Quality?

[Ganzxel]

Hello,

The pages below are the pages from One Piece 521. The raws were provided by Franky House is around MQ-HQ. I would like to know what are the quality of the pages below if it was rated. (please rate the pages below )

Spoiler

Spoiler: sample

The pages were cleaned by me in around 5 - 10 minutes. I'm currently trying to learn HQ speed cleaning and any comments whatsoever would be very much appreciate .

Thank you in advance

Note: Huhu... I think I posted this in the wrong section cause I found a similar topic in the "MHA Edited Manga Branch". Can someone please move the thread to the correct place, please?

[kirimi]Thread moved. [/kirimi]

 

[1211]

HQ speed cleaning, that doesn't seem to fit well together..

Anyways on the first one you overleveled, as you can clearly see that in the greys, the 2nd one is way better

Referring to the sample spoiler here, and I'd rate it LQ-MQ

 

[Ganzxel]

Thanks 1211 for the comments and critique. I thought the first one look quite burn too.

I guess one set of actions is not suitable for all the pages after all. I'm trying to imitate Binktopia speed scans - which for me is the ultimate speedscan quality. I'll try to do better next time

 

[wade69]

Bink are quite close to the diffuse type of cleaning but theres is unique and they don't like sharing.

 

[Ganzxel]

Yes I figure that much when I tried to ask for some advice. Sob sob... But I will not give up.