Battle Ging Freecss vs Silva Zoldyck vs Chrollo Lucilfer

The President

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 18, 2016
Messages
785
Reaction score
2,437
Age
31
Country
Canada
Late to the party but Ging is most definitely the strongest of the 3, without question. Ging is one of the strongest fighters in the manga period, up there with the likes of Netero (at least old Netero). Characters like Silva and Chrollo are top-tier, but not "god tier" so to speak. Whos stronger between Chrollo and Silva is up in the air, given that Chrollos ability is so circumstantial id still pick Silva as the more capable overall fighter if I had to.

Killua started far stronger, but it has always been made clear that Gon had more potential. If Hisokas interest in Gon over Killua isnt enough proof of that, then maximized (adult) Gon should be. Killuas isnt far behind though.
 

MasniBog

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 21, 2018
Messages
841
Reaction score
1,466
Age
29
Country
Serbia
Ging would win probably
 

howdydodah

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
80
Reaction score
10
Gender
Hidden
Country
Philippines
Pertaining to Ging, we know he is genius when it comes to nen.
Factors:
One of the Designers of Greed Island
On the spot copying/mimicking at a certain level of someone elses hatsu. Albeit with a more basic nen utilization.
Highly academic when speaking with colleagues, very tactical/strategic in both fighting and diplomacy.
Take aways:
(Greed Island) We do not know how much he has contributed to it's creation all we know that it was his brainchild.
Proof: He assigned different nen users with running it's system.
Nen talent, we know he is smart but is he really powerful? He uses tricks to beat his enemies just like Hisoka does, but does he fight man to man just like Hisoka does? It's still a mystery.
And he sometimes goof offs.

Now we know he's a genius but is he really effective against people of the same calibre e.g. Silva, Chrollo, Zeno, and Pariston? Or maybe even Beyond?

Now for Silva.
Factors:
High Mastery of Emission(Chrollo fight - nen balls)
High Physique levels (Zaoldyeck we know that + Benz Knife)
High Levels of Enhancement Mastery(Cheetu, crater - enhanced punch)
Take aways:
Folks, we have feats. Based on all that we know he is a battle oriented nen user and we haven't seen him utilizing his own nen category yet. I'm also willing to bet he has mastered all the nen types, a good balanced fighter. Able enough to throw emission balls destructive enough on par with Uvogin's 20% or maybe 50% power(Inaccurate just looking at the damage in environment). Able to make a big crater with an enhanced punch much like Uvogin's BBI, but less effective since Transmuter(Also, we don't know how much power he used there). He can literally utilize basic nen at levels higher than any one else we've seen except for a Royal Guard and Uvon. Not even Razer's destruction of the Ryodan's boat can top off Silva's emission feat.

And Lastly Chrollo
Factors:
High Level Mastery of all nen types is a given for his Specialty
Mid level Physique levels, since I'm looking at Hisoka as high level and then to Zaoldyeck's and Uvon and Netero's as extremes.
High Nen Capacity and Nen effectiveness to compensate for low Physical prowess(Can defend against Zeno's enhanced punches even though he is considerably weaker physically).
Really advantageous Specialist Ability.

If it's a no prep fight, Chrollo is a no go. If it is? Almost certainly the guy to come out on top even with Ging's crazy talent. Nobody can top Skill hunter.

So I see this as Silva the face to face hand to hand no prep fighter and Chrollo with the prep. I just don't see Ging being at the extremes at both. At best he's a jack of all trades master of none in these scenarios, unless we see something else?
 

Kanmuru

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
515
Reaction score
743
Gender
Male
Country
Argentina
Is skill hunter that extremely OP?
On paper yes, but in the fight against hisoka looks like it's not the case.
Why would you need an army of nen puppets, 4 diferent hatsus, several conditions and a lot of planning to take 1 guy down?
Skill hunter vs an extreme hatsu like Hyakushiki kannon is pointless, he's not even opening his book, might be dead already.
Ging probably has some nasty move like HK, that can't be countered. Also if someone is just faster and going for the kill the guy is in a real problem, he can't summon the book and meet all the conditions if you just attack all the time. Heck, even hisoka could go all in without let him speak and win..
Chrollo is not an elite machine like RNG netero or ging, he'll be already dead if it wasn't by illumi's call in york new,
 

howdydodah

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Aug 5, 2013
Messages
80
Reaction score
10
Gender
Hidden
Country
Philippines
It kinda is actually, he could steal one of his teammates abilities and use them to beat either of them or at the same time.
Nen is crazy and if he gets a hold of an extremely powerful nen ability then that could be his trump card. If it's a prep fight Silva might be smart enough to prolong his fight but I don't see him getting away alive. Now with Ging, I can confidently say that he could probably counter Chrollo at a 30% success rate, but again Skill hunter is too much of a wild card here.

Both Silva and Ging aren't stupid enough to directly attack an unknown opponent, especially Silva who knows about Skill hunter. That's the only reason why Chrollo was able to survive the 2 on 1 fight in all honesty. The unpredictability of his skill hunter is perplexing to even the most experienced masters.

Edit: Nothing can top skill hunter on prep. Just like it's hard to see anyone beating Kurapica on a straightforward battle.
 
Last edited:

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,673
Reaction score
61,374
Gender
Male
Country
France
Is skill hunter that extremely OP?
On paper yes, but in the fight against hisoka looks like it's not the case.
Why would you need an army of nen puppets, 4 diferent hatsus, several conditions and a lot of planning to take 1 guy down?
Skill hunter vs an extreme hatsu like Hyakushiki kannon is pointless, he's not even opening his book, might be dead already.
Ging probably has some nasty move like HK, that can't be countered. Also if someone is just faster and going for the kill the guy is in a real problem, he can't summon the book and meet all the conditions if you just attack all the time. Heck, even hisoka could go all in without let him speak and win..
Chrollo is not an elite machine like RNG netero or ging, he'll be already dead if it wasn't by illumi's call in york new,
Chrollo is definitely a genius. Skill Hunter is very good and he has plenty of tools. But he did all of this to be 100% sure of his victory against Hisoka. In a fight without preparations, he wasn't sure he would have won.
 
Top