NARUTO CPA 343 MQ OR HQ?

[Kawazoe]

hello i'm a new in this forum.I'm a italian Manga Editor.
for you this is a HQ or MQ?

http://www.sendspace.com/file/98i1fm

 

[manu]

Well you rated it MQ... I think you knew the answer ^^;

Its a very good MQ, I'd say that you just need to learn how to manually do your grays. Filters just don't get the job done. Also some lines need to be redrawn. Such as the ko'd ninjas on page 2.

 

[Kawazoe]

thank a lot for answers.For you my scan is beeetwen mq\hq?

 

[ttxdragon]

It's Low MQ/High LQ,
reasons:
- dirt in whites on several pages
- lines choppy/overleveled one several pages
- "smudge" visible on some pages
- detail lines sometimes nearly completely dissappear
- JPEG noise from saving
- on some pages there is grey behind the text instead of white
- you just drew squares where there is the need to redraw what was behind the text
- greys are worse than in the raw.

to judge it good/high mq i'd say at least have the greys a bit better, no jpg noise, clean the whites a bit more in places and don't overlevel.


and another minor thing:
number them please 01,02,03,etc,10,11,12,etc...
makes it better for viewing int he correct order when using a direct-reader like cdisplay.

 

[Allashandra]

I agree with ttx. In addition to what he said you have two pages at least where the grays have gone missing entirely.

 

[Kawazoe]

thanks for the councils. I am already working in order to improve them