Need Help!!

[Sussertod]

hi ppls

can someone tell me which one looking better because i want to know.
same page with 2 different cleaning style.

raw is from ch.204 Air Gear
i know there is some dust in the cleaning page and its a quick cleaning experiment ... ^^

Spoiler

------------------------------------------------------
raw page



03



03-1



------------------------------------------------------

raw page



11



11-1

 

[MXC]

03-1 and 11-1 are the best by far. the 03 first one needs a lot of cleaning still

great work on the -1 ones

 

[Digitalr]

03 03-1 Terrible, way too dark (both) ... but 03 wins because it preserves the details a little better

11 11-1 Both are terrible, both are too blurry and 11-1 is way too dark

 

[Sussertod]

thanks for you guys feedback
yea.. that what i want to hear XD its kinda dark and blurry...
ohh well its just a experiment XD so dont mind


here is the preclean of both page i think it look ok

Spoiler

page 03

page 11

 

[Digitalr]

heh I know AG isn't the easiest series to clean, so keep experimenting and you'll hopefully get some decent results

 

[MXC]

I still think it's very good for a "quick cleaning experiment" like u said in your post...would you mind sharing about this quick method?

 

[spades]

I still think it's very good for a "quick cleaning experiment" like u said in your post...would you mind sharing about this quick method?

do u mean denoising..?