Fantasy - Irene and Brandish vs Isghar | Page 2 | MangaHelpers



  • Join in and nominate your favorite shows of the summer season 2023!

Fantasy Irene and Brandish vs Isghar

Who wins?


  • Total voters
    24

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
2,144
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Could've easily, they acknowledge this at the beginning of the arc. Alvarez simply weren't a big enough threat to warrant the risk at the time. Tartaros and FACE were. Plot decided Tartaros was a good time to use FH, plot also decided that Alvarez wasn't a good time. Plot, plot, plot.
Who said anything about Natsu being a planet wiper? He doesn't need to be. A DF FDK Fist erased Zeref's body, a DF Secret Combined Flame Art would kill everyone in Alvarez. Natsu wouldn't even need to get close, they'd all just die.
Jacob got soloed by Mirajane who is from Ishgar. August couldn't beat Gildarts and Cana alone despite being serious enough to kill himself. Eileen could barely beat Erza and Wendy, despite going all out. END is from Ishgar. Ultear AND Chelia are from Ishgar. The spriggans were stomped, some of them twice, Alvarez were just too weak. It's why they needed FH to fight Acnologia, while Ishgar destroyed him. And current FT alone are currently going after 5 Acno tiers.
They could have but the risk is too great afterward, their treat was on part with that of using Etherion and Face, and Makarov’s did not have the stomach to use FH against Face, so by transitive property, if he needed to use FH to counter face but couldn’t which was a necessary déterrant against Alvarez, Alvarez is a worthy threat for FH but is too risky to use, in fact, they considered using FH against both Acno and Alvarez, implying they are of the same threat level. Zeref would not have died anyway since a similar curse with the same affect would not be able to kill him the same way., yet getting close was enough to freeze Natsu or make him shake in his boots and his igneel power reacted violently to their presence, Jacob‘s power was greatly reduced via closing his eyes. August was not taking things seriously, he was serious in the sense he would sacrifice himself for Zeref, Irene was playing too until later which Erza had her power boost to match. END still in a league on his own. Still Cheria is stronger than before with GS magic, put her against someone else and alone, she would likely loose, their defeats were circumstantial, they were strong as FT acknowledged time and again, and yet Irene managed to send Acno away and let him drift in the ocean. Ishgar used stronger spells to incapacitate and play on his weaknesses. And Brandish’s power could harm a slightly weakened Acno tier.
 
Last edited:

Vex_Haid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2021
Messages
1,091
Reaction score
240
Country
Canada
Because of plot Alvarez weren't all killed the first chapter of the arc. Mavis literally sat around doing nothing the entire war. The most powerful magic in the FT universe, did literally nothing. FT could have left Mavis in the crystal and just used it to power Natsu alone, and he'd wipe Alvarez off the map.
Current Natsu doesn't even need FH. The punch that killed Aldaron would destroy the entire Alvarez army, Zeref and every single spriggan except maybe August. Just one shot takes them all down.
August and Eileen could barely beat two members of FT each lol.
Ultear is from Ishgar. END is from Ishgar. God Serena is from Ishgar. Gray and his Ice Immunity are from Ishgar. Gajeel is from Ishgar.
Alvarez can't beat Ishgar. They couldn't preskip, they can't now.
Lmao

Yeah by what feats is the punch that killed aldo enough to destroy the entire army? Nah alot of spriggans would survive it, hell god serena will eat it. you tried tho

Irene was playing with erza and wendy, August was playing with gildarts and cana, wdym they could barely beat them? even an enchanted berserker from irene sent erza flying back
Ultear is dead, END was made by Zeref so he doesn't count, God Serena is a part of alvarez, Gray was the one to fight invel was cause he was the only one that can beat him due to ice immunity, gajeel ate bloodmans power thats how he beat him, and yes they will always beat ishgar (exc for mavis who with FH one shots everyone in FT except for acnologia, Igneel and FH zeref)
 

Hexbend

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
863
Reaction score
1,197
Age
22
Country
United States
How people still try to scale brandish to gajeel's performance against Aldo is just baffling.....like she herself said he couldn't do jack
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
2,144
Country
Imperium of Mankind
That’s not how it works, her magic may not organ bust someone stronger, but increasing her own size increases her stats to match or be stronger. and the only reason why she doesn’t is because she doesn’t have DSM to bypass his magic immunity defenses
 

Vex_Haid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2021
Messages
1,091
Reaction score
240
Country
Canada
That’s not how it works, her magic may not organ bust someone stronger, but increasing her own size increases her stats to match or be stronger. and the only reason why she doesn’t is because she doesn’t have DSM to bypass his magic immunity defenses
its hexbend, he wont understand

Brandish>Giant Gajeel is jsut basic kn\owledge
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,564
Age
29
Country
Australia
Lmao

Yeah by what feats is the punch that killed aldo enough to destroy the entire army? Nah alot of spriggans would survive it, hell god serena will eat it. you tried tho

Irene was playing with erza and wendy, August was playing with gildarts and cana, wdym they could barely beat them? even an enchanted berserker from irene sent erza flying back
Ultear is dead, END was made by Zeref so he doesn't count, God Serena is a part of alvarez, Gray was the one to fight invel was cause he was the only one that can beat him due to ice immunity, gajeel ate bloodmans power thats how he beat him, and yes they will always beat ishgar (exc for mavis who with FH one shots everyone in FT except for acnologia, Igneel and FH zeref)
Natsu erased Zeref's body with a lesser attack lmao, not only does the army die, but so does every spriggan, with the possible exception of August and God Serena and even they probably die.

Eileen went full dragon and tried to nuke Erza and Wendy lmao, only to get sliced out of the form. August literally killed himself against Gildarts and Cana. So when I say they could barely beat them, I mean, they could barely beat them.
Ultear is an old lady, she's not dead. Of course END counts, END is Natsu and Natsu sides with Ishgar. By that logic Brandish is part of Ishgar, because she sided with Ishgar, each side had their turncoats. Gray fought Invel because he is from Ishgar. Gajeel stomped Bloodman the moment he could touch him.

Ishgar simply has better feats than Alvarez does, there's nothing special about it.
Ishgar defeated Alvarez, in canon. That right there is already a slam dunk for me.
Alvarez can't beat Acnologia without FH, Ishgar did.
Ishgar has killed 2 more nerfed Acno tiers since then and will likely kill 3 more by the time the manga is done.

Now, what has Alvarez done? They collectively shat their pants at the mere thought of Acnologia. And.... that's about it. Did they even take out anyone meaningful on Ishgar's side? It's kind of pathetic.
They could have but the risk is too great afterward, their treat was on part with that of using Etherion and Face, and Makarov’s did not have the stomach to use FH against Face, so by transitive property, if he needed to use FH to counter face but couldn’t which was a necessary déterrant against Alvarez, Alvarez is a worthy threat for FH but is too risky to use, in fact, they considered using FH against both Acno and Alvarez, implying they are of the same threat level. Zeref would not have died anyway since a similar curse with the same affect would not be able to kill him the same way., yet getting close was enough to freeze Natsu or make him shake in his boots and his igneel power reacted violently to their presence, Jacob‘s power was greatly reduced via closing his eyes. August was not taking things seriously, he was serious in the sense he would sacrifice himself for Zeref, Irene was playing too until later which Erza had her power boost to match. END still in a league on his own. Still Cheria is stronger than before with GS magic, put her against someone else and alone, she would likely loose, their defeats were circumstantial, they were strong as FT acknowledged time and again, and yet Irene managed to send Acno away and let him drift in the ocean. Ishgar used stronger spells to incapacitate and play on his weaknesses. And Brandish’s power could harm a slightly weakened Acno tier.
Yeah, they could have. Makarov had the stomach, he simply gathered it too late.
Yeah, but they didn't, aka plot like I said.
Doesn't matter if Zeref would have died, you don't need to kill Zeref to beat him. Mavis can kill him anyway.
Natsu doesn't need to get close.
So was Mirajanes by fighting in human form lmao.
August was going max seriousness, demonstrated clearly by his willingness to kill himself.
Eileen went full dragon and used her ultimate move against Erza, got shut down on both accounts.
END is weaker than Natsu.
So? Cheria is from Ishgar, so is Ultear. Ishgar using the resources at hand is perfectly logical.
Only when given to Gajeel.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
2,144
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Incorrect as Makarov literally stated at the second to last chapter of Tartaros that he did not have the courage to do so. plot dictates that the risk is too great as for obvious reasons. Mavis could only kill him with Love as it was necessary to kill him to defeat him, which is the One Magic at the end of the day, he definitely does, so? it is proven that human form Mira is strong on her own even intimidating strong enemies before, and since she struggled against fodder soldiers, Jacob's self induced handicap was around that level or less that at least. His seriousness came at the end with As Magia, for the whole fight he was trying to get an answer to his question, and Erza had Irene's power when Wendy possessed her so that made her capable of handling it barely, END is stronger as proven by his encounter with Brandish, before she could affect Natsu, but not END, and without those two working together, they are not winning. and Gajeel is weaker than Brandish as his only value is his dragon kryptonite.
 

Vex_Haid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2021
Messages
1,091
Reaction score
240
Country
Canada
Natsu erased Zeref's body with a lesser attack lmao, not only does the army die, but so does every spriggan, with the possible exception of August and God Serena and even they probably die.

Eileen went full dragon and tried to nuke Erza and Wendy lmao, only to get sliced out of the form. August literally killed himself against Gildarts and Cana. So when I say they could barely beat them, I mean, they could barely beat them.
Ultear is an old lady, she's not dead. Of course END counts, END is Natsu and Natsu sides with Ishgar. By that logic Brandish is part of Ishgar, because she sided with Ishgar, each side had their turncoats. Gray fought Invel because he is from Ishgar. Gajeel stomped Bloodman the moment he could touch him.

Ishgar simply has better feats than Alvarez does, there's nothing special about it.
Ishgar defeated Alvarez, in canon. That right there is already a slam dunk for me.
Alvarez can't beat Acnologia without FH, Ishgar did.
Ishgar has killed 2 more nerfed Acno tiers since then and will likely kill 3 more by the time the manga is done.

Now, what has Alvarez done? They collectively shat their pants at the mere thought of Acnologia. And.... that's about it. Did they even take out anyone meaningful on Ishgar's side? It's kind of pathetic.
What lesser attack? SF which burned natsus soul couldn't even make zerefs body bleed yet natsu somehow erased him? and no, natsus attack isnt doing anything to the spriggans

LOL, erza didn't do ANYTHING to force irene to get out of that form, Irene transformed into a human herself since Irenes dragon form is her real form and her human form is basically an appearance, As stated by Zeref, Her human form is exactly the same as her dragon form, He literally said that it was just an appearance and she will never become human again LMAO

August never killed himself, In fact he no sold gildarts strongest attack, Got back up like nothing after being hit by it. I guess no selling something = dying by your logic? so what if ultear is an old lady? she can only exist when time is stopped thus plot to save the mcs from getting killed by dimaria, Nah, END does not count since natsus demon seed was made by zeref and natsu lost his end form. Gray is the only one in ishgar that can counter invels hax, invel will beat anyone in ishgar except for FH mavis with ice lock. Gajeel stomped bloodman due to plot btws, Mashima restricted him from his hax like macro

Name the better feats that ishgar has then, ishgar only defeated alvarez because alvarez's top wizards killed themselves and zeref died due to love lmao, ishgar mages themselves believed in canon that they stood 0 chance against alvarez. that right there is already a slam dunk for m
Because acnologia was toying with them, Ishgar themselves is afraid of acnologia LMAO, you literally made 0 sense. If acnologia were to try then he would demolish all of ishgar, sorry but none of your fanfic will change that proved by canon
Ok show me ishgar beating 2 nerfed acno tiers oh wait? Dragon Gods? same people who were hiding from acno in a different continent?
 

Seven777

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Sep 16, 2016
Messages
5,568
Reaction score
10,564
Age
29
Country
Australia
What lesser attack? SF which burned natsus soul couldn't even make zerefs body bleed yet natsu somehow erased him? and no, natsus attack isnt doing anything to the spriggans

LOL, erza didn't do ANYTHING to force irene to get out of that form, Irene transformed into a human herself since Irenes dragon form is her real form and her human form is basically an appearance, As stated by Zeref, Her human form is exactly the same as her dragon form, He literally said that it was just an appearance and she will never become human again LMAO

August never killed himself, In fact he no sold gildarts strongest attack, Got back up like nothing after being hit by it. I guess no selling something = dying by your logic? so what if ultear is an old lady? she can only exist when time is stopped thus plot to save the mcs from getting killed by dimaria, Nah, END does not count since natsus demon seed was made by zeref and natsu lost his end form. Gray is the only one in ishgar that can counter invels hax, invel will beat anyone in ishgar except for FH mavis with ice lock. Gajeel stomped bloodman due to plot btws, Mashima restricted him from his hax like macro

Name the better feats that ishgar has then, ishgar only defeated alvarez because alvarez's top wizards killed themselves and zeref died due to love lmao, ishgar mages themselves believed in canon that they stood 0 chance against alvarez. that right there is already a slam dunk for m
Because acnologia was toying with them, Ishgar themselves is afraid of acnologia LMAO, you literally made 0 sense. If acnologia were to try then he would demolish all of ishgar, sorry but none of your fanfic will change that proved by canon
Ok show me ishgar beating 2 nerfed acno tiers oh wait? Dragon Gods? same people who were hiding from acno in a different continent?
Nah, just the DF Demolition Fist that erased Zeref's flesh. Right at the start of the fight. Yeah, a better, bigger version of that erases all spriggans along with the entire army.

Sure, except slash her bleeding guts out lol. Bitch sliced her neck to waist. And that was after busting her ultimate move too. THIS is the woman you're placing all your hopes on lmao?

Literally killed himself. Tried to suicide nuke everyone, fucked even that up. Gildarts attack not only had him screaming and shrieking in pain like a little bitch when he got hit by it, it also literally drove him to suicide.
You said she was dead, she isn't. So what if she can only manifest in time shit? That's her magic. I could easily say that Dimaria having time magic in the first place is just plot. It's all the same.
Course he counts. Natsu sides with Ishgar, he fights for Ishgar, and he took out 3 spriggans plus Zeref for Ishgar.
Literally any top tier FT member low diffs Invel. Erza, Laxus, Natsu, even Mirajane, they all destroy him.
So? He restricted Mirajane from using Macro too lmao.

Oh, sure.
Beating Alvarez
Beating Acno
Beating Dragon Cry
Beating Pheonix
Beating Aldaron
Beating Mercphobia

What's Alvarez's feats?
Beating the GoI and Sting's gang lmao.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
2,144
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Alvarez Beating Natsu, FT, Acno, etc.
 

Hexbend

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
863
Reaction score
1,197
Age
22
Country
United States
That’s not how it works, her magic may not organ bust someone stronger, but increasing her own size increases her stats to match or be stronger. and the only reason why she doesn’t is because she doesn’t have DSM to bypass his magic immunity defenses
You just proved my point............baffling :notlikethis
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
2,144
Country
Imperium of Mankind
You just proved my point............baffling :notlikethis
how? her power increases with size increase. and the only reason she uses Gajeel is because the only thing of value is his DSM attribute, if it is not a dragon but say a god, then the result would be different.
 

Hexbend

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
863
Reaction score
1,197
Age
22
Country
United States
how? her power increases with size increase. and the only reason she uses Gajeel is because the only thing of value is his DSM attribute.
Read what I said, then read what your saying

If you still don't get it, your being willfully ignorant at that point.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
2,144
Country
Imperium of Mankind
Read what I said, then read what your saying

If you still don't get it, your being willfully ignorant at that point.
what you said is not the same as what I said as her power is needed to actually make a noticeable dent in Aldoron for Dragon Slayers via size increase, unless you are going to say base Gajeel regular punches are stronger than Natsu's Fire Dragon King Demolition Fist.
 

Hexbend

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
863
Reaction score
1,197
Age
22
Country
United States
what you said is not the same as what I said as her power is needed to actually make a noticeable dent in Aldoron for Dragon Slayers via size increase, unless you are going to say base Gajeel regular punches are stronger than Natsu's Fire Dragon King Demolition Fist.
reading comprehension :epicfacepalm
 

Hexbend

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2019
Messages
863
Reaction score
1,197
Age
22
Country
United States
answer the question or drop it.
idk how many times, people have disproven you on this, but you still can't comprehend that what your saying supports my stance.

I'll say it again, Brandish doesn't scale to Gajeel's performance against Aldo.
 

WoWfan

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 1, 2016
Messages
6,395
Reaction score
2,144
Country
Imperium of Mankind
idk how many times, people have disproven you on this, but you still can't comprehend that what your saying supports my stance.

I'll say it again, Brandish doesn't scale to Gajeel's performance against Aldo.
nothing was disproven as what you said about Brandish's power is enough to match that of slightly weakened Aldoron, but what's stopping that is his hax magic immunity which is why Gajeel took the stand instead, she does scale as she was the one supplying the power to Gajeel. and considering you don't have an answer, you likely don't have anything else to say.
 
Last edited:

Vex_Haid

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2021
Messages
1,091
Reaction score
240
Country
Canada
"Gildarts attack not only had him screaming and shrieking in pain like a little bitch when he got hit by it, it also literally drove him to suicide."

Not gonna respond to kids post anymore, To much of a mind f*** to even process lmao
 
Last edited:
Top