

I thought luffy was the same not doing anything when he was caught llike roger...just the lightning that saved luffy

 

[hrseber]

I think that both Garp and Dragon were on Gol D. Roger's crew and after Roger was captured by the head of the marines, the buddha guy, they seperated ways. Garp joined the marines because they saw his potential and he realized he needed to keep control of the pirates to not let them rampage since his commander in chief is now dead. But his son, Dragon, knew what Roger did about the true history and decided to go to the other extreme and reshape the world accrodingly.

Something, that I think is more and more likely the way they speak of them (WB and Shanks that is when they meet up)

 

[OP_overlord]

well the manga says that garp was the only person to coner roger and y would he do that if he was on his ship but dragon could have been on rogers ship

 

[Absolutio]

well the manga says that garp was the only person to coner roger and y would he do that if he was on his ship but dragon could have been on rogers ship

I dont think that dragon was on roger's ship, coz if he was, WhiteBeard would've mentioned him as one of those few ppl who're left from the old times, in his chat with shanks.

 

[Gear2fu]

i know this is a little off topic but where do you think the rebels that dragon is leading are hiding i expect it to be somewhere like that last island of the grand line.

 

[OP_overlord]

in this recent manga chapter they say that they are chillin on and island called pagado or something like it in the grandline i dont think that it is the second to last island

who did WB mention from the old times when he was talking to shanks i forgot

 

[Absolutio]

in this recent manga chapter they say that they are chillin on and island called pagado or something like it in the grandline i dont think that it is the second to last island

who did WB mention from the old times when he was talking to shanks i forgot

if i'm not mistaken he mentions garp, sengoku and roger, while referring to the old days.

 

[mugen]

Garp is the guy who maybe did in fact capture Gol..
I mean that is possible after seeing a bit of his strength
that is what Mugen thinks.....