Discussion Most Overrated Character(s)

[grey matter]

Well Acno since the beginning of Edolas, again, they could have had longer fights, but anyway, not that bad.

Lmao. Zeref, the archmage, the strongest human until that point, had a fist fight as his final battle. And with "infinite magic" FH lost to POF savage flames. His character and behavior changed according to plot the entire time, conveniently chalked upto his "curse of contraditions"
Absolute trash, worst main villain I've seen in all of anime/manga

Acno was also trash, the dude was a majestic and mysterious wild card when he was introduced. Got reduced to a maniacal retard who fights just cause, and who jobs according to the plot.
But hey, at least the dude retained his hype and dignity, I'll give him that. It took the entire continent's powers amplified many times over (by Meledy) + 7 DS combined to beat him.

 

[WoWfan]

Lmao. Zeref, the archmage, the strongest human until that point, had a fist fight as his final battle. And with "infinite magic" FH lost to POF savage flames. His character and behavior changed according to plot the entire time, conveniently chalked upto his "curse of contraditions"
Absolute trash, worst main villain I've seen in all of anime/manga

Acno was also trash, the dude was a majestic and mysterious wild card when he was introduced. Got reduced to a maniacal retard who fights just cause, and who jobs according to the plot.
But hey, at least the dude retained his hype and dignity, I'll give him that. It took the entire continent's powers amplified many times over (by Meledy) + 7 DS combined to beat him.

Despite them showing to exchange magics too. Flames that are hot enough to burn time itself? that reach absolute hot? His character is defined by the torment of living forever, anyone would lose their minds especially from solitude and losing loved ones because of them unintentionally. Acno's character has always been that, destruction and hatred against Dragons, the only stupidity he showed was his inability to smell other DS and Dragons on other continents.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 19, 2021, Original Post Date: Oct 19, 2021 ---

honestly, Selene is more overrated than anyone, due to her planning not making any sense.

 

[Kenneth Latorre]

Can you imagine going arcs, hyping up a character, and every arc that character is hyped up even more than previously before, the character becomes even more godlike by getting a power up. Only to go out embarrassingly with one punch.

no other villain will reach That level because no villain will have enough time to garner such amounts of hype. It sucks but that’s reality.

 

[WoWfan]

yeah, that is likely what will happen to Selene

 

[Gladiolus]

If after going through Alvarez and Aldoron arcs you still hope Mashima is gonna deliver a satisfying fight against the main villain, you haven't read Fairy Tail well.

 

[WoWfan]

Most unsatisfactory would be Jose fight since they kept saying that he was on a level akin to Makarov But he one shots him later.

 

[Steven]

Hate to say it but most overrated pleb is Acno

Dude was hyped like hell,yet Igneel ripped his arm off and even after he got a big powerboost,he got yeeted away by getting baited on a boat...

Second place is Zeref.Also hyped like hell,was in the end just a CQC fighter...and got solo'd by Natsu.And on top of that he was a trashtier Villain

 

[Kurumi Tokisaki]

And on top of that he was a trashtier Villain

I thought you liked him? To me, he is just another generic immortal tragic trope.

 

[Steven]

I thought you liked him?

I never liked Zeref.How i can believe someone like that

will ever fit as Pre-Final Villain.

His goal suxs,his design dont fit for the strongest Black Mage and his on-screen presence is non-exist

 

[Vex_Haid]

since suzaku and selene aren't on this list, ill go with skullion

also for the post above me, zerefs goals aren't trash. he was gonna reset the entire timeline and wanted to get rid of acnologia + almost everyone else, and his immortality.

 

[Lucy>Wendy&Elfman]

In Fairy Tail Guild only, who do you think are the most overrated characters?

Mine:

Wendy: apparently she can clap Brandish & she is equal to Natsu. She is also stronger than Gray, Erza, Gajeel and Mira.

Mirajane: seems she can effortlessly stomp CSK and all 12 Zodiac spirits at once in BSS. Jellal, Laxus and Erza are also fodder to her, and she is Gildarts' level

Elfman: he can solo both Lucy and Wendy at the same time and he is above Gray


Jet: he is faster than everyone in the guild.

 

[grey matter]

In Fairy Tail Guild only, who do you think are the most overrated characters?

Mine:

Wendy: apparently she can clap Brandish & she is equal to Natsu. She is also stronger than Gray, Erza, Gajeel and Mira.

Mirajane: seems she can effortlessly stomp CSK and all 12 Zodiac spirits at once in BSS. Jellal, Laxus and Erza are also fodder to her, and she is Gildarts' level

Elfman: he can solo both Lucy and Wendy at the same time and he is above Gray


Jet: he is faster than everyone in the guild.

I have literally seen nobody say that for Wendy, Jet and Mira lol. (except maybe Mira being Gildarts level, I think I've seen that one before)

I haven't see anyone putting Elfman above Gray either.
But he will solo both Lucy and Wendy lol. You can blame Mashima for that

 

[Lucy>Wendy&Elfman]

I have literally seen nobody say that for Wendy, Jet and Mira lol. (except maybe Mira being Gildarts level, I think I've seen that one before)

I haven't see anyone putting Elfman above Gray either.
But he will solo both Lucy and Wendy lol. You can blame Mashima for that

Nah he won't. But too lazy to make a debate again.

They would low-diff him.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 4, 2021, Original Post Date: Dec 4, 2021 ---

I have literally seen nobody say that for Wendy, Jet and Mira lol. (except maybe Mira being Gildarts level, I think I've seen that one before)

I haven't see anyone putting Elfman above Gray either.
But he will solo both Lucy and Wendy lol. You can blame Mashima for that

Comic Vine and Reddit.

 

[Vex_Haid]

Suzaku is the most overrated and trash character

 

[Lucy>Wendy&Elfman]

I voted for Mirajane, Wendy and Brandish but I have some honorable mentions for the most overrated characters:

- Elfman
- Kyria
- Skullion
- Dimaria

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 12, 2021, Original Post Date: Dec 11, 2021 ---

I add Irene to the most wanked FT characters.

Apparently she's far stronger than Zeref.

 

[WoWfan]

How so for Irene being stronger than Zeref?

 

[Lucy>Wendy&Elfman]

How so for Irene being stronger than Zeref?

Reddit

 

[Static]

Reddit

You mean /r/Tenrojima? I haven't seen many posts there saying Irene is stronger than Zeref lol.

 

[WoWfan]

Reddit

I don't think that should be a concern here though

 

[Lucy>Wendy&Elfman]

Most of Spriggans are overrated tbh. When they were introduced, the only thing which made them impressive were their hax and their immense Magic Power. Not their fight abilities. Only the likes of August, God Serena or Ajeel really impressed me with their fight abilities. Maybe Wall tho but the other ones... Meh. The only thing they have is hax.

--- Double Post Merged, Dec 31, 2021, Original Post Date: Dec 31, 2021 ---

Most of Spriggans have relative MP except the top three. Seeing how Neinhart was afraid of Jellal when he powered up, I can even argue that FT guild top tiers can have more MP than average Spriggans (which might be not true).