Canon Lucy vs Brandish

[Darklord#10]

Spoiler

Spoiler

Spoiler

They should be around the same level of power

 

[WoWfan]

actually, the mechanics of it is that the person is too strong that they hate would make them unable to use their powers, so if she doesn hate Brandish, she would still use her powers.

 

[Darklord#10]

actually, the mechanics of it is that the person is too strong that they hate would make them unable to use their powers, so if she doesn hate Brandish, she would still use her powers.

Do you believe gray=natsu?

 

[WoWfan]

Do you believe gray=natsu?

With recent showings, I would not think so.

 

[Darklord#10]

Do you believe gray=natsu?

Shouldn't Lucy be stronger than brandish she has the power to move stars right?

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 3, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 3, 2023 ---

With recent showings, I would not think so.

Wdym you would not think so? It's a simple yes or no.

 

[WoWfan]

Shouldn't Lucy be stronger than brandish she has the power to move stars right?

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 3, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 3, 2023 ---

Wdym you would not think so? It's a simple yes or no.

Like I said, would not think so based on showings, unless you think Gray can defeat a DG. I say this because nothing is Absolutely certain on scaling in this world.

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 3, 2023 ---

Not really as the. Power to move stars came from Gotfried which is a spell that required multiple people to pull that off, not from her own individual strength.

 

[Aniokku]

Lucy wins this, I can't take Brandish seriously when she found herself ridiculed against Neinhart. Let's face it, they can say what they want about Brandish, but she is a character who has never shown anything and who only lives on mashima's statements (like most spriggans). Lucy has already defeated Kyria, who is a much more formidable opponent, it is clear that the fairy princess takes this

 

[LuckSlayer]

If they are of similar strenght because of the rival switch (as of right now), and Brandish can't organ bust... I would still give it to Brandish but mid/highdiff. Why? 'cause even tho Brandish was holding off in x792, Lucy was giving a fight where Brandish herself was bothered to fight back.

It depends on what Lucy shows right now as Brandish and, at the end of day... Command T may be able to take many of her spells to throw them back to Lucy. Let's wait for the next chapters.

 

[Garmadooon]

I voted for Lucy but this can go either way. If she uses Command T better than Brandish she will definitely surpass her and confirm that average Spriggan 12 are powercreeped (only August Irene and GS are relevant)

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 4, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 4, 2023 ---

And lol at those who think Brandish can stomp Lucy. She never stomped anyone in Alvarez and took the most L. I love Brandish but she is overrated.

 

[Darklord#10]

I love Brandish

 

[WoWfan]

Lucy wins this, I can't take Brandish seriously when she found herself ridiculed against Neinhart. Let's face it, they can say what they want about Brandish, but she is a character who has never shown anything and who only lives on mashima's statements (like most spriggans). Lucy has already defeated Kyria, who is a much more formidable opponent, it is clear that the fairy princess takes this

I doubt anything Lucy does would scale to Giant Gajeel who was powered by Brandish who could somewhat hurt a somewhat weakened Aldoron.

 

[Aniokku]

I doubt anything Lucy does would scale to Giant Gajeel who was powered by Brandish who could somewhat hurt a somewhat weakened Aldoron.

Use all the magical power of wizards from an entire continent and lock up Acnologia >>>>>>>>>> make gajeel giant for 5 minutes

 

[WoWfan]

Use all the magical power of wizards from an entire continent and lock up Acnologia >>>>>>>>>> make gajeel giant for 5 minutes

Acno was weakened at that point because of motion sickness. It makes him vulnerable to magic attacks too.

 

[Darklord#10]

5

3

 

[LuckSlayer]

Lucy wins this, I can't take Brandish seriously when she found herself ridiculed against Neinhart. Let's face it, they can say what they want about Brandish, but she is a character who has never shown anything and who only lives on mashima's statements (like most spriggans). Lucy has already defeated Kyria, who is a much more formidable opponent, it is clear that the fairy princess takes this

Im sorry but Lucy defeating Kyria does not mean she can beat Brandish. The thing with this is... All of Fairy Tail was so surprised of Brandish MP in x792, and Gray is saying they got that battle in the bag, means that she's more powerful in x793 (some even are afraid of her still as we saw in Aldoron's arc). Also, we saw her handling a Taurus Form Lucy kick with ease and throw back Aqua Metria (a big AoE spell).

Brandish making Kyria real small would also make her win no/middiff at much. I know people saying that her magic did not work in Neinhart and bla bla bla, but it was because of Irene (and we know for a fact that enchanters are Mashima's way of making impossible possible).

 

[Aniokku]

Acno was weakened at that point because of motion sickness. It makes him vulnerable to magic attacks too.

The dizziness was only momentary, Acnologia got up almost immediately and tried to get out, he succumbed because Meredy came to connect Lucy with all the magicians on the continent, and still, this is a better achievement than what Brandish did with Gajeel

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

Im sorry but Lucy defeating Kyria does not mean she can beat Brandish. The thing with this is... All of Fairy Tail was so surprised of Brandish MP in x792, and Gray is saying they got that battle in the bag, means that she's more powerful in x793 (some even are afraid of her still as we saw in Aldoron's arc). Also, we saw her handling a Taurus Form Lucy kick with ease and throw back Aqua Metria (a big AoE spell).

Brandish making Kyria real small would also make her win no/middiff at much. I know people saying that her magic did not work in Neinhart and bla bla bla, but it was because of Irene (and we know for a fact that enchanters are Mashima's way of making impossible possible).

The difference with Kyria and Brandish, is that Kyria still scratches the level of Laxus and Erza in the current manga, Brandish doesn't.

Mashima's statements about a character's MP level are always empty, we come from an arc where we were given 2 characters that were supposed to be "Gildarts level" and were easily beaten by Erza and Laxus. What does it matter that Gray says that they have the victory assured with Brandish, when it is Natsu who defeated Aldo with one blow


If Brandish couldn't defeat Lucy when she was little, what makes you think she'll defeat Kyria? Let's face it, Kyria would humiliate Brandish without much difficulty, don't forget that Brandish doesn't have any notable achievements in combat, Kyria does.

Now you say that Neinhart was enchanted by Irene and that's why her magic didn't work, but you have to remember that only one blow from Natsu base was enough to defeat him, Brandish is just a smoke seller

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023 ---

3

So people on this forum are praising Brandish for making Gajeel giant for 3 minutes, but ignoring and underestimating that Lucy locked Acnologia in the Fairy sphere?

This is terrible but not surprising, there are people who continue to believe that Irene was at the level of August or Acnologia or that she can defeat Selene

 

[WoWfan]

The dizziness was only momentary, Acnologia got up almost immediately and tried to get out, he succumbed because Meredy came to connect Lucy with all the magicians on the continent, and still, this is a better achievement than what Brandish did with Gajeel

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023, Original Post Date: Sep 5, 2023 ---

The difference with Kyria and Brandish, is that Kyria still scratches the level of Laxus and Erza in the current manga, Brandish doesn't.

Mashima's statements about a character's MP level are always empty, we come from an arc where we were given 2 characters that were supposed to be "Gildarts level" and were easily beaten by Erza and Laxus. What does it matter that Gray says that they have the victory assured with Brandish, when it is Natsu who defeated Aldo with one blow


If Brandish couldn't defeat Lucy when she was little, what makes you think she'll defeat Kyria? Let's face it, Kyria would humiliate Brandish without much difficulty, don't forget that Brandish doesn't have any notable achievements in combat, Kyria does.

Now you say that Neinhart was enchanted by Irene and that's why her magic didn't work, but you have to remember that only one blow from Natsu base was enough to defeat him, Brandish is just a smoke seller

--- Double Post Merged, Sep 5, 2023 ---

So people on this forum are praising Brandish for making Gajeel giant for 3 minutes, but ignoring and underestimating that Lucy locked Acnologia in the Fairy sphere?

This is terrible but not surprising, there are people who continue to believe that Irene was at the level of August or Acnologia or that she can defeat Selene

It still lingers as long as you are on a vehicle, though you could try and fight but it still affects you, in fact you use more effort which makes it hard to move. If it was temporary then he would have just flown up or use Dragon breath. Actually this was Post SBT Acno which makes him vastly stronger than before and other DGs.

 

[Sevently]

Brandish stomps.

 

[Aniokku]

Brandish stomps.

Lucy no diff Aquarios solos

 

[WoWfan]