Luffy vs. Zoro! Who would win?

Naruffy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2009
Messages
783
Reaction score
317
Gender
Male
Country
United States
If you really think Zoro would beat Luffy then I feel sorry for you. Would he really deserve the title of captain if he would loose in a fight to his second mate? Zoro strong, I don't deny that, but in a fight against Luffy he would get beaten. Oh, and Gear 2 increases power and speed, while Gear 3 reduce speed but gives much greater power than in Gear 2.

luffy has the advantage having been rubber but if he wasnt rubber hell be weaker than sanji

Rubber makes him more durable, but if he wasn't rubber I'm sure he'd be as durable as Zoro. When you think about it wouldn't Luffy's punches be stronger if he wasn't rubber? By this I mean that isn't bone harder than rubber?
 

WhiTeBearÐ

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Apr 25, 2007
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Age
41
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Hi Guys =)

Thats a great discussion about my absolute favourite One Piece character:
Roronoa Zoro :)

In my opinion, Luffy is stronger. Not because of his "über" abilities, but rather because he has to be stronger. He is the captain, he must protect his crew, a captain must always be the "best" crew member otherwise it would be senseless to be the captain if your crew members out classes you in every aspect.

If we would assume that Luffy wouldn´t be the captain or zoro would still be a pirate hunter, then it would be a damn close fight. Both are outstanding and surely count to the strongest fighters in One Piece.

In regard to the crew ranking:

1. Luffy as Captain
1.5 Zoro as the second crew member and the strongest after luffy.
.
.
.
.
.
the others ^^
 

El-Thor

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Messages
455
Reaction score
110
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Actually, Luffy and Zoro are probably on the same level as far as pure strength goes. Zoro is probably even stronger. Plus, Zoro has a HUGE advantage being a sword user.
 

Captain golddigger

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2010
Messages
116
Reaction score
47
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Whhaaaat....luffy is hell alot stronger than zoro!!( Brute strength) but a battle between them would be pretty close....with zoro's skill with his swords damn...idk who'd win...and their will to fight on...now i definitely don't know.
 

DutchPhoenix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
651
Reaction score
86
Gender
Hidden
Country
Netherlands
sadly Oda said they had the same combat power and are totally equal in strenght when you could ALL of their abilities they still on par :(
 

St Michael

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2010
Messages
166
Reaction score
34
Age
36
Gender
Male
Country
France
sadly Oda said they had the same combat power and are totally equal in strenght when you could ALL of their abilities they still on par :(
I think it's no longer the case though.
Oda stated this before Enies Lobby didn't he ?
 

vollfied

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Mar 8, 2008
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Age
38
Gender
Male
Country
Indonesia
I think it's no longer the case though.
Oda stated this before Enies Lobby didn't he ?
Yes, I think I heard of this too. On the sbs or something?

I still think that even on Enies Lobby they both are roughly on the same level. Remember that Luffy didn't equal Lucci on the battle, Luffy had a big problem with Lucci and even got defeated once before coming back up.

Zoro and Sanji fight with someone only half as strong but they didn't have as many hard times. Considering that on Marinford arc, Luffy (though gaining battle experience) did not gain additional power, they must be on roughly the same level before time skip.

So I think just like in crocodile case, enel case and lucci case. Luffy win mostly because of his spirit to protect his friend. Wonder if that will present against zoro.

So my point is, either they are the same (pre time-skip) or luffy is a little bit stronger (because well he is the captain, more battle experience, and has defeated more stronger bad guys).
 

buzz_off

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Dec 13, 2007
Messages
20
Reaction score
0
Age
44
Gender
Male
Country
Saudi Arabia
Hi all
I go with Ero-Sanji:
Luffy's weakness isn't swords it's just that his body reacts the same way ours would against swords. He's natural weakness would be heat/fire and cold/ice.

Now those of you who say that Zoro is stronger than Luffy physically I'll have to disagree.

Luffy broke the nose that Zoro presumably even at 100% couldn't break even when using his swords.

Luffy could shatter steel long before Zoro could cut it and we all know that when Zoro cuts metal he's not using brute strength but the opposite. To date I still doubt Zoro could break metal bare-handed.

Zoro carried a building, Luffy did this: http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/209/20/.

To top that Luffy carried a ball approximately 10 times his size, swung it around a lot and finally struck it so hard against Enel shattering it in the process.

In terms of physical power Luffy wins imo.


From the beginning Luffy is the strongest among of them (Luffy in higher and different level); then come Zoro and after him come Sanji.

Luffy always fight enemies stronger than their enemies; Luffy's enemy have double strength of of Zoro and Sanji enemies.

Luffy have to become strongest to protect his crew.

Luffy learned under Reylagh: he learned all colors of haki.

After he trained by Reylagh he is far stronger than Zoro; He have to beat the strongest to be the PK.
 

Aoko Aozaki

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Jul 22, 2010
Messages
57
Reaction score
17
Age
37
Gender
Male
Country
Belgium
Hi all
I go with Ero-Sanji:
Luffy's weakness isn't swords it's just that his body reacts the same way ours would against swords. He's natural weakness would be heat/fire and cold/ice.

Now those of you who say that Zoro is stronger than Luffy physically I'll have to disagree.

Luffy broke the nose that Zoro presumably even at 100% couldn't break even when using his swords.

Luffy could shatter steel long before Zoro could cut it and we all know that when Zoro cuts metal he's not using brute strength but the opposite. To date I still doubt Zoro could break metal bare-handed.

Zoro carried a building, Luffy did this: http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/209/20/.

To top that Luffy carried a ball approximately 10 times his size, swung it around a lot and finally struck it so hard against Enel shattering it in the process.

In terms of physical power Luffy wins imo.


From the beginning Luffy is the strongest among of them (Luffy in higher and different level); then come Zoro and after him come Sanji.

Luffy always fight enemies stronger than their enemies; Luffy's enemy have double strength of of Zoro and Sanji enemies.

Luffy have to become strongest to protect his crew.

Luffy learned under Reylagh: he learned all colors of haki.

After he trained by Reylagh he is far stronger than Zoro; He have to beat the strongest to be the PK.
Yeah,but Zoro has(or have?) 3 swords!Even the badass Dante originally is using only 1 sword.
Edit:
Rubber makes him more durable, but if he wasn't rubber I'm sure he'd be as durable as Zoro. When you think about it wouldn't Luffy's punches be stronger if he wasn't rubber? By this I mean that isn't bone harder than rubber?
There are different types of rubber.Try one punch on EPDM Rubber.Or even if you punch any kind of rubber its most likely that you will take more damage than the rubber itself.
 
Last edited:

WhiTeBearÐ

Registered User
初心者/ Shoshinsha / Beginner
Joined
Apr 25, 2007
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Age
41
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Hi all
I go with Ero-Sanji:
Luffy's weakness isn't swords it's just that his body reacts the same way ours would against swords. He's natural weakness would be heat/fire and cold/ice.

Now those of you who say that Zoro is stronger than Luffy physically I'll have to disagree.

Luffy broke the nose that Zoro presumably even at 100% couldn't break even when using his swords.

How was zoro supposed to do it ? He suffered from a terrible wound he got during his fight with mihawk...a normal person would have died or would be several months lieing in a bed, yet he still fought!!


Luffy could shatter steel long before Zoro could cut it and we all know that when Zoro cuts metal he's not using brute strength but the opposite. To date I still doubt Zoro could break metal bare-handed.

Well, zoro can shatter steel to if its 1mm thick :roll: ...can you post the chapter where luffy shattered steel ? (onemanga doesnt host manga´s anymore...btw.)


Zoro carried a building, Luffy did this: http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/209/20/.

To top that Luffy carried a ball approximately 10 times his size, swung it around a lot and finally struck it so hard against Enel shattering it in the process.

He only made use of his devil fruit and the physical aspects coming along with it. ;)

In terms of physical power Luffy wins imo. Dont think so, zoro managed to deflect several attacks from Oz, luffy could do it only through his -pimp-up-shadown-version-, even sanji deflected an attack of oz


From the beginning Luffy is the strongest among of them (Luffy in higher and different level); then come Zoro and after him come Sanji.
Thats true, because luffy is the captain and its only natural for the captain to be the strongest

Luffy always fight enemies stronger than their enemies; Luffy's enemy have double strength of of Zoro and Sanji enemies.

Thats not exaclty true...

Luffy have to become strongest to protect his crew.
True

Luffy learned under Reylagh: he learned all colors of haki.

After he trained by Reylagh he is far stronger than Zoro; He have to beat the strongest to be the PK. Did you forgot who trained zoro ? the strongsest swordsman in whole OP at that moment...i believe, zoro is now able to fight and beat devil fruit users with similar body aspects like crocodile, aokiji, kizaru (logia users...) And, no one nows what happed to his eye...maybe he got some sharingan like eye (power) ^^
just my 2 cents
 

LnDRash

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2009
Messages
2,443
Reaction score
2,646
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Rubber makes him more durable, but if he wasn't rubber I'm sure he'd be as durable as Zoro.
I highly doubt this...

After his fight with Moria Luffy passed out from exhaustion. Zoro, who himself was also in very bad shape at that time, took in all of Luffys pain and exhaustion from that fight and was still standing.

IMO its pretty save to say Zoro is superior in terms of pain tolerance and stamina.
 

Dice

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2007
Messages
536
Reaction score
109
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Pre timeskip I'd definitely agree that Zoro has a higher natural pain tolerance at least as long it's about an attack that ignores the rubber-properties. I think that's quite logical since many times Luffy receives a punch etc. the pain is lowered by his rubberbody.
You could notice that he is quite surprised when he is hit by punch that ignores his rubberbody.

I believe that Luffy trained a lot with Rayleigh and received a lot of these "rubber-piering"-punches so that his pain-tolerance grew a lot.

Pre timeskip I'd say that a fight could go either way. Luffy having the upperhand in terms of power and speed and Zoro having the advantage because of his swords (please notice that I didn't say that Luffy is weak against swords (well at least not weaker than any normal person^^)).
Pre timeskip and without the gears I'd say that Luffy is little bit faster than Zoro and that they are equal in terms of raw power. Using the gears the difference in speed gets bigger and Luffy gains the upperhand in rawpower but since Zoro is no pushover I guess it still could go both ways depending on the situation and luck.
 

Naruffy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2009
Messages
783
Reaction score
317
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Zoro's a beast, I don't doubt that, but saying he could beat Luffy in a fight just dosen't work. Regardless of who is more durable, Luffy is that captain, and if the captain can't beat his on of his own crew mates then he dosen't deserve to be captain.

I highly doubt this...

After his fight with Moria Luffy passed out from exhaustion. Zoro, who himself was also in very bad shape at that time, took in all of Luffys pain and exhaustion from that fight and was still standing.

IMO its pretty save to say Zoro is superior in terms of pain tolerance and stamina.
Luffy is rubber, so he has a natural defence to most attacks, so he dosen't have to worry about pain and exhaustion. If Luffy wasn't he's have to have some other way to be strong, and would have to become naturaly durable.
 
Last edited:

Navid.

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2006
Messages
216
Reaction score
18
Age
42
Gender
Male
Country
Iran
Regardless of who is more durable, Luffy is that captain, and if the captain can't beat his on of his own crew mates then he dosen't deserve to be captain.
Don't agree with this at all, strength should have no bearing on who can be a captain or not... Leadership, ambition and caring for your crew is what counts.

As far as Luffy vs Zoro goes, they are by far the two most natural combat centric characters of the crew, and both have goals centred around becoming as powerful as possible during their journey.

I think the difference between them is so small that any fight between them has the possibility to go either way, and no matter who wins the other will sustain some serious injuries.
 

Naruffy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2009
Messages
783
Reaction score
317
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Don't agree with this at all, strength should have no bearing on who can be a captain or not... Leadership, ambition and caring for your crew is what counts.

As far as Luffy vs Zoro goes, they are by far the two most natural combat centric characters of the crew, and both have goals centred around becoming as powerful as possible during their journey.

I think the difference between them is so small that any fight between them has the possibility to go either way, and no matter who wins the other will sustain some serious injuries.
A captain is supposed to the leader of the crew, but is also supposed to be the strongest. What good is a captain if he's weaker than his crew? Clearly those who stand at the top of the One Piece world are the strongest and have the greatest ambition.

Luffy realised that while having ambition and caring for your crew is needed to be a great captain, so is strength. He was separated from his crew because he wasn't strong enough to beat an opponent. After that Luffy decided he needed to be stronger than everyone in order to protect his crew and realize his ambition.

Kind of wandered off my point but basically, IMO, Luffy needs to be stronger than Zoro because being a captain in a pirate world isn't just about being caring towards your crew or being a good leader. Most of the strongest captains in the One Piece world are known and feared for their strength, not their compassion towards their crew.
 

El-Thor

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Messages
455
Reaction score
110
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It's not always about being the strongest. You have to have heart, compassion, leadership skill and loooooooooooooooooove.

Besides, every SH has their own unique power and ALMOST everyone on the crew can beat the others.
 

Naruffy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2009
Messages
783
Reaction score
317
Gender
Male
Country
United States
It's not always about being the strongest. You have to have heart, compassion, leadership skill and loooooooooooooooooove.

Besides, every SH has their own unique power and ALMOST everyone on the crew can beat the others.
In this manga it is, since Luffy can't get to the without being the strongest. Or will he be able to beat BB with love, and compassion?

I'm not saying that strength is all that matters, I'm just saying that it's important since Luffy needs to be strong to achieve his goal of becoming Pirate King, we all know he had the other quality's to begin with.

I just think that if Zoro was capable of beating Luffy, he wouldn't of joined him or he would've continued bounty hunting.
 
Last edited:

Dice

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jan 7, 2007
Messages
536
Reaction score
109
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
Germany
Well he should be the strongest in a sense but that doesn't mean that he could lose against someone of his crew - depending on the circumstances. With Zoro it's such a close call (in my opinion) that it could go either way.
Sometime a person has an powerful ability but still isn't the strongest. If you take a look at perona and who defeated her you will know what I mean. That time Ussop was the strongest in a sense^^.

Furthermore how could he know if he can beat him if there was never a real fight. As long as he respects Luffy because of his strenght and his will he'll follow him...that's all that's matters to him.
 

El-Thor

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 7, 2007
Messages
455
Reaction score
110
Gender
Male
Country
United States
In this manga it is, since Luffy can't get to the without being the strongest. Or will he be able to beat BB with love, and compassion?

I'm not saying that strength is all that matters, I'm just saying that it's important since Luffy needs to be strong to achieve his goal of becoming Pirate King, we all know he had the other quality's to begin with.

I just think that if Zoro was capable of beating Luffy, he wouldn't of joined him or he would've continued bounty hunting.
This is off topic though. I'm not saying it doesn't matter if he is weak or not in the World. Of course it matters. I was talking about being the strongest in the crew is not a prerequisite for being captain. Robin can EASILY beat everyone in the crew, including Luffy. But does she kick everyone's ass and become captain? Nope, because she has her own goals and because the mangaka doesn't want her to.

People join Luffy because the guy has some sort of stupid/brave aura around him. His crew is full of dreamers and he is the biggest dreamer of them all.
 

Naruffy

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2009
Messages
783
Reaction score
317
Gender
Male
Country
United States
This is off topic though. I'm not saying it doesn't matter if he is weak or not in the World. Of course it matters. I was talking about being the strongest in the crew is not a prerequisite for being captain. Robin can EASILY beat everyone in the crew, including Luffy. But does she kick everyone's ass and become captain? Nope, because she has her own goals and because the mangaka doesn't want her to.

People join Luffy because the guy has some sort of stupid/brave aura around him. His crew is full of dreamers and he is the biggest dreamer of them all.
I said in my previous post I was going of topic by saying that. Zoro is strong, and he recognizes that Luffy is also a strong and at a level greater than or equal to himself IMO, because of this, and Luffy's personality, goal and such Zoro stays with the crew. Robin is another topic I disagree with but I don't want to go into. Buggy's the only captain I've seen (or can think of) in One Piece that is weaker than his crew. I'm trying the say that being the strongest in the crew is a prerequisite because it makes no sense to recruit people that you could be beaten by, how can you lead people as a pirate that you yourself can't beat? I won't go on after this, since we could go on forever.

I understand that Zoro isn't weak to be 1-hit K-O'd by even a Gear 2 Luffy. In my opinion they're even only when Luffy is in his normal state. If Luffy were to go Gear 2 however, I don't think Zoro would be able to win.
 
Top