Presented? Yes. But here's what SIU said in a blog post:
Source.
So, most of the Princesses are not from the 10 Families, and if they are, most aren't direct descendants.
I know that it's not what you are trying to say, but my point is that, the more we explore the Tower, the less special the descendants seem. Descendants of the 13GW already get great genetic talent even if there are rare cases when they don't share the talent of the FH, Regulars who aren't from the 10F can have talent rivalling the 10F descendants. Even among these descendants their talents(genetic or not) vary. As Regulars, I think it's easier for 10F descendants to stand out since they have a good environment in general and good genetic talent they can exploit but the non 10F Regulars who got to become Rankers or High Rankers have nothing to envy to 10F descendants IMO(besides prestige I guess) because they got to polish their skills, techniques etc.
The average 10F descendant is stronger than the average non 10F descendant but it becomes more irrelevant at a high or very high level is what I want to say. Hatsu has never been portrayed as particulaly talented AFAIR, but he is dedicated to the sword and I have no doubt he'll become a High Ranker.
Yes but it's TOG where people can live for thousand of years easily. Charisma is a thing but from what we have seen, power eclipses charisma. A large part of the fanbase believe that the Ha Twins are Enne tier and if they are they must have crazy deeds. And yet they are still eclipsed by a youngster.
From what we know Adori and Enne are ranked that high because of their feats in battle, so why aren't these two Ha the same? It's been centuries that Enne has been inactive but these Ha aren't in the top 17. Enryu's single achievement still makes him top 2 in the ranking. These two should have records too. Enne and Adori are ranked even higher than some of the FH, even an ennemy of the ZA, Luslec is so it's odd.
If these twins are so outstanding why aren't they favored compared to Yuri? My opinion might change as we learn more about Yuri and the family but for now I'll stick with Yuri is more talented and has more charisma, which makes her stand out even more, she also gets away with all the crazy stuff she does because of Ha favoritism and her standing.
At least her talent and charisma have been stated. To me it is more tangible than "being a kid of two Irregulars makes you stronger than the kid of a single Irregular". Baam, despite his lineage is a special Irregular and the only one capable of reaching Zahard's level. Enne is also portrayed as special and even she has Adori, who isn't a 10F descendant as someone comparable in power among the Princesses. These Ha Twins don't seem to be as exceptional as Enne despite their lineage.
Plus when you have a lineage like that, I think it's more likely than your genetic gifts will be more nuanced, not that they'll stack. Guess we'll see more with the likes of Lyborick and Yura(we don't know much about her father but it looks like he was rather strong and Yura doesn't have a body as strong as most Ha, but she has other skills they don't). Anak is kinda similar, her physical ability is inferior to most Princesses it seems like she has great Shinsoo talent(could create more Bangs than Laure before) and IIRC SIU said that her race can move more easily in Shinsoo(I don't have the source for this though).
I already knew this information you mentioned, but is it still valid? There are many gaps in this. Does SIU only count the princesses rankers? Or does it encompass all princesses? Because we have:
Maschenny, Yuri, Hagi, Horn, Shilial, Lilial, Maria, Rose and Gladmerry.
With the first 3 mentioned, we have confirmation that they are from 10 families, being two DDs. Arie Horn was the first Princess Zahard, of the Arie family given to elitism and how restricted the Arie family is in relation to lineage (remember that Inieta for not being a DD was discriminated against and did not learn the family's special techniques) I very much doubt that a non-DD princess arises from the Arie family, the same argument applies to Arie Rose. Gladmerry, she could end up being an adopted daughter, given the background of the Hendo Lok family. Lilial and Shilial discriminate against Androssi for not being a princess of the 10 families (she is adopted after all) and Maria is a DD of the Koon family, since she is also Eduan's daughter. Only with that we have several princesses from the 10 families, the only thing that remains is the question of Enne.
SIU has sometimes shown that outside information can end up being revised later on like the curse of the Arie princesses and possibly Yama's past. Besides, there are many princesses that we don't have full names or we don't know if there is any relationship, like Repellista, she can be a daughter or descend from the Tperies, since she has an opera. People like Garam too, I don't particularly rule out her being a Koon, but it's personal, without proof. And there is still a supposed princess of the 10 families, Yulia who was the one who caused the loss of the Reflejo's vision. And there are others like Pondo, Heice etc.
I know that it's not what you are trying to say, but my point is that, the more we explore the Tower, the less special the descendants seem. Descendants of the 13GW already get great genetic talent even if there are rare cases when they don't share the talent of the FH, Regulars who aren't from the 10F can have talent rivalling the 10F descendants. Even among these descendants their talents(genetic or not) vary. As Regulars, I think it's easier for 10F descendants to stand out since they have a good environment in general and good genetic talent they can exploit but the non 10F Regulars who got to become Rankers or High Rankers have nothing to envy to 10F descendants IMO(besides prestige I guess) because they got to polish their skills, techniques etc.
The average 10F descendant is stronger than the average non 10F descendant but it becomes more irrelevant at a high or very high level is what I want to say. Hatsu has never been portrayed as particulaly talented AFAIR, but he is dedicated to the sword and I have no doubt he'll become a High Ranker.
That is precisely the point: high-level rankers and regulars powerful, who are not from the 10 families are few and rare. SIU has always emphasized genetic inheritance in ToG. Analyze a little, among the regulars and elite high-rankers that we know and properly know their origin, in proportion, how many are from the 10 families and how many are not? And going back a little more to the beginning of our debate, in terms of lineage, how many of these have no significant descent?
Their individual talent is another matter, but the fact that you have a good lineage influences and defines much of your potential is a fact. People like Kallavan, EVK and Khel Hellam who appear to have no lineage have external powers, I am not taking their credit, far from it, you still need to be a monster to deal with these skills, but still, there are people stronger than them and most are from 10 families.
From what we know Adori and Enne are ranked that high because of their feats in battle, so why aren't these two Ha the same? It's been centuries that Enne has been inactive but these Ha aren't in the top 17. Enryu's single achievement still makes him top 2 in the ranking. These two should have records too. Enne and Adori are ranked even higher than some of the FH, even an ennemy of the ZA, Luslec is so it's odd.
If these twins are so outstanding why aren't they favored compared to Yuri? My opinion might change as we learn more about Yuri and the family but for now I'll stick with Yuri is more talented and has more charisma, which makes her stand out even more, she also gets away with all the crazy stuff she does because of Ha favoritism and her standing.
At least her talent and charisma have been stated. To me it is more tangible than "being a kid of two Irregulars makes you stronger than the kid of a single Irregular". Baam, despite his lineage is a special Irregular and the only one capable of reaching Zahard's level. Enne is also portrayed as special and even she has Adori, who isn't a 10F descendant as someone comparable in power among the Princesses. These Ha Twins don't seem to be as exceptional as Enne despite their lineage.
First of all, I already let you not share the idea that the Ha twins are as strong as Enne, I don't have enough information to position myself in this.
The Ha twins, founded ALL the Ha family, since Yurin had no more children, that is, they have been around, at least, since the beginning of the genesis, they are stabilized people, Yuri is practically an idol, we have already seen with Androssi how popular princesses are in the tower, I still don't understand why you use charisma and popularity to associate in a matter of talent between the twins and Yuri, honestly, it doesn't make any sense. You think that from what we have been given she is the most talented in the history of the Ha clan, all right, it is your right, but her argument being more popular within the family, says nothing.
Plus when you have a lineage like that, I think it's more likely than your genetic gifts will be more nuanced, not that they'll stack. Guess we'll see more with the likes of Lyborick and Yura(we don't know much about her father but it looks like he was rather strong and Yura doesn't have a body as strong as most Ha, but she has other skills they don't). Anak is kinda similar, her physical ability is inferior to most Princesses it seems like she has great Shinsoo talent(could create more Bangs than Laure before) and IIRC SIU said that her race can move more easily in Shinsoo(I don't have the source for this though).
Given that all of the cursed by Zahard are peoples who survived his genocide, in fact we can assume that there is a lineage behind it too, like the native DDs. About Laure, he was said to be the best wave controller among the regulars at the time of the workshop battle and when asked SIU said he could do more than 3 baang, that is, at least 4. Given how good he is with Shinsoo , in terms of experience and technique, being even better than Baam at the time, he is quite capable of using 5, but there is a discussion for another time.