Games Mafia Game Thread - Game 4

[Riku]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Theory is good, but as you pointed out, has problems. Also a liar doctor or detective might appear. Sure, after that you can narrow down the suspects, but then there is the coin flip chance you'll kill a real one.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Farfalla......cutie listen SHADDUP ALREADY OKAY YOU DONT KNOWNothing NOTHING! *cries*

And he is not breaking the rules, scav and channy could be mafia members or they could not, it could be a clever lie by ust, if he posted a pm confirming that they were mafia then he'd get banned from the game and we'd have to start over again.

 

[scav]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Farfalla......cutie listen SHADDUP ALREADY OKAY YOU DONT KNOWNothing NOTHING! *cries*

And he is not breaking the rules, scav and channy could be mafia members or they could not, it could be a clever lie by ust, if he posted a pm confirming that they were mafia then he'd get banned from the game and we'd have to start over again.

yawn

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

You are next mafioso!

 

[scav]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

You are next mafioso!

yawn~

---

dont worry digital i havent forget ya, u're still very suspicious

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

What if the Mafia Boss chose one of his fellas to throw in the fire? I mean, they could agree to ask one of the two Mafias do act suspicious so he would die first. Then, if the Mafia Boss was the first one to incriminate the bait, in the future people would follow his opinion more easily, and the dead dead Mafia guy would still be able to play thru PM, still being a part of all the strategy so Mafia group could win, right?

For example... If Imperius analysis is right... and the guy he suspected (don't recall who) is voted, killed and turns out to be a Mafia, people would trust Imperius opinion. It would be more easy for him to incriminate townies after that, to keep himself and the other Mafia safe.

---

@DD
Come here and try to keep me quiet ò.ó
I said MAYBE u.u you're the one that looks like a girl the most!

 

[Evil3ye]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

The Mafia has not had the chance yet to discuss a strategy as they are only allowed to communicate in the night.

Reminder: Any private Communication while the Day Phases is not tolerated and will lead to the exclusion of the game and all following Mafia Games.

 

[scav]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

What if the Mafia Boss chose one of his fellas to throw in the fire? I mean, they could agree to ask one of the two Mafias do act suspicious so he would die first. Then, if the Mafia Boss was the first one to incriminate the bait, in the future people would follow his opinion more easily, and the dead dead Mafia guy would still be able to play thru PM, still being a part of all the strategy so Mafia group could win, right?

For example... If Imperius analysis is right... and the guy he suspected (don't recall who) is voted, killed and turns out to be a Mafia, people would trust Imperius opinion. It would be more easy for him to incriminate townies after that, to keep himself and the other Mafia safe.
<hr noshade size="1">

@DD
Come here and try to keep me quiet ò.ó
I said MAYBE u.u you're the one that looks like a girl the most!

DD is a male but he dont have balls

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Evil, u keep making me cry ;-;

DD is a boobs hater u.u I've seen his sig.

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

What if the Mafia Boss chose one of his fellas to throw in the fire? I mean, they could agree to ask one of the two Mafias do act suspicious so he would die first. Then, if the Mafia Boss was the first one to incriminate the bait, in the future people would follow his opinion more easily, and the dead dead Mafia guy would still be able to play thru PM, still being a part of all the strategy so Mafia group could win, right?

For example... If Imperius analysis is right... and the guy he suspected (don't recall who) is voted, killed and turns out to be a Mafia, people would trust Imperius opinion. It would be more easy for him to incriminate townies after that, to keep himself and the other Mafia safe.

That's better, Imp(mr MEANIE!) suspected Mr angry and pretty much everyone here thinks the same, and it would be a bad move really, there is 12 townies and only 3 mafia, killing one of your own in the first turn is borderline retarded.

 

[CBlitz]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

What if the Mafia Boss chose one of his fellas to throw in the fire? I mean, they could agree to ask one of the two Mafias do act suspicious so he would die first. Then, if the Mafia Boss was the first one to incriminate the bait, in the future people would follow his opinion more easily, and the dead dead Mafia guy would still be able to play thru PM, still being a part of all the strategy so Mafia group could win, right?

For example... If Imperius analysis is right... and the guy he suspected (don't recall who) is voted, killed and turns out to be a Mafia, people would trust Imperius opinion. It would be more easy for him to incriminate townies after that, to keep himself and the other Mafia safe

hmm back when I was Mafia boss, this was also an alternative but I didn't want to throw one of my men into the fire in the first round if it were possible. My guess is that Mafia won't try this at the very beginning, mainly because they haven't had a chance to speak to each other yet. So the first round is a bit strange since the mafia members act by themselves and not as a group

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

That's why it's called strategy '-' There's risks. But Evil alrdy said this can't had happened, thank you u.u

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

I have a feeling farfalla is not mafia at all........

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Well, that's good for me, so thx again XD

 

[Riku]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Okay here are my real takes on everyone and this is my last contribution to the game:

1) CBlitz is dodgy. 1 Pretty indifferent post, and an other a loud accusation when I started to be oh so obvously mafia, Can't say for sure, but I think he might mafia.
2)digitaldude - His reasoning is solid and he really seems to aim for the better good of townies. Anouncing hider status might be a good cover for a mafia, but I still doubt that.
3)Imperium - Solid reasoning, based on common patterns of certain users. So obviously hyst is just hysting and I am awfully lying since I'm always so calm and sure never have tantrums. Not certain, but pretty confidented he is a townie.
4)scav- his behaviour for unknown reasons reminds me of xaduy game 1. So he is my second guess for mafia.
5)goodboy- not suspicous. solid defense on the earlier hunt. a townie
6)After_Image - He hasn't posted (?) and I have no idea for the remaing mafia, so I guess it's him.
7)Raizen - a townie I suspect. Hard to say anything with so little posts by him
8)Mr. funny is not funny indeed
9)Farafalla- She's cute so how could she be mafia.
10)kakashi- nothing to say really, prolly a townie.
11)Freid - Goes by gut feeling and took a lot of effort to write a good post against hyst. A townie.
12) I'm obviously mafia. I'm so level-headed that keep so much noise is suspicious. I'm soo obviously lying.
13)Hyst is trolling.
14)Pirulito - Hard to say since hasn't posted much.
15) Channy - He playes like a new townie player always plays.

Thank you, I'm done with this game. After slaying me, I'd go after the this far quiet guys. The easiest way to get along is simply to get the loud ones destroy each other.

I'm pissed this ended this way, but I'll go watch some Moomins or Disney classics, I'll always feel better after that.

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Dead lions makes you feel better? ;-;

Don't be so upset, Ustegius^^ People can still change votes (I think all of the ones that had alrdy voted still can change it). That would happen more easily if you could find a solid hint against someone else. Voting so far doesn't mean u'll be this round dead guy^^

 

[digitaldude]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Ust and scav can't change their votes(they voted twice now), I am not changing my vote, cblitz will probably also not change his vote, and who do you think the mafia is ms cute?

 

[CBlitz]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Farfalla is mafia boss

calling it now

 

[Farfalla]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

I'm not gonna lie XD I thought about Ustegius. But I haven't voted yet 'cause I wasn't that sure. I think u guys were kinda premature in your voting decision, it was too early to have something solid. That's why I believe someone changing vote is not that hard to happen XD I mean, except for those who alrdy voted twice.

---

Farfalla is mafia boss

calling it now

ME? O.O
U said that based on what? XD

 

[scav]

Re: Mafia Game Thread - Game 4 - DAY 1

Okay here are my real takes on everyone and this is my last contribution to the game:

1) CBlitz is dodgy. 1 Pretty indifferent post, and an other a loud accusation when I started to be oh so obvously mafia, Can't say for sure, but I think he might mafia.
2)digitaldude - His reasoning is solid and he really seems to aim for the better good of townies. Anouncing hider status might be a good cover for a mafia, but I still doubt that.
3)Imperium - Solid reasoning, based on common patterns of certain users. So obviously hyst is just hysting and I am awfully lying since I'm always so calm and sure never have tantrums. Not certain, but pretty confidented he is a townie.
4)scav- his behaviour for unknown reasons reminds me of xaduy game 1. So he is my second guess for mafia.
5)goodboy- not suspicous. solid defense on the earlier hunt. a townie
6)After_Image - He hasn't posted (?) and I have no idea for the remaing mafia, so I guess it's him.
7)Raizen - a townie I suspect. Hard to say anything with so little posts by him
8)Mr. funny is not funny indeed
9)Farafalla- She's cute so how could she be mafia.
10)kakashi- nothing to say really, prolly a townie.
11)Freid - Goes by gut feeling and took a lot of effort to write a good post against hyst. A townie.
12) I'm obviously mafia. I'm so level-headed that keep so much noise is suspicious. I'm soo obviously lying.
13)Hyst is trolling.
14)Pirulito - Hard to say since hasn't posted much.
15) Channy - He playes like a new townie player always plays.

Thank you, I'm done with this game. After slaying me, I'd go after the this far quiet guys. The easiest way to get along is simply to get the loud ones destroy each other.

I'm pissed this ended this way, but I'll go watch some Moomins or Disney classics, I'll always feel better after that.

dude u started by voting on gb now u say he have a solid defense, after all that badmouthing against Hyst u end up to say he's just trolling ( following and copying others words when the wind change), now u attack cummy and me ( cuz i remind u Xad? cmon u could at least find something better )
u're changing ur mind too much, plus all the crying-angry part (" i dont want to be kicked at the beginning again, im pissed, blablabla" make u more suspicious)