Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread v.9

[Josef]

Hardy placed Nunos vote on gnut, but Nuno voted for Gary, Evil gonna school Hardy now.

 

[benelori]

But then Josef got killed, and because of that his vote was removed i guess.
So it's 5 vs 5 and Gary has more locked votes?

Aha, that makes sense

 

[Farfalla]

Haha we're a weird bunch, we get excited, active and wish for moar when shit ends

 

[xi0]

Hardy placed Nunos vote on gnut, but Nuno voted for Gary, Evil gonna school Hardy now.

Am I allowed to call foul? Because things like that happening with only 10 minutes left confuses the picture for anyone trying to catch-up/follow the thread.

That's precisely why the locking rule is flawed.

/salt

 

[Nuno]

easy game easy life boys

 

[jorped]

fuck you Gary

 

[Farfalla]

There, problem solved, both dead xD


YES

(edit: nvm, but still YES)

I guess the inactives are ruining the game...

 

[jorped]

Wtf i am confused..

 

[Nuno]

we'll talk about it when the DAY STARTS jorped! No talk here!

 

[xi0]

What kind of bullshit is this? Get the count wrong with 10 minutes to go, tied vote means nothing because of locked votes? Really?

Yeah okay, I'm done

 

[Hardy]

What kind of bullshit is this? Get the count wrong with 10 minutes to go, tied vote means nothing because of locked votes? Really?

Yeah okay, I'm done

It was corrected in like 3 mins ._.

I still had no idea about this locked vote bullshit. Real? I wish I was around for that discussion, because that's stupid.

When? I haven't played or followed since 34 iirc

It's funny because that's the game that introduced the rule.

 

[xi0]

It was corrected in like 3 mins ._.





It's funny because that's the game that introduced the rule.

Yeah, but people thought that was the actual count even after the thread was locked! It influenced the result


Was it of any consequence? I don't remember it, I don't like it.

 

[Hardy]

Yeah, but people thought that was the actual count even after the thread was locked! It influenced the result


Was it of any consequence? I don't remember it, I don't like it.

Not really, I was reading the discussion, people got confused because Josef died and that modified the votes.

Yeah, it was done when I had a shit ton of votes against me, and in the end it was tied, so we did the locked votes thingy. It's to avoid ties and having to kill 2 people.

 

[xi0]

Not really, I was reading the discussion, people got confused because Josef died and that modified the votes.

Yeah, it was done when I had a shit ton of votes against me, and in the end it was tied, so we did the locked votes thingy. It's to avoid ties and having to kill 2 people.

What if someone wanted to change their vote to gnut, but thought he was dead already because of the error, and didn't think it was necessary? How is that "not really" influencing the result?

Well that's stupid precisely because of this situation. Mass confusion, no clarity, vote doesn't actually matter. GG.

 

[MidoBan]

hinata and naruto died together, it was almost poetic

 

[Hardy]

What if someone wanted to change their vote to gnut, but thought he was dead already because of the error, and didn't think it was necessary? How is that "not really" influencing the result?

Well that's stupid precisely because of this situation. Mass confusion, no clarity, vote doesn't actually matter. GG.

Who did that? Why is an error that lasted 3 mins so important anyway, when there were other 10 mins left?

It ain't confusing if you know the rules. The votes have the same value as always, it's just that locked votes are more important now.

 

[Farfalla]

If people are very interested/affected by the case, shouldn't they be following the votes?
Plus, there were people asking what happened here, but mostly the ones that came by later. The ones that were around were able to get the pieces together when asked, cause they were following. I don't see it as a critic mistake like that...

 

[FrostyMouse]

Who did that? Why is an error that lasted 3 mins so important anyway, when there were other 10 mins left?

It ain't confusing if you know the rules. The votes have the same value as always, it's just that locked votes are more important now.

This is a bad rule, regardless.

I haven't played since like Game 30, so I missed the application of this new rule.

 

[Evil3ye]

So what happened was, basically some already figured it out on their own, Hardy misplaced 3c's vote. which was irritating, that's true. A fresh vote up date should have been make to clear it, not editing the previous post.

Josef's vote got removed from gnut, because of Josef passing (no active player anymore). That tied gnut with xi0, both having 5 votes. xi0 having more locks, two to one, thus he got lynched.

Unfortunately Nico did nor post nor vote, thus he got host killed.

design getting a penalty vote next turn for not voting.

/end day two

 

[Farfalla]

Well it's better than people keep dragging the phase in the last minutes, after doing nothing for hours...