Obscure characters connection in One Piece

[Akaii]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

ah...but one idiot with such a thought would not hurt..since one piece is all about idiots...since luffy did what no pirate with morals will do declare war against the WG..so..yeah..why not...and it was just a thought on me part..eheh....

 

[Schabrak]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

Because of Luffys moral he has acted against the WG. To free his nakama. He did all he could do, risking his own life. That has absolutly nothing to do with being an idiot. Dragon has started a war against the WG too, so is he an idiot too? No. One Piece is about Luffy, (who is a little bit slow/dumb at times) who has a dream he wants to achieve. Not a story about idiots. It's no Boboboobo Boobobo.^^

 

[MonkeyD.ODZ]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

Maybe Gold D.Roger is Dragon wife 's father. It's very interesting.

 

[cachaco99]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

i wrote this somewhere but im putting it here where it belongs

about roger and luffy. at first i was thinking that luffy is the reincarnation of roger. that MAY be possible but i kinda hope it doesnt happen cause i need the idea and i dont want people saying i ripped off the idea from one piece. anyways now im hoping that roger is luffy's grandpa. at first i was gonna leave it just as i said but i dont want people thinking im new to one piece. yes i know garp is luffys grandpa but what if roger was the grandpa on luffy's mother's side. roger and luffy have alot in common(similar eyes, hair style/color, and personality) just like garp and luffy (narcolepse, and somewhat personality). that would be cool if luffy was related to roger in the sense that luffy is his grandson. think about it. garp and roger crossed eachother alot, why? garp said he wanted luffy to be a marine, the reason was because he didnt want luffy turning into a pirate, maybe like roger (if they were related cuz that would make roger and garp in-laws cuz of dragon and luffy's mom). the reincarnation idea is good cuz roger said he wouldnt die but the roger being luffy's other grandpa also has alot of possibilites. think about it, luffy's family is bad ass and crazy.

Garp-a powerful marine vice admiral that crossed paths with roger many times
Dragon-a powerful/famous guy, also most wanted man alive
Luffy's mom-nothing known yet but sure to be crazy
Ace-brother to luffy and second division captain of whitebeard's crew
Luffy-the main hero of the story and the next pirate king

now you see that luffy's family rocks. just imagine

Roger-pirate king and luffy's other grandpa.

that would make their family the most bad ass of everyone in the one piece world. imagine if that happened. and luffy found out. luffy would be so happy. since he was amazed by shanks being in roger's crew.

so all im saying is that the luffy being roger's reincarnation is a good idea but the roger being luffy's other grandpa is better and has more possibilites.

its like how zuko from avatar is the grandson of the previous firelord and also the grandson of the avatar himself. when i heard that i was like DAMN. avatar the last airbender is a good show.

or kinda like dbz where pan is the granddaughter of goku, the most powerful sayian and hercule the most "famous" human on earth

 

[JC123]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

So where do Ace and BB fit in?

 

[c0nflikt]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

i think this theory is silly but its possible that Dragon was part of Roger's crew.

 

[Schabrak]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

Since Shanks and Buggy already were in, it seems very unlikely for Dragon to be in the crew. [But it could have been the reason why Shanks visited Luffys isle.]

 

[bittman]

Re: Gol.D Roger and Dragon brothers?

I'm with the "legacy of the destroyed country" idea.

Besides, with recent developments on One Piece I would be surprised if:
A) Roger had a child before he died due to his blitz of the Grand Line
B) Shanks somehow didn't know Luffy was related to Roger
So Luffy being related to Roger is ruled out in my book, but I'm sure someone will discredit this with ease.

Why do all the people who make a lovely family of D's always forget B.B and Saul? Speaking of Saul, giant's live for hundreds of years, Saul was probably at least 100 (going on knowledge, rank and strength) so don't give me that one family or legacy crap which Roger may have started. Saul had his D well before Roger's parents named their herculean child.

 

[monkey D luffy]

Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

aokiji as a vice admiral: (top left panel)
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/397/11/
brook while he was a live: (top roght panel)
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/488/04/

there is a great resemblance between them dont you think?

 

[Imitorar]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

Aokiji had glasses and an afro. Brook had glasses and an afro. All you've shown is that Oda draws afro'd glasses-wearers similarly.

 

[Razh]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

Geezus...

So, do you have any indication besides the fact that they both have afros and are tall?
Aokiji is a lot taller anyway.

Gee, this is an interesting topic.

 

[Fox666]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

That is funny... Brook is Aokiji father!! =P =P Oda just love afros. That all.

Aokiji is a lot taller anyway.

Well, at least Brook is exactly the same size as Kizaru: http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/511/17/

 

[kkck]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

aokiji as a vice admiral: (top left panel)
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/397/11/
brook while he was a live: (top roght panel)
http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/488/04/

there is a great resemblance between them dont you think?

Rather than the resemblance being because of aokiji, I think the resemblance is there because there was a fight between ships. The scenarious are similar because in both of them there were cannonballs and that sort of stuff.

Also I very much doupt aokiji had anything to do with what happened to brook since that would mean aokiji's age would be anywhere between 50-100 years old. If we consider that robin was about 10 years old during the ohara incident and right now she is 28 (I think it was said in a sbs), then the ohara incident happened 18 years ago. If aokiji was 30 years old back them, (I dont think he was that old though), then right now he would be 48. There is no way aokiji was even alive when brooks crew was massacred. And wasnt it said that brooks crew was defeated by pirates?

__________________________________________________
On another point, when brook was in shaky in the SA arc, he commented on how he may have heard of a rookie called roger back in the day. If silver is the same age as roger (somewhere between 60 and 70), then it is very possible that brook has some interesting information about roger and might have even met him.

 

[monkey D luffy]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

geez i just asked!
just go ahead and kill me

 

[Razh]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

Aokiji's height.

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/319/10/

And Brook isn't as big as Kizaru. He does wear a cylinder on his head. And on that pic Brook is closer to the perspective than Kizaru.(to foxes)

monkey, you didn't just ask. You made a topic. You could have just as well asked it in mega convo.

 

[monkey D luffy]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

k my bad i will either give the thread the right prefix (which has for some reason changed cuz im sure i chose question) or will ask in the convo

 

[Fox666]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

And Brook isn't as big as Kizaru. He does wear a cylinder on his head. And on that pic Brook is closer to the perspective than Kizaru.(to foxes)

Yeah, but Brook is in a crouching position.

 

[gfire2]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

im 100% with u on this one, oda is just crazy enough to pull these kinda things and im crazy enuff to love it. i say they are related!

i say brooke is aokiji's uncle or father (father is the least likely but u never noe)

i remember ppl grilling the guy who started the theory abt auction house belonging to don flamingo and guess wat? he was spot on abt it.

 

[Imitorar]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

And I remember personally grilling people who thought that Hancock was Luffy’s mother, or who thought that Marguerite would join the Straw Hats. And guess what? They weren’t right. Sometimes something can be so subtly hinted that almost nobody gets it or thinks it makes sense, and yet Oda pulls it off, such as Doflamingo owning the auction house. Other times, people THINK that something is being subtly hinted or implies, when in reality they’re just interpreting something stupidly. To say that Brook and Aokiji are related would be to do the latter. Oda is known to enjoy wacky things in his story, but he’s not really one for stupid relationships that don’t really even matter. Besides, you think Oda would do this? You also think that Gold Roger’s alive, so forgive me for feeling that your thinking something is so is far from any indication that it actually is.

 

[gfire2]

Re: Is Brook Related to Aokiji?

And I remember personally grilling people who thought that Hancock was Luffy’s mother, or who thought that Marguerite would join the Straw Hats. And guess what? They weren’t right. Sometimes something can be so subtly hinted that almost nobody gets it or thinks it makes sense, and yet Oda pulls it off, such as Doflamingo owning the auction house. Other times, people THINK that something is being subtly hinted or implies, when in reality they’re just interpreting something stupidly. To say that Brook and Aokiji are related would be to do the latter. Oda is known to enjoy wacky things in his story, but he’s not really one for stupid relationships that don’t really even matter. Besides, you think Oda would do this? You also think that Gold Roger’s alive, so forgive me for feeling that your thinking something is so is far from any indication that it actually is.

i never liked the idea of hancock being luffys mom and i dont usualli support random theories like that but i could understand y ppl grill others for things like this (coz there has been so many threads like these in the past and i guess ppl are tired of these), but i actualli like this theory and i realli enjoy thinking abt it (mite even get some laughter just thinking abt the possibilites the moment brooke and aokiji meet)

my thoughts