Politics North Korea's hostage situation

What do you think of the situation when US sent Bill Clinton to secure the journalists' release?

  • US has taken up the soft approach and negotiated with North Korea.

    Votes: 3 100.0%
  • North Korea are fed up of being isolated and released them as a form of gesture.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    3

Dark-san

Translator
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 20, 2009
Messages
140
Reaction score
12
Gender
Male
Country
Singapore
As everyone knows it, just last week the two female American Journalists that accidentally crossed over to the North Korean border from China got freed due to the diplomatic effort by Bill Clinton. But just today, a South Korean Engineer got freed after an intervention by Hyundai's chairman.

Quoted from Channel News Asia at 13 August 2009:

North Korea frees South Korean detainee after four months

SEOUL - North Korea Thursday freed a South Korean worker it had detained since March, raising hopes of better cross-border relations after 18 months of bitter hostility from the communist state.

Yu Seong-Jin came home across the tightly guarded frontier in the evening.

"I'm very happy to return home safely," he told a crowd of reporters at the border, thanking all those who worked for his release.

After a brief medical check the engineer for the Hyundai Asan company was to be reunited with relatives waiting near the border, Yonhap news agency reported.

Hyundai Group chairwoman Hyun Jung-Eun had travelled to the North Monday to seek Yu's release, days after former president Bill Clinton went to Pyongyang to meet leader Kim Jong-Il and win a pardon for two American journalists.

Yu, 44, was earlier handed over to Hyundai Asan officials at the Seoul-funded joint industrial estate in the North's border town of Kaesong, where he was detained on March 30.

The North had held Yu incommunicado since then, accusing him of insulting its political system and urging a northern worker at the estate to defect.

Inter-Korean relations have been icy since a conservative government took office in Seoul in February 2008 and took a tougher line on cross-border relations.

International tensions have also risen this year following the North's latest nuclear and missile tests and a US-led drive for tougher sanctions.

However, North Korean officials signalled to Clinton that they want better relations, according to US officials.

An association representing South Korean firms in Kaesong said it hoped Thursday's release "will improve frozen ties between South and North Korea and rejuvenate the Kaesong industrial complex."

Hyun had earlier extended her stay in the North until Friday, heightening speculation she would meet leader Kim as she did in 2007.

The North is still detaining the four-member crew of a South Korean squid fishing boat which sailed across the border on July 30 due to a faulty navigation system.

It told the South Thursday an investigation was still continuing.

Analysts say the North's priority is improving relations with the United States but to do this it must also mend ties with South Korea to some extent.

"The release will be a turning point in frozen ties between the two Koreas," Dongguk University professor Koh Yu-Hwan told AFP. "It reflects Pyongyang's belief it cannot improve relations with Washington without easing cross-border tensions.

"North Korea also badly needs economic help from South Korea to overcome economic difficulties and food shortages, which have worsened this year due to international sanctions and regional tensions."

The Seoul presidential office welcomed the release but said its policy would not change.

"It seems a bit too late, but it is a relief that Yu is finally returning to his family," said spokesman Lee Dong-Kwan.

"The government will continue to maintain its policy consistency toward North Korea."

Some 40,000 North Koreans work for 105 South Korean companies at Kaesong, which was developed mainly by Hyundai.

The auto, shipbuilding and construction giant pioneered business exchanges with the North, opening its first venture -- the Mount Kumgang resort on the east coast -- in 1998.

But its projects have been hard hit by the worsening relations.

The Kaesong estate is the last one still operating. Its future has become increasingly clouded since Pyongyang demanded huge extra wage and rent payments from Seoul and detained the engineer.

Tours to Mount Kumgang have been suspended since July 2008, when North Korean soldiers shot dead a Seoul housewife who strayed into a poorly marked military zone.

Hyun's visit was partly aimed at restarting the Kumgang tours, officials say.

- AFP /ls

Up-to-date, the North currently has another four more South Korean fishermen under custody. But then back to the entire situation if we look at it from another angle if we had look back at the two journalists case.

There are a lot of unanswered questions like,

1) Are there any secret dealings made in exchange for their release?
2) Why did the North Korean regime asked for Bill Clinton to come?

The international spotlight on this situation at the current moment is as followed,

1) Is it that the United States gone soft?
2) Or is the recent hostage release by the North a sign of gesture to show that the North Koreans are fed out of being left out?

Vote and tell us why you think that you are right on this?

For now, let us just say that it is god bless that the two journalists came back unharmed. And may god be with the families of the four fishermen that is still in custody.
 

redcometfm

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2008
Messages
712
Reaction score
51
Gender
Male
Country
Portugal
Wonderful how an ex-politician can broker such an exchange. Did Clinton even have legitimate authority? Will other politicians fly around the world to deal with situations when its the job of our CIA/FBI/White House?

Im predicting similar situations in the future.
 

Kaiten

Harasho
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Aug 20, 2007
Messages
27,293
Reaction score
15,166
Gender
Hidden
Country
Abu Dhabi
Clinton was an official envoy. He was sent by the White House. The CIA is intelligence and counter - intelligence, they don't negotiate hostage releases. The FBI only has jurisdiction over U.S. It is not uncommon for Democratic administrations to send former Presidents as negotiators. President Carter had worked for President Clinton in that capacity.

From what I understand, Kim Jong - Il really wanted to meet Bill Clinton. That's why he went rather then Hilary or Al Gore. Considering how insular and perverse the North Korean government can act, I wouldn't read to much into it. Most likely they used it to buy future good will, next time they ask for financial aid.
 
Last edited:

Drmke

MH Senpai
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jun 22, 2009
Messages
4,224
Reaction score
1,235
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Palestine
I thought that entire situation should have just been left alone.

I mean it is truly awful that those women were capture and not allowed to go back home, but what in the hell did they think would happen when they went over there?

They must have thought they would expose North Korea's horrible secrets and sneak back home heroes or something. They went into a country that brainwashes its people into hating Americans and they thought they would be welcome with open arms...the United States should have just left them. Helping them get out will only encourage more of this type of behavior creating more and more tension between the U.S. and North Korea.
 
Top