Quarterfinal Holo vs Hinata Hyuuga

[Lambu]

People really don't know the meaning behind waifu.

Agree, I think there's a big misconception of the term in this event.

Waifu is not a girl with "Wife" traits (such as cooking, taking care of the children... you know that shit) but a fictional girl you would want as your wife, that you would wish to marry. Of course being a good cook or being a "good mother" are positive features for a waifu but they do not define the idea of waifu.

Therefore, things like "she takes good care of children --> she would make a better waifu" are just bs. The real questions should be:
Which girl do you like better? Which one would you prefer to be in a relationship with?
In this case I can only say I prefer Holo over Hinata by a wide margin, she's a strong willed woman, very intelligent and sharp girl that would make an amazing partner in life.

If you prefer some woman devoid of personality that only takes care of you until you die... good for you, but as I said in the thread of Mirajane I have higher standards towards women... and I hope you all have hehe

 

[Nii]

^ I think there's a little bit of a misconception here. Ofc traits like "she's a good mother" etc. don't define a good waifu. A waifu is your waifu bc you love her, for whatever (unreasonable) reason, that's true. But you don't win an argument or a competition by saying "VOTE FOR HER BC I LUB HER", that's just silly and won't convince anyone, nor does it make for an interesting Waifu War.

You rack your brain to come up with sound arguments and nice pictures to support your waifu or favourite, you dig up a salt mine to throw salt around like your life depends on it, bc people love salt and you want the people to love your waifu. This is how it's supposed to work. (Salty) Bread and circuses is what moves and pleases people, and hence that's what we do.

 

[Selene]

never really watched holo's anime is good?

i heard alot of mixed reviews

 

[M3J]

Voted Hinata because not only do I know her, but she's been waifu enough. She even tried to protect Naruto against Pain, which takes guts. Even Sakura never did that.

 

[Lambu]

^ I think there's a little bit of a misconception here. Ofc traits like "she's a good mother" etc. don't define a good waifu. A waifu is your waifu bc you love her, for whatever (unreasonable) reason, that's true. But you don't win an argument or a competition by saying "VOTE FOR HER BC I LUB HER", that's just silly and won't convince anyone, nor does it make for an interesting Waifu War.

You rack your brain to come up with sound arguments and nice pictures to support your waifu or favourite, you dig up a salt mine to throw salt around like your life depends on it, bc people love salt and you want the people to love your waifu. This is how it's supposed to work. (Salty) Bread and circuses is what moves and pleases people, and hence that's what we do.

Never said otherwise, I know events like this doesn't move without salt or convincing stuff. Yeah, as you said the "she is great because I love her" is nonsense, but I actually never said anything like that
What I wanted to say with that post is that "waifu" is not the same as "stereotype of wife", I only tried to remark that difference.

From my side please bring as much salt as you want, it makes all this way more interesting

 

[amit-monsterman999]

well going for hte wolf now

 

[Spirit]

Ho-lo Ho-lo Ho-lo!

 

[Brandish μ]

Hinata has very few attractive points. And it would be almost impossible to know them as she's timid af.

Honestly her opponent could've been BigMom and I would've voted against Hinata. Revenge votes are the easiest to cast.

Spoiler

 

[Luca Blight]

I mean:

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

Hinata is a fine wife, no doubt. But Holo as a character is awesome all around.

Wait... did Hinata beat Erza?!! D:

 

[XXEliteXXAceXX]

It seems I was mistaken. Well, got to eat my words now...

 

[Styx]

No surprise Hinata made it through given the amount of FT hate exists in the world.

Voting for Holo because she's Holo and she's superior.

 

[Hakuteiken]

Warning: This post is more anti-Hinata than pro-Holo, so, proceed with caution.

I really don't know how Hinata has shown more of a support to Naruto than Holo did to Lawrence. Holo was always there with Lawrence for the whole story, whereas Hinata was just a 700-chapter-long meek-looking stalker, only getting to be paired by Naruto because Kishimoto wanted Sakura for Sasuke. I knew any form of pairing between those four would be horrendous, and we got one of the variations, of course. God bless.

Here is a fun fact. The best thing that Hinata achieved in the entire series, or rather her highest moment ever, was her showing up in the fight against Pain. In better words, the best thing Hinata has ever done was.. to get beaten to the ground repeatedly in something that cannot be considered a fight even. Absolutely hilarious.

Maybe I shouldn't overlook her character's other aspects. She easily showed the least aptitude to be a shinobi out of anyone in the story thanks to her timid personality. Now, this wouldn't be a major issue if it actually wasn't the only thing that was going for her. Flash forward a couple of years, and Hinata seems to have better mental strength, yet we realize that she actually had nothing else to make up for her lack of personality. She is basically the "loves the main character from the shadows" type of girl who has no other defining attributes. Tenten was a complete joke as far as character development goes, without a doubt the worst supporting character Kishimoto created for me. And how was Hinata a better developed character than Tenten? She secretly loved Naruto. Okay, I laughed.
And since there was absolutely no realistic romantic connection between Hinata and Naruto, Kishimoto went ahead and wrote an emotional suicide scene for Neji, A lot of garbage had to be written to make it work, yet none was an attempt to give Hinata a personality.

Either way, comparing Holo to Hinata is a heresy. One was a well-written character with a personality, while the other one was not necessarily poorly written, since something that did not exist to begin with might not be considered poor, after all.

 

[Ice devil slayer]

Can someone explain how hinata is even here ? How tf did she beat erza ?

 

[Juliana]

Can someone explain how hinata is even here ? How tf did she beat erza ?

She beat Erza because this is a waifu competition, not a harlots' one.
That's why I'm voting for her (also because idk Holo Very well).

 

[ForSeaGle]

Hinata gives best cuddles...
Easy win for me

 

[Styx]

Hinata wasn't just a stalker, she was actually there for Naruto when others hated him and at the most important parts of his life. We actually get to see plenty of reasons why she fell in love with him. She may not be strong, but she's a good waifu even before she became a waifu. <3

 

[Nii]

Thinking about it again, it's actually kinda funny. Hinata and Holo defeated almost every FT character in this tournament single-handedly. They're... the Fairy Tail Slayers Who knew two waifus could be more deadly than Zeref and Acnologia? maybe bc both turned out to be shit-tier characters

Should my waifu fail I'm quite fine with one of them winning this tournament, slaying all those FT girls is a massive deed that deserves applause.

 

[Arjuna]

Holo for me.Simply no other reason Holo is better than Hinata.

 

[Styx]

Nah, just a whole bunch of racists against mages voted against the FT characters.

 

[Kiki]

she's timid

She is no longer timid. Move on from past. She has changed from timid to determined. This is Hinata's character development

none was an attempt to give Hinata a personality.

That war gave her personality. She slapped some sense into Naruto, convincing him not to give up.