Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread

[Imperium]

To balance out power between groups we could add a Mafia cop, and the vampire-ish Saulus is a cool character too.

After reading about Saulus, i really want him in. Its sounds like a cooler version of what you were suggesting regarding revivals.

 

[Evil3ye]

Hurry up and finish the game already!

Also, who comes up with the killing scenarios? The mafia or Evil, they can be funny sometimes.

A mixture

---

END GAME 1

I'll like all participants to answer few general questions to improve further games.

-Was it hard for you to uncover the Mafia (Townie question)?
-Was it hard for you to disguise your identity (Mafia question)?
-How well could you play within your own role?

-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way?
-Is there anything else you'd wish to have changed for the next game (ignoring more roles)?

 

[Bugzee]

- kakashi and Xadyu didn't help AT ALL.
- When you have two bakas as fellow mafia members, off course you'll find it hard to disguise your true identity.
- I think I did extremely well considering the situation I was in. I should've killed Utsegius earlier on though. I left him in the game for far too long.

- You were awesome, E3. Thanks. I think you could announce the deaths, etc in a more convincing way. Don't go with the same style each time...like "so and so got lynched..."
- There should be a stipulation whereby the mafia could obtain the power to kill more than one person.

 

[Totinona]

I'll like all participants to answer few general questions to improve further games.

-Was it hard for you to uncover the Mafia (Townie question)?
-Was it hard for you to disguise your identity (Mafia question)?
-How well could you play within your own role?

-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way?
-Is there anything else you'd wish to have changed for the next game (ignoring more roles)?

- I think it was hard for me, but mostly because it's just very difficult for me as a person. End up reading too deep it to it etc.
- I think I played within my role OK. But one of the difficult parts are that the doctor is active in the night phase as well (townies might get suspicious etc).
- I think you did the job great so, no.
- I think the mafia is quite powerful in their roles so, maybe more pro-town roles or something (if the number of people participating is enough of course).

 

[Bugzee]

Oh yeah and the pictures were cool but change it up every so often; they influence the overall feel of the game and atmosphere.

One thing to take into consideration; it's fine adding all these new roles and rules but please can we add them bit by bit. I don't want everything to be added into the next game straight away.

kakashi is the biggest baka in the FF.

 

[After_Image]

-Was it hard for you to uncover the Mafia (Townie question)?
-Was it hard for you to disguise your identity (Mafia question)?
-How well could you play within your own role?

-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way?
-Is there anything else you'd wish to have changed for the next game (ignoring more roles)?

- Not so much the first two but trying to figure out the third mafia member was difficult.
- I think I played my role of a townie pretty well.
- No you did a great job.
- I like the game as it is right now so no changes for me. You could make the deaths a little more intriguing though.

 

[Evil3ye]

sticking to one day and one night pic per game?

 

[destiny4ever]

-Was it hard for you to uncover the Mafia (Townie question)?
It wasn’t easy for me I must say but I also must say that it wasn’t as hard at the beginning as it was towards the end when just one mafia member was left in the group. It was also hard in the sense that I didn’t want to accuse/kill an innocent one because of an error.

-How well could you play within your own role?
I think I did well during the first two days, but I didn’t do so well during the third day. In fact, I did so poorly I got myself killed.

-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way?
You did a great job but maybe you could write the deaths of the players in a more dramatic way or maybe you could allow each player to write his/her own death in a role-playing kind of way.


-Is there anything else you'd wish to have changed for the next game (ignoring more roles)?
No that I can think of atm.

 

[Evil3ye]

-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way?
You did a great job but maybe you could write the deaths of the players in a more dramatic way or maybe you could allow each player to write his/her own death in a role-playing kind of way.

yeah, thats a good point. I think it was Xadyu who tried to do that sth-sth after being killed off.

And I also appreciateed when Buggy sent me that PM with the killing text :P
But here I see the problem that it might reveal too much of its writer already -if we'd standardised it-

 

[Bugzee]

You liked my lil role play? Lynching CBlitz was fun.

Anyone else liked the playground crime-scene?

 

[Xadyu]

Was it hard for you to disguise your identity (Mafia question)?

-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way?
-Is there anything else you'd wish to have changed for the next game (ignoring more roles)?

Normally I last pretty long in these kind of games, but I drew attention with posts that weren't meant that way, fail, lol.

You could definitely add more of a story to the deaths of people and maybe an intro the the town and it's happenings.

I'd really love some RP'ing, this will drastically make the game more fun and exciting. Maybe some adjustments to roles, as weaknesses, for example allergies, or phobia's.

This will challenge people more in the RP'ing element, and besides the normal roles, the players could get 'jobs', to define their characters and help the RPing.

Like, Bugzee could be the baker, Imp the village idiot. Mayor, Storeowner, etc. etc.

Maybe give people even relationships with each others, you know, couple, siblings, etc.

 

[CBlitz]

I'd really love some RP'ing, this will drastically make the game more fun and exciting. Maybe some adjustments to roles, as weaknesses, for example allergies, or phobia's.

I like the roleplaying idea, it becomes a lot more fun that way. Also yeah, add some narrative to the whole thing, it'll be more interesting to see who dies that way

 

[destiny4ever]

yeah, thats a good point. I think it was Xadyu who tried to do that sth-sth after being killed off.

Yes, and it was pretty creative and fun to read and in addition it gave his death a whole new feeling, it made it more real if that makes sense.

But here I see the problem that it might reveal too much of its writer already -if we'd standardised it-

Reveal too much? I don’t see how. Maybe we could add a few rules so that the writer doesn’t give away too much info.

You could definitely add more of a story to the deaths of people and maybe an intro the the town and it's happenings.

I'd really love some RP'ing, this will drastically make the game more fun and exciting. Maybe some adjustments to roles, as weaknesses, for example allergies, or phobia's.

This will challenge people more in the RP'ing element, and besides the normal roles, the players could get 'jobs', to define their characters and help the RPing.

Maybe give people even relationships with each others, you know, couple, siblings, etc.

I like all of those ideas. I’m all for adding a rping element to the game. I think it will make the game more fun and more interesting.

 

[Totinona]

Normally I last pretty long in these kind of games, but I drew attention with posts that weren't meant that way, fail, lol.

You could definitely add more of a story to the deaths of people and maybe an intro the the town and it's happenings.

I'd really love some RP'ing, this will drastically make the game more fun and exciting. Maybe some adjustments to roles, as weaknesses, for example allergies, or phobia's.

This will challenge people more in the RP'ing element, and besides the normal roles, the players could get 'jobs', to define their characters and help the RPing.

Like, Bugzee could be the baker, Imp the village idiot. Mayor, Storeowner, etc. etc.

Maybe give people even relationships with each others, you know, couple, siblings, etc.

About the relationships part;
Is it only the townies or could a townie and a mafia be for example siblings?

 

[Xadyu]

About the relationships part;
Is it only the townies or could a townie and a mafia be for example siblings?

No limitations between roles, a mafia and a townie could be siblings or a couple. It doesn't matter.

 

[Imperium]

I like the "jobs" suggestion more than new suggestions for new roles. We could define their characteristics, give them influence in the game like, the bartender might get a hint at every night phase etc The village idiot (not me ) could be given wrong info etc That would be more enjoyable than your typical straight laced game and add the rpg element to it.

 

[Xadyu]

Well, I only mentioned those to help the RPing bit, we should just keep it to the original roles with maybe a new one here and there.

 

[Bugzee]

So like...when's the next game going to start?

 

[Akiyama]

I forgot this is the sign up thread too.
Yes, I want to play in the next round when ever it starts.

 

[Charlie]

Count me in too.