Team Irene vs Mid Tier Spriggans

[MonkeyD-Dragon]

Irene gets into an argument with mid tier spriggans,they decide to fight it out while August is outside :
Round 1 - Ajeel & God Serena vs Irene
Round 2 - Wahl & Bradman vs Irene
Round 3 - Invel & Dimaria vs Irene
Note : Dimaria can't use Age Seal.
Irene gets healed after each round.
They intend to kill each other,so no tie in this match-up.
Poll info : You get 3 choices for the 3 rounds, one for each round. BUT if you think one side wins all of the rounds,the vote one of the last 2 choices.

 

[Demon Hunter]

Round 1 - Ajeel & God Serena > Irene - low diff = scaling from Erza
Round 2 - Wall & Bradman > Irene - low diff = Bloodman can hold off Irene while Wall charges up his Etherion and blasts her away
Round 3 - Invel & Dimaria > Irene - low diff = Ice lock is enough for this

oh well...

 

[Brandish μ]

Irene wins all.

Round 1 - medium, maybe higher
Round 2 - in between mid-high
Round 3 - low-mid diff

 

[BluePegasus]

1). Irene > Ajeel & God Serena (mid diff)

2). Wall & Bradman > Irene (high diff)

3). Invel & Dimaria > Irene (mid diff)

I guess.

 

[Seven777]

Eileen>Azir & God Serena, high diff.
God Serena is powerful, and can fight Eileen head on for a time. Azir is a bitch to deal with while in Sand World, but in the end they're overwhelmed. She wont be able to hit intangible Azir while God Serena is distracting her, but God Serena wont last long enough to take Eileen out, Azir is then quickly disposed of once Eileen can focus on him.

Wahl & Bradman>Eileen high diff.
Etherion is a big problem, i have it as the strongest spriggan attack at the moment by far. Thats why i usually give Wahl the win in team battles. All he needs is his comrade to distract the opponent for a few seconds so he can charge it. Bradman's a wily bastard and can distract Eileen that long, Overskelter, Tenchi Kami, that final curse i cant remember, all things that are annoying and will wear Eileen down. After Bradman eventually dies Wahl finishes Eileen with Etherion.

Eileen>Invel & Dimaria low-mid diff
Invel is one of the scrubbier spriggans, i mean his offense consists solely of nameless Ice Blasts, as if that shit does anything to Eileen. Ice Armor is useless cause Eileen isnt a melee fighter, and neither is Invel.
Dimaria is better, but not by much, not without Age Seal.
The two of them together can put up a bit of a fight, but Eileen isnt challenged much like she was with the first 2 rounds.

 

[Demon Hunter]

ahem Ice Lock anybody???

Invel might not have big firepower but Ice Lock and Ice Slave are pretty OP.

I don't see a reason why it wouldn't work on Irene.

and Dimaria's beams should pierce her because they are >>> swords.

 

[**Silver**]

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 30, 2016, Original Post Date: Dec 30, 2016 ---

ahem Ice Lock anybody???

Invel might not have big firepower but Ice Lock and Ice Slave are pretty OP.

I don't see a reason why it wouldn't work on Irene.

and Dimaria's beams should pierce her because they are >>> swords.

i cant understand how the hell someone is voting for Irene winning....

Ajeel already overpowered Erza...
Dimaria Wrecked Wendy...

is People thinking that Erza and Wendy is stronger Than (Wahl and Bloodman or God Serena and Ajeel)

 

[Seven777]

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 30, 2016, Original Post Date: Dec 30, 2016 ---

i cant understand how the hell someone is voting for Irene winning....

Ajeel already overpowered Erza...
Dimaria Wrecked Wendy...

is People thinking that Erza and Wendy is stronger Than (Wahl and Bloodman or God Serena and Ajeel)

Its cause Erza ad Wendy havent actually beaten Eileen. Eileen isnt even close to going all out.
Erza and Wendy are only Wahl/Bradman level if they defeat her in an all out fight

 

[Arjuna]

Round 1 - Ajeel & God Serena vs Irene

Irene wins mid to high diff
Round 2 - Wahl & Bradman vs Irene

Irene wins mid diff
Round 3 - Invel & Dimaria vs Irene

Irene wins high diff.


To be honest it would not have mattered if Age Seal was allowed.As Irene>Chronos Age Seal would not have worked on her.


Irene has neither gone all out against Erza and Wendy.Sbe took a direct hit frim Erza without defending.And Wendy is a DS and Emchanter so her current performance is not much unexpected as Irene is a Dragon.

 

[T.C.]

Ajeel>Erza and Serena>>Wendy so the 1st round goes to them.
Irene might win the 2nd round high-diff.
Round 3: Invel locks Irene up (dejavu for Irene) and Dimaria does to her what she was planning to do to Lucy.

 

[TeamWendy]

You guys are aware that Irene stomps them all right?? Since we know that this is "Fairy Tail" the only reason she's having a hard time with Erza and Wendy is because they are GOOD GUYS and FAIRY TAIL MEMBERS and there's no way in Hiro's eyes will an antagonist will be more valuable than good guys. If she will fight the spriggans then she takes it, if she'll lose then it's AGAINST the plot, and we know that Mashima's focal point is "PLOT."

 

[Takuan]

You guys are aware that Irene stomps them all right?? Since we know that this is "Fairy Tail" the only reason she's having a hard time with Erza and Wendy is because they are GOOD GUYS and FAIRY TAIL MEMBERS and there's no way in Hiro's eyes will an antagonist will be more valuable than good guys. If she will fight the spriggans then she takes it, if she'll lose then it's AGAINST the plot, and we know that Mashima's focal point is "PLOT."

Using "plot" in a power thread is counter productive though. Else i'd just argue that Erza can solo Acnologia because the manga proved that she was the PoF Queen and able to win under extreme circumstances thanks to plot (see Erza VS Kyouka or Erza VS Kagura/Minerva).
You just can not use this as an argument. Though i agree with you.

 

[FeatherineAugustusAurora]

Irene clears.

Round 1: Irene wins high diff due to God serena’s slayer advantage but I still see Irene winning this due to superior MP and her showings against Acnologia. Although acno wasn’t serious but so was Irene, but I’m not implying that Irene>Acno. Acno is still much more powerful than Irene. Also, Ajeel’s sand is simply useless against someone who can instantly and easily turn winter into spring. Element magic users are at huge disadvantage against a high enchanter like Irene. Irene low diffs Ajeel and high diffs Serena.

Round 2: Irene stomps. Walh and Bradman are not that impressive and one nuke from dragon Irene will incinerate them. Etherion takes time to cast and since none of them have dragon slayer magic, they wouldn’t do shit to Irene’s dragon form.

Round 3: Irene stomps. Now first off, Invel and Dimaria are Hax af but they lack firepower to take Irene, and Irene having much higher MP and with her enchantment hax, which was already proven when she enchanted neinhart and brandish’s hax didn’t work. So she could easily bypass invel and dimaria’s hax, leaving them to use fire power which could be easily tanked by her dragon form.

Dragon Irene>>God soul>Invel’s ice armor

 

[grey matter]

Round 1:
Spriggans win.
Ajeel would've beat Erza, and human Eileen is Erza tier. Serena > Erza, so there is that. Human Eileen gets mid diff'd
Erza one shotted Dragon Eileen the moment she got DS magic. Serena at most needs two proper shots. Spriggans win this as well

Round 2 and 3:
Dragon Eileen low diffs, nobody has DS magic here. Though human Eileen may get defeated in round 2

 

[sharkai]

1) irene wins mid diff or low diff
2) irene wins mid diff or low diff
3) irene wins mid diff or low diff

The above is only for human irene. Dimeria time seal doesnt matter, it wont work on her

If its dragon irene, she takes all six all at the same time (low diff). With only serena having any chance of scratching her.

 

[Ronin31]

Agree with Sharkai. To compare Spriggan's Tier at Irene/August's Tier is like asking if Elfman or Raijin shuu's tier can compete with Laxus, Erza or Gildarts's tier.

Spriggans are strong but can't compete. It is protrayed like that Irene and August are for above them.
No offense as well for Elfman and Raijin shuu (only exemple because they are in the middle of the Guild Strength), but Laxus, Erza or Gildarts can take them both.

Only analogy.

For me, Irene for the win. Her MP is so above that it can annihilate their and her enchantments are hax. Even without using Dragon Form, I put her for the win.
Only God Serena had a chance to put a decent fight, before falling as well.

 

[grey matter]

1) irene wins mid diff or low diff
2) irene wins mid diff or low diff
3) irene wins mid diff or low diff

The above is only for human irene. Dimeria time seal doesnt matter, it wont work on her

If its dragon irene, she takes all six all at the same time (low diff). With only serena having any chance of scratching her.

Agree with Sharkai. To compare Spriggan's Tier at Irene/August's Tier is like asking if Elfman or Raijin shuu's tier can compete with Laxus, Erza or Gildarts's tier.

Spriggans are strong but can't compete. It is protrayed like that Irene and August are for above them.
No offense as well for Elfman and Raijin shuu (only exemple because they are in the middle of the Guild Strength), but Laxus, Erza or Gildarts can take them both.

Only analogy.

For me, Irene for the win. Her MP is so above that it can annihilate their and her enchantments are hax. Even without using Dragon Form, I put her for the win.
Only God Serena had a chance to put a decent fight, before falling as well.

Injured Erza was fighting almost on par with human Eileen WITHOUT friendship bullshit. No way human Eileen is taking round 1 and round 2. Human Eileen takes round 3 because they're full hax and Eileen's MP >>

Dragon Eileen loses to round 1 because of Serena. Serena > Erza, and Erza with DS magic one shotted dragon Eileen

 

[Ronin31]

For me, by analogy, Eileen is, for the Spriggans, who is Erza for Fairy Tail. The same, August is, for the Spriggans, who is Gildarts for Fairy Tail. Serena, by analogy, is the same as Natsu for Fairy Tail. Natsu can pull a fight against Erza or Laxus's Tier, but for me, they are still above.

God Serena had great portrayal, I like him and like I said, I wanted him a full fight vs Gildarts because they were portrayed as the same deity : the strongest Wizard of Ishgar. Never mind if Serena is above, equal or below Erza. The fact is Erza couldn't compete against Eileen. In the beginning she was toying at her even with Wendy's enchants. You can't compare a full "PoF Erza" to a "normal Erza", the same way as you can't compare "Dragon Force Natsu" to "Basic Natsu". They are not in the same tier.

And then, Erza slashed Irene and dealt unjuries but it was not enough. If she didn't smile, reminding Eileen Maternal's Love, Erza was clearly dead. Erza couldn't win, even with her max Hax level.

They, Eileen and August, are portrayed above the others Spriggans. Jacob, Brandish, Neinhart established that. They are on another level.

But I agree, God Serena had potential to be a super warrior, portrayed as one of the strongest, before being destroyed by Mashima himself. Clear disappointment for me.

 

[sharkai]

Injured Erza was fighting almost on par with human Eileen WITHOUT friendship bullshit. No way human Eileen is taking round 1 and round 2. Human Eileen takes round 3 because they're full hax and Eileen's MP >>

Dragon Eileen loses to round 1 because of Serena. Serena > Erza, and Erza with DS magic one shotted dragon Eileen

actually problem is the name erza. whenever they think of erza they think of a fodder or something.

let me show this from a different perspective
erza is near equal to laxus (no red lightening no enchantment)
so we are gonna replace erza with laxus and see irene feats

normal laxus speed will be equal or below irene, who once stopped erza in mid charge. majority of laxus attack (all the way up to reiko red lightening) will turn into flowers. irene durability is such that an enchanted laxus (boost in speed and power) when striking against distracted irene (irene admiring a nearby loli) will not even move irene.

injured erza just saw wandy fall with horrible wounds, thats pof man. this erza was operating above laxus. and yet, still couldnt get a single hit on irene who has lost her cool (bad guys dont get pof).

now lets talk about her opponents here.
ajeel is fast but he is technically useless, even his sand world wont do anything. wahl is below laxus in cqc, thus even more below irene. serena has no cqc feat. rest are literally non factor. bradman maybe could do something, but irene enchantment will work here fine.

spam. wahl, serena and irene can span. wahl span was better than serena, and irene should span attack faster and harder.

so max difficulty each can give is mid diff (even if you replace serena with gildarts, he still cant do much, gildarts is above laxus, but not that above)

as for dragon weakness. why hasnt gajeel used any dragon slayer spells against aldron yet. if his punches are so effective (aldron face is in the mud at the moment) shouldnt his ds spell one shot this dragon. irene single swipe took out erza. aldron headbutt did nothing to gajeel

 

[Ronin31]

Yeah… If Erza is a problem, as said by Sharkai, you can replace her by Laxus who is in her tier and even Gildarts, slightly above but not so far.

The gap between Eileen and classic Erza was so high, that I think even Gildarts can't compete with Eileen. Eileen was too strong, even for max PoF Erza where she was far above Laxus' Tier (like Dragon Force Natsu is far above Gajeel's Tier for exemple).

But if PoF Amped is also a problem, stop speaking about Erza, and Fairy Tail's characters.

See God Serena and Eileen against the same foe to make an analogy : Acnologia.

No offense for God Serena, strong Spriggan, but when Acno arrived, he was ready to fight but died in less than a second. Acno did only blitz him and stroke him to death by a slap.
Eileen did far more against him. She surprised him by her strength. He asked her her name. He was curious. Agree, Acno was playing but Eileen did the same. She only took mesure of his Legend and knew that he was too strong for her. Man, she did better in their duel than the 7 Dragon Slayers individually.

This analogy showed us the gap between Spriggans Tier like Serena, too strong for classic wizard and Eileen/August's Tier, too strong for the Spriggan's Tier. And finally Acnologia, too strong for August/Eileen's Tier. It is pyramidal