One Piece Mega Convo Thread, the 1st Chapter

[Razh]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

The story time since the beginning of Monkey D. Luffy's piracy is around the 100 days. At the end of TB, when the SH left Thriller Back, it was about the 80th day. You just have to re-read all the chapters of OP and count the days that spend.

Lol, count the days. That's under the assumption that Oda showed each and every day on Merry and Sunny. Which he didn't. SH were never shown eating every day, catching food, taking a piss, taking a dump, reading, cooking, playing training, inventing weapons taking baths and so on and so on.
Sorry, but taking One Piece and trying to count days by flipping pages is a terrible waste of time, not to mention a little naive.

 

[OunknownO]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

The story time since the beginning of Monkey D. Luffy's piracy is around the 100 days. At the end of TB, when the SH left Thriller Back, it was about the 80th day. You just have to re-read all the chapters of OP and count the days that spend.

it doesn't happen everything just in 100 day here you go...

http://www.onemanga.com/One_Piece/490/10-11/ look at robin section

 

[darkband]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

That says that that was when Robin left West Blue and entered the Grand Line. Not the SH's. They left East Blue some undetermined time ago, which is more likely months instead of years. Probably longer than 100 days as you said but not five years. Here Crocodile says that she had been with BW for about 4 years. So it has been a year at most since Alabasta though I don't think it was that long. This is all speculation though.

 

[OunknownO]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

That says that that was when Robin left West Blue and entered the Grand Line. Not the SH's. They left East Blue some undetermined time ago, which is more likely months instead of years. Probably longer than 100 days as you said but not five years. Here Crocodile says that she had been with BW for about 4 years. So it has been a year at most since Alabasta though I don't think it was that long. This is all speculation though.

robin is from grand line or west blue I'm not sure.... Wouldn't be retarded for manga to last only 200 days... "I will complete my life long dream in half of year" XD

 

[darkband]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

robin is from grand line or west blue I'm not sure.... Wouldn't be retarded for manga to last only 200 days... "I will complete my life long dream in half of year" XD

Robin is from West Blue as shown here. And it's not about how long the adventure lasts, its about how many mushrooms Luffy eats and all the other fun stuff he does.

 

[thunderwonder]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

if roger reached raftel in three years then it surely wouldn't take SH 5 years just to get to half. I too believe that its nearly an year.

any guesses on the floor on which fight is gonna start??

 

[Lord Rayleigh]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

No matter what anyone says here, I stay with my thaught, that the Mugiwaras are sailing for ca. a year now.

The number of days I said are a result of a study done by the better and the most viable french site about the OP World : La Volonté du D

It's not like Odachi did mention every second they were sailing through the sea/ocean.

Oda often mentions the days that spend between each travel in boat and each arc.

 

[Lee-tyme7]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

Yes even if you can never be 100% sure in One Piece it seems White Beard fututre is settled. The question is rather who will kill him ? (shichibukai, Admiral, crocodile...)
I don't think that one of the World Powers will take him down but his disease or Roger's old wound will give Whitebeard the final blow. He is old and his health isn't in a good condition, this war will probably worn out to the max.
And I personally think that it would be ironic, if the old Pirate King 'kills' Whitebeard. His death would cause a new Pirate Age just like how Roger did.

White Beard's not sick! He is still healthy and living, the wound he got is not an illness it's a sucker punch he got from Black Beard. BB wounded him and escape that's why WB order Ace to go kill him cus he couldn't do it himself. And when Shank ask him to call off the BB hunt he refused cus he was fill with hatred for revenge. heres the pic of WB and Shank, remember Shank got his scar from BB as well:
http://www.mangafox.com/manga/one_piece/v45/c434/6.html

here is when Ace first met WB he looks healthy enough:
http://www.mangafox.com/manga/one_piece/v54/c525/3.html

---

The story time since the beginning of Monkey D. Luffy's piracy is around the 100 days. At the end of TB, when the SH left Thriller Back, it was about the 80th day. You just have to re-read all the chapters of OP and count the days that spend.

Does anyone here do the math? Who actually knows how long they spend in each arc? I wanna know if it's really about a year only cus it's seem forever. so 10 yrs for us is 1 yrs in OP time?

 

[OunknownO]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

White Beard's not sick! He is still healthy and living, the wound he got is not an illness it's a sucker punch he got from Black Beard. BB wounded him and escape that's why WB order Ace to go kill him cus he couldn't do it himself. And when Shank ask him to call off the BB hunt he refused cus he was fill with hatred for revenge. heres the pic of WB and Shank, remember Shank got his scar from BB as well:
http://www.mangafox.com/manga/one_piece/v45/c434/6.html

here is when Ace first met WB he looks healthy enough:
http://www.mangafox.com/manga/one_piece/v54/c525/3.html
<hr noshade size="1">



Does anyone here do the math? Who actually knows how long they spend in each arc? I wanna know if it's really about a year only cus it's seem forever. so 10 yrs for us is 1 yrs in OP time?

bb didn't give that wound whitebeard.... Gold D. Roger had give him that wound... that why he said when he sees shanks it reminds him of Gold D. Roger(shanks was a trainee on rogers ship)

 

[Lee-tyme7]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

WB to Shanks: "The wound I got from that guys aches whenever I look at ur face " WB is referring to Roger, since Shanks used to be on his ship. BB flew cause he killed a fellow crewmate consequently a son of WB.

Also there is weak point in ur logic, why should WB send Ace after BB, if according to you even WB couldn't defeat him? I mean it's clear that Ace isn't as strong as WB.

I thought WB was talking about the scar on Shank's face? is that right? What kinda wound did Roger inflicted upon WB anyway? And I get what you saying about sending Ace to do a job WB can't, maybe like I said BB sucker punch him and fled and since WB is injured and BB was under Ace command the rules are Ace gotta handle BB.
Plus in Ace flashback we see a healthy WB standing giving a helping hand to Ace, (we know this took place years after Roger's death cus Ace and Luffy wasn't born the time Roger died) even if he was injured by Roger that's gotta be like a couple years old wound. If you're saying Roger injured him that fight between them have to take place a long time ago before Rogers death. That wounds have ta be a crippling wound like poison or something to last that long. It also doesn't explain how he was able to stand helping Ace at the time.

 

[goldb]

Re: One Piece 541 Discussion/542 Predictions

I thought WB was talking about the scar on Shank's face? is that right? What kinda wound did Roger inflicted upon WB anyway? And I get what you saying about sending Ace to do a job WB can't, maybe like I said BB sucker punch him and fled and since WB is injured and BB was under Ace command the rules are Ace gotta handle BB.
Plus in Ace flashback we see a healthy WB standing giving a helping hand to Ace, (we know this took place years after Roger's death cus Ace and Luffy wasn't born the time Roger died) even if he was injured by Roger that's gotta be like a couple years old wound. If you're saying Roger injured him that fight between them have to take place a long time ago before Rogers death. That wounds have ta be a crippling wound like poison or something to last that long. It also doesn't explain how he was able to stand helping Ace at the time.

When Whitebeard is talking to Shanks about the wound he received, he was referring to Roger. When we see the flashback of Ace and Whitebeard, we know that happened within the last 3 years of the current storyline since Ace left his village 3 years before Luffy...so either that's a mistake on Oda's part or something else yet to be explained. The scar on Shank's face was done by Blackbeard as he mentioned himself.

 

[gold349]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Jimbie and Ace have had a battle...one where Ace nearly died and Jimbie said he was as beaten up as him...who knows this could be where we see WB stretch his hand out to Ace to join his crew.

 

[Lee-tyme7]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Yeah, Oda has the tendincy to not explain much and that's what I hate about mangas you have to wait for the explaination. Same goes for what color of clothes they are wearing, ya know. Why couldn't the manga tell us wat color that house is? or say, "Hey nice blue shirt ur wearing!" just so we get the picture and not wait for the anime.
But that scene between WB and Shank could go both ways for me until Oda explain it otherwise.

 

[Gcat88]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

thats the beauty of OP. it leaves everything for later. a lot is explained in the manga u jus gotta wait for it. one of my fav. aspects of OP is the suspense and not knowing how everything is truly connected.

 

[Lee-tyme7]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Speaking of Scars and wound I don't remember how Luffy got his scar under his left eye? I heard it's from that bandit where he first met shank but I don't think it happen then. Must be after that, during the training with Ace and one of their friend Garp mention.

 

[thunderhead6482]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Luffy got his scar from slicing himself to prove to Shanks that he was tough.

 

[Lee-tyme7]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Yeah, but that's the manga I don't remember that in the anime? Does the manga not count if they didn't show it in the anime? What, suddenly Oda change is mind about that important scene?

 

[BlackHair]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

1 Manga
2 Anime

Oda has less influence in the Anime and since the Manga is directly from him, it's "more" canon. About the slicing scene, well the anime probably skipped that cause it may had a bad influence on kids or sth.. idk lol

 

[Imitorar]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

Manga is ALWAYS more canon than anime when the anime is based on the manga. Otherwise you get into all sorts of plot holes, like the Rumble Ball issue from the Davy Back Fight arc in the anime, or Zoro cutting steel in the Warship Island arc. But what happened was that Toei basically censored the scene. They didn't want anyone to imitate it, so they didn't animate it. They also changed things on Baratie so that instead of Zeff eating his own leg, his leg is torn off when he rescues Sanji, and had Brogy's hand completely covered with wax on Little Garden so that it wouldn't look like he'd been stabbed through the palms. There are other examples, these are just the ones that come most readily to my mind.

 

[d3death]

Re: One Piece Mega Convo (Spoilers!)

wow! never knew about that zeff difference.. i guess i'll start reading from chapter 1 after my finals..

thanks for info..