Games Mafia Game 108 - Mob Psycho 100 (75%)

[Crescent Jinx]

This is on discord but will put here too.

 

[Baka Taichou]

Ah why did I get a penalty vote btw I voted and I posted more than three times yesterday

who would you vote for today marm?

making a list

 

[Marmalade]

who would you vote for today marm?

making a list

Undecided yet, going to get back on this after I'm fully caught up (doing a full reread bc my work break speed read probably made me miss a lot of things)

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 13, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 13, 2022 ---

*of the day, not the whole thread

 

[GrySun]

Given Demon was mafia, we are looking at potentially 5 mafias still. 2 of Demon‘s team and 3 of the Janitor team.

By PoE it should be among Kat, GB, Shijima, Brandish, Wojack, Raven. I find it hard to believe that lynching in this group could go wrong.

Some of the people not listed here that could be scum:
Holt/DD - imo Apprentices were claimed too early to be some fake, and are more likely Insane to add to mafia numbers so not a threat yet. There‘s a chance one of them was really just bold and lied to make decent cover.

Erin/Farf - singling them out because they have some strange secondary. Erin could be from either team as either team would know Demon‘s role, and Farf could be the deep wolf just for the sake of there being one, but are both more likely town. Unless mafias got 2 special secondaries while town started with the pgo/potato.

Baka - could be faking Necro, but with Spy dead now it‘s largely a dead-end claim. Sam said he was blocked N1, and with nobody claiming Prostitute they may have been blocked by the same Escort. Claim is too spicy I think to be done by a person that saw her mafia team is small meaning 2 mafia teams, so Baka should be town.

Marma is too confirmable to be mafia.

To conclude, it‘s not looking very promising for us that there‘s so many potential scum remaining, but I feel the group of 6 above is currently far more likely scum than the names below.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 13, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 13, 2022 ---

Actually, could it just be 1 mafia while the SK is given some 1-time Janitor secondary?

 

[Baka Taichou]

Given Demon was mafia, we are looking at potentially 5 mafias still. 2 of Demon‘s team and 3 of the Janitor team.

By PoE it should be among Kat, GB, Shijima, Brandish, Wojack, Raven. I find it hard to believe that lynching in this group could go wrong.

Some of the people not listed here that could be scum:
Holt/DD - imo Apprentices were claimed too early to be some fake, and are more likely Insane to add to mafia numbers so not a threat yet. There‘s a chance one of them was really just bold and lied to make decent cover.

Erin/Farf - singling them out because they have some strange secondary. Erin could be from either team as either team would know Demon‘s role, and Farf could be the deep wolf just for the sake of there being one, but are both more likely town. Unless mafias got 2 special secondaries while town started with the pgo/potato.

Baka - could be faking Necro, but with Spy dead now it‘s largely a dead-end claim. Sam said he was blocked N1, and with nobody claiming Prostitute they may have been blocked by the same Escort. Claim is too spicy I think to be done by a person that saw her mafia team is small meaning 2 mafia teams, so Baka should be town.

Marma is too confirmable to be mafia.

To conclude, it‘s not looking very promising for us that there‘s so many potential scum remaining, but I feel the group of 6 above is currently far more likely scum than the names below.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 13, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 13, 2022 ---

Actually, could it just be 1 mafia while the SK is given some 1-time Janitor secondary?

you forget Nat claimed spy too, so she can check me out anytime

 

[ShijimaTheSilentMan]

So guys I can reveal something, Demon was mafia doctor. I had one use investigator as a secondary role hence my hint (see double avy = double role)


Amazing that none of the killing parties targeted our necromancer who could secure a spy role

Are you a detective?

 

[GrySun]

Brandish was kinda calm about me saying I‘d kill him, but I‘m still unsure whether that‘s more a town or mafia Brandish reaction. Either way I‘m killing him if I get lynched, if not I‘m cursing other people from that batch of 6.

 

[Farfalla]

Erin/Farf - singling them out because they have some strange secondary. Erin could be from either team as either team would know Demon‘s role, and Farf could be the deep wolf just for the sake of there being one, but are both more likely town. Unless mafias got 2 special secondaries while town started with the pgo/potato.

Just a comment here that I didn't have to come out of my way to mention my secondary like that, not sure that's what a scum would do after seeing another in the same situation that could be even a part of the Janitor team. Sure, I expected there would be more and question why only us, but maybe some just didn't mention, maybe those are to complicate the Psy with the traitor, idk. I'll admit maybe I'm being hasty on believing Erin is town cause of that, just don't think her playstyle is her hesitant scum self either.

 

[GrySun]

you forget Nat claimed spy too, so she can check me out anytime

you forget she‘s claiming Paranoid Spy, her results aren‘t gonna be useful. For Necro she wouldn‘t see you target dead players but living players anyway.

 

[ShijimaTheSilentMan]

Scenario 1 sane and insane apprentice

Scenario 2 someone is liar.

Gry herself is a liar and you can't see that. But I'm the only one saying this, you don't believe me.

 

[Baka Taichou]

you forget she‘s claiming Paranoid Spy, her results aren‘t gonna be useful. For Necro she wouldn‘t see you target dead players but living players anyway.

she said either she's paranoid or DD lied about his target.

 

[Crescent Jinx]

also I think someone else voted Gry, not sure if before or after me

There was another vote that I saw but that person is sick today. But I will check again to see if someone else besides Wojak

 

[Raven]

ah sorry I thought I did, it is odd, I personally saw that as a language barrier sort of thing (mostly because I didn't rly understand it)

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 13, 2022, Original Post Date: Dec 13, 2022 ---

agreed, my main sus since D1
agreed, my main sus since D1
disagreed, this is how she played every game we were in together don't remember her ever changing playstyles, though she did deceive me one time when she was santa and had my back throughout the game ;-; /trauma. But yea, I can't agree based of just that.

not to mention i'm main reason you are still alive now. My vote lock on grysun last min saved you

 

[Farfalla]

you forget she‘s claiming Paranoid Spy, her results aren‘t gonna be useful. For Necro she wouldn‘t see you target dead players but living players anyway.

On that note...

In the past, paranoid spies would ALWAYS get a result, no? Didn't we change that later? So it would match the sane one and only show a random result when the sane would get a real one? Gonna even ask Hardy on that.

 

[Raven]

specially after the necromancer claim.

 

[Farfalla]

not to mention i'm main reason you are still alive now. My vote lock on grysun last min saved you

As if mafia wouldn't favor from getting on a townie good' side if that's the case '_'

 

[Raven]

As if mafia wouldn't favor from getting on a townie good' side if that's the case '_'

explain how saving a good role like necromancer is mafia favor.

 

[GrySun]

On that note...

In the past, paranoid spies would ALWAYS get a result, no? Didn't we change that later? So it would match the sane one and only show a random result when the sane would get a real one? Gonna even ask Hardy on that.

Idk about past but now Paranoid Spy sees no action if target does nothing. Are you saying if Kat was lying she‘d make a mistake thinking Paranoid Spy always gets a result, and this means she is legit?

 

[ShijimaTheSilentMan]

@Crescent Jinx get well soon.

 

[Farfalla]

explain how saving a good role like necromancer is mafia favor.

She could only get BG back then which at best would kill her anyways, plus can be killed later on. Wasn't a threat at the time and now we even see that with a Spy she gets blocked. Meanwhile mafia could do what you're doing: make it look like you're an ally

 

[Raven]

Farfalla projecting at this point.