Discussion Mafia Game "Discussion" Thread

[Imperium]

Im in.

 

[After_Image]

Me 2.

 

[GEshode]

Of course I am in, too...^^

 

[CBlitz]

s-stupid FF! Its not like I want to be in....

but yeah count me in

 

[Riku]

I'm in too ^^

---

-Was it hard for you to uncover the Mafia (Townie question)?
Was hard, but not that hard, and surprisingly it came harder near the end game. At firt I thought it would be easier, with so many hints around.
-How well could you play within your own role?
No problems really, untill certain player decided I was mafia, and other players followed, at that point it was kinda hard to get rid of suspicion. On the other hand, that prevented me from being lynched during night.
-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way?
Not really, you were awesome. But some kinda prologue, and death desprections could be fun as many stated. And I loved the photos.

__________________

 

[Evil3ye]

Ok. We'll add the Jobs into the new game, but more like 'ordinary' jobs. Seperate, purely RPG relevant jobs, that don't affect the true identity of each player (like no Policeman, Doctor:P)..

For Example: Limpy the musician (hidden identity; 'Townie') and Bugzee the office clerk (Mafia Boss) lol.

As for new Pro Player, I'll add the Insane Cop as Pro Townie and Boss as Pro Mafia into the next game.

Any other suggestions?

Please share your ideas of daily life Jobs as well.

---

So like...when's the next game going to start?

I forgot this is the sign up thread too.
Yes, I want to play in the next round when ever it starts.

Count me in too.

Im in.

Me 2.

Of course I am in, too...^^

s-stupid FF! Its not like I want to be in....

but yeah count me in

I'm in too ^^_

8 players I count already

 

[Bugzee]

I can't wait!

 

[Imperium]

Are you adding an Insane and a normal cop? Because there would be no point in adding only an insane cop. The person who is given the role of "cop" will now know they are insane not much of a surprise (which is the point of the role).

 

[Xadyu]

I'm in too~

 

[Imperium]

-Was it hard for you to uncover the Mafia (Townie question)?
I think some players did very well in hiding themselves, especially Bugzee. So it did get harder towards the end.
-How well could you play within your own role?
Adequately. I think at times i voted to fast but on hindsight it seemed to get the game moving at a better pace.
-Is there anything the moderator could do in a different/better way? Nothing really stood out.
-Is there anything else you'd wish to have changed for the next game (ignoring more roles)?
The jobs rpg element described above mainly.

I forgot about this

 

[Evil3ye]

Yes. Insane cop and Mafia boss will be added to the already existing pro player roles. I'm thinking to rename them though, since we'll have normal professions already

Like Cop to 'Hobby detective' or something whaddo ya think :P

Oh and as already suggested the mafia will have to write a longer killing scenario by the end of each night, not just PM 'Kill Akiyama', but like 'Akiyama shall be strangle to dead when he's going home from the bordel' I'll slightly change it, so that there will be no chance that the mafia could give themselve away by their 'hand writings'.

 

[destiny4ever]

I'm in.

 

[Akiyama]

I would like Recruiting Mason role to be added. Its not a huge advantage to the townies but it gives us something to do. The head mason goes around at night picking a fellow townie and turning the member into a mason so they can talk via PM. Of course if he picks a mafia member he dies so there is a risk involved.

For the MH theme it could be called Recruiting Black Op. :|

 

[Evil3ye]

Not sure about that, I believe it's a bit too powerful Townie.. After like two/three days the mafia will not have a chance to win in a player pool of 10-11..

 

[Bugzee]

There's way too many advantages for the townies imo and I don't see the point in adding all these roles UNLESS we get a good number of participants in the first place. ^^

 

[Akiyama]

kkck wanted to be included this time, he will show up sooner or later. We still have some members that played in the first game but have yet to announce their participation in the 2nd game. Tina who might sleep for 16 hours and Kakashi.

 

[Evil3ye]

Don't worry. Will start the game on wednesday, so they probably will be able to register by themselves

If we'll have >15 by then, then the Recruiting Manson will be included...

 

[Akiyama]

You can always make a mafia member a cop. He can inspect the townies to find out their roles.

 

[kkck]

I do want in. I have to go through the rules again though.

 

[Evil3ye]

PLAYER LIST
01 [user]Bugzee[/user]
02 [user]Akiyama[/user]
03 [user]Charlie[/user]
04 [user]Imperium[/user]
05 [user]After_Image[/user]
06 [user]GEshode[/user]
07 [user]CBlitz[/user]
08 [user]Ustegius[/user]
09 [user]Xadyu[/user]
10 [user]destiny4ever[/user]
11 [user]kkck[/user]