Discussion Ludociel Abiding in Mael

Admiral Teach

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
1,433
Reaction score
2,073
Country
Water Tribe
First, I apologize for posting this. I resisted the temptation for about ever since the final fight. Part of me rationalized the obvious, that it is not possible, but still... the other half of me won't sit quiet until someone explains for Nakaba:

Why did Mael not just have Ludo use him as a temporary vessel? Mael just lets his dear elder brother fade particle by particle in his arms when he could have him just inhabit his body, or maybe even possess it? You're telling me that Goddesses can inhabit humans, entirely different species, guitars, staves, swords and even giant ugly rock statues, but not members of their own race, including specifically their own blood-brother, about as physically close as possible bar twins? Really?

And we even have a three-headed Goddess with six wings. That's a whole 'nother thread post and entirely rational argument for Fusion-Ha! potential in itself. And more than enough evidence that surely more than one Goddess could inhabit the same body. I mean, if Ludo is literally dead, by all implication, would it not be better in Mael's mind to save him and have him enter his body?

Let's assume combining actually does create a Fusion-Ha scenario with a totally different "person" being born, with no magic power upgrades in this special case with Ludo, given he is only a spirit and temporary particles, not a actually Goddess in the flesh and blood. So that the changes would be unhealthy during combat, with Mael and Ludo vanishing like Cussack and Chandler and becoming someone new, mentally. Is that not better in the mind of Mael, than losing his dearly loved brother?

I mean, all it would have taken is giving them a brief few panels for Mael to say, "Come on, nii-sama! I don't mind if I vanish!", and Ludo replying, "Never! I could never allow myself to be responsible for "changing" you! Even if it means a part of me survives! I'd rather all of me die than only a piece of you live on in the person "we" would become!"

And then of course maybe a very simple and reasonable explanation that normally, sure, it would be a no-brainer, but the Graces wouldn't mix and might kill them both or create a destabiliziation that Demon King-possessed Mel would instantly exploit. That's all that it would take to satisfy me right here. And it can be arguably implied, kind of.

But dang it if it doesn't bother ol' Teach something fierce like an itch in my boots that this was never mentioned once. Ludo is dying right in front of them all and he's just possessed two people, and yet we have a living breathing flesh-and-blood Goddess who is also his closest possible blood kin standing right there, who he loves dearly, and would be in total spiritual sync, if that means anything, and yet nothing's mentioned.

Or hell, why not let him inhabit Elizabeth? He would never dare ask this, obviously, but wouldn't she? She is all up for saving random demons she doesn't know well and pities for their losses but isn't willing to help out a member of her own race? She sure did a lot to help Mael. Nothing for Ludo? Just how much worse is Ludo compared to her dear lover? I mean really? For anyone else sure they might draw a line, but Elizabeth has consistently shown herself to be most forgiving and gentle and willing to help others at need or request. Why not basically order Ludo?

Come on, Nakaba! This is by far not the most glaring flaw in the series ending, but, mechanically, it's a big question mark among many. The fact that it is an overlooked plot hole in a prairie dog convention's worth of plot holes, basically says everything, including why I neglected to bother with this... but I have now. It is out of my system. It will no longer plague my easily distracted mind from now on. I can live my life searching for One Piece and scheming my end of manga triumph in peace now.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
46,474
Reaction score
25,034
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
Good question but unfortunately there aren't any answers, good or otherwise. Up until the moment ludociel "died" I honestly thought that the archangels weren't dead so much as they were simply back in spirit form and their lives could be easily saved by merely inhabiting whatever junk can contain them. Earlier than that I had the crackpot theory that sariel and tarmiel would possess king and diane but that didn't quite pan out either. Anyways, there is no rational explanation to this other than for reasons unknown to us the archangels couldn't simply possess whatever junk or people around once their bodies faded.
 

Admiral Teach

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
1,433
Reaction score
2,073
Country
Water Tribe
Well, it's out of my system now, so it doesn't bother me anymore.
 

Merlin918

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
616
Reaction score
711
Country
United Kingdom
First, I apologize for posting this. I resisted the temptation for about ever since the final fight. Part of me rationalized the obvious, that it is not possible, but still... the other half of me won't sit quiet until someone explains for Nakaba:

Why did Mael not just have Ludo use him as a temporary vessel? Mael just lets his dear elder brother fade particle by particle in his arms when he could have him just inhabit his body, or maybe even possess it? You're telling me that Goddesses can inhabit humans, entirely different species, guitars, staves, swords and even giant ugly rock statues, but not members of their own race, including specifically their own blood-brother, about as physically close as possible bar twins? Really?

And we even have a three-headed Goddess with six wings. That's a whole 'nother thread post and entirely rational argument for Fusion-Ha! potential in itself. And more than enough evidence that surely more than one Goddess could inhabit the same body. I mean, if Ludo is literally dead, by all implication, would it not be better in Mael's mind to save him and have him enter his body?

Let's assume combining actually does create a Fusion-Ha scenario with a totally different "person" being born, with no magic power upgrades in this special case with Ludo, given he is only a spirit and temporary particles, not a actually Goddess in the flesh and blood. So that the changes would be unhealthy during combat, with Mael and Ludo vanishing like Cussack and Chandler and becoming someone new, mentally. Is that not better in the mind of Mael, than losing his dearly loved brother?

I mean, all it would have taken is giving them a brief few panels for Mael to say, "Come on, nii-sama! I don't mind if I vanish!", and Ludo replying, "Never! I could never allow myself to be responsible for "changing" you! Even if it means a part of me survives! I'd rather all of me die than only a piece of you live on in the person "we" would become!"

And then of course maybe a very simple and reasonable explanation that normally, sure, it would be a no-brainer, but the Graces wouldn't mix and might kill them both or create a destabiliziation that Demon King-possessed Mel would instantly exploit. That's all that it would take to satisfy me right here. And it can be arguably implied, kind of.

But dang it if it doesn't bother ol' Teach something fierce like an itch in my boots that this was never mentioned once. Ludo is dying right in front of them all and he's just possessed two people, and yet we have a living breathing flesh-and-blood Goddess who is also his closest possible blood kin standing right there, who he loves dearly, and would be in total spiritual sync, if that means anything, and yet nothing's mentioned.

Or hell, why not let him inhabit Elizabeth? He would never dare ask this, obviously, but wouldn't she? She is all up for saving random demons she doesn't know well and pities for their losses but isn't willing to help out a member of her own race? She sure did a lot to help Mael. Nothing for Ludo? Just how much worse is Ludo compared to her dear lover? I mean really? For anyone else sure they might draw a line, but Elizabeth has consistently shown herself to be most forgiving and gentle and willing to help others at need or request. Why not basically order Ludo?

Come on, Nakaba! This is by far not the most glaring flaw in the series ending, but, mechanically, it's a big question mark among many. The fact that it is an overlooked plot hole in a prairie dog convention's worth of plot holes, basically says everything, including why I neglected to bother with this... but I have now. It is out of my system. It will no longer plague my easily distracted mind from now on. I can live my life searching for One Piece and scheming my end of manga triumph in peace now.
Maybe he can't possess Elizabeth because of her curse? Idk. While with Mael the 2 grace explanation you said makes sense to me. Although in that case, he really could have just asked another human to let him possess them. Ban is one good example who is also already strong. At that rate, there is one way to make it not possible. Maybe the possession done by goddess clan members takes time to do if it's on someone they haven't already possessed. AKA, Fraudrin as a demon can easily re-possess Dreyfus in 1 second, after having made him a vessel for 10 solid years, but against someone a demon or goddess has never possessed before, it takes time to do that, and there just wasn't enough. That's the best I can think of really.
 

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
Theoretically, anyone there in Ludoshel's presence would've been perfectly capable of being his vessel until he manifested his original form.. hell Hendrickson literally offered HIS life for Ludoshel and whilst the AA noted he couldn't use his power to the full whilst in the druid, it was never said that possession itself was impractical.

Mael himself would be the perfect host since he's a blood related Goddess with the rank of an AA. OR Elizabeth whom biologically might be human but has the spirit of a Goddess and should be able to host every Goddess but her mother.

It's Nakaba trying to pull at the heart strings, eventhough any logical person would see through this shitty cover and realise his "death" actually made no sense when there was the perfect solution right there all along next to him.

Sariel & Tarmiel may have been inable to possess Elizabeth, King, Diane, or Gowther due to them being in a fight against Mael... but Ludoshel had no such excuse.
 

Admiral Teach

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
1,433
Reaction score
2,073
Country
Water Tribe
I think Sariel and Tarmiel literally ran instantly out of juice and just... died. There probably wasn't even time for Elizabeth to possess them, given they are tied to their Graces and she like Mel would probably needed a few hours at best to absorb them both at once. One at time, maybe, but there was no such time and a mad, mad Archademon blasting them with weaponized Decrees. It their case, there was just no time and no viable solution that would feasibly work, it seems.

What makes it so ridiculous in hindsight is that I know one of the two mentioned that they would need to find new hosts later before they dissipated... and then Ludo loses his sexy female host and then goes on to just deteriorate even when there was clearly time after Mael came to bring the light of day.

So yes, obviously it was a heartstring pull. But why? Why waste panels on a character needlessly dying when another great character and so happens to be brother is lying in his own blood not fifty feet hence? Why not have Ludo "hibernate" in Mael to recover and then have a scene between Mael "Estarossa" and a dying Zeldoris? Since obviously he understands the concept of brotherhood (and moral decency) that Zeldoris' biological brother very clearly does not possess.

I simply cannot remember a time where I anticipated waiting two weeks just to see a story finally end. Good grief I swear I hope Supreme Deity doesn't just pull herself out of her horn of Cernunnos or whatever and blow up Liones or something. Because I just want to watch Meliodas fade into oblivion so I can forget I read this manga twice. (It was worse second time around. I don't know why this became popular when manwua like Fen Sheng Ji didn't take off. That was one awesome story and very satisfying ending. Had a moral-less protagonist, too)
 

Samael Morningstar

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
4,556
Reaction score
4,471
Age
25
Gender
Male
Country
India
It would have been like two consciousness in one body.
 

Tragicdeath

Banned
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
2,127
Reaction score
1,014
Country
United States
Thats a great question. As a matter of fact this NNTverse has a lot of what if's. It make the readers believe in differnt things in how it suppose to be done which IMO makes this story one of the best shonen. I mean look how the readers interact on the failures of the expectations NS have been doing yet we still follow this NNTverse no matter how shitty it have become. I mean we could have just all leave and unfollow this shitty NNT but still everyone is finishing it up to the end. Thats why I do believe this shonen really is something that makes it beautiful in an ugly way. You just look outside the box to see how great it have become despite it became a shitty shonen.
 

Samael Morningstar

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
4,556
Reaction score
4,471
Age
25
Gender
Male
Country
India
Thats a great question. As a matter of fact this NNTverse has a lot of what if's. It make the readers believe in differnt things in how it suppose to be done which IMO makes this story one of the best shonen. I mean look how the readers interact on the failures of the expectations NS have been doing yet we still follow this NNTverse no matter how shitty it have become. I mean we could have just all leave and unfollow this shitty NNT but still everyone is finishing it up to the end. Thats why I do believe this shonen really is something that makes it beautiful in an ugly way. You just look outside the box to see how great it have become despite it became a shitty shonen.
Well everyone even said fairy tail to be the worst but look at it, even till it's end everyone read it and now everyone is also reading it's sequel 100 years quest. It's not only NNT
 
Top