Discussion Intelligence in Nanatsu No Taizai

Commanderaxe

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2017
Messages
1,358
Reaction score
4,270
Age
30
Country
United States
I still think given the fact that she instantaneously figured out the complexity of her own curse & Meliodas is a strong intelligence feat. I mean, Meliodas knew he wasn't ageing but didn't even question the existence of an immortality curse but Elizabeth did and figured out every nuance of their curses.

I'm not denying that Elizabeth lacks in combat intelligence, but at the same time she doesn't completely forego it. For example, when ''Estarossa'' came forth with the intention of collecting Derriere's commandment, instead of outright fighting him on the spot, she sent him away and created distance between Derriere (the target) and Estarossa whilst sending him to the AA's presence. It's a pretty simple feat anyone else could do, but it shows she just isn't a stupid girl when it comes to any combat situation.

Combat intelligence obviously isn't her forte given she's a peaceful person, but in terms of PURE intelligence I believe she's quite smart in it, considering she figured out the curses, the reasoning behind Mael's behaviour with the commandments and is generally fully aware of every nuance of her own clan's magic, which even the AA's aren't fully established in (apparently).

So yeah, she's pretty average but because I'm a biased fan who doesn't accept any criticisms, she's the best and you're wrong for thinking otherwise!:arf:pwnge
Lol ill give you that she was knowledgable of her clans magic, although she loses a point for not instantly recognizing Maels magic in Escanor despite being around him for over a day post-awakening. Doesnt make sense she didnt even mention it, especially after being shown how much she cared for Mael. Something like that shouldve blown her mind.

As for the curse, I highly doubt she deduced that straight up. She knew that she will always reincarnate and they would also always meet, she also knew EXACTLY how many days she would die in, after remembering. She also knew that she would die before his eyes every single time they met. How tf could she possibly know all of that during their first meeting. Not even Merlin could deduce that shit because theres just too many variables to account for with not enough knowledge.

More than likely she was given details of the curse, most likely familar with it herself. After all knowing shed die in exactly 3 days and all of the other specifics when that was her first reincarnation, (or at least first one where she and Mel met) would be impossible.

Also didn't everyone know that the commandments were making Mael insane? Idk theres just nothing i can find that puts her above the likes of Escanor, Ban or Elaine. Any higher and thered just be no feats to support it
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
Lol ill give you that she was knowledgable of her clans magic, although she loses a point for not instantly recognizing Maels magic in Escanor despite being around him for over a day post-awakening. Doesnt make sense she didnt even mention it, especially after being shown how much she cared for Mael. Something like that shouldve blown her mind.
This isn't specific to Elizabeth though? Literally everyone didn't recognise the sun blessing inside Escanor despite it being blatantly obvious, so Elizabeth not recognising it (and everyone else) is simply due to Nakaba keeping it quiet for the ''big reveal'' of it belonging to the mightiest member of the Four Archangels previously whom was given it by the Supreme Deity. For example:

-Meliodas, the rival of Mael recruited Escanor and knew him for years, yet not a single comment on his power being the sun blessing? Even when he went berserk in 231?

-Merlin commented on the mysterious nature of Escanor's power despite nothing about it being mysterious.

-None of the commandments even went, ''oh yeah its the sun blessing'' and instead said ''No human in the past posessed such power! Who is he?'' when it was once again, blatantly obvious it was Mael's power.

So, if Elizabeth never directly commented on the power being that of her mother's and of Mael's, its not because she didn't recognise it too be so, but because Nakaba-sensei simply made every character act ''dumb'' around it for plot purposes. Hell, if the AA's instantly recognise that its the sun blessing in Escanor's presence, Elizabeth should do so as well but simply won't say anything due to Nakaba not wanting her too. I mean, Elizabeth was very worried for Meliodas health when battling Escanor, which could be attributed to her knowing how powerful the sun blessing is.

As for the curse, I highly doubt she deduced that straight up. She knew that she will always reincarnate and they would also always meet, she also knew EXACTLY how many days she would die in, after remembering. She also knew that she would die before his eyes every single time they met. How tf could she possibly know all of that during their first meeting. Not even Merlin could deduce that shit because theres just too many variables to account for with not enough knowledge.
Okay, some nuances of the curse she could easily deduce but how does she immediately deduce that:

-She even dies at all after getting back her memories?
-That with her first reincarnation, knew that she would die in 3 days if memories were awakened?
-That Meliodas would lose emotions upon death and be immortal?
-ETC

Yes, Elizabeth figuring out all this information on her first reincarnation is partially due to Nakaba's plot, but at the same time, it's due to the fact she is intelligent and aware. She knew her mother was going to punish her and immediately figured out that they were cursed, whilst Meliodas was completely unaware and didn't even think ''mhmm immortality''.

More than likely she was given details of the curse, most likely familar with it herself. After all knowing shed die in exactly 3 days and all of the other specifics when that was her first reincarnation, (or at least first one where she and Mel met) would be impossible.
Given details of her curse? From whom?

Also didn't everyone know that the commandments were making Mael insane? Idk theres just nothing i can find that puts her above the likes of Escanor, Ban or Elaine. Any higher and thered just be no feats to support it
I can't remember the specific chapter, but there was a moment where Mael was doing some power cloud thingy and Elizabeth explained what it was, didn't seem like an average and general intelligence moment too me.
 

Commanderaxe

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2017
Messages
1,358
Reaction score
4,270
Age
30
Country
United States
This isn't specific to Elizabeth though? Literally everyone didn't recognise the sun blessing inside Escanor despite it being blatantly obvious, so Elizabeth not recognising it (and everyone else) is simply due to Nakaba keeping it quiet for the ''big reveal'' of it belonging to the mightiest member of the Four Archangels previously whom was given it by the Supreme Deity. For example:

-Meliodas, the rival of Mael recruited Escanor and knew him for years, yet not a single comment on his power being the sun blessing? Even when he went berserk in 231?

-Merlin commented on the mysterious nature of Escanor's power despite nothing about it being mysterious.

-None of the commandments even went, ''oh yeah its the sun blessing'' and instead said ''No human in the past posessed such power! Who is he?'' when it was once again, blatantly obvious it was Mael's power.

So, if Elizabeth never directly commented on the power being that of her mother's and of Mael's, its not because she didn't recognise it too be so, but because Nakaba-sensei simply made every character act ''dumb'' around it for plot purposes. Hell, if the AA's instantly recognise that its the sun blessing in Escanor's presence, Elizabeth should do so as well but simply won't say anything due to Nakaba not wanting her too. I mean, Elizabeth was very worried for Meliodas health when battling Escanor, which could be attributed to her knowing how powerful the sun blessing is.



Okay, some nuances of the curse she could easily deduce but how does she immediately deduce that:

-She even dies at all after getting back her memories?
-That with her first reincarnation, knew that she would die in 3 days if memories were awakened?
-That Meliodas would lose emotions upon death and be immortal?
-ETC

Yes, Elizabeth figuring out all this information on her first reincarnation is partially due to Nakaba's plot, but at the same time, it's due to the fact she is intelligent and aware. She knew her mother was going to punish her and immediately figured out that they were cursed, whilst Meliodas was completely unaware and didn't even think ''mhmm immortality''.



Given details of her curse? From whom?



I can't remember the specific chapter, but there was a moment where Mael was doing some power cloud thingy and Elizabeth explained what it was, didn't seem like an average and general intelligence moment too me.
Yes but theres a difference in that the 3 archangels and Jelamet were confirmed to be capable of recognizing it. While Mel, Merlin and the others didnt. If we put aside plot reasons, which is actually the real reason lel, then its because they werent exposed enough to be familar. Now ofc we know that Mel and Mael fought, but if i were looking for a logical not plot bs answer that would be it. Elizabeth shouldve had just as much exposure to his grace as the AA but either she didn't, or she wasnt sure. We also cant say Mel and Mael knew each other for years as they had only 1 confirmed meeting.

I think maybe she was given details through either her mother when she died, or she simply gained awareness of it through magical means. Also Mel WAS aware he stopped aging, but immortality couldnt have necessarily been the answer. He simply couldve had his aging slowed down or been forced into a childlike form by the DK. He had no way of being 100% sure. The second she regained her full memories she shouted "I remember!" Then went on a detailed explanation of the curse. There were no " I think ", "its possible that.." nothing that hinted deduction, but a full on explanation of information already jammed into her head.

As for Maels cloud well she can definitely make observations and form thoughts around them, shes not brain dead lol. Just average indeed. Not that big of a deal regardless, 90% of tazai characters are of average intelligence. It's certainly no death note
 
Last edited:

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Gallan becauase he found out to beat Merlin and turned into stone despite shes immune to decrees. I dont know how Gallan did it but I think its his witts that made Merlin fallen. Next is Hawk Mama shes smart because she never said anything even a single word. With that I think shes so smart because whatever word you say would be used against you and so far she never spoken even a single word. 3rd one is Mael hes so smart that he overanalyze everything. I think he needs to calm down for him to be great.

And on the side note for the stupidiest who else but Elizabeth. She has the power but is not using it that makes her stupid.
 

Estarossa173

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2018
Messages
1,468
Reaction score
2,789
Age
29
Country
United States
Gallan becauase he found out to beat Merlin and turned into stone despite shes immune to decrees. I dont know how Gallan did it but I think its his witts that made Merlin fallen. Next is Hawk Mama shes smart because she never said anything even a single word. With that I think shes so smart because whatever word you say would be used against you and so far she never spoken even a single word. 3rd one is Mael hes so smart that he overanalyze everything. I think he needs to calm down for him to be great.

And on the side note for the stupidiest who else but Elizabeth. She has the power but is not using it that makes her stupid.
How do you know he actually found out how to beat Merlin? I think galand just got lucky that Merlin didn’t know anything about his abilities. Galand doesn’t strike me as the sort of person who has wits.
 

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
How do you know he actually found out how to beat Merlin? I think galand just got lucky that Merlin didn’t know anything about his abilities. Galand doesn’t strike me as the sort of person who has wits.
Its all about the results bro. I dont have any idea how he have pulled it but the result was clear Gallan beat Merlin. How can you say he doesnt have witts where in fact he has the least power and have been in TC for a long time that ddnt die. Kalmadios, zeno and aranak were dead so as og but galland have survived. Except for estarossa.
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
Its all about the results bro. I dont have any idea how he have pulled it but the result was clear Gallan beat Merlin.
Given what you said before and as you are talking about intelligence, this makes no sense.
 

Arjuna

The Emperor Who Rules the World
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2015
Messages
16,366
Reaction score
25,476
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
India
Its all about the results bro. I dont have any idea how he have pulled it but the result was clear Gallan beat Merlin. How can you say he doesnt have witts where in fact he has the least power and have been in TC for a long time that ddnt die. Kalmadios, zeno and aranak were dead so as og but galland have survived. Except for estarossa.
Galland didn't even know Merlin had protection.He just got lucky.
 

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Given what you said before and as you are talking about intelligence, this makes no sense.
Haha. It seems Im getting under your skin huh.lol. In NNT it doesnt matter how you win as long as the results like Escanor beating AM Mel. So as Gallan beating Merlin it goes down to history he beat Merlin.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Galland didn't even know Merlin had protection.He just got lucky.
Most probably but he still beat Merlin.haha
 

Arjuna

The Emperor Who Rules the World
伝説メンバー / Densetsu / Legendary Member
Joined
Oct 31, 2015
Messages
16,366
Reaction score
25,476
Age
31
Gender
Male
Country
India
Haha. It seems Im getting under your skin huh.lol. In NNT it doesnt matter how you win as long as the results like Escanor beating AM Mel. So as Gallan beating Merlin it goes down to history he beat Merlin.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Most probably but he still beat Merlin.haha
Tha didn't have anything to do with his intelligence

Tell me how can you say this guy has intelligence

 

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Tha didn't have anything to do with his intelligence

Tell me how can you say this guy has intelligence

Hahaha. Hes just so impulsive like any other genius's. Imagine Galand were petrified but has the ability to use telepathy.
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
Haha. It seems Im getting under your skin huh.lol. In NNT it doesnt matter how you win as long as the results like Escanor beating AM Mel. So as Gallan beating Merlin it goes down to history he beat Merlin.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---

Most probably but he still beat Merlin.haha
Yes you can get under my skin. Your comments on Eli are the most blatant examples. Seeing the contents of our discussion earlier and the level of logic you use on this topic, I do admit, I am bothered to a degree. Even so, in this matter we aren’t talking about wins or losses we are talking about intelligence. And I don’t see your reasoning and statements as valid. Because I see this, and because I choose to do so, I question you. That’s it, simply put. An idiot buff man can beat a skinny young prodigy, black and blue. His win, in and of itself, doesnt make him any less an idiot.

A boy throwing a tantrum, running outside and kicking a rock in anger because his mom didn’t give him a cookie isn’t a genius because he discovered a hundred dollar bill under the rock he kicked.
 
Last edited:

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Yes you can get under my skin. Your comments on Eli are the most blatant examples. Seeing the contents of our discussion earlier and the level of logic you use on this topic, I do admit, I am bothered to a degree. Even so, in this matter we aren’t talking about wins or losses we are talking about intelligence. And I don’t see your reasoning and statements as valid. Because I see this, and because I choose to do so, I question you. That’s it, simply put. An idiot buff man can beat a skinny young prodigy, black and blue. His win, in and of itself, doesnt make him any less an idiot.

A boy throwing a tantrum, running outside and kicking a rock in anger because his mom didn’t give him a cookie isn’t a genius because he discovered a hundred dollar bill under the rock he kicked.
You know what bro youre telling me about insult but you seem the one whos taking it personal by insulting me. Although I have a bad news for you bro it doesnt matter because Im not affected at all.hahaha. Anyway, in regards of Ely thats just my own opinion because with greater power comes with a bigger responsibility therefore she seems dumb to know that in my own opinion. Cheers mate just dont go on to personal matters we are grown man isnt it?
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
You know what bro youre telling me about insult but you seem the one whos taking it personal by insulting me. Although I have a bad news for you bro it doesnt matter because Im not affected at all.hahaha. Anyway, in regards of Ely thats just my own opinion because with greater power comes with a bigger responsibility therefore she seems dumb to know that in my own opinion. Cheers mate just dont go on to personal matters we are grown man isnt it?
You said that you were “getting under my skin.” I told you, so that I maybe honest towards your comment rather than ignore it, that in many occasions you do. Do with that what you will.

If you think I enjoy getting a rise out of someone you are mistaken. I have insulted before, unintentionally or not, so to reduce further hypocrisy, I think it is best if I don’t mention it from here on as much as I can help

I was referring to your multiple slut comments. And other, rather disgusting, comments in that light. We are grown men. So I judge the value of your words, logic and person, given where you were and where you are now, just as you should judge me likewise. I understand that I get “personal.” I believe the man that makes a comment is to be held in similar consideration as the comment he makes. Helps me better understand said comments


Now that those are out of the way, you didn’t tell me your thoughts on my analogies in relation to your “galland is intelligent because he beat Merlin.”
 
Last edited:

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Ok its fine with me. :)
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Hmm? Am I not being civil? I take just about everything seriously. Am I disrespectfully offending?
Bro we should stop this because it doesnt make any sense anymore ok. Cheers mate. :)
 
Top