Monkey D. Luffy VS Magellan

[TheLuffySmile]

Strawhat Pirates Captain

Monkey D. Luffy
VS
Impel Down Vice chief warden

Magellan

Location: Same bridge they fought on last time. Both at full power and stamina.

Who would take the win?

 

[RezzieThaRapper]

I'm going to say Luffy.

The reason being is that Luffy is definitely the more skilled fighter, and has immunities to most of Magellan's poisons.

He has to watch out for the Red Demon poison still, but if Haki can block lava, it will take him on more easily in my opinion.

Speed is Luffy obviously, strength is Luffy obviously.

Technique may go to Magellan, but 90% of his arsenal is useless in my opinion.

 

[KingOfNight]

I'm going to say Luffy.

The reason being is that Luffy is definitely the more skilled fighter, and has immunities to most of Magellan's poisons.

He has to watch out for the Red Demon poison still, but if Haki can block lava, it will take him on more easily in my opinion.

Speed is Luffy obviously, strength is Luffy obviously.

Technique may go to Magellan, but 90% of his arsenal is useless in my opinion.

Luffy's immunity can only go so far. Magellan can produce several types of poison, and as stated by doctors, countering all of them is impossible. They also have melting effects, so Luffy can't touch him. The Red poison is simply absolute.

We're talking about a guy who could scare two Shichibukais away and bring down the whole BB Pirates in a second. Not to mention being acknowledged by Hancock as a very powerful individual. I don't even think the SH Pirates combined can beat this guy.

 

[hawk eye]

I'm going to say Luffy.

The reason being is that Luffy is definitely the more skilled fighter, and has immunities to most of Magellan's poisons.

He has to watch out for the Red Demon poison still, but if Haki can block lava, it will take him on more easily in my opinion.

Speed is Luffy obviously, strength is Luffy obviously.

Technique may go to Magellan, but 90% of his arsenal is useless in my opinion.

that depends on the level of haki doesn't it?! people like shanks would be capable of that, but luffy?! i don't think so! hody's teeth were enough to bypass his haki, no way he is blocking demon venom with his level of haki yet!

 

[DutchPhoenix]

i go with magelan, his red poison devil would kill luffy.
Luffy's adamant haki isnt nearly strong enough.
Luffy is a bad matchup for magalan,

zoro would win though, since he dont need to touch him.
for sample http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lIgjI0OEaA

Sanji might be able to win also with his long range fire kicks

 

[Impossibility]

Luffy's style is pretty awful for taking on Magellan, but at the same time, he's already picked up a pretty good immunity because of his prior battles. That immunity allows him to put up some fight, but I don't think it's going to change the outcome in the end. I'd favour Magellan, he's a monster.

 

[KuroKarasu]

Magellan has a hax DF and good control over it but other than that he can't do anything. He didn't seem to be using haki and he was neither fast nor very strong. I'm going with Luffy - he only beat BB crew because he surprised them.

 

[DutchPhoenix]

Magalan did seem to be very tough, however speed wasnt his virtue