Conditional Mirajane vs Brandish

[kian]

Mirajane battles Brandish in the same location as Lucy. Both full power, fresh.

Restrictions:​

​

- Brandish can’t shrink/implode organs​

- Macro isn’t allowed.​

​

Who wins?

*lmk if thread has been made before and i’ll take it down.

 

[Ramen]

Going with Mira.

Alegria should heavily injure her if not beat her if she runs out of time.

 

[Brandish μ]

Brandish gets nerfed too much here. She's basically at the level of nerfed Jacob now, so Mira wins.

 

[Demon Hunter]

Mira would beat her easily in a physical confrontation.

But Brandish can just throw a rock and enlarge it to island size to squash her.

I guess Mira can throw her off balance with her nuke.

 

[Seven777]

Mira. Would be funny if Brandish got a proper fight this arc before Mira does

 

[grey matter]

No organ expositions?
Mira no diffs Brandish.

Brandish was getting blitzed by Lucy, and without "organ burst" her combat ability is Lucy tier

--- Double Post Merged, May 4, 2020, Original Post Date: May 4, 2020 ---

But Brandish can just throw a rock and enlarge it to island size to squash her

But that would affect Brandish also, right? Unless the fight starts kms away, I don't see that as being a viable strategy.

If the pebbles are enlarged to building level, Mira just destroys them with her nuke

--- Double Post Merged, May 4, 2020 ---

Going with Mira.

Alegria should heavily injure her if not beat her if she runs out of time.

Wouldn't need Alegria, Satan Soul would be more than enough

 

[Ramen]

Wouldn't need Alegria, Satan Soul would be more than enough

Meh

 

[Plutogrim]

Brandish med diff.

 

[grey matter]

Brandish med diff.

??
How?

 

[Plutogrim]

??
How?

Brandish can still shrink Mira into a cockroach size and step on her.
Also, Brandish can just shrink Mirajane nuke and throw it back to her twice as explosive.

 

[Ramen]

Mira would just blitz

 

[Demon Hunter]

But that would affect Brandish also, right? Unless the fight starts kms away, I don't see that as being a viable strategy.

If the pebbles are enlarged to building level, Mira just destroys them with her nuke

True.

Not that it matters.

Mira would nuke her or blitz her.

 

[grey matter]

Brandish can still shrink Mira into a cockroach size and step on her.
Also, Brandish can just shrink Mirajane nuke and throw it back to her twice as explosive.

Brandish couldn't do it to Lucy lol. Mira would be too fast for her to step on. Mira attacks too fast for Brandish to shrink her attacks, her speed is Lucy tier

True.

Not that it matters.

Mira would nuke her or blitz her.

Yep, this is a case where blitz easily applies. Brandish's stats are Lucy tier, she has instantly blitzed and stomped

 

[Zelefomavis]

Brandish written by Mashima ? Mira wins.

If Brandish could actually use her powers efficiently ? Brandish: she can reduce her opponents to a smaller size than what she did to Lucy. Exhibit : Marin. When she first reduced him during her introduction, it looked like he was obliterated due to how small he got. She probably made him bigger later because if he was finger size all along, they clearly would have spotted him. (DS got heightened senses).

So Brandish reduces Mira to a ridicously small size and gets into her giant form. Just has to wait for Mira to use all of her MP and she wins without even breaking a sweat. She can even drink cocktails and eat mangos while waiting.



And if you say :
1) But Mira can still beat her, even if small she got all her strength! From Lucy showing while using blades in small size she could barely cut Brandish's hands. If she used them in regular size, Brandish would have been had more than small cuts. Being small impairs your strength.

2) but Mira will blitz her before, that only goes if she goes alegria at the beggining of battle.Mira never does that right of the bat, she always start in BSS to judge her opponent. She could probably blitz Brandish even in BSS if she was bloodlusted, but she is not. She did not blitz Lucy in BSS during the latest fight. And that's because Mira never goes full throttle at the beggining.


Tl;dr
Anyway, Brandish with her MP, and magic she already showed (Making people small and making herself giant) should be able to take it handily. However the way her fight were written by Mashima ? Mira takes it.



I'm still hoping for better showing for Brandish. It already started though in 100YQ, she casually rescued Gray without anyone noticing not even Skullion while not being close to them (they would have noticed her tremendous MP) . My queen is on her way to show who's best girl.



Also Ps: Brandish showed she can enhnace or reduce specific part of the body : what's to stop her from making one of mira's feet giant, the other leg small as f*** etc : try fighting when your whole body is messed up and you Can barely move properly.
Even without organ busting the truth is Brandish's magic is broken asf and will never be used properly so she doesn't break plot. We already have one Wendy.

 

[Cosmicstar]

Logically Brandish would still win as she can still compress Mirajane nukes and throw them back at her. Brandish can also enlarge herself and make herself physically much more powerful than Mirajane. Unless Brandish is completely incompetent during this battle I don't see Mirajane winning. She would be nothing more than a net or a flee to Brandish.

 

[Plutogrim]

Imagine a tiny flying Satan Soul.

 

[Kiki]

sounds like the Brandish that fought Lucy in Albareth?

I think at least Mira can put up a better fight than Lucy

 

[Orphan Prince]

If Brandish is smart and is trying from the start, she can easily screw with Mira's body, for example, she enlarges limbs and shrinks others, give her T-rex kind of arms and shrink her legs to the size of an ant, she can't move, Brandish enlarges herself and steps on Mira, that, or she does to Mira what she did to Marin, shrinks her, so small that she can pick her up with her toes, Brandish picks Mira up with her toes, squeezes and crushes her in half.

Brandish shrinks her, picks her up, and crushes her.

There are so many ways that Brandish can kill Mira before she can do anything.

Low-mid diff without Mashima PoF.

Mira with Mashima wanting her to win, mid diff due to Brandish's low durability but broken hax.

 

[grey matter]

If Brandish is smart and is trying from the start, she can easily screw with Mira's body, for example, she enlarges limbs and shrinks others, give her T-rex kind of arms and shrink her legs to the size of an ant, she can't move, Brandish enlarges herself and steps on Mira, that, or she does to Mira what she did to Marin, shrinks her, so small that she can pick her up with her toes, Brandish picks Mira up with her toes, squeezes and crushes her in half.

Brandish shrinks her, picks her up, and crushes her.

There are so many ways that Brandish can kill Mira before she can do anything.

Low-mid diff without Mashima PoF.

Mira with Mashima wanting her to win, mid diff due to Brandish's low durability but broken hax.

It says no organ burst

 

[Ramen]

It says no organ burst

The whole Organ Bust thing was stupid from the beginning.