Secrets of Doflamingo

7pac

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
150
Reaction score
28
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

I honestly prefer Akainu tbh.
 

REN KOUEN

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 20, 2012
Messages
5,480
Reaction score
1,292
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

I honestly prefer Akainu tbh.
well he is certainly a hated character, and i agree that he isnt exactly a "good guy"

but was he really the "villain" of the war arc? he certainly gained the most attention and hatred from the fans

but something tells me he will have a more focused roll as a "main villain" of an arc later on, maybe not

but i can certainly respect your opinion on that, Oda did a great job of making most OP fans hate that guy right off the bad

not only for
killing ace

but also for
lying to squardo to get squardo to betray WB

hes just a low down bastard who isnt a respectable admiaral like kizaru is or how aokoji was

now kizaru isnt exactly a nice guy, however he doesnt seem to have the below the belt style of akainu

who may very well be the most hated man in OP

of course my favorite villain overall would probably be marshall D teach

i just love BB because he is a real pirate, like if you pictured a pirate in your mind, you picture a sloppy rum drinking cut throat bastard who would gut his own mom for treasure

that my friends is black beard

and it will be epic when he gets his main arc (he will be a lasting villain before then too im sure) its going to be something to see
 

Seafarer

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2013
Messages
167
Reaction score
60
Gender
Male
Country
France
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

I have to agree, DD is by far the best-developped villain in the entire series. BlackBeard and Akainu both committed hate-inducing acts, but neither of them has half the character depth of Doflamingo. We know very little about the history that backs their motivation, which makes them seem very shallow in comparison.

Plus, sooner or later past villains eventually "lost it" and resorted to gratuitous acts that made them hatable to the audience but did not make much sense and destroyed their character:
- CP9 turning to cold-blooded murder and wide-scale destruction after years of patient infiltration
- Spandam (the guy is a childish-minded psychopath. No-one in their right mind would entrust to him the government's top secret police, seriously)
- Crocodile attempting to bomb the population of the very kingdom he's trying to seize
- Ener trying to destroy the whole of Skypiea (although Ener is simply insane, so his acts don't have to make sense)
- Hodi trying to sink FI
- ...

Dofla has yet to perform one of those, which makes him much more solid as a character. I hope he doesn't, truth be told. He's already a perfect villain the way he is now.
 
Last edited:

danzouismadara

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 26, 2008
Messages
2,951
Reaction score
640
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

yes, since DD is pretty much part of all the immoral things in one piece. Plus, he is dangerously strong and ruthless.
 

7pac

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2013
Messages
150
Reaction score
28
Age
34
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

well he is certainly a hated character, and i agree that he isnt exactly a "good guy"

but was he really the "villain" of the war arc? he certainly gained the most attention and hatred from the fans

but something tells me he will have a more focused roll as a "main villain" of an arc later on, maybe not

but i can certainly respect your opinion on that, Oda did a great job of making most OP fans hate that guy right off the bad

not only for
killing ace

but also for
lying to squardo to get squardo to betray WB

hes just a low down bastard who isnt a respectable admiaral like kizaru is or how aokoji was

now kizaru isnt exactly a nice guy, however he doesnt seem to have the below the belt style of akainu

who may very well be the most hated man in OP

of course my favorite villain overall would probably be marshall D teach

i just love BB because he is a real pirate, like if you pictured a pirate in your mind, you picture a sloppy rum drinking cut throat bastard who would gut his own mom for treasure

that my friends is black beard

and it will be epic when he gets his main arc (he will be a lasting villain before then too im sure) its going to be something to see

I surely agree with you! BlackBeard is the stereotypical Pirate we would picture ourselfs. But I still see him kinda of a joker, Yeah he's a villain but he's like luffy, but evil.
Funny that we keep using the terms "evil" and "good", since there is no such things but just beliefs of every individual, Either way, Akainu is both hated, incredibly strong, awesome, altho I hate him, I still love him, awesome character in my opinion. And he's like coolminded, like he focuses on what he has to do, and doesn't fuck around like 90% of the one piece world, if you notice. The only 2 characters that don't just blabber but attack I saw, were WhiteBeard and Akainu.

It's still early tho, the characters have not been developed yet. Oh And I must correct you on the fact that BlackBeard is the last Villain, He is not.

In my opinion the story goes like this:

Luffy-> Conquers Yonko's and most of the New World
Luffy-> Fights with BlackBeard Before Reaching Raftel ( for some reason I'm sure to reach raftel you need to have the ability to hear the voice of all things, otherwise the other yonko and thousands pirates have just been fuccking around for decades...??)
Luffy-> Reaches Raftel, Becomes Pirate King, Discovers The Blank Century Secrets.
Luffy-> Starts a Huge War, Pirates vs Marines and WG.
Luff-> And Strawhats battle with the 5 Elder Stars


So imo, it goes BB->Akainu->WG
 

REN KOUEN

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 20, 2012
Messages
5,480
Reaction score
1,292
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

I have to agree, DD is by far the best-developped villain in the entire series. BlackBeard and Akainu both committed hate-inducing acts, but neither of them has half the character depth of Doflamingo. We know very little about the history that backs their motivation, which makes them seem very shallow in comparison.

Plus, sooner or later past villains eventually "lost it" and resorted to gratuitous acts that made them hatable to the audience but did not make much sense and destroyed their character:
- CP9 turning to cold-blooded murder and wide-scale destruction after years of patient infiltration
- Spandam (the guy is a childish-minded psychopath. No-one in their right mind would entrust to him the government's top secret police, seriously)
- Crocodile attempting to bomb the population of the very kingdom he's trying to seize
- Ener trying to destroy the whole of Skypiea (although Ener is simply insane, so his acts don't have to make sense)
- Hodi trying to sink FI
- ...

Dofla has yet to perform one of those, which makes him much more solid as a character. I hope he doesn't, truth be told. He's already a perfect villain the way he is now.
i do believe we will receive much more background about black beard, especially since he also has the will of D and his father was apparently an important pirate

akainu on the other hand..... we may not be as fortunate to learn as much about his past and history, but who knows. Oda does love to go into the past and tell stories.

So far Oda has done a great job of using flashbacks to fill us in on details of certain characters.
 

zelllogan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2005
Messages
2,205
Reaction score
1,001
Age
42
Gender
Male
Country
Belgium
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

Don Flamingo didn't make enough to make the straw hats hate him. He didn't arm the strawhats directly.
Crocodile is still far ahead for me.
 

REN KOUEN

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Feb 20, 2012
Messages
5,480
Reaction score
1,292
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

Don Flamingo didn't make enough to make the straw hats hate him. He didn't arm the strawhats directly.
Crocodile is still far ahead for me.
Well Df was behind the human slavery auction that lead luffy to attack the celestial dragon camie getting caught and hachi getting shot

and he was also behind ceasar capturing those kids and experimenting on them

he has been behind much of the strawhats frustration

and give him some time, the arc isnt over yet, i could see him really pissing some of them off before the end of the dressrosa saga
 

zelllogan

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 8, 2005
Messages
2,205
Reaction score
1,001
Age
42
Gender
Male
Country
Belgium
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

Well Df was behind the human slavery auction that lead luffy to attack the celestial dragon camie getting caught and hachi getting shot

and he was also behind ceasar capturing those kids and experimenting on them

he has been behind much of the strawhats frustration

and give him some time, the arc isnt over yet, i could see him really pissing some of them off before the end of the dressrosa saga
I'm giving him time but you're the one talking about "so far" in the manga :).
He needs to do something massive to obtain the level of hate crocodile had. Basically, he needs to kill Law,Rebecca or Kinemon.

When luffy heard about BB in this arc, he nearly didn't react even though he is also responsible for the death of his brother & the destruction of chopper's land. Indirect hits doesn't matter. Luffy needs to see up front evil deeds. Concerning Dofla, Luffy started to see it in the jail at the coliseum but that's nowhere near enough.
 
Last edited:

hoeru

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 22, 2011
Messages
1,558
Reaction score
705
Gender
Hidden
Country
Mauritius
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

"Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?"

He's interesting and has some sort of charisma. But best by far? How does anyone measure this? Blackbeard hid himself for 20 years within the Whitebeard Pirates and then suddenly became a Yonko within a year as his plan started to unfold.

Luffy has still many villains to take out. Shichibukai, Yonko, Marine officers - there should still be one left from the worst generation.
 

ukimix

Intl Translator
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Aug 13, 2011
Messages
3,313
Reaction score
2,810
Gender
Hidden
Country
Colombia
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

"Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?"

He's interesting and has some sort of charisma. But best by far? How does anyone measure this? Blackbeard hid himself for 20 years within the Whitebeard Pirates and then suddenly became a Yonko within a year as his plan started to unfold.

Luffy has still many villains to take out. Shichibukai, Yonko, Marine officers - there should still be one left from the worst generation.
The best by far ≠ the best thus far. So I think he's simply asking if DD is the best villain we have seen until now.

Imo, yes; he's the best or the one I have enjoyed the most until now.
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

Plus, sooner or later past villains eventually "lost it" and resorted to gratuitous acts that made them hatable to the audience but did not make much sense and destroyed their character:
- CP9 turning to cold-blooded murder and wide-scale destruction after years of patient infiltration
- Spandam (the guy is a childish-minded psychopath. No-one in their right mind would entrust to him the government's top secret police, seriously)
- Crocodile attempting to bomb the population of the very kingdom he's trying to seize
- Ener trying to destroy the whole of Skypiea (although Ener is simply insane, so his acts don't have to make sense)
- Hodi trying to sink FI
- ...

Dofla has yet to perform one of those, which makes him much more solid as a character. I hope he doesn't, truth be told. He's already a perfect villain the way he is now.
Cp9 has always been cold blooded murderer, that is their true face. The question here is not to be surprise about their so call ruthlessness but rather how were they able to stay undercover. But even that question was answer within the series. Rob Lucci and the likes didn't hide their opinion how disgusting the whole thing was. By "being professional" and "bottle up the urge to kill," they are just that more murderous. However, Rob Lucci had always been professional through out so I don't get the "wide scale destruction" comment at all.

Oh geez, Spandam, come on, you don't get Spandam?? That is precisely the point. It showed incompetent in the government. But one piece spell it out with the character by making him as cartoonish as possible. I have been following politics long enough to know there are clowns like Spandam all over. From Palin to Bachman to Perry to Hermain Cain to Ted Cruz, and those are just the Americans. Also the number one point to Spandam which touch on the Celestial Dragon is this "NEPOTISM."

On Crocodile, he wants the throne. And more than that, he wants the ancient weapon. The throne is just a convenient to work without attracting attention very much like Doflamingo. He wants to build a powerful military force by using the ancient weapons and force pirates under his flag. Although, Crocodile didn't really state the reason for the bomb, it is clear to me. For 1, that isn't the entire population of Alabasta, it is just a small portion. For 2, he planned to build a military out of pirates he doesn't need army/people with morality that are able to stand up to him. Wiping them out in one sweep is the best thing for him. Once he got the ancient weapon, which was supposed to be during the plan Utopia, he had the bargaining chip against the world government. But he wasn't successful in that.

Enel does whatever he wants. But Enel is also one of the more intelligent enemy that Luffy encounter.

And then there is Hody. Geez, I thought he said exactly why he did what he did?? The other ones are kinda old so I explain them. But this is fairly recent. I am not even bother.
 
Last edited:

Seafarer

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2013
Messages
167
Reaction score
60
Gender
Male
Country
France
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

Yes, yes, Oda is thorough as a storywriter. However, just because there is a story justification for every little thing doesn't mean that it makes sense and builds an enjoyable character, or that we have to like it.

On the matter of CP9, how else do you call burning down the siege of Galley-la, trying to murder the mayor, and openly assaulting the shipwrights? Honestly, if they were prepared from the start to resort to such methods, why even bother with infiltration? This is precisely the aspect of CP9 I have trouble with. Either they're straightforward brutes or they're cautious infiltrators, but being both at a time doesn't make much sense.

As for Spandam, just because he is the embodiment of a social comment doesn't mean that he should be a caricature through and through.

Crocodile is probably the one character I shouldn't have included in the list. The bombing is arguable, but everything prior to that was a masterplan.


Anyway, we simply do not have the same appreciation of characters. I do not see a point in discussing it further.
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

Yes, yes, Oda is thorough as a storywriter. However, just because there is a story justification for every little thing doesn't mean that it makes sense and builds an enjoyable character, or that we have to like it.
Just you or "we"?? Who are we?? So now you are going from understanding to like??

Honestly, if they were prepared from the start to resort to such methods, why even bother with infiltration? This is precisely the aspect of CP9 I have trouble with. Either they're straightforward brutes or they're cautious infiltrators, but being both at a time doesn't make much sense.
No, no, and no... Didn't you read the manga.. I don't want to tell you things and then you are going to be defensive and said well although I don't understand that doesn't meant I gonna like it. Like Hody, I perfectly understand him. He is okay as villain I like others better. Again, if you want me to enlighten you I will, but if you want to have a fix set of belief then feel free to do so.

As for Spandam, just because he is the embodiment of a social comment doesn't mean that he should be a caricature through and through.
This one I would argue. To me as a specific reader, he is a social commentary. Maybe Oda doesn't meant him that way, but it is logical within the One Piece world. In fact, meaphe like Spandam as a villain very much. I hold her opinion (as a literature analysis and the fact that she makes a ton of videos on One Piece reviews that I think were mostly intellectual) with much much more weight than yours.

http://www.youtube.com/user/meapheandjunk

Best One Piece reviewer on the web.... (this statement is an opinion not fact).

Anyway, we simply do not have the same appreciation of characters. I do not see a point in discussing it further.
Well, there is understanding and there is "like" or "not like." I see you as misunderstanding some of the characters. I do too sometimes. If you want me to explain what my flaw understanding, I would. But don't be too close minded and defensive if I call you out on it.

---------- Post added at 05:52 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:38 PM ----------

If anyone had the same view of Seafarer and want my interpretation on the matter, I will continue. I thought his last comment is laughable. Mixing misunderstanding with like or not like. Sure the title of this thread does have to do with like and not like, but if you going to put out posts that are inherently flaw, then be ready for them to be criticize. (Or never mind, since we all gonna like different things like tacos and tacos and tacos, and apples, and Chinese food. There is like no point to talk about anything.)

As for the topic of this thread, the current arc isn't over yet for me to decide. Each previous villains brought something different to the "angle" of villainy. I don't know why but I like the semi unpredictable Enel. Unlike most of the previous villains, Doflamingo does not have a clear upper hand in the plot and or driving the Strawhats into a corner yet (or create a desperate situation) (which I kinda like because Oda is trying something different). But then again, that is the way Oda want to tell the current arc. Doflamingo's ambition though seemed to be second only to Black Beard.
 
Last edited:

MBVC

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2012
Messages
1,190
Reaction score
164
Gender
Male
Country
Bouvet Island
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

"When luffy heard about BB in this arc, he nearly didn't react even though he is also responsible for the death of his brother & the destruction of chopper's land"


Please don't blame BB for Ace dead. Ace was killed because he was stubborn, he thought he could beat the crap out of Akainu but he wasn't powerful enough. Honestly speaking, he made huge mistakes twice, I really don't understand why Ace thought he could finish BB easily base on his inexperience in both skills and power. Of course he saved Luffy by fighting BB but he really shouldn't have fought with Akainu in that situation. Defending WB's honor makes sense if and only if he'd had the ability to win not by loosing his life meaninglessly. Luffy is only a little bit more realistic when he decided to run from smoker or ordered his crew to run away from both Aokiji and Kizaru.


Only Akainu was serious and a jack@$$ during the war, both Aokiji and Kizaru had several chances to kill Luffy but both of them just stopped him from moving forward because they all knew Garp would have hunted them down afterward if Luffy died. Aokiji could have frozen both Jinbei and Luffy on the ice (Aokiji > Jinbei on ice) and Kizaru could have aimed at Luff's big head instead of that small key.
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

Please don't blame BB for Ace dead.
That part bother me a bit. But I could make some sense out of Ace, if WhiteBeard didn't sacrifice himself, then maybe things will turn out for a different. What Akainu pretty much did was spitting on Whitebeard face when WhiteBeard is making the most selfless decision. And maybe because of Ace that they got into that mess in the first place, he felt that he had to do something. I supposed that is something in the spur of the moment and you can't think clearly because you are so clouded with your emotions. When Ace die, I recall a large portion of One Piece fans in mangahelpers were piss and felt that he die for no reason. I could understand that sentiment.

The whole Akainu and Aojiki dynamic is very interesting. In the overall picture, I still have trouble seeing Akainu as a villain like Magellan. But if he keeps up his good work on Marineford, I may change this opinion.
 

MBVC

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2012
Messages
1,190
Reaction score
164
Gender
Male
Country
Bouvet Island
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

I really don't mind him defending WB's honor, but at least he had to win otherwise it's really stupid to die without any damage to the insulter. To sum it all up, Ace was an ignorant bastard, he overestimated himself and underestimated both BB and Aikainu.

Luffy did the same thing when he punched a CD, if he asked Sanji to think up a plan to kidnap that CD for saving Camie & Hacchi then it's harder for the marine to know who did it, those underlings who worked for CD were weaklings, I think Sanji, Robin and Usopp (these 3 are quite efficient doing sneaky things) were more than enough handling the rescue operation, but I guess bunching a CD is much more cooler than kidnapping one, not to mention Luffy dislikes any kind of kidnapping too.
 
Last edited:

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

I really don't mind him defending WB's honor, but at least he had to win otherwise it's really stupid to die without any damage to the insulter. To sum it all up, Ace was an ignorant bastard, he overestimated himself and underestimated both BB and Aikainu.
I don't recall the exact details. When that chapter came out a lot of people share your sentiments, but funnily enough, with the passage of time, people look at Ace's death quite fondly. Part of it is within Ace's nature (the good + the bad). I meant he was reckless enough to go up against Whitebeard in the first place. Beside he isn't the smartest tool in the shed anyhow. Even now, I thought it was brilliant that Oda kill Ace before Whitebeard to f*ck with people's head. As far as characters' behaviors and if they acted natural up until the moment of Akainu killed Ace, I am leaning toward "yes, the whole thing sort of logical." But I could understand the criticism that Ace's death is flaw.

But boy, BlackBeard sure have a lot of guts. He need the government to be on his side after offending WhiteBeard. On that meant time, he fled to Paradise when WhiteBeard had much less influence in as opposed to the New World while he gather up followers. But he took so much risks too. If WhiteBeard had send Marco or Jozu or even Vista (or 2 and 3 of the commanders), then Blackbeard would be in big trouble. Though at time, I felt BlackBeard is more of a background element of the plot instead of a villain. He will be one sooner or later. Now that I think about it I don't really hate a villain in One Piece. In some series (manga/books/tv/movies), there are great villains that make your blood boil with rage and you just want to beat the shit out of them. I don't feel that way about One Piece villains.
 

MBVC

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 5, 2012
Messages
1,190
Reaction score
164
Gender
Male
Country
Bouvet Island
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

At least BB left Ace alive so that WB could rescue him, and they almost succeeded only if Ace decided to go all out revenge for WB after the war, maybe in 1-2 years then he'd have died honor with his full pride. What BB told WB was true that he didn't kill Ace only WB failed to save him, that's all.

I only dislike Spandam for being a f**head, I was quite disappointed that Robin didn't break several of his limbs but I really don't want him dead of course. Hody receives his punishment from those pills, Akainu was used by BB to create another bigger monster and he has to deal with the huge consequences afterward.
 

weixiaobao

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
4,323
Reaction score
917
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Re: Is Don Flamingo the best villain thus far in One Piece ?

At least BB left Ace alive so that WB could rescue him, and they almost succeeded only if Ace decided to go all out revenge for WB after the war, maybe in 1-2 years then he'd have died honor with his full pride. What BB told WB was true that he didn't kill Ace only WB failed to save him, that's all.
Okay, this is what Mr. Seaferer didn't get in his post. Things change, characters change to adopt. BlackBeard wants the shichibukai title to get access to Impel Down. But he didn't plan on capturing Ace, and because of Ace he got to start the whole war and draw out WhiteBeard. He made a huge gamble on WhiteBeard dying but it pay off big time. Like wise, Rob Lucci and companions were dutifully follow their duty and then Nico Robin show up and speed up the whole process. If I am recall correctly, once Nico Robin show up, Spandam changed their order (which more like hurry up, maybe it may be even be in the background and not on the panels). Rob Lucci's assassination of Iceburg guy was a pretty good plan for the objective that he wanted.

I only dislike Spandam for being a f**head, I was quite disappointed that Robin didn't break several of his limbs but I really don't want him dead of course. Hody receives his punishment from those pills, Akainu was used by BB to create another bigger monster and he has to deal with the huge consequences afterward.
I don't think people supposed to like Spandam, he was meant to be hate with his pettiness. Meaphe pointed out something that was I overlooked about Hody. Hody is a cheater lol. But of all of the villains, Hody's original plan was doom to fail since the start and may even jeopardize fishmen even more if he succeed. Once the drugs kick in, he would be too old and weak to led the fishmen. And they would pretty much consume by Big Mam or other forces.
 
Top