Conditional Natsu vs Erza

[Shoutmon]

I saw some posts in the power ranking thread and thought that this would be an interesting match-up, so who wins?

Location:Grass prairie.
Current power levels.
morals off.

Round 1: Base Natsu vs Erza.
Restrictions: Igneel's power, FDKM, Nakagami armour.

Round 2: FDKM Natsu vs Nakagami Erza (Which can be sustained for 5 minutes)
Restrictions: Igneel's power.

 

[Plutogrim]

Erza wins scenario 1 and loses 2.

 

[Arjuna]

Natsu wins both situations.Natsu uses one 1 or 2 FDK spell in Base state and Erza gets defeated.And in situation 2 Natsu stomps.

 

[Char]

Erza wins scenario 1, and loses scenario 2.

The gap that separated them from the beginning was closing bit by bit until by the Tartaros arc LFDM Natsu was pretty much Erza's equal, I'd dare say, LFDM Natsu was Erza's equal even using Nakagami.

Nakagami is a debatable armor. It's her strongest (or it was prior to the timeskip) and it can 'cut through' magic, but its mechanism is little explored. How does it cut magic? what kind of magic? etc.

All in all, I see Erza as a swordsman cqc specialist, who is ultraversatile in terms of elements, and can overwhelm Natsu. If she can't using her base armors she's gonna do so combining fire empress armor for defense and water sword to deal more damage to him. I think she can mid diff him.

Now in BDKM he literally heats anything in a radius to an extent an enemy can recoil in pain and that is not gonna help. Erza should defeat him quickly and she's not gonna achieve such a thing, since BDKM Natsu is just too powerful and his offense is on spriggan level.

 

[Arjuna]

I think we are mistaking thinking that Erza is comparable to Base Natsu.There is no feat of hers to compare to him.No
FDK Roar, Demolition Fist, the fact that he can keep up with her in terms of speed, vastly superior feats of physical strength of Natsu.He easily blew up the Ant pit where Erza couldn't do anything.That too without using his major spells.He has a mountain level FDK attack which Erza doesn't have.So Erza is no more comparable to Base Natsu.

 

[Seven777]

Erza wins round 1 for sure.
For round 2, i dont know.... is Erza above even FDK Natsu....? I just... dont know...

 

[Stormsfury]

Spoiler

After the last chapter, I give Erza the win in both scenarios

 

[Boomburst]

Spoiler

PoF Erza wins both rounds, without it it's the other way around.

 

[Plutogrim]

Erza wins both round low diff.

 

[Demon Hunter]

Spoiler

Erza stomps both rounds.

 

[BluePegasus]

AH GUYS STOP. Natsu all the way.

 

[Arjuna]

Spoiler

Well Erza was enchanted and her sword had DS Magic so she could one shot Irene with her sword.

But here she will not have DS advantage or Wendy so Natsu still wins.

 

[Kurumi Tokisaki]

POF Natsu destroys POF Erza.

 

[Darklord#10]

DF natsu>>>>Erza=>fdk natsu>>base natsu

 

[Darklord#10]

DF natsu>>>>Erza=>fdk natsu>>base natsu

This is still my answer