Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread v.10

[FrostyMouse]

i love how you look to see who is banned

i don't know faust...no disrespect.but,you bailed on us last time...can you control your temper now?...

Well, I had actually thought he was banned, which is why he didn't play in the Naruto Game.

Still, that's the other thing. He bailed on us last time and he's been banned for inactivity while just playing in a game before.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Well, I had actually thought he was banned, which is why he didn't play in the Naruto Game.

Still, that's the other thing. He bailed on us last time and he's been banned for inactivity while just playing in a game before.

he was just banned. in general.

 

[Evil3ye]

i dunno. i mean like, i wont host like for one more month at least, if you wanna do a game, why not. biggest problem would be gathering people with your bad reputation, but if some are willing to play, i dont see why that game shouldnt happen. its like their own risk, though im not vouching for anyone who didnt past the test and got a recognition

 

[xi0]

He should be banned for several games at the very least...

 

[FrostyMouse]

he was just banned. in general.

Oh, he was? The thing doesn't mention it, but...

 

[Evil3ye]

was it the eyeshield game? honestly, i cant even judge, as i didnt follow it, nor did i fully understand what actually happened, nobody bothered to give me a full report lol

i dont want to decide on something i dont have much info about. majority votes?

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

just bann it.

 

[Faust]

Okay. Nevermind.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

 

[xi0]

If you abandoned a game as a host, you shouldn't have a right to play or host. Just like a player getting banned for being MIA. Someone who's banned in that case obviously shouldn't be allowed to host either. Not up to me to decide a punishment, but it should be the same.

 

[gnut]

i'm not even asking that...if what i brought up matters.
it's if he can keep himself from doing it again...losing his cool and making it personal?

i'm willing to give him another shot...only if he makes a legitamate promise he won't flip.
i don't think that's unreasonable.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

you will be a solo player m8

 

[xi0]

i'm not even asking that...if what i brought up matters.
it's if he can keep himself from doing it again...losing his cool and making it personal?

i'm willing to give him another shot...only if he makes a legitamate promise he won't flip.
i don't think that's unreasonable.

That can be left up to participants if they want, after he's served an agreed-upon ban. It would be ridiculous for him to serve no ban at all for what happened.

 

[Evil3ye]

yeah he's been banned, so naturally he missed out on a lot of games in between anyway. you want him to be banned from games, now that it actually matters, because he is back on the site or what?

 

[xi0]

Site bans have/had nothing to do with Mafia and what happened. So we're just going to assume he would have played/hosted every game he missed?

 

[Evil3ye]

i dont know, that never happened before. just thinking excluding him now is kinda super random, as it all was so long ago. for playing anyways.

honestly, i would rather strip him down from the privilege to host at all though, i just thought it not gonna be an issue anymore, from the moment we stripped him down from the section authority. like common sense, yet he is applying again, and people in fact seem to be not bothered and would sign up, so who cares

 

[Faust]

The last time I played was in Game 35 (3rd game after the Eyeshield Game). So I already missed a lot of games and now I still have to be punished for the Eyeshield Game (Game 32) which happened in December 2013? I admit that I really fucked up that game (Didn't host kill the inactives right away, I didn't expect the game to last till Dec. 24 here which I won't be able to accomodate, Imbalanced in roles) So I understand if Evil3ye and digitaldude and the admins/mods won't allow me to host again. But banning me to play on upcoming games as well, why? I already missed playing on five games (Game 36, 37, 38, 39, 40.) I think it's enough punishment for what I did in the Eyeshield Game (Game 32). Besides they even let me play in Game 34 (co-hosted by MidoBan and Evil3ye) and 35 (hosted by Evil3ye) probably to tell me a message "Dude, we'll let you play but allowing you to host I guess not" . But the decision isn't on my hands so... But IMO, just ban me for hosting permanently and let me play on Game 41.

---------- Post added at 10:11 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:01 AM ----------

I think xi0's point is that I should still receive punishment because after what I did in Eyeshield (Game 32) Evil3ye and MidoBan allowed me to play in Game 34 and 35.

 

[xi0]

Details got confused, but I still don't think someone who abandons a game should be able to host again.

 

[Evil3ye]

The last time I played was in Game 35 (3rd game after the Eyeshield Game). So I already missed a lot of games and now I still have to be punished for the Eyeshield Game (Game 32) which happened in December 2013? I admit that I really fucked up that game (Didn't host kill the inactives right away, I didn't expect the game to last till Dec. 24 here which I won't be able to accomodate, Imbalanced in roles) So I understand if Evil3ye and digitaldude and the admins/mods won't allow me to host again. But banning me to play on upcoming games as well, why? I already missed playing on six games (Game 36, 37, 38, 39, 40.) I think it's enough punishment for what I did in the Eyeshield Game (Game 32). Besides they even let me play in Game 34 (co-hosted by MidoBan and Evil3ye) and 35 (hosted by Evil3ye) probably to tell me a message "Dude, we'll let you play but allowing you to host I guess not" . But the decision isn't on my hands so... But IMO, just ban me for hosting permanently and let me play on Game 41.

agreed. theres no point in post-ban right now, should have been dealt right away

 

[Faust]

That was very bad decision making in my part. I shouldn't have started that Eyeshield Game in the first place because I won't be able to host in 25. I just thought that it would end before Dec. 24, 11:59PM (here in my time zone so it's 23 on you guys) but I was wrong. We needed to get on the road on Dec. 25 midnight so we'll be able to spend Christmas Day with my mother who was staying on an 80km away north of our province because our relatives requested her help. I apologize for the Eyeshield Game.