Games MAFIA GAME 19 END!

[kkck]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I am at a loss now, I have no idea of who to vote for. In my defense wizzard did seem to go out of his way to make himself appear suspicious though. I still can't believe he was telling the truth though. I also can't believe nichan did not even bother to at least deny the contact he had with wizzard to some extent so to at least appear less suspicious either.

So maybe mazino is a mafia and you guys were right? Or maybe benelori is and the whole thing about him being a whore and protecting others is a cover? I mean, we have no way to confirm that he actually protected someone and if they are mafia they could simply pretend. There is no guarantee that any given role will be here right? Or maybe the inactive ones are just watching us tear each other apart.

 

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I tried protecting Hardy last night. Didn't work out as well as I hope it would.

If that's true then you're possibly insane, you might even be the one who killed him and the mafia kill failed for some reason.

so wizzard was telling the truth :/ ...didnt expect that coming
it is like u say niichan,hardys dead makes bene less suspicious,but what if that was the plan????i thought shin could be the sickly townie,but that could be unlikely if bene is speaking the truth which i have to consider as truth too(so50/50),cuz i was too persisitent before,when i didnt believe wizz at all....also now u and kkck r suspicious too(as the numbers r decreasing), i guess one of u is mafia and one could be the sickly townie..

Yes, it could have been his plan too. Or like I mentioned above they didn't even plan to kill Hardy, who knows.

Bene claims to be the prostitute though, that's a different role from the sickly townie. Prostitute blocks night actions while the sickly townie blocks day actions.

Everyone is suspicious at this point, what sucks is that I can't judge anyone besides bene, kkck and you (a bit), the rest practically says nothing. This makes the game incredibly dull and boring + very hard to actually figure out the mafia members. It's not impossible that they the two remaining ones are among the active people but I would guess it's likely that at least one inactive one is a mafia =/

I'm not sure about you (don't know enough about you) and bene (still kinda doubt him), kkck appeared to be someone who's trying really hard to find the culprit but I don't know enough about him either to make a final judgement.

At this point I honestly would prefer killing off the inactive ones because there's no point in keeping them if they just make one or two posts each day. Or DD is starting to be more strict because of this goes on all the active people will die while the inactive ones practically do nothing and prolong the game unnecessarily.

---------- Post added at 06:06 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:00 PM ----------

I am at a loss now, I have no idea of who to vote for. In my defense wizzard did seem to go out of his way to make himself appear suspicious though. I still can't believe he was telling the truth though. I also can't believe nichan did not even bother to at least deny the contact he had with wizzard to some extent so to at least appear less suspicious either.

So maybe mazino is a mafia and you guys were right? Or maybe benelori is and the whole thing about him being a whore and protecting others is a cover? I mean, we have no way to confirm that he actually protected someone and if they are mafia they could simply pretend. There is no guarantee that any given role will be here right? Or maybe the inactive ones are just watching us tear each other apart.

I felt like that would only make things worse but maybe you start to believe me now regarding that this weird behaviour of wizz is just how he usually is. We never had any contact besides this thread, it's a shame our doctor died but at least we can focus on other people now.

And no, DD can just decide on the roles he wants to use. Bene could very well be lying, as could Mazino. There's nothing clearly suspicious though and the inactive guys make this a damn lot more difficult.

Who do you believe is the most suspicious on atm?

 

[Mazino]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

If that's true then you're possibly insane, you might even be the one who killed him and the mafia kill failed for some reason.



Yes, it could have been his plan too. Or like I mentioned above they didn't even plan to kill Hardy, who knows.

Bene claims to be the prostitute though, that's a different role from the sickly townie. Prostitute blocks night actions while the sickly townie blocks day actions.

Everyone is suspicious at this point, what sucks is that I can't judge anyone besides bene, kkck and you (a bit), the rest practically says nothing. This makes the game incredibly dull and boring + very hard to actually figure out the mafia members. It's not impossible that they the two remaining ones are among the active people but I would guess it's likely that at least one inactive one is a mafia =/

I'm not sure about you (don't know enough about you) and bene (still kinda doubt him), kkck appeared to be someone who's trying really hard to find the culprit but I don't know enough about him either to make a final judgement.

At this point I honestly would prefer killing off the inactive ones because there's no point in keeping them if they just make one or two posts each day. Or DD is starting to be more strict because of this goes on all the active people will die while the inactive ones practically do nothing and prolong the game unnecessarily.

yeah they r extremely inactive,zasz and thorn,but thorn also cant be the sickly townie,cuz he wasnt allowed to vote the last day(could be mafia),as i cant now
but hardys dead also makes shin suspicious for me,cuz he didnt get along with hardy at all,and also hardy is detective so he could be the target of the mafia,even if bene blocked shin..it could be his partner to do the killing and slowly i start to doubt that he just said that he is mafia just out of fun,also i think u and kkck would profit from hardys dead cuz he cant investigate u anymore,which could have been a real asset for us townies if he found out that one of u is mafia

i still say bene is the most suspicous,but shin caught up to him (will be at my physio...be back in 2 hours sry cant help it)

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

The only thing I can say for certain, and correct me if I'm wrong is that KD can't be either sane nor insane doctor...or at least the possibility of being insane is really low...the mafia knows whom the target is so they cover it up as well...if the kill is KD's kill as an insane doctor, then it's a huge stretch to say that the janitor picked the same name as well...

So KD is either mafia, or a naive doctor...

What bugs me though is shin's behaviour...not only he forced me to break the tie, although it's funny that only I felt that the tie is wrong(I did expect others to change their votes), but he did so nonchalantly(reading the pages is boring?), without even thinking of the consequences of a double townie kill...because that was the biggest risk...if Mazino is townie as well, then this night would've been a disaster...

If he is a mafia, then this hold shtick gets another meaning entirely, and not to mention that it strengthens the suspicion around me, for being the only to change the vote...

He is inactive and he managed to even be more suspicious than wizzard ever was lol...and it certainly passed over both niichan and mazino who are on the top of my list as well...

votekill shinsengumi

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I can vote now, right

wizzard could be blamed for his own demise. He was too vocal and gave the wrong vibe.

 

[shinsengumi]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Oh yeah not to mention that Gumi's willingness to kill people made him nr.1 target for me

well thats not true ,i asked digi before what happens if there is a tie and he answered someone has to change his/her vote .i asked that question especially for this kind of situations and i thought it wasnt possible to kill 2 people by vote

**********
aside from that ,now i read the roles again , i already said it was suspicious for a person to reveal his/her job ,like doc or detective .but there is insane and naive doc/detective so mafia cant really jump on them without thinking .BUT prostitute is different ,there are no variations to the prostitute .so revealing yourself as prostitude makes no sense .you are just asking the mafia to kill you .if i were a mafia ,you would be the first person i would kill . there is still doubt in my mind because prostitude's power is not that scary ,you dont know who is who after all and you can just waste your moves on random people all the time .. but i got my eyes on you

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Spoiler

The only thing I can say for certain, and correct me if I'm wrong is that KD can't be either sane nor insane doctor...or at least the possibility of being insane is really low...the mafia knows whom the target is so they cover it up as well...if the kill is KD's kill as an insane doctor, then it's a huge stretch to say that the janitor picked the same name as well...

So KD is either mafia, or a naive doctor...

What bugs me though is shin's behaviour...not only he forced me to break the tie, although it's funny that only I felt that the tie is wrong(I did expect others to change their votes), but he did so nonchalantly(reading the pages is boring?), without even thinking of the consequences of a double townie kill...because that was the biggest risk...if Mazino is townie as well, then this night would've been a disaster...

If he is a mafia, then this hold shtick gets another meaning entirely, and not to mention that it strengthens the suspicion around me, for being the only to change the vote...

He is inactive and he managed to even be more suspicious than wizzard ever was lol...and it certainly passed over both niichan and mazino who are on the top of my list as well...

votekill shinsengumi

Shin 1x(benelori)

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

So Shin. Are you saying you were trying to get two people killed at once?

 

[shinsengumi]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

re-read my post

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Looking at the votes from the last round and what I know, I am getting suspicious of these guys who voted against wizzard ( kkck, kdowns, mazino, shin). At least, one or two of them should be mafia. niichan sounds legit to be honest.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

well thats not true ,i asked digi before what happens if there is a tie and he answered someone has to change his/her vote .i asked that question especially for this kind of situations and i thought it wasnt possible to kill 2 people by vote

**********
aside from that ,now i read the roles again , i already said it was suspicious for a person to reveal his/her job ,like doc or detective .but there is insane and naive doc/detective so mafia cant really jump on them without thinking .BUT prostitute is different ,there are no variations to the prostitute .so revealing yourself as prostitude makes no sense .you are just asking the mafia to kill you .if i were a mafia ,you would be the first person i would kill . there is still doubt in my mind because prostitude's power is not that scary ,you dont know who is who after all and you can just waste your moves on random people all the time .. but i got my eyes on you

Usually prostitutes don't really have any power, only if they are very very lucky...which I was in this game, thanks to the hostkills and Lala's heroic death...we were only left with 2 mobsters, and one with a special ability...suddenly the odds jumped and I had to take the chance to reveal my role...because even if I die, the people whom I blocked gain some trustworthiness...

Well except that I blocked you this night...but I didn't like the tie of the last day phase, and you just popped in not even caring you will set a tie...that's why I'm voting you...however if you have a role and you know you were blocked then it's your chance to speak up I think

About what digi said...that's true...someone will have to change the vote...but only while the day phase lasts right? And nobody showed any initiative and I even woke up early today to see if there's any movement...nobody even tried to break the tie...

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

How long will the phase last?

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

How long will the phase last?

At most 24 hours and it started roughly 3 hours ago

 

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Looking at the votes from the last round and what I know, I am getting suspicious of these guys who voted against wizzard ( kkck, kdowns, mazino, shin). At least, one or two of them should be mafia. niichan sounds legit to be honest.

Don't forget bene in that list, in the end he voted for him too. I thank you though. Now we should probably focus on the five of them (if Zasz is mafia I'm going to get mad), who do you think is the most suspicious?

And I dunno if you said the truth when you said you're detective but who did you investigate?

 

[digitaldude]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

21hours but we can finish it earlier if you guys vote.

 

[thornofcarrion]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

@ niichan :You

---------- Post added at 11:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:06 PM ----------

I am not 100% certain. I was wrong about wizzard. I thought he was guilty but he turned out the opposite.

 

[kdowns]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

I honestly found Wizzard really suspicious, which is why I placed my vote on him. I didn't exactly believe his doctor claim completely when he claimed.

 

[shinsengumi]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Well except that I blocked you this night...but I didn't like the tie of the last day phase, and you just popped in not even caring you will set a tie...that's why I'm voting you...however if you have a role and you know you were blocked then it's your chance to speak up I think

i was suspicious of wizzard and voted for him ,its true i didnt care about making a tie because i was convinced wizzard was a mafia
i have the odd feeling that all the remaining mafia members are inactive .even more so than i am

-----------
remember when i first said i was thinking you could be the janitor ? it kinda makes sense being a janitor and faking a prostitude , baiting people into revealing their roles . its ingenious even

 

[Nii]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

Guys start talking about who you think is suspicious now XD no point in talking about wizzard now, or is it really like everyone besides me was so focused on him that he didn't even think about other possibilities?

21hours but we can finish it earlier if you guys vote.

Won't happen because of guys like Zasz

@ niichan :You

---------- Post added at 11:08 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:06 PM ----------

I am not 100% certain. I was wrong about wizzard. I thought he was guilty but he turned out the opposite.

Doesn't matter anymore, it's in the past.

 

[benelori]

Re: MAFIA GAME 19

i was suspicious of wizzard and voted for him ,its true i didnt care about making a tie because i was convinced wizzard was a mafia
i have the odd feeling that all the remaining mafia members are inactive .even more so than i am

Or at least one is, and the other one is just subtly directing things or letting them flow...

remember when i first said i was thinking you could be the janitor ? it kinda makes sense being a janitor and faking a prostitude , baiting people into revealing their roles . its ingenious even

It definitely is ingenious, but Hardy backed me up and for him it was 100% that I was the prostitute...only the prostitute and the guy who was blocked know that it happened...

Do you have a specific role? Did you perform anything this night?