Games Mafia Game Thread - Game 11

[Lawl Po Bia]

yes guys we got the mafia boss !^^ shame farf died

 

[Evil3ye]

One down And then the big fish, Boss

RIP Farfalla, what an unfortunate love

 

[BBB Banana]

Would Far have used her powers against mafia considering she was a lover? I think some characters shouldn't be lovers as it would screw townies over.

It's useless to have a daytime vigilante who's also a lover.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

ok i am investigating Evil3ye today, to clear the suspicion so to say.

 

[Evil3ye]

Lol goodboy. You are next

 

[Organizized]

She could have picked a side she wanted to win. I mean, she was still Townie so even if she died and the Townies won, she would've won right? It's too bad she wasn't here when the votes started hailing down on kkck... :/

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Lol goodboy. You are next

sounds like a threat

 

[blai]

Go back to sleep, children.

---

Since I'm in a ridiculous hurry because I'm, for some reason, incredibly busy, I'll just leave a normal update.

END NIGHT 2

[Awesome Narrative Text]

The city is ours.

Victim:
[user]Xadyu[/user] (???)

Other events:
[user]Zeltrax[/user] got poisoned in his sleep and can't vote next phase

---

START DAY 3

As long as we breathe...
​

---

 

[Zeltrax]

Oh great.
So uh, I'm gonna stay at the hospital while you guys enjoy this round.

 

[BakaHaze]

Report in Good_Boy.

You're the detective, what'd investigation say?

---

Also, Zeltrax, you can talk, just can't vote...

 

[Zeltrax]

Oh okay, I'll talk from my bed then.

How many badguys are there left?
This includes all kinds of third parties.

 

[BakaHaze]

I'm thinking:
4 Civs
2 Borgia
1 Merc.

This is assuming that both (???) were killed by Mafia Janitor and thus MUST be civs (or merc, giving civs even greater advantage.)

And if GB nailed the investigation we might be able to get another Mafia in the bag.

 

[Organizized]

Finally, I get to share my notes.

Note #1

Nah, I had a plan o.o
If kkck didn't die today, we would win in day 3.
That's cause... we had 10 players. 3 mafias(2, +1lover), 1 neutral, 6 townies (5, +1 lover). After this day, it would be 9, like 3/2 mafias, 1 neutral, 5/6 townies. After the night time, kkck would kill someone, the mercenary would kill another one, if we got lucky, this could end like: 2 mafias, 1 neutral, 4 townies. I could talk to kkck during Night Time to arrange that. Then, in day 3, I would shoot someone. It would be 2 mafias, 1 neutral, 3 townies. Ok, we would still need to kill one more townie to get the 3-2-2 number^^

Reading this, I gather they wanted to get rid of 1 mafia and 2 Townies in Day 2 + Night 2. The best way to rid of the mafia would undeniably be to get him lynched during the day since kkck can’t kill his own mafia members and they couldn’t be sure that the Mercenary would kill a mafia. Since kkck knew who the mafia members were, so should Farfalla, right?

Going by this, the one Farfalla voted for (kkck didn’t vote until he voted for himself) should be mafia. good_boy was the one she voted for at first, and I’ve had suspicions about him before. However, she then changed her final vote to Evil3ye. This might have been a desperate action, or seen as a chance to kill two birds with one stone (even out the votes between Evil and kkck and do it by voting for a mafia).

Note #2

Evil3ye sure changed his opinion of kkck really fast... From the neutral approach:

Might change to kkck to save my own ass, although I suspect him less than Zeltrax, Banana and goodboy.

to suddenly being absolutely certain that kkck was mafia:

No way he is a freaking Townie! Lets kill this Mafia!

VOTE KILL KKCK

which feels very much like just bandwagoning to try to cast suspicion off himself since ”mafia wouldn’t kill mafia, right?”...

Note #3

Nobody has stepped up and claimed the role of Detective since good_boy did so, right? If there is someone out there who is Detective, this should be a good time to reveal yourself, since it would pretty much prove that good_boy is full of sheet and a mafia. And even if no one does, I still think good_boy is full of it and the real second Detective (if there ever was one) was either Xadyu or it's Channy (the two most inactive ones who don't seem to be reading the thread and thus might have missed GB claiming to be Detective).

The main reason I believe this is because good_boy said he's a Detective, but the Mafia went and killed Xadyu who's been low profile throughout the whole game. If good_boy really was Detective, he would've most likely been killed tonight, and not someone the Mafia don't know whether he's worth getting rid of or not.

Good_boy and Evil3ye are high-level suspects in my eyes now.

------------------------------ End of notes.

On another note... The Mercenary didn't kill anyone tonight? Or his victim was saved?

 

[BakaHaze]

Ahh, screw waiting. Here comes my accusations.
Finger of suspicion: Evil3ye.
Mafia's Aim: To blend in as well as possible as townie and avoid lynching, while slowly killing towns in the shadows.
Evil has been INCREDIBLY pro-town throughout, moreso than many confirmed Townies who have just been doing suspicios things like pointing fingers or lacking posts.
The other point is that Xadyu was SURE that Evil was mafia; while he never gave a reason he was quickly and surely eliminated.

If I'm gone by next night as well, please vote Evil.

Anyways:

Lol goodboy. You are next

Threat much.

One down And then the big fish, Boss

RIP Farfalla, what an unfortunate love

Somewhat excessive with the celebrations of death of mafia boss; drawing attention away.

No way he is a freaking Townie! Lets kill this Mafia!

VOTE KILL KKCK

More super pro-townie.

Yeahhhh sure Mafia You are gambling now that there are two more Detectives in game, a Naive and Sane or Insane. The number of players this time is not big enough though, so that the real remaining.

Yeah, accusations.

You are definitely suspicious, since you were pulling your little bait tricks in the beginning. Getting rid of you is getting rid of one of the main targets. I would love to see who you'd be voting...

As before.

It's hard to tell if kkck is suspicious or not. Personally I put him on the same level as Channy and maybe Zeltrax. They do post, but very little and have rather very neutral posts, except when they...

A thinking townie pose...

Oh wow Cardinal, this was the bulletproof huh?

Damn, is it not good at all.

Anyways, to get this moving, I will vote. Might change to Banana later though, but for now I'll stick to my previous...

Not good at all, huh?

Not much point going much further back than this, but viewing all of Evil's posts has much cumulative effect and shows how, uncannily protown he is.

Again, hope I don't get lynched tomorrow...

Ooh, just before I post: Orgz Agrees

Edit: About merc: I think that was Xad, who was then killed...

 

[BBB Banana]

Again, hope I don't get lynched tomorrow...

Oh snap big slip mafia. You're saying you hope you don't get lynched tomorrow you are clearly mafia in my eyes now.
Throwing suspicion into evil who was xadyu's number one suspect.... was the easiest way to pass unoticed.

Vote Kill Bakahaze

Baka and good boy must be mafia.

 

[Zeltrax]

Finally, I get to share my notes.

Note #1



Reading this, I gather they wanted to get rid of 1 mafia and 2 Townies in Day 2 + Night 2. The best way to rid of the mafia would undeniably be to get him lynched during the day since kkck can’t kill his own mafia members and they couldn’t be sure that the Mercenary would kill a mafia. Since kkck knew who the mafia members were, so should Farfalla, right?

correct me if I'm wrong but...

3/2 mafias, 1 neutral, 5/6 townies. After the night time, kkck would kill someone, the mercenary would kill another one, if we got lucky, this could end like: 2 mafias, 1 neutral, 4 townies. I could talk to kkck during Night Time to arrange that. Then, in day 3, I would shoot someone. It would be 2 mafias, 1 neutral, 3 townies.

This is all random and a matter of possibility, there's so many ways that it can unfold.
I'm sorry for being slow but why is there a need for a mafia to die? Why is there a need to remove a mafia

Note #2

Evil3ye sure changed his opinion of kkck really fast... From the neutral approach:


to suddenly being absolutely certain that kkck was mafia:



which feels very much like just bandwagoning to try to cast suspicion off himself since ”mafia wouldn’t kill mafia, right?”...

kkck had 4 votes that lead up to his demise.
The way I see it both BBB and Evil are suspicious, both can kill him or kill someone else.
Evil may just be slower but he doesn't really need to kill his boss, he can just lynch someone else in the list and make both 3-3, killing off that someone(townie or 3rd party) if he is indeed mafia.
Besides, kkck is the big bad.

Note #3
this should be a good time to reveal yourself, since it would pretty much prove that good_boy is full of sheet and a mafia.

I really doubt it and its too far fetched, if its true he's taking a really risky gamble when he claimed his role. That theory of yours that xadyu is the detective is awesome tho, but if we believe in that then we can't believe in whatever gb found out in his investigation.
I don't think we would want that...

On another note... The Mercenary didn't kill anyone tonight? Or his victim was saved?

What's the mercenary role again? He can kill anyone, townie or mafia..if I'm not wrong?

 

[BakaHaze]

Ummm...One of us is real, and one of us is insane....

..meh...no role revealing

 

[Zeltrax]

..meh...no role revealing

Actually you can , it just makes it less fun/mindf*cking
but nobody says you can't.

Those who can't/don'twanto simply because its too risky or they are mafia.

Oh snap big slip mafia. You're saying you hope you don't get lynched tomorrow you are clearly mafia in my eyes now.
Throwing suspicion into evil who was xadyu's number one suspect.... was the easiest way to pass unoticed.

Vote Kill Bakahaze

Baka and good boy must be mafia.

I don't know what to make of this

 

[BakaHaze]

Fine. I'm the real detective.

Evil came up as janitor.

I just wanted GB's results to double check my sanity.

I already inv'd Kdowns on first night, Came up perfectly as bulletproof to me.

Didn't like my role revealed because it would mean town would keep advantage. W/E I'm at risk of being lynched anyways.

Boo, BBB

 

[BBB Banana]

Hey Guys I was thinking ... what if Xadyu was the Mercenary but was killed by mafia? And that's why there was no mercenary kill today.

It could be possible if the whore targeted him.

---

Fine. I'm the real detective.

Evil came up as janitor.

I just wanted GB's results to double check my sanity.

I already inv'd Kdowns on first night, Came up perfectly as bulletproof to me.

Didn't like my role revealed because it would mean town would keep advantage. W/E I'm at risk of being lynched anyways.

Boo, BBB

Mafia....

You changed your opinion too fast after your slip and I voted for you and second....

The result doesn't apear as janitor it apears either as guilty or Innocent.

And you steping up and revealing your role so quickly shows you are mafia and scared for your life.