Most evil One Piece character?

[Super Angillis]

I decided to go with Doflamingo over the Tenryubito in the end. The Tenryubito seem to at least have some concern for each other. Doflamingo seems to have absolutly no care for anyone but himself. Although the Tenryubito would pretty much singlehandedly explain why Dragon's revolution seems to be doing so well. As to why the WG supports the Tenryubito, I think it's got something to do with money. I mean, look how casually they throw around sums in the 100's of millions of berries.

 

[ZenoArmani]

Sorry. I didn't remember Onigumo when I wrote the alternatives, but he seems much the same as Rob Lucci (Rob Lucky, heh), Spandam, and Akainu for sure.

Anyway, here is the updated list:

1) DonQuixote Doflamingo; The Shabondi Tenryuubito
2) The Gorousei
3) Akainu
4) Spandam
5) Eneru; Shiryuu
6) Rob Lucci
7) Crocodile; Blackbeard
8) Arlong
9) Moria; Sengoku
10) Vegapunk; Vapolo; Kuro; Bellamy
11) Don Krieg; Eustace Kid
12) Kizaru; "Other"
13) Morgan

And no votes yet for Aokiji or Boa Hancock.

It's a bit weird that Crocodile rates so low now.

 

[Gecko Moria]

Doflamingo, Rob Lucci, ONIGUMO and Akainu are pure evil.. I think onigumo will be one of the greatest villian in future of one piece because he is "Absolute Justice" follower and have great potential in his fruit..

I wouldn't exactly classify characters that follow the "Absolute Justice" code as evil, just extremely radical. In the end, they're simply following what they consider to be prudent and/or what they are instructed to do. The real villains here are the people who command them to carry out "Absolute Justice" (e.g. Gorosei). Obviously, there are people (Aokiji, Garp, Saul etc.) who must be commended for choosing a more honorable path despite orders from superiors.

 

[vagabond87]

I wouldn't exactly classify characters that follow the "Absolute Justice" code as evil, just extremely radical. In the end, they're simply following what they consider to be prudent and/or what they are instructed to do. The real villains here are the people who command them to carry out "Absolute Justice" (e.g. Gorosei). Obviously, there are people (Aokiji, Garp, Saul etc.) who must be commended for choosing a more honorable path despite orders from superiors.

I see your point... So we can call them less honorable then every single other character in one piece

 

[Lord Rayleigh]

I wouldn't exactly classify characters that follow the "Absolute Justice" code as evil, just extremely radical. In the end, they're simply following what they consider to be prudent and/or what they are instructed to do. The real villains here are the people who command them to carry out "Absolute Justice" (e.g. Gorosei). Obviously, there are people (Aokiji, Garp, Saul etc.) who must be commended for choosing a more honorable path despite orders from superiors.

Those guys are completely evil. As you said (i.e " Aokiji, Garp, Saul etc...) a marine officer does not need to support Absolute Justice, it is a personal choice. Besides, if those guys became the marine/government leaders, they would establish a system that would be a disaster for the world. We all know Absolute Justice would create a No Freedom land. Those guys are definitely more dangerous for people than evil pirates.

 

[ZenoArmani]

Apparently more dangerous for their own people too...

Anyway, I mostly agree. There is also a difference between someone who is "just following orders" because he/she is too scared not to, say, dump Agent Orange on civilians, or work as a Nazi extermination- or Japanese rape-camp guard, or in this case goes along with putting entire countries to the torch, and someone who enthusiastically enforces and encourages these principles and creates the fear to stand up against the practices with the literally fascist threat of immediate execution othervise, and will gladly wipe out thousands of his/her own men simply to exterminate a mostly benevolent freebooter. The latter category is worse. It's not about fear and desperation, just about pure evil.

As Rayleigh said, if Akainu, Spandam, Rob Lucci, Onigumo, and their likes were in charge they would do exactly the same things as the worst of the Gorousei. There is absolutely no moral difference between them, beyond that Akainu's type is also extremely tough and courageous, but that's hardly an excuse.

 

[RichardMNixon]

Doflamingo definitely has a bit of the Joker in him.

I think I mostly voted for the leaders in the poll, the only one I added that doesn't have too many votes is Kidd. The guy kills anyone who laughs at him and has a bounty higher than Luffy's: earned by slaughtering civilians. Maybe he has a nobler purpose than the Tenryuubito, but he's still a bastard.

 

[Drmke]

I voted for Crocodile just because he has done the worst evil so far imo. Trying to tear a country apart by having its people destroy themselves is pretty bad. Blackbeard doesn't strike me as full-on evil yet. He just seem like another pirate to achieve his dreams, just going about it differently than Luffy.

Don't really know enough about Doflamingo to say he is the most evil character though honestly, it seems like he might be when more about him is revealed. All the marine guys are just doing what they consider justice. They view pirates as evil so its hard to really say they are evil. Though CP9 weren't very good guys but seems like they are reforming.

Watch us all be surprised when Luffy turns out to be evil at the end of the series

 

[vagabond87]

Watch us all be surprised when Luffy turns out to be evil at the end of the series [/QUOTE]

He can be "evil" in the future, but not in the same league as Akainu,Lucci,Onigumo.. Not so long ago we heard from Sqado that his entire crew was killed by Roger so isnt someone killing entire enemy crew evil??? Their was Sqados "family" just like strawhats for our rubberman. Maby in future Luffy will have to kill someone(Kaidou maby) because he will have no other choice- with great power he will have great responsibilty and have to make some hard choices. I hope we will see deaths in one piece- after first really big death in the series. Whitebeards death..

 

[Super Angillis]

We don't know what happened with Squardo's crew though. We don't know if they attacked Roger and his crew and it was self defence for example. Although in a lot of ways, that is just another thing in this arc that shows us why it's a good thing Luffy doesn't kill his foes. Without the help of the likes of Buggy, Mr. 3 and Crocodile, Luffy probably wouldn't have made it out of Impel down. And without Crocoboy's intervention, the first attempt to execute Ace would have succeded. As Mihawk said, Luffy's most terrifying ablility is his ability to gather allies.