Discussion Lodestar Island x Laugh Tale

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,007
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
Inuarashi pointed out that what Crocus said about the end of the Log Pose conflicts with what they know



According to Crocus, if you simply follow the Log Pose you reach Laugh Tale at the end



However, we learned later that at the end of the Log Pose there's an island called Lodestar Island.

Normally, that's where someone learns about the Poneglyph, and that the red Poneglyph reveal the location of another island.



Looking closely at the image with Crocus, it shows both Lodestar Island and Laugh Tale.

It would seem to reach Laugh Tale, you just have to follow the Log Pose in Lodestar Island.



I think a clue may be in this panel:



Once you follow the four red Poneglyphs, Laugh Tale will pop out of existence, and all you have to do is follow the Log Pose in Lodestar Island?
 

Lord Rayleigh

Intl Translator
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
3,142
Reaction score
4,296
Gender
Male
Country
France
I am not sure to understand what you are saying.

Are you saying that the intersection point from the 4 coordinates mentioned by the Road Poneglyphs is not actually Laugh Tale but a location from where the New World logpose charged at Lodestar will start working?

I like the idea that the logpose from Lodestar needs to be used along with the 4 Road Poneglyphs. That would be a clin d’oeil to Jaya where people were saying the logpose was broken but it was actually working.

However, let’s be realistic here, there is no way the Straw Hat Pirates will ever follow the New World logpose to Lodestar as it would require them to go through many islands from the New World, and the New World trio-log pose probably has loops that prevent from going to Lodestar unless the navigator always choose the good path.

And even if this would be a clin d’oeil to Little Garden where SH Pirates had to use a logpose already charged, I don’t like the idea of SH Pirates needing a logpose from the Roger Pirates who were the first crew to reach Lodestar in centuries.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,007
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
I am not sure to understand what you are saying.

Are you saying that the intersection point from the 4 coordinates mentioned by the Road Poneglyphs is not actually Laugh Tale but a location from where the New World logpose charged at Lodestar will start working?
I'm trying to make sense out of Crocus and Inuarashi seemingly contradictory statements.

I like the idea that the logpose from Lodestar needs to be used along with the 4 Road Poneglyphs. That would be a clin d’oeil to Jaya where people were saying the logpose was broken but it was actually working.

However, let’s be realistic here, there is no way the Straw Hat Pirates will ever follow the New World logpose to Lodestar as it would require them to go through many islands from the New World, and the New World trio-log pose probably has loops that prevent from going to Lodestar unless the navigator always choose the good path.

And even if this would be a clin d’oeil to Little Garden where SH Pirates had to use a logpose already charged, I don’t like the idea of SH Pirates needing a logpose from the Roger Pirates who were the first crew to reach Lodestar in centuries.
I think Laugh Tale is physically located past Lodestar Island, so they have to get there anyway.

There was a timeskip of a few weeks after Thriller Bark, which we didn't get to see what the Straw Hats were up to.
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Inuarashi pointed out that what Crocus said about the end of the Log Pose conflicts with what they know



According to Crocus, if you simply follow the Log Pose you reach Laugh Tale at the end



However, we learned later that at the end of the Log Pose there's an island called Lodestar Island.

Normally, that's where someone learns about the Poneglyph, and that the red Poneglyph reveal the location of another island.



Looking closely at the image with Crocus, it shows both Lodestar Island and Laugh Tale.

It would seem to reach Laugh Tale, you just have to follow the Log Pose in Lodestar Island.



I think a clue may be in this panel:



Once you follow the four red Poneglyphs, Laugh Tale will pop out of existence, and all you have to do is follow the Log Pose in Lodestar Island?
I think it could be a retcon by Oda, or the fact that the wording is ambiguous enough that it's not necessarily explicitly stated here that the last island the log pose gets you to, is Laugh Tale, but that the logs all eventually converge, and the last island itself is Laugh Tale. I think there's some intentional vagueness in how this is worded, as it's definitely not explicitly stated there.

There's two things of interest, IMO:

IIRC Roger said the log-pose (which I believe is magnetic) spins rapidly when on Road Star. This would indicate something funky with the magnetic field on Road Star, and why I'm partial to a theory that an older user of Kidd's fruit (awakened version) used their ability to essentially sever the connection from Load Star to the true final island.

I also think that we will see Road Star, because it's been indicated that while it's not Laugh Tale, it's definitely housing something incredibly interesting. I would imagine that the four Road Poneglyphs are a part of a five piece puzzle, with Road Star itself being the sixth piece. Since Laugh Tale is an island, surrounded by water, I suspect it's hard to find in the OP-verse even with coordinates, or whatever. So I wouldn't be surprised if there's either a log-pose similar to what Robin gave Luffy on Whiskey Peak (which pointed straight to Arabasta) or a location within Road Star itself where the magnet isn't all fucky to set your log-pose correctly, and the poneglyphs simply make a map that points to the location that houses those.

Only time will tell.
 

HereNThere

Alive Ain't Always Livin'
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
8,395
Reaction score
12,211
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Oda did kind of sidestep Crocus' words, but, nothing Crocus said conflicts with what we know. The Log Pose is necessary to traverse the Grand Line, all the islands converge to a single point, and Laugh Tale is the final island on the Grand Line.

Technically, he never implicitly stated that the Log Pose led straight to Laugh Tale. Now, the way he worded it does make it seem like that'd be the case and everyone would be well within their rights to call him an ass for that because that would be the reasonable and obvious assumption given what he said, but he still has plausible deniability.

Oda even addressed that point in the chapter by placing a bit of blame on the crew:



They assumed the converged point would be Laugh Tale, when Crocus never actually said it would be Laugh Tale.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,453
Reaction score
25,024
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
I think oda has used intentionally vague language to keep readers guessing. Oda has been pretty consistent in that he has the ending of one piece planned out, I would assume this includes the details to the end of the strawhat's voyage. I also think there are two other factors that play a role here:

1.- Crocus as a former roger pirate would know everything. He knows that the roger pirates got to laugh tale early and there are people who will come after them. Much like rayleigh knew. Rayleigh offered to tell the strawhats everything but he ultimately left it all for the strawhats to find themselves. Which is presumably more in the spirit of the journey itself. Basically, crocus didn't tell spoilers either. And hoped that if the strawhats were the destined crew or whatever they would also find the answers they need.

2.- Inuarashi doesn't actually know how to get to laugh tale. Oden wasn't clear on the details with anyone. So what we heard from him could easily be incorrect, inaccurate or incomplete. Maybe the 4 red poneglyphs don't point towards laugh tale but rather to the key to getting to laugh tale. A bit of a crackpot theory but maybe the 4 poneglyphs merely point to a location where the log post would lock on to laugh tale.. Somewhere in load star.

In short, crocus knows everything but wasn't telling spoilers and inuarashi is probably not a very reliable source, being both young and absent from the final part of roger's voyage.
 

Lord Rayleigh

Intl Translator
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Aug 20, 2008
Messages
3,142
Reaction score
4,296
Gender
Male
Country
France
The most simple explanation for why Laugh Tale cannot be reachable by logpose is that it does not have any magnetic field which would mean that Laugh Tale came to existence differently from other Grand Line islands. Now that we know that Joy Boy was the previous user of the Hito Hito no Mi model Nika and that we witnessed some of the DF awakened powers, there is a possibility that Laugh Tale was not discovered but created by Joy Boy. He could have stretched some material and things (like the ocean floor, clouds etc…) and fixed them in a location in the middle of ocean. Joy Boy would thus have made his Ancient Kingdom land instead of conquering it from an existing people. This would also make Laugh Tale some unique island within the Grand Line instead of only a difficult place to reach.
 
Last edited:
Top