Discussion The Sinner... who saw it coming?

GreedHunt

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2018
Messages
218
Reaction score
375
Age
27
Country
Spain
I remember that the first time I heard of someone predicting that Chandler and Cusack used to be a single demon was here, one or two weeks ago. I liked the idea but I didn't really think it would happen. Who predicted it, and why? Did I miss some cool foreshadowing or was it just a random theory that worked? I'm really curious.
 

the powerscaller

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Oct 25, 2018
Messages
468
Reaction score
400
Age
25
Country
India
It was me who theorized it and it became true not just me but another fellow whom I don't know too said so
 

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
I don't know who made that theory but it wasn't random at all. You have this:



And then this:



So yeah, it was completely foreshadowed and almost nobody noticed it.
 

Boldon

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2018
Messages
308
Reaction score
939
Age
29
Country
Switzerland
"he split that power into 10 fragments"

Meaning that the DK defeated the sinner+10C?

Meaning the sinner we see is 10 commandments weaker than the one who fought the DK?

Jesus Christ
 

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
"he split that power into 10 fragments"

Meaning that the DK defeated the sinner+10C?

Meaning the sinner we see is 10 commandments weaker than the one who fought the DK?

Jesus Christ
And the DK still defeated him. 50% of his power + the Sinner's own should be above him in his 50% state. So, unless the DK could retrieve his power from the Sinner at the moment the fight started, it doesn't make much sense. Maybe he couldn't figure out The Ruler's weakness and that's why he lost despite having more power? Or maybe the Sinner couldn't control the power that the DK lent to him? It wouldn't be that strange considering that for 99% of the Demons is suicide to absorb more than one commandment (5% of his power).
 

GreedHunt

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2018
Messages
218
Reaction score
375
Age
27
Country
Spain
I don't know who made that theory but it wasn't random at all. You have this:



And then this:



So yeah, it was completely foreshadowed and almost nobody noticed it.
I thought Nakaba could never surprise me too much after the Mael twist, but oh boi was I wrong. Granted, this was less obvious that Estarossa having something strange going on with it, but still. My respects to whoever noticed it.
 

Admiral Teach

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2017
Messages
1,433
Reaction score
2,073
Country
Water Tribe
I remember how so many were raving and pulling out their hair about how such an asspull the Masters were. How it was inexcusable for them to be even existing, let alone lending a hand or being as powerful as, and ultimately much, much stronger, than the 10C. Despite that it was said they were old or not even considered actual military, and therefore not calculated among the warriors and all that. They were still an intolerable writing fumble because it was not foreshadowed.

Those people are silent now. :derp

The reveal was indeed totally foreshadowed. But I had no clue they were the fabled first servant. That said, I did suspect we would get a fusion somewhere at the end. Not sure why, it just seemed like something that ought to happen, and this way fits perfectly. I am not sure how I feel about the Sinner's design. It's basically a manitcore thingy from the Legend of Zelda, but with four arms and a human head. Perhaps he will have multiple forms? He seems strong enough and more than boss material at this point, even final boss should Nakaba not wish to make someone else the big bad, like Meliodas.
 

LaserBeam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2017
Messages
1,791
Reaction score
1,984
Age
40
Country
Greece
Is this the official translation? is if it then


I like how in the 3rd panel it says that <<- but the power was so great it could even threaten his position>>

this line is generic and to be honest you can barely understand that he gave the power according to this line
because in the line zeldris speaks hypothetically since it put the word ( could )in it you do not speak hypothetically if something happened
The line should had been different it should had been something like this << but the power was so great that it threatened his position>>

Also his silhouette from that shaded panel is really bad to show that it was him because the guy has a horse like the bottom part but the shaded silhouette it looks like it has a normal bottom body with 2 legs instead of 4 also his head shape is different a yes and now i am rewatching the panel nowhere you can see that he had 4 arms
 

BurlapJack

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 29, 2018
Messages
2,045
Reaction score
3,997
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Is this the official translation? is if it then


I like how in the 3rd panel it says that <<- but the power was so great it could even threaten his position>>

this line is generic and to be honest you can barely understand that he gave the power according to this line
because in the line zeldris speaks hypothetically since it put the word ( could )in it you do not speak hypothetically if something happened
The line should had been different it should had been something like this << but the power was so great that it threatened his position>>

Also his silhouette from that shaded panel is really bad to show that it was him because the guy has a horse like the bottom part but the shaded silhouette it looks like it has a normal bottom body with 2 legs instead of 4 also his head shape is different a yes and now i am rewatching the panel nowhere you can see that he had 4 arms
Maybe this is a beast form and his dormant resting form is humanoid
 

Laoufette

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2015
Messages
160
Reaction score
215
Age
30
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
I remember how so many were raving and pulling out their hair about how such an asspull the Masters were. How it was inexcusable for them to be even existing, let alone lending a hand or being as powerful as, and ultimately much, much stronger, than the 10C. Despite that it was said they were old or not even considered actual military, and therefore not calculated among the warriors and all that. They were still an intolerable writing fumble because it was not foreshadowed.

Those people are silent now. :derp

The reveal was indeed totally foreshadowed. But I had no clue they were the fabled first servant. That said, I did suspect we would get a fusion somewhere at the end. Not sure why, it just seemed like something that ought to happen, and this way fits perfectly. I am not sure how I feel about the Sinner's design. It's basically a manitcore thingy from the Legend of Zelda, but with four arms and a human head. Perhaps he will have multiple forms? He seems strong enough and more than boss material at this point, even final boss should Nakaba not wish to make someone else the big bad, like Meliodas.
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
I remember how so many were raving and pulling out their hair about how such an asspull the Masters were. How it was inexcusable for them to be even existing, let alone lending a hand or being as powerful as, and ultimately much, much stronger, than the 10C. Despite that it was said they were old or not even considered actual military, and therefore not calculated among the warriors and all that. They were still an intolerable writing fumble because it was not foreshadowed.

Those people are silent now. :derp

The reveal was indeed totally foreshadowed. But I had no clue they were the fabled first servant. That said, I did suspect we would get a fusion somewhere at the end. Not sure why, it just seemed like something that ought to happen, and this way fits perfectly. I am not sure how I feel about the Sinner's design. It's basically a manitcore thingy from the Legend of Zelda, but with four arms and a human head. Perhaps he will have multiple forms? He seems strong enough and more than boss material at this point, even final boss should Nakaba not wish to make someone else the big bad, like Meliodas.
I don't get the point of your post. They still came out of nowhere. The Demon of Origin came out of nowhere.
Nakaba handled the Ten Commandments very poorly and introduced two demons that were later made to seem as if their introduction were logical, but the point stands that their existence was never foreshadowed and their entrance into the story was poorly executed. Had we gotten a hint that the Demon King had a servant prior to Cusack and Chandler's first appearance, it would be considerably better, but again, that isn't the case. Their and the Sinner's identities were introduced to fill in for the gap that the Ten Commandments failed to accomplish in the story.
There was zero build-up. Zero hints. Nothing.
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
I don't get the point of your post. They still came out of nowhere. The Demon of Origin came out of nowhere.
Nakaba handled the Ten Commandments very poorly and introduced two demons that were later made to seem as if their introduction were logical, but the point stands that their existence was never foreshadowed and their entrance into the story was poorly executed. Had we gotten a hint that the Demon King had a servant prior to Cusack and Chandler's first appearance, it would be considerably better, but again, that isn't the case. Their and the Sinner's identities were introduced to fill in for the gap that the Ten Commandments failed to accomplish in the story.
There was zero build-up. Zero hints. Nothing.
Why didn’t people label the existence of the 10c “out of nowhere”? How about the 4 AA? How about indura? The six black Knights? Deathpierce? Arden? Deldrey? Gerheade?
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
Why didn’t people label the existence of the 10c “out of nowhere”? How about the 4 AA? How about indura? The six black Knights? Deathpierce? Arden? Deldrey? Gerheade?
  • Because we knew nothing about the Demon Clan at that point. We were introduced to the most elite and dangerous group of the Demon Clan, however, and having that establishment be broken later on does not add up.
  • Because we knew nothing about the Goddesses.
  • Indura came out of nowhere.
  • Because they were weaker than the TCs. Complete coherence in the story.
  • Because they were weaker than the SDS. Coherent progression.
The difference in story coherence is marked in these comparisons.
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
  • Because we knew nothing about the Demon Clan at that point. We were introduced to the most elite and dangerous group of the Demon Clan, however, and having that establishment be broken later on does not add up.
  • Because we knew nothing about the Goddesses.
  • Indura came out of nowhere.
  • Because they were weaker than the TCs. Complete coherence in the story.
  • Because they were weaker than the SDS. Coherent progression.
The difference in story coherence is marked in these comparisons.
We knew nothing and their intro had them just pop out. The info we got right after was Mel calling them “the elite unit that work directly under the demon king.” What coherency was challenged by introducing two powerful old men that had little military involvement as of the most current time, who were tasked merely to teach the two princes? Old men. Veterans of a clan. Clans have no old people? Are they a military unit? Did Mel call the 10c the most powerful individuals of the clan?

What do we know now about the two clans? I am fairly sure information is lacking in that regard so how much of a difference is there in are understanding of two massive clans that occupy their own realms of all places, now compared to before?

Indura did. It was about as out of nowhere as mel being heir to the throne no?

The 10c being a stronger force than the six black knights is coherent

The sds being stronger is coherent

So how does chandler and cusack fall out of place given your importance of coherency if they are not related to the military as is the 10c?
 

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
We knew nothing and their intro had them just pop out. The info we got right after was Mel calling them “the elite unit that work directly under the demon king.” What coherency was challenged by introducing two powerful old men that had little military involvement as of the most current time, who were tasked merely to teach the two princes? Old men. Veterans of a clan. Clans have no old people? Are they a military unit? Did Mel call the 10c the most powerful individuals of the clan?

What do we know now about the two clans? I am fairly sure information is lacking in that regard so how much of a difference is there in are understanding of two massive clans that occupy their own realms of all places, now compared to before?

Indura did. It was about as out of nowhere as mel being heir to the throne no?

The 10c being a stronger force than the six black knights is coherent

The sds being stronger is coherent

So how does chandler and cusack fall out of place given your importance of coherency?
Saying that they never fought during the war is a poor excuse to justify the introduction of two demons who can individually solo the whole elite group of the Demon Clan. You cannot just randomly drop something of that caliber and expect everything to progress normally. Hey, you have the elite Ten Commandments who match the elite Four Archangels. The strongest demon, Meliodas, versus the strongest angel, Mael.
But wait! There are actually two beings that can replace the Ten Commandments! But they don't fight! That's something... right?
No...

Meliodas being a heir to the throne was predictable. His power had been foreshadowed. He was hiding too much for something not to be going on.
Indura was just a random power-up that made a demon go from getting almost one-shot to easily overwhelming the second strongest Archangel. There's a difference.
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
Saying that they never fought during the war is a poor excuse to justify the introduction of two demons who can individually solo the whole elite group of the Demon Clan. You cannot just randomly drop something of that caliber and expect everything to progress normally. Hey, you have the elite Ten Commandments who match the elite Four Archangels. The strongest demon, Meliodas, versus the strongest angel, Mael.
But wait! There are actually two beings that can replace the Ten Commandments! But they don't fight! That's something... right?
No...

Meliodas being a heir to the throne was predictable. His power had been foreshadowed. He was hiding too much for something not to be going on.
Indura was just a random power-up that made a demon go from getting almost one-shot to easily overwhelming the second strongest Archangel. There's a difference.
Is it? First of all, magic has an incredible range of effects, so saying that the two have no issue overcoming the 10 is questionable at best. Speaking from a realistic standpoint if I called a unit the most elite unit in the service of a king, where is the contradiction in stating that there is a retired veteran more skilled than the individuals of this “most elite unit”? He ain’t a unit. Time is progressive. Is there no logic in there existing a person who has done this before and has cultivated past his prime holding a candle against the new generation in skill and ability? Add a fantasy element and the decay of age is quite curtailed no? Am I lacking common sense?

How does the degree of personal power have anything to do with figuring out who papa is? I asked about his birth not his power. If mel were exceptionally weak would you find the dk being his father to be incoherent? Estarossa is a really good example of this regardless of the truth involving him. Mel being prince is predictable but the fact that a clan has elders is out of nowhere? A clan. Elders. This is nothing new. The relationship between the old and clans is quite near universal. The people of greatest power, influence and respect within clans were their elders. Just from the real world aspect alone of Asian cultures built in respect and reverence for elders, woven even into their language, and this realities appearance in just about all walks of their literature. You heard the term clans being coined but never thought elders to be predictable?
 
Last edited:

Gallon

Artichoke
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 6, 2015
Messages
6,197
Reaction score
13,371
Gender
Male
Country
Joker
Is it? First of all, magic has an incredible range of effects, so saying that the two have no issue overcoming the 10 is questionable at best. Speaking from a realistic standpoint if I called a unit the most elite unit in the service of a king, where is the contradiction in stating that there is a retired veteran more skilled than the individuals of this “most elite unit”? He ain’t a unit. Time is progressive. Is there no logic in there existing a person who has done this before and has cultivated past his prime holding a candle against the new generation in skill and ability? Add a fantasy element and the decay of age is quite curtailed no? Am I lacking common sense?

How does the degree of personal power have anything to do with figuring out who papa is? I asked about his birth not his power. If mel were exceptionally weak would you find the dk being his father to be incoherent? Estarossa is a really good example of this regardless of the truth involving him. Mel being prince is predictable but the fact that a clan has elders is out of nowhere? A clan. Elders. This is nothing new. The relationship between the old and clans is quite near universal. The people of greatest power, influence and respect within clans were their elders. Just from the real world aspect alone of Asian cultures built in respect and reverence for elders and this realities appearance in just about all walks of their literature. You heard the term clans being coined but never thought elders to be predictable?
Galand is just as old, yet he is still part of the Ten Commandments. Cusack and Chandler do not have the benefit of doubt in the sense of their age. We're talking about an elite unit of warriors here - elders are generally associated with being wiser and more knowledgeable, but certainly weaker in firepower than the top fighters of the clan. Having a retired military veteran generally indicates they have lost the purpose they once had, and this is by no means the case with the two masters - they're far, far above anything we've ever seen from almost all demons; it's absurd. Had their powers been comparable to the Ten Commandments or had they been previously in the ranks of the elite group, then the story could have added up due to the obvious generation gaps in the TCs, but power levels above 150,000 when your above-average Commandment barely pushes 50,000? Come on...

Relevance. Build-up. Fame. Meliodas had all of those. Galand said he was a heretic who shook the entire clan to its core. Zeldris said his betrayal led to their sealing. Fraudrin was demolished by Meliodas. Gloxinia and Drole noted that he was a crucial ally in the fight against the Demon King. Everything hinted at Meliodas having been revered among the demons.
Having elders is okay. Having elders who can wipe the floor with the highest demons is not. You can have an advisor to the Demon King, a retired demon who once used to be part of the Ten Commandments, or anything of the like - however, when you cross the boundaries and make every other demon irrelevant in the face of two who never had a build-up, you lose a good chunk of credibility.
 

T25

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2018
Messages
1,109
Reaction score
834
Age
28
Country
United States
Galand is just as old, yet he is still part of the Ten Commandments. Cusack and Chandler do not have the benefit of doubt in the sense of their age. We're talking about an elite unit of warriors here - elders are generally associated with being wiser and more knowledgeable, but certainly weaker in firepower than the top fighters of the clan. Having a retired military veteran generally indicates they have lost the purpose they once had, and this is by no means the case with the two masters - they're far, far above anything we've ever seen from almost all demons; it's absurd. Had their powers been comparable to the Ten Commandments or had they been previously in the ranks of the elite group, then the story could have added up due to the obvious generation gaps in the TCs, but power levels above 150,000 when your above-average Commandment barely pushes 50,000? Come on...

Relevance. Build-up. Fame. Meliodas had all of those. Galand said he was a heretic who shook the entire clan to its core. Zeldris said his betrayal led to their sealing. Fraudrin was demolished by Meliodas. Gloxinia and Drole noted that he was a crucial ally in the fight against the Demon King. Everything hinted at Meliodas having been revered among the demons.
Having elders is okay. Having elders who can wipe the floor with the highest demons is not. You can have an advisor to the Demon King, a retired demon who once used to be part of the Ten Commandments, or anything of the like - however, when you cross the boundaries and make every other demon irrelevant in the face of two who never had a build-up, you lose a good chunk of credibility.
Hmmm

I find Merlin more of a danger to credibility than most
 
Top