Discussion luffy=law=kid????

[I Am Atomic]

Before time skip kid had higher bounty but is he stronger than luffy?
Luffy has accomplished more than the other two after all.
Luffy: defeated 2 warlord, beat cp9.....oh thats it
law and kid: beat a pacifista easily and another one came right after that and they might have defeated it as well which SH couldnt do...... thats it.
So who do u think would win if there was a fight between these 3?
I would go for law cuz he has the best power.

 

[seimei]

As far as I can remember, before time skip, someone (i forgot, I guess Hachi or Rayleigh or Shakky) said that Kid's bounty is higher than Luffy because of the casualties Kid brings are higher, and Kid hurts more civilians than Luffy.

If it is rumble between the trio before time skip, I guess Law will win easily with his powers (assuming the three of them have not mastered Haki yet.

If it is after the time skip, I guess it is pretty hard to imagine but I guess Luffy will have the upper hand, since I think in the terms of speed, Luffy is up ahead compared with the metalhand Kidd or Law (except Law uses Shambles a lot which drains lots of his energy.

For the bounties, I guess it should probably like this after Dressrosa:

Law>Kid>Luffy


But I dont really know, Oda hasn't show us much about Kid in the past two years and his character and power development.

 

[I Am Atomic]

As far as I can remember, before time skip, someone (i forgot, I guess Hachi or Rayleigh or Shakky) said that Kid's bounty is higher than Luffy because of the casualties Kid brings are higher, and Kid hurts more civilians than Luffy.

If it is rumble between the trio before time skip, I guess Law will win easily with his powers (assuming the three of them have not mastered Haki yet.

If it is after the time skip, I guess it is pretty hard to imagine but I guess Luffy will have the upper hand, since I think in the terms of speed, Luffy is up ahead compared with the metalhand Kidd or Law (except Law uses Shambles a lot which drains lots of his energy.

For the bounties, I guess it should probably like this after Dressrosa:

Law>Kid>Luffy


But I dont really know, Oda hasn't show us much about Kid in the past two years and his character and power development.

Why is kid and law's bounty greater than luffy's????

 

[Ricko]

I think it depend of the situation.

For me Luffy is the best close combat fighter of the 3 !

Law got the most versatil power but don't seem very usefull against someone strongest

Kidd may have the most destructive one if is power is magnetic power and not only over metal (thinking of Magneto in X-man) he make him nearly invicible in sea against canonball and most ship.

 

[seimei]

That's only my speculation, but i think the two year hiatus has some effect on Luffy. Not to mention he almost always involved in confidential cases..
Here is the cases which is not included into Luffy's Bounty:
- defeating Wapol
- defeating Enel (whom Oda said should have 300.000.000 bounty)
- defeating Moria
- Punk Hazard
He should've been getting 500 mil bounty the first time he went to shabaody island. Not to mention his crew is a handful of disaster. One of them knew the blueprint of Pluton, and the other knows how to activate it. Look how much of a threat they are for the world govt.
But alas, Luffy doesn't show any interest in threating anyone consciously.

Law's bounty stopped as he become a sichibukai, after dressrosa, we might find out what will the govt do to his title.

Differrent from those two, Kidd seem to be the only one who fight ferociously in the new world ever since he got there. They just drowned 2 Big Mom's ship, a nice way to get attention.
I think an active Kidd should have a higher bounty than the other who is not as active as him.

But after Luffy fight a yonkou, i guess it will change into Luffy>Kidd>Law

 

[M3J]

It's unknown. Luffy likely would beat them in a fight, but then there's Law's devil fruit to think of, as well as Kidd's love for carnage and ability to fight. He likely has or can make weapons that can hurt Luffy and Law.

 

[lildeboe16]

I feel like Kidd is just going to show up to be a power house capable of fighting luffy

 

[Kaishaku]

I love how everyone just ignores that he haven't seen anything Kid did, give or take a bit of showing off.

 

[TitaniumOxide]

I think law will win if it is a 1vs1vs1. Exchange hearts, room, shambles, then use mes, steal the hearts and bam he win. If it is a 1vs1 with luffy law cannot trade hearts so he will have to deal with luffys speed. In this case I think he will lose, all luffy has to do is figure him out, how his powers work and after some blood luffy will win. Law vs kidd though or luffy vs Kidd I cannot say. We haven't seen him do shit for a while. For all we know killer might be the real boss. Killer seems to be more calm and collected anyways.

 

[Freid]

I feel like Kidd is just going to show up to be a power house capable of fighting luffy

I hope so. I think Kidd's ability lends itself better to haki reinforcement than Law's ability does, so he has more progressive potential and might make a better rival for Luffy.

 

[I Am Atomic]

I think law will win if it is a 1vs1vs1. Exchange hearts, room, shambles, then use mes, steal the hearts and bam he win. If it is a 1vs1 with luffy law cannot trade hearts so he will have to deal with luffys speed. In this case I think he will lose, all luffy has to do is figure him out, how his powers work and after some blood luffy will win. Law vs kidd though or luffy vs Kidd I cannot say. We haven't seen him do shit for a while. For all we know killer might be the real boss. Killer seems to be more calm and collected anyways.

Are you kidding me?

---------- Post added at 11:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:16 AM ----------

How will luffy fight against law if he is cut in half? There is no way luffy can stop laws sword with haki cuz law even cut full metal vergo!!!!

 

[seimei]

[/COLOR][/B][/U]

Are you kidding me?

---------- Post added at 11:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:16 AM ----------

How will luffy fight against law if he is cut in half? There is no way luffy can stop laws sword with haki cuz law even cut full metal vergo!!!!

Ikr, Luffy will use his speed to avoid Law's room and if Law is clever enough to see it, he will change place with kid to receive Luffy's redhawk.
When its 1 vs 1 law x luffy, i hope luffy will manage to give law his jet gatling before law makes any room.

Altough i dont know much of Kidd's development. He will be extremely had to fight if for example he can control iron in human blood. (Hoho)

 

[Holt]

law and kid: beat a pacifista easily and another one came right after that and they might have defeated it as well which SH couldnt do...... thats it.

About the pacifista, the SH's did take it down (zoro was also badly injured remember). The had to take on an admiral, sentomaru and a couple other pacifista's right after. They were way outta their league there. Same would have happened to Kidd and Law.

Law's room is certainly hax, but the thing is when he cuts things, its like division and not zoro (or normal swordsman) bloody cutting and all. Luffy and Kidd both have kinda counters to that. Luffy stretches (he could reach out and re attach his other parts), Kidd is metallic, atleast he could form a makeshift mecha body. Assuming Law manages to cut them anyway.
Law would be first to fall IMO. His abilities require too much stamina and he's physical abilities wouldn't match up here if he runs outta juice.
I don't know how much Kidd can do, but given luffys 'can't give up' attitude, I'll give this to him.
Law starts out basically pushing the others while they adapt to the conditions, then Kidd takes over while laws stamina drops, luffy is usually slow to get into gear in fights so he'll be last to come up and push the other two. Then he slightly manages a win.

Simply put, I think it would be average fight all round without anyone getting too much of an edge but luffy wins because he outlasts them I think.

 

[TitaniumOxide]

[/COLOR][/B][/U]

Are you kidding me?

---------- Post added at 11:18 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:16 AM ----------

How will luffy fight against law if he is cut in half? There is no way luffy can stop laws sword with haki cuz law even cut full metal vergo!!!!

This is good logic but there must be some kind of hindrance we do not yet know of. I mean there has to be some kind of limit because going by your logic, law can just finish Doflamingo the same way right? He instead got trashed thus far by mingo. Law's ability is a strong one but Luffy is fast as hell, he only need to zip out of law's room. Remember everytime he uses his sphere it drains energy.

And I am not kidding about killer seeming more calm and collected thus far. Wasn't he the one who told the 3 captains to calm down during their alliance chat? He was having this /facepalm moment going wow these guys are so hotheaded and immature they cannot even sit down and just talk calmly.

 

[lildeboe16]

I think nobody can really make a heads or tails about any of these three fighting capabilities until this arc is over but we would still only know about Law and Luffy.
The simple fact of Kidds crew is that we know next to nothing about what they can do and the crew structure. But I do know that we cant gauge Kidds fighting capabilities when we havent seen him yet so Kidd could very well be shown as a very difficult Rival to Luffy in the future.
Now with Law fighting DD which resulted in a very tragic defeat and Luffy being DDs next oppent. I think we can then gauge the vaule of Law's fight capabilities if "Luffy can just absolute destroy DD or it becoming a fight like Rob Lucci where he was pushed to his absolute limit." So if DD is shown to be a pushover or a man capable of being a worthy oppent. We can then start ranking where Law would fall in ranks of fighting capabilities between Luffy and Kidd(who we know next to nothing about). So only after this arc can we start placing ranks on these Three SNs.