Obscure characters connection in One Piece

[haruka9]

Possible connection between Brooke and Cindry

I already expressed this though as part of my reply in sahugani's chapter 458 review. But do you guys think that Brooke and Cindry had a connection in the past? This sounds crazy but my theory is that Brooke was the one who proposed to Cindry and got mad when she broke his plates. If you judge by the way Brooke speaks, you'd think that he's a noble man because of his politeness and chivalrous manner of speaking. Noble men are known for that. Plus, his clothes are sophisticated and uses canes that are used by the upper class before. Besides, Nami guessed that Cindry might be from the upper class too. But Cindry's real story is not yet revealed so there is an air of mystery about that (like who is the man who proposed to her, how did she die, how did she disappear, who really is Cindry, etc.). And the short detail about her past wouldn't be mentioned by Dr. Hogback and in the story if it's not that important. And have you guys notice that the simple events in One Piece (that we tend to ignore because we think that it doesn't have any vital role) have something to do with the current or future events? They are related if you get to correlate the past stories to the present storyline. Thus, I'm thinking that the short explanation about Cindry's past will be explained later on because it has a big role on the story.

If my theory is correct that both parties (Brooke and Cindry) are noble people, then it's okay to think that there might be a connection between the two before. And maybe, Brooke was the one who proposed to her.....

Sounds crazy but well, it's just a theory. Hope to hear from you guys.... What do you think?

 

[Anti-panda]

Re: Possible connection between Brooke and Cindry

All I can say is it's highly doubtful that a high class nobleman would be a pirate.. considering who most pirates steal from is rich people .. I'm not saying it's possible ... just highly unlikely.

 

[haruka9]

Re: Possible connection between Brooke and Cindry

yes. i consider that point of view too

 

[Absolutio]

Re: Possible connection between Brooke and Cindry

and cindry was an actress.. might be a noble but still.. Her shadow is the one that having the proposal memories..

 

[Naelyan]

Re: Possible connection between Brooke and Cindry

Well, anyway, either it's the actress or the owner of the shadow, I doubt she's over 50 years old, especially her body, it died 10 years ago, and brooke spent this 50 last years on his ghost ship, he certainly didn't have a maid with him.

 

[lordHokage]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

If Luffy's grandmother is Vice-Admiral Tsuru, then Dragon was ex-marine.

 

[Razh]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

So far, every D character had a D in their name when they were introduced.

And now, someone makes a wild guess about Tsuru. Of course, it could be true.

But right now, I could say that Doflamingo is Sanji's dad, and nobody could say that it's more probable that Tsuru is a D, or at least prove it.

Oh, about Dragon being a former admiral, a guy on Vegapunk forum had a nice theory. I don't think it's impossible that he was an admiral.
http://www.vegapunk.com/forums/index.php?topic=2320.0

 

[Yans86]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

Actually the female doesn't need to have the D. in her name,because the surname follow "Monkey D." follow the male line.....think about it,where did u take your surname?from your father or from your mother???so actually this isn't impossibile.......and even if this is not a family reunion,with Garp and Dragon,we can't have the mother and the grandmother accidentally died in the past or something stupid like that because you state the female aren't important in Oda Universe......and moreover,a Vice-Admiral,the most dangerous man,the mistery about Portgas D. (Ace),and the future Pirate king....if we don't understand the family connection,inside and outside,Iwon't think that we are going to understand all their actions....

 

[Razh]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

So, you're saying that maybe she isn't a D, but married one of them? If she doesn't have a D, then she isn't D.

Would someone remind me of the reasons why it's so possible that she is a D?

 

[Yans86]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

She doesn't have to be a D. for marry a D....and obviously the surname of the son,pass in the male line......

 

[Tsukisama]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

I doubt it. If a female member of Luffy's family is ever revealed, it will probably only be his mother, but for now, I believe that Luffy's known family will remain a sausage fest.

 

[wing_gundam]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

Yes i think she is luffys grandmother

Offtopic
About Dragons name could it be like Gold Rogers's name?
Gold rogers real name was Gol D. Rogers so if Dragons name was monkey D. ragon?

Lol for that logic he'd have to be Monkeyd Dragon.

D came from his first name (or fake first name). Plus I think was used more to add the D factor later into Oda's plot rather than a rationalization from the beginning.

 

[Yans86]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

Actually we know that they are Monkey D. Garp, Monkey D. Dragon and Monkey D. Luffy.......so no problem about that.....
PS
I would like to know why everyone want a female D.....is not necessary actually.Couldn't Garp and also Dragon,marry a "normal" girl?The D. is something connected to the anciente history,we know that,but this doesn't mean that you must have both your parent with a D.,to be a D.!!!!!!!We found out 7 D. characters in all one piece world....so everyone of them to find a D. female to marry.........too stupid!!!!!lololollolloll
PPS
Sorry for my bad english..

 

[Razh]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

Who said that a female D has to be married to a male D?
What are you talking about...

 

[DutchPhoenix]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

maybe luffy has a sister

 

[Razh]

Re: VICE-ADMIRAL TSURU......LUFFY'S GRANDMOTHER

Maybe Darth Vader is Luffy's real dad. He had an affair with Luffy's mom.

Your point?

 

[neomaster121]

Franky and Nami related

Both of them were abandoned by pirates so the links there discuss until the spoilers come out im bored

 

[Akainu]

Re: Franky and Nami related

sth. new to think about ^^ lets see.
both left behind by pirates? was Nami? I can't remember atm
going by hair colour (the most important fact ever , I know) I'd rather throw in Nojiko.
furthermore I don't think, that the SH are related to each other, though the family background would be a nice thing to read I don't think we get much of it till the very end as thats usualy the drama that connects some stranger to the SH.

all over imo possible ^^

 

[Imitorar]

Re: Franky and Nami related?

You can't take a random factor like this and expect it to yield a relationship. I mean, Franky is 16 years older then Nami, and he was found by Tom when he was 10, before Nami was even born. How could the parents have gone from Water 7 to East Blue in a year? They aren't alike in personality or anything either. And it's just unlikely, I see nothing in such a relationship that would benefit the story, meaning there is no reason for Oda to have done it. Nami and Franky were abandoned by different pirate crews and are not brother and sister.

 

[kkck]

Re: Franky and Nami related?

I dont remember ever reading nami was related to pirates, if i remember correctly her original village was attacked by pirates and she was saved by bellemere.