Discussion This Series as a Whole

What do you think of this series as a whole?

  • 1. Not even worth my breath

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • 2. Trash

    Votes: 4 7.8%
  • 3. Awful

    Votes: 3 5.9%
  • 4. Meh

    Votes: 4 7.8%
  • 5. Average

    Votes: 4 7.8%
  • 6. Fine

    Votes: 11 21.6%
  • 7. Good

    Votes: 15 29.4%
  • 8. Very Good

    Votes: 4 7.8%
  • 9. Great

    Votes: 3 5.9%
  • 10. Masterpiece

    Votes: 3 5.9%

  • Total voters
    51

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
So, now that the series has officially ended, I believe it's time for a thread like this in which each and every one of us voices his/her opinion regarding the series as a whole. What did you think of it? What did you like and what did you dislike from it? If you had to give a mark out of 10, what would that mark be? I'll start:

- Holy Knights Saga (first 100 chapters)

Probably the best arc of the series overall, IMO. Most of the Sins except Escanor were introduced. Be it because of their abilities, background or personality, pretty much all of them were interesting. The fights during that arc were among the best of the series too. There was a decent amount of tension, the battle choreography was way better and each and every character used his/her own abilities accordingly. The villains were fine I guess, nothing spectacular from a character standpoint, but at least they were a threat, unlike the majority of the villains that will come later on. There were some plot twists here and there about Gil and Margaret, and some foreshadowing regarding the curse of the main couple of the series.

Overall Note: 7,5-8/10

- Ten Commandments Saga (100-200 chapters)

This arc was still fine for the vast majority of the time, however, it is also the arc in which the series introduced some concepts that were handled in a pretty bad way, like the PL system, a system that Nakaba barely even cared about and that IMO, it shouldn't have never been introduced in the first place. The overall PL differences between the characters didn't follow any logic at all, sometimes character A stomped character B with a measly 10K difference (see Escanor vs Galand) and other times this difference could have been way more than that and a character would still be able to keep up (though, this problem mainly affects the later parts of the series, in which for example Diane can force the DK out of the lake with her PL being 50K). The differences and the distribution of stats between magic, strength, and spirit were never explained in a proper way, but still, this arc still respected this system to some extent, the problem I'm saying is really severe in the next arcs.

The introduction of the Commandments was done pretty well. Galand showing up and massacring each and every one of the Sins to show the overwhelming difference between the two established them as a massive threat. Escanor (one of the best characters in the series, despite his whole sacrifice in the final fight being meaningless, IMO) was introduced with a pretty overpowered that power that brought an equally overpowered weakness. Even if some characters were stomped by him and Mel at that point, it was still fine, since we knew for a fact that the Commandments getting trashed were nowhere near the strongest of the bunch and we held (at least I held) on the idea that the upper echelon commandments would be able to tango with the Sins. The Second Vaizel festival arc was done pretty well and ended with a pretty high note with Mel's death. There were some BS moments though, just like Escanor transforming at night, but they were still passable. The real bullshit came at the end of the saga, more specifically in the Defense of Liones arc, that started really good with Escanor facing Estarossa, but went to shit afterward. The strongest Commandments were slapped around like flies mostly by Mel and Escanor (Merlin and her Infinity also had their own part in all of this) and all chances of potential danger, interactions between characters and good fights were thrown into the trash can. To add more salt into the injury, we got a panel saying that the Seven Deadly Sins were specifically formed to defeat the Ten Commandments, but none of them did anything noteworthy against them with the exception of Mel and Escanor.

Overall Note: 6/10

- Memories of the Holy War + Corand Battle + Prelude to the Second Holy War Saga (200- 280)

The reason I'm making this separation is that I consider those three to be the last decent arcs this series had to offer. In the flashback of the Holy War, we got to see Eli as a Goddess, as well as three of the four AA, and their clash with the Commandments. We also saw Gowther's origins (one of the best backstories of the series IMO). Other highlights were the Mel vs Escanor fight, that despite not being that much of a mindblowing fight when it came to choreography, the hype of seeing Mel in AM overpowering Escanor in his different day stages and seeing his peak for the first time brought massive levels of hype within me as a reader.

After that, we got to see the introduction of the masters, one that was kinda out of nowhere, to be honest. I think Nakaba made a serious mistake trashing and disposing of all the Commandments so quickly and since he realized that Zeldris alone was too little of a threat to the Sins, he had to pull this new demons way stronger than the Commandments (who were stated to be the best warriors of the clan previously) to fill the gap his bad execution had left previously. Even then, they didn't disappoint in this arc (at least not yet). Chandler vs Sins was among the best fights of the series. It didn't lack tension, each and everyone used their own abilities more or less accordingly and the teamwork of the Sins, as well as Chandler's massive arsenal of spells (somehow greater than his creator, lol) was a nice sight to see. Cusack teaching a lesson to Arthur on where he stood when it came to power and him seemingly killing him with his ability Resonant was a great moment too. Mel dissolving the Sins to become DK in order to break the curse, the AA forming an alliance with the Sins and the other Holy Knights, as well as the Mael reveal were pretty good too, especially the Mael reveal, a reveal that to this day and from my personal opinion, stands at the highest point of Nakaba's writing skills, along with chapter 224 featuring the cursed lovers' flashback. The amount of foreshadowing we got since the first appearance of Estarossa was really good, same for chapter 224.

Overall note: 7,5/10

- Final Saga (280-346)

I put all of these chapters in one final paragraph because, from this point onwards, Nakaba's writing exponentially decreased really fast, to the point that if you had told me that a novice had substituted Nakaba when writing, I wouldn't be surprised at all.

1. King's ridiculous power-up: We knew that the strongest Fairy King before him clocked at a max of 50K (since we don't anything of Dahlia, and likely we'll never know), but this guy suddenly grew up strong enough to treat 200K+ character like a complete and utter joke and could keep up to some extent with the DK. Don't get me wrong, we knew he was going to be the strongest Fairy King in history, and we have recently known that the Sacred Tree was a godly being and a direct offspring of Chaos just like the DK and the SD all along, but that doesn't change the fact that his power-up was still ridiculous. This really ruined the Mael arc for me, an arc that for the most part had been pretty good.

2. The massive inflation of the PLs that made absolutely no sense within the context of the story and was only made to make the numbers higher and hype that failed to deliver anything at the end, since like I said the PL system wasn't even well done before that point, and to that point onwards it became way worse.

3. The Sinner: We learned that the Masters were originally one being and that twist was pretty good since we were told that the DK gave his power to one certain servant that had Chandler's stick and Cusack's swords, however, what came after that was humiliation after humiliation for the poor guy. A massively weakened Escanor lasted a few chapters against him (this is again another proof that the PL system didn't matter at that point), Ludo humiliated him and Mael destroyed him with one attack. For a being that was hyped as the fusion of the two strongest demons besides the DK and Meliodas, he sure left a lot to desire at the very least.

4. The Demon King: The main villain of the series along with the Supreme Deity, the god of all demons, a being with an amazing design and the creator of really powerful curses and magic that had all the wisdom of the Underworld got reduced to a jobber that only swung his big sword upwards and downwards, someone that got disrespected in every battle he fought against the protagonists (to the point that some of them even talked about marriage in the middle of the final fight, lol) and someone who only desired destruction because he felt like it, with no real motives behind. To summarize, a total joke.

5. Mel's OG magic that basically destroyed the main core of this series' plot: the journey to break the curse. A magic that we don't know what it is, why he didn't even use it until now and that disappeared as fast as it appeared, without us learning anything from it. By far one of the worst things Nakaba has done. I won't talk about it too much since I already posted some walls of text explaining why I think like this in the Meliodas thread, but basically the problem here was that Nakaba failed to deliver a proper explanation as to why he couldn't use it until now ("I am afraid" is not a proper explanation). Nakaba's obsession with Mel got worse as the series went on, to the point that the spotlight of other characters got reduced considerably because of that and we were left with a lot of questions.

There are other really big problems with this final arc, like Wild's pointless death (and pointless revival too, but I guess dude deserved it), Escanor's pointless death, some characters actually forgetting that they have really strong abilities (like Merlin's Double Impact and Ban's Snatch and Hunter Fest that weren't really used at all like they never existed), fake tension and fake drama, but by far, the biggest one for me is the Supreme Deity. No matter how shit the DK's treatment was, he at least got one, unlike her. The Supreme Deity, the other main villain of this series that should've had the same relevance as the Demon King in the story, didn't utter a word until the very end and was left like she didn't even exist in the first place. Even if he were to introduce her in the sequel, what relevance could she have when we have Arthur around with the powers of the creator of the verse?

Not only the overall character of the Supreme Deity was left like it didn't even exist in the first place, but the whole Goddess Clan got left with very little development and screentime compared to the Demon Clan. Eli is perhaps, besides her mother, the worst victim of this. The deuteragonist of this series barely had any important moment at all, there are really few that come to mind, compared to the dozens and dozens that Mel had. She also got barely fleshed out and the overall writing about her felt inconsistent to say the least, sometimes she was a damsel in distress and some other times she was an incredible warrior. Now that I'm onto this, she isn't the only one victim of this, at this later part of the story it felt like the characters were as strong as Nakaba needed them to be, there was no power scaling and consistency with anything. The female characters got really left behind too and the Giants got the short end of the stick and a shit development, tbh.

Of course, there were some decent moments too, like the Assault Squad vs the top Demons, the development of some Sins (like Escanor's pride transforming into humility and Ban, the greed, sacrificing pretty much everything for his loved one, as well as other developments), but sadly they got completely overshadowed by the bad ones.

Overall note: 2-3/10

Overall, looking at the series as a whole, most of it was pretty decent (far from being perfect as flaws were still there like any other fictional work, but overall pretty enjoyable), the only chapters that suffered from a really bad writing quality IMO were the ones that featured the Defense of Liones Arc, as well as this whole final arc that I commented. However, those two, especially this finale, do great harm in the series as the end is really important and the quality drop was enormous. If the series had continued with the same quality as the previous arcs, this for me would have been easily a 7/10, perhaps even more, but sadly and thanks to this finale it stays as a 5/10 at best for me.

It's really sad because I think this series had a ton of potential, but in the end, I'm gonna have to leave it thinking of what it could have been instead of what we actually got.

PD: Sorry for the wall of text, I got a little too carried away, but I felt I had to do it.
 
Last edited:

Aurelius

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 10, 2019
Messages
3,154
Reaction score
8,864
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Another quality post @Shadowlord123. I agree with most of your points, so I'll keep it short.

Holy Knight Saga

This was a strong opening arc to a manga. The main group, Meliodas, Ban, King, and Gowther, were enjoyable and Hendrickson was a strong opening villain. Arc also set up well for future arcs.

Grade: 7.5/10

10 Commandment Saga

Arc had some great battles and hype moments. But, it became the Mel and Escanor show, and after a good introduction, the commandments were easily dealt with and not explored nearly enough. Other sins were basically irrelevant as well.

Grade 4.5/10

1st and 2nd Holy War

Imo the best part of the manga. Introduced to OG Gowther, Archangels, AM Mel, The One, and Wild. There were a lot of great moments, such as learning about the curse, seeing the DK and SD, and the now infamous battle between Mel and Escanor. My favorite part was Estarossa's reign of terror and then his reveal as Mael. The Mael reveal was Nakaba's best writing.

Grade 8/10

Final Saga

Absolute garbage. We all know the problems with this, so not really gonna rehash or I'll be here all day. Imo, the worst part of it and what really left a bad taste in mouth was how it tainted Nakaba's earlier work and rendered many plot lines as absolutely meaningless.

Grade 1/10

Overall

3/10: Do not recommend and I will not read the sequel. All it comes down to is Nakaba was unable to execute his vision. What I'll remember is this a story in which the main cast became unlikable, especially the bottom-tier MC and FMC.
 
Last edited:

OtakuFreak

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Nov 20, 2017
Messages
4,804
Reaction score
9,617
Age
26
Country
Fun Forum
The series as a whole is good, since there was lots of high's despite the low's. Plus, I still find enjoyment in the manga regardless of the quality.

Holy Knight Saga:

From what I can remember, this arc is probably the best in writing quality. Pretty much all of the characters (especially the main) were excellent, all interesting and had their own dynamics in background or development. The biggest highlight of this saga was with the humour and light moments that the sins had. Diane's ''crush'' on Meliodas was hilarious to me. Ban not giving a shit was phenomenal. Gowther being oblivious to his logical comments on the group. King trying to get Diane's attention. Hawk insulting Meliodas and protecting Elizabeth at all corners, etc.

The biggest problems I had with this arc, is that it doesn't feel important anymore. It was entertaining, sure, but in the overall picture of the series which was a historical war between the Goddesses and Demons, it felt pointless. I mean, we find out that Meliodas and Elizabeth were cursed and that they were children to the Gods and had this long past together and with the significant jump in PL's in the villains, Demon Hendrickson at 5K looks pretty non-significant looking back, but that's probably my fault from looking back instead of looking at where the manga was at the time.

I'd give it a 9/10 in terms of quality and overall enjoyment. There was very little that I disliked about it (nothing that stood out to me) and the only thing that takes away from it is how fast the rest of the series jumped in significance.

Commandment Saga:

The introduction of each commandment member, especially Galan was very good. We definitely felt the threat of their Resurrection in the story and it gave a new dynamic to the series, which went from the sins being the strongest amongst the series, to being completely outclassed. The arc itself gave way to some fights which I still consider as one of the greatest in the series: Meliodas VS Kings, Estarossa VS Escanor, etc.

However, because the commandments were so powerful it left the majority of the characters that we gained an attachment to in the Holy Knight Saga feel sidelined. I mean, did any of the sins besides Meliodas, Merlin and Escanor actually do anything? Diane lost her memory for the 20th time, Gowther was becoming obnoxious, King was just craving after Diane for the entire saga and Ban's character went downhill when Elaine returned to life (imo).

Then again, the commandments were all interesting characters and gave their own dynamic and history to the series. I liked Gloxinia and Drole especially, but the ending to the saga felt EXTREMELY disappointing. It basically turned into a fest that wanked Meliodas and Escanor especially, but then again, can you blame Nakaba when all of the commandments were way above any of the other sins?

Just another note, I liked how Elizabeth's background was being touched upon before in a subtle way, especially with the interaction with Derieri and Monspiet.

I'd give it a 6/10 considering that the majority of the arc was good, but the ending was pretty bad.

First & Second Holy War Saga:

Easily the favourite part of the manga for me. One of favourite characters got a lot more exposure, as we saw the Goddess Elizabeth interact with Meliodas and we even got to see her fight (which is still her best battle and feats). Seeing the Four Archangels (Goddesses getting exposure was very good) fighting the Ten Commandments was also pretty amazing, since I love the dynamic of light vs darkness fighting.

It gave further exposure to Gloxinia and Drole as well, who we wondered why they betrayed and joined the Ten Commandments. Even after the end of the memories arc, the quality of the manga just got even better, Gowther got his memories back, Elizabeth got her memories back as well and we learned about the nature of Meliodas and Elizabeth's relationship, along with the proper introduction of the Gods (224 is still the best chapter in the series, imo).

We then see Elizabeth return to her real self, interacting with the rest of the sins and take a bigger role in the story (her assistance against Melascula was pretty dope) whilst other plot points such as Meliodas losing his emotions and fighting Escanor, Chandler and Cusack getting introduced (which had its issues, but they were good characters), Chandler fighting the sins, Meliodas awakening and going to Camelot to become Demon King (shitting on Zeldris and Estarossa was pretty dope as well). The revival of the Four Archangels and the prelude to the second holy war was good as well. Even the second holy war itself was good, Estarossa actually being Mael was one of the best twists in the story, seeing more of the Demon King fighting in purgatory (we will avoid mentioning the greatest sin of that fight for obvious reasons).

The Original Demon returning, the fight between Zeldris/Masters and Ludoshel/Escanor/Merlin was pretty good as well despite the flaws in it and having Mael fight against Zeldris was another highlight of the series.

We then get the revival of the Demon King by possessing Meliodas which was pretty epic. Him trolling Elizabeth for one of the chapters was pretty funny as well, but the fight quickly declined with Ban's return and Mel's emotions ass-pulling even further.

200 to 300 had one moment after another pretty much back to back and was the best saga in the manga. There were flaws in the arc, but in comparison to the final arc, they were pretty small and forgetabble.

Final Saga:

Oh boy, Nakaba not going through with Elizabeth's ''death'' was a mistake and the return of the Demon King was even more pathetic, considering he just got humiliated by everybody, including a 50,000 PL Giant who still is inferior to Drole in every way.

It was such a decline in quality that it feels like Nakaba wasn't writing anymore. Why does a God get humiliated by fodder characters and need a lake of infinite magic to just stand a chance when he has his prime body and magical power back? Why does a curse of fate and destiny get reduced to fodder by Merlin and Meliodas? Why does Escanor's pathetic life force boost him to a comparable level to the Demon King despite only using a fourth of the Supreme Deity's halved power?

There's so many plot holes and the power scaling went out of the window even further, especially with the return of Chaos.

Chaos was a somewhat nice addition as it added background to the history of the series, but once again for every positive point the series gets, we get 10 plot holes and inconsistencies for the rest of the story.

Cath was a pointless villain

Arthur is a trash character and will always be

Merlin and the sins forgive each other for any crime because ''friendship''

Elizabeth got reduced to part 1 sidelining again when she was given a more prominent role in the first and second holy war.

Gelda is a forgetabble character and the romance she has with Zeldris is trash (don't @ me).

Honestly, a 2/10 for the entire arc as it just fucked everything up.

Overall:


The most sour note left by the series ending is that we have so much loose ends and missing information. One of the core, fucking villains got left to the side like fodder, and half the other characters still have missing backstories, fully power showings and everything else inbetween.

It's a good series, but after chapter 310, the series died for me and just went downhill until it reached an almighty low. It felt like Nakaba gave up and was forced to push until 346.
 

Jdmp53

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2018
Messages
912
Reaction score
1,228
Age
29
Country
Gotei 13
I wanted to write my own thoughts on each arc...but above 3 has done plenty well...so I'd just leave with what nakaba did what i liked in the series compared to to other shounen ..

First off the introduction of not just 1 MC but a team of 7 and not the usual 3 ..the dynamics of each characters with others and each with their own unique OP abilities which meant they didn't had to go through generic powerup through physical training by kicking rocks and doing pushups XD..

The training arcs which always provided something else.. were really good..Mel accepting the loss and containing his Wrath to be able to access more power... King and diane getting to experience the true power of their clans all the while giving us a good flashback arc , ban's indirect training while fighting the enemy ...

There was no rival.
After watching so many generic shounen which always presented the MC with a rival..it was getting old and nakaba brought us good friendship between the sins..expecially banxmel and king as well..

Foreshadowings And character development

As a big mystery genre fan ..i was always thrilled to see the twists play out every few arcs...and the joy u get re-reading the whole manga with a diff perspective was always satisfying..

Many characters had some believable interactions and their growth from the moment they were introduced to certain part of the series is easily noticeable even the side characters such as Jericho and the antagonists got some (looking at the demon couples)..

Finally I want to say about the romance...
Really like how he didn't waste much time in confirming our ships ..both Melxeli and Kingxdiane...the former being the tragic and being the driving plot and the other being fully explored...it was a nice addition in a battle shounen to give the readers something to root for..

Of course.. ..all the points I made above are for until ch300....past that it just falls apart...
 

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
I'm very interested (and it's not irony) in knowing the reasoning behind the opinion of those who voted great or even masterpiece. Y'all don't need to write walls of text if you don't feel like it, but a different perspective would be very nice to see :hee
 

Aurelius

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jul 10, 2019
Messages
3,154
Reaction score
8,864
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I'm very interested (and it's not irony) in knowing the reasoning behind the opinion of those who voted great or even masterpiece. Y'all don't need to write walls of text if you don't feel like it, but a different perspective would be very nice to see :hee
:catshrugMasterpiece was probably Zorra. Her comments on the chapter thread shout this, lol
 

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
:catshrugMasterpiece was probably Zorra. Her comments on the chapter thread shout this, lol
Personally I think he/she (idk) is the one who gave the 9 since it didn't look like he/she liked the last arc about Arthur too much.

You know what? Now I'm really interested. @Zorra_akuma How do you feel about the series overall?

Everybody who wants to write his/her opinion is equally welcomed ofc.
 

Demonspeed

The Bull
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,827
Reaction score
61,578
Gender
Male
Country
France
Overall, 7/10, maybe 8. The DK fight was terrible but honestly way too many fans make the series look worse than it is because they wanted fanservice for their favorite characters or/and were too attached to their headcanons.
 

Zorra_akuma

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 12, 2019
Messages
834
Reaction score
1,212
Gender
Female
Country
United States
Personally I think he/she (idk) is the one who gave the 9 since it didn't look like he/she liked the last arc about Arthur too much.

You know what? Now I'm really interested. @Zorra_akuma How do you feel about the series overall?

Everybody who wants to write his/her opinion is equally welcomed ofc.
nah that wasnt me to be honest i didnt know this thread existed until you tagged but if you want to know my opinion i can share it for you. also im a girl lol
 

HereNThere

Alive Ain't Always Livin'
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Mangahelper
Joined
Jul 8, 2009
Messages
8,395
Reaction score
12,211
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The first 100 chapters are quality. The series was one of my favorite reads at the time for a reason. It was well written, engaging, just an overall good read that I couldn't wait for week after week.

I voted 7 and it's Those 100 chapters alone keep this series from getting anything less than 5.
 

Zahvix

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 26, 2014
Messages
618
Reaction score
1,140
Gender
Male
Country
Holy Britannian Empire
I've decided to give the series 4/10. I enjoyed the first arc when it was all about Mel and Eli looking for the Sins and facing the Holy Knights. As far I remember, there wasn't any moment I didn't like in that arc and I especially loved the fights. Plus most of the Sins were enjoyable back then and I was hooked whenever Nakaba went into the Sin's past.

The Ten Commandments arc started off strong with a lot of good fights, character development, introduction of characters such as Escanor and some of the Commandments ect. However, I didn't like that Diane lost her memories again, Escanor stealing the spotlight from the other Sins by beating most of the Commandments himself, and I thought the tournament part was a little boring.

I honestly disliked the rest of the series. It felt like the series became all about wanking off the Sins and showing off their friendship power even if it meant down those things in nonsensical ways. Most of the antagonists were underwhelming and quickly became jokes. It didn't help how some of them were dumbed down just so the Sins could win. I could care less about characters like the Four Archangels, The Sinner, and Wild. Finally, the most disappointing thing about the last three arcs was how I was constantly disappointed. Whenever there was something I was really hyped for, it was always followed up by something that ruined the moment for me.

Overall, I think this series started on a high note only to flatline after it's second arc.
 
Last edited:

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
nah that wasnt me to be honest i didnt know this thread existed until you tagged but if you want to know my opinion i can share it for you. also im a girl lol
It would be really nice and interesting if you could share it and sorry, I didn't know you were one (that's why the "he/she" :XD)
 

Valhalla

ᛏᚺᛖ ᚹᚺᛁᛏᛖ ᚹᛟᛚᚠ ᛟᚠ ᚷᛖᚱᛟᚡᛟ
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2016
Messages
1,687
Reaction score
7,078
Gender
Male
Country
Winterfell
I would give it a 7 or a 6. The Holy Knight Saga is easily the best part of the manga, super dope stuff that got me into this manga. Started reading it right around Gowther's reveal and Dawn Roar arc and it was a blast.
The 10 Commandment Saga started awesome and was good for the most part, but had few stinkers. Still it was pretty good.
Now The Holy War Saga had some good moments happening untill the Estarossa/Mael twist. After that, the manga really fell flat on its face. The best thing that happened after Estarossa/Mael stuff was probably Zeldris against the Assault team and then against The One. After that fight came wonky and awkward writing, accompanied by the Original Fodder who was trash,, then the Fodder King pulling the same shit twice and still getting his ass rocked pretty embarrassingly, and then a cat monster for a final villain with Arthur and chao stuff, bruh, why? Nakaba should have ended it with the DK and then put the Chaos stuff and Cath into the sequel. Aside from that, there were other issues but oh well.
Overall 6, maybe 7-ish/10. Its still very enjoyable manga with a superb first half, and a wonky second half that had a weak ending.
 

LaserBeam

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 16, 2017
Messages
1,791
Reaction score
1,984
Age
40
Country
Greece
- Holy knights arc 5/10
Probably it where the writing manga was at it's best the protagonists interesting enough to make you interested about them.
The theme of the story not original at all like the whole medieval type of knights and demons and creatures is a very overused theme of story as it holds not much complexity.
The lack of danger still strong within the 1rst arc but back then i thought ok " it is the 1rst arc the enemies will keep getting stronger and the action will impove a lot"
At least hendricksen was a decent villain with some ok motives in comparison.
The power scale consistency started to be wacky when we had examples like:

Helbram using a bit of hendricksen powers one shots meliodas but when meliodas faces hendricksen he couldn't do a crap against meliodas
until he drunk the grey demons blood which by the way keep in mind when mel and the sins faced him mel never fought him with his pod but with his base state with no pod powers the whole time, merlin didn't bothered participating in that fight despite making her introduction at that moment and escanor well we all can quess to why.


- Ten Commandments Saga 4/10

Strong start with gallant wiping the floor with few of the sins
but around the labyrith tournament at vyzel with dolor and gloxinia was the point where things started towards the big downfall
The rest of the arc was just sad.
Meliodas solo 9 of the commandments while at the same time literally going easy on them and was stopped only because he used revenge counter
which was stopped by estarossa love commanent and not by estarossa power himself was stupid as hell!!!!

Then he died and we learn the dude can die but can come back so it was stupid ass point to kill him ah yes and during those months of time skip
the commandments somehow where not stronger at all and escanor, merlin and meliodas bodied them

First & Second Holy War Saga: 2/10

The 1rst holy war arc was pretty decent as we needed to learn what happened but too bad it never answered the real question of how and why.

Chandler totally saved the shitty action/ conclusion of the commandments unfortunately the man himself as badass as he was him and cusack.
Literally they were introduced out of nowhere like there is not even a panel before they got introduce like for example a mentioned about them
during the 1rst holy war would have been a nice way to say to the audience that " hey there are 2 top ranked demons who are the 2 masters of the princesses or whatever"

Merlin bodies them and escanor defeats zeldris witha finger just because he could" imagine if he could destroy zeldris with a finger imagine if he actually had used a freaking punch right?"

Original demon was a interesting idea but he was sidewiped like a fodder

Possesed Meliodas vs the sins should had been the end fight

The 2.0 of the dk vs the sins was totally unecessary and escanor died because the author had to show that someone died even though his death was stupid as hell!!!!!

Final Saga: 0/10


Pointless arc in my book the whole chaos thing came right out of nakaba sweet ass he tried to build up one chapter before saying us about chaos
by making vivian sprouting words...

Merlin somehow faked everything up to that point to have her goal achieved

The whole cosmogoly about chaos was something that should had been introduced way way earlier instead of after 320 chapters
This part literally has not ties to the plot at all.
Like the only thing this dude made it was probably because this part was something like a prequel like an introduction to arthur's story.

ok my overrall rate should be: 2,75
and because i am a nice guy i am gonna make it a nice round 3 because it's about 2,5

So 3 out 10 for me. I honestly thought it would have went way lower.
 
Last edited:

XXGenesis

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Oct 8, 2011
Messages
3,148
Reaction score
1,900
Age
35
Gender
Male
Country
Turkmenistan
Changed my vote from 5 Average. To a 6 Fine. Only because of Characters like Ban, Escanor & early Meliodas before he died. Also the series was interesting early on. Until the story just suffered heavily in it's 2nd half. Which made it all not so enjoyable. Main Villian horribly treated in terms of showings, random power showings and the last arc, im not a English major or anything but im sure it's missing literacy elements that make up a good story. All in All NNT is relatively average with loveable characters & supernatural abilities, but the plot is horrible overall
 

Merlin918

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
616
Reaction score
711
Country
United Kingdom
I think the series had a lot of good in it. The first arc was basically perfect. The Ten Commandments still added to the hype and were mostly a reasonable development. It dropped in quality at the Liones Defensive Battle but it was still passable in action intensity and believability. The Holy War Arc made it start getting much more intense and fun again especially after the flashback. In fact the holy war was still going strong and only got better over time as the epic Mael/Estarossa reveal occured. It added tons of depth to what otherwise would be a bland cast of Archangels, they had something to fight for which all made sense now. Made Ludociel a lot better too. And the Assault Force Cocoon battle was all great at first too! The One being used full force, Ludociel's powers, Chandler and Cusack's consistently hyped power levels, etc. Even Merlin's asspullery was all acceptable since it wasn't unbeatable and Ominous Nebula put her in serious danger. It was all great!

And then came the DISASTER CHAPTER chapter 291, when Merlin fodderized both Demon Masters. That was just so bad. It was only barely salvaged in a way by the ending of the chapter immediately shifting focus to the full on Mael revelation and its effects on Ludociel, but it just ruined the sense of balance. From then on i always asked 'why isn't merlin using double impact/spellspam/etc' and it just messed up so much. But at least at the beginning there were sort of excuses.

The Sinner wasn't horrible right away, and him having trouble with King's new broken mode wasn't so bad. The Chrono Coffin was acceptable in a way. It just all felt hollow though since Merlin had already fodderized 2 demon masters at once, like at that rate what was stopping her from doing the exponential spell buildup as she cast chrono coffin? It was too weird. But at least there was a semblance of believability.

Chapter 300 renewed my hype a little. The DK showed himself as immediately overpowered and caused serious trouble for the protagonists, and his reveal of possessing Meliodas was a nice twist. And then the end of the chapter made it obvious that Ban was gonna fodderize him and i was just so disappointed. It remained like that from then on and he literally just got solo'd by Ban and Mel fighting from the inside. No, Mel should not have been able to fight from the inside, it made the sneaky possession plan of the DK's totally meaningless if it didn't knock Mel's consciousness out and make him irrelevant until the DK took major damage. Said damage should have required seriously good cooperation from all Sins on the level of the teamwork in the Mael vs everyone battle if not much much more due to the reputation of the DK, but no.

At the end of Chapter 302 the zero tension emotional tone and portrayal completely destroyed all hype for me. Meliodas just pronounced the DK's sin and said he's bad and will lose and i knew that was it. And i was right. Even after his revival the Zeldris stuff didn't mean anything, Meliodas sparing his murderous little brother who wanted mass genocide had zero negative consequences. I was never afraid for the sins the whole zeldris battle. There was no real hype to the choreography of it either. It was just so bad at that point.

This is just me doing a basic short summary of the combat intensity stuff and how it was badly done imo. There is a lot more i could say about the manga and i will do that in a much longer review. Maybe i will edit the post so this is a spoiler subsection of a big wall post. But overall my rating is that the hype and intensity for each arc just from a combat/intensity/coolness of the fighting styles overall were like this:

Arc 1:8/10
Commandments Arc:7/10
Holy War:9/10
Chapter 291 and onwards:1/10

That's my overall opinion of the manga, sadly the ending was super super lackluster and undermined all the hype. The worst part? Nakaba didn't have to negate the hype at all! He had all the pieces in place to logically resolve it without having no choice but to do asspulls. He had the story very well balanced PL wise to the point where it all basically could have made sense in the end. But he didn't, and that makes the failure even worse imo.

I will also include things like internal story logic, things Nakaba should've had them do but didn't like a moral debate about whether or not to purposefully activate Eli's curse to get her Goddess powers active, Arthur trying to get Excalibur the moment the Demons attack, Merlin being more balanced, King and Diane being better rulers that deserve their positions, Eli maybe using the Graces as a countermeasure to the Commandments, the SD showing up as a result of a failed Grace-absorption plan by the Sins involving elizabeth intended to defeat DK Meliodas, and a good deal of other stuff. Along with individula character evaluations of what was missing if i have time. But overall I do feel like Nakaba was just that close to having it be nigh-perfect, great potential was within his reach all the way up to chapter 291 and even to some extent until chapter 301 ruined absolutely everything, but now the climax is kinda just ruined and it's too late sadly.

But why did that happen? I feel like Nakaba just wussed out of killing certain characters. For example, Zeldris, who i think should have died and him being spared completely negates meliodas's whole system of morality and justice for the entirety of the manga. SD also messed up a lot with her absence. The primary problem is that Nakaba did not follow through in having the characters stick to their ideals because he didn't want to kill off characters and for whatever reason stopped trying to make anything tense, and that just messed everything up. He tried to wuss out of many consequences of the manga. Final example:All the people who the demons ate souls of en mass were forgotten like they didn't mean anything and Zeldris was still spared despite being the direct cause of all this. This is just ridiculous and unforgivable. Even Vegeta from DBZ is not that bad and DBZ is mostly a comedy not meant to be taken too seriously. All that bad stuff towards the end seems to partly be a consequence of this Wuss Mentality Nakaba developed. Oh well, hopefully my attempts to imagine the outline of what a better version would've been for my big review will be entertaining for you guys.
 

everythingnice

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 12, 2019
Messages
528
Reaction score
808
Gender
Female
Country
Fairy Tail
I give the Holy Knights Saga a 9/10, incredibly well written with few mistakes, well-written characters, their abilities, and the fights were topnotch.

For the Ten Commandments Saga I give it 8/10, I would have given it a 7/10 if it wasn't for emotional moments like Meliodas' trial in the Druid Cave, Ban's backstory with Zhivago, and Meliodas' death.

From his death till the flashback arc ends, I would give it a 8/10 too and this 8 majorly comes from the flashback arc, empowered with Gerheade and Gloxinia's backstory, then Gowther's backstory, and the Goddess Elizabeth being introduced. Plus we get to know more about Derieri. One point comes from Estarossa vs Escanor, and Elizabeth being able to destroy Derieri's hand.

From there on the Holy War Saga gets 6/10 for me. Great moments like Meliodas vs Escanor, Sins vs Chandler, and Estarossa being the Archangel Mael boosted this, plus Arthur also fought quite well and his "death" was quite emotional to me. And then there were those emotionally heavy moments with Meliodas and Elizabeth and the way their relationship took dives. I didn't score it any higher because...well...the Sinner was a loser, Merlin's asspulls got frustrating, Meliodas' original magic which is now buried unexplained, and then that uninteresting, not bad but uninteresting fight against DK Mel.

But it wasn't until the epilogue chapters the series took a HORRENDOUS nosedive. I give it 0.5/10 to the epilogue chapters.

After them the series became extremely frustrating with the fucking DK, MERLIN, MAEL, DIANE, Meliodas, Elizabeth. King and Ban were plain and not fun as they used to be (I can only remember King's proposal to Diane during the whole fight). and don't even get me started on ESCANOR. It was a HORRIBLE mistake to not introduce the Supreme Deity, even if her battle would have been bad it still would have been something new. And then the Chaos thing, while better than the DK fights, was also uninteresting. I didn't like Cath as a villain at all. He was simply a kitty trying to eat meat. Nothing more, nothing less. 2/10 for that awesome moment of Bloody Ellie we got and Arthur's revival.

Overall, I'd give this series 7/10.
 

Shadowlord123

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
May 20, 2018
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
5,158
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
I think the series had a lot of good in it. The first arc was basically perfect. The Ten Commandments still added to the hype and were mostly a reasonable development. It dropped in quality at the Liones Defensive Battle but it was still passable in action intensity and believability. The Holy War Arc made it start getting much more intense and fun again especially after the flashback. In fact the holy war was still going strong and only got better over time as the epic Mael/Estarossa reveal occured. It added tons of depth to what otherwise would be a bland cast of Archangels, they had something to fight for which all made sense now. Made Ludociel a lot better too. And the Assault Force Cocoon battle was all great at first too! The One being used full force, Ludociel's powers, Chandler and Cusack's consistently hyped power levels, etc. Even Merlin's asspullery was all acceptable since it wasn't unbeatable and Ominous Nebula put her in serious danger. It was all great!

And then came the DISASTER CHAPTER chapter 291, when Merlin fodderized both Demon Masters. That was just so bad. It was only barely salvaged in a way by the ending of the chapter immediately shifting focus to the full on Mael revelation and its effects on Ludociel, but it just ruined the sense of balance. From then on i always asked 'why isn't merlin using double impact/spellspam/etc' and it just messed up so much. But at least at the beginning there were sort of excuses.

The Sinner wasn't horrible right away, and him having trouble with King's new broken mode wasn't so bad. The Chrono Coffin was acceptable in a way. It just all felt hollow though since Merlin had already fodderized 2 demon masters at once, like at that rate what was stopping her from doing the exponential spell buildup as she cast chrono coffin? It was too weird. But at least there was a semblance of believability.

Chapter 300 renewed my hype a little. The DK showed himself as immediately overpowered and caused serious trouble for the protagonists, and his reveal of possessing Meliodas was a nice twist. And then the end of the chapter made it obvious that Ban was gonna fodderize him and i was just so disappointed. It remained like that from then on and he literally just got solo'd by Ban and Mel fighting from the inside. No, Mel should not have been able to fight from the inside, it made the sneaky possession plan of the DK's totally meaningless if it didn't knock Mel's consciousness out and make him irrelevant until the DK took major damage. Said damage should have required seriously good cooperation from all Sins on the level of the teamwork in the Mael vs everyone battle if not much much more due to the reputation of the DK, but no.

At the end of Chapter 302 the zero tension emotional tone and portrayal completely destroyed all hype for me. Meliodas just pronounced the DK's sin and said he's bad and will lose and i knew that was it. And i was right. Even after his revival the Zeldris stuff didn't mean anything, Meliodas sparing his murderous little brother who wanted mass genocide had zero negative consequences. I was never afraid for the sins the whole zeldris battle. There was no real hype to the choreography of it either. It was just so bad at that point.

This is just me doing a basic short summary of the combat intensity stuff and how it was badly done imo. There is a lot more i could say about the manga and i will do that in a much longer review. Maybe i will edit the post so this is a spoiler subsection of a big wall post. But overall my rating is that the hype and intensity for each arc just from a combat/intensity/coolness of the fighting styles overall were like this:

Arc 1:8/10
Commandments Arc:7/10
Holy War:9/10
Chapter 291 and onwards:1/10

That's my overall opinion of the manga, sadly the ending was super super lackluster and undermined all the hype. The worst part? Nakaba didn't have to negate the hype at all! He had all the pieces in place to logically resolve it without having no choice but to do asspulls. He had the story very well balanced PL wise to the point where it all basically could have made sense in the end. But he didn't, and that makes the failure even worse imo.

I will also include things like internal story logic, things Nakaba should've had them do but didn't like a moral debate about whether or not to purposefully activate Eli's curse to get her Goddess powers active, Arthur trying to get Excalibur the moment the Demons attack, Merlin being more balanced, King and Diane being better rulers that deserve their positions, Eli maybe using the Graces as a countermeasure to the Commandments, the SD showing up as a result of a failed Grace-absorption plan by the Sins involving elizabeth intended to defeat DK Meliodas, and a good deal of other stuff. Along with individula character evaluations of what was missing if i have time. But overall I do feel like Nakaba was just that close to having it be nigh-perfect, great potential was within his reach all the way up to chapter 291 and even to some extent until chapter 301 ruined absolutely everything, but now the climax is kinda just ruined and it's too late sadly.

But why did that happen? I feel like Nakaba just wussed out of killing certain characters. For example, Zeldris, who i think should have died and him being spared completely negates meliodas's whole system of morality and justice for the entirety of the manga. SD also messed up a lot with her absence. The primary problem is that Nakaba did not follow through in having the characters stick to their ideals because he didn't want to kill off characters and for whatever reason stopped trying to make anything tense, and that just messed everything up. He tried to wuss out of many consequences of the manga. Final example:All the people who the demons ate souls of en mass were forgotten like they didn't mean anything and Zeldris was still spared despite being the direct cause of all this. This is just ridiculous and unforgivable. Even Vegeta from DBZ is not that bad and DBZ is mostly a comedy not meant to be taken too seriously. All that bad stuff towards the end seems to partly be a consequence of this Wuss Mentality Nakaba developed. Oh well, hopefully my attempts to imagine the outline of what a better version would've been for my big review will be entertaining for you guys.
I agree with pretty much everything you've said. For me, even though I think the quality fell hard after chapter 280 with King's power-up, the chapters between that and 300 were still pretty enjoyable. Not only we still had the whole Camelot battle against the Masters and Zeldris to look forward, but also DK Mel, an element that kept us really interested up until that point. I don't know if I was the only one, but I thought that Nakaba giving the Sins such ridiculous powers ups would serve for a really great final struggle against their Captain possessed by the DK and not being him one-sidedly beating the crap out of them. I thought that maybe that was the reason. You can imagine my disappointment the moment Ban started to fight evenly with him alone. Even at that point, I still had my hopes up, I was thinking to myself: "Well, maybe the DK is holding back or is still unused to his new vessel. Once he fights seriously, everyone will start sweating blood" but sadly that moment never came. In fact, the moment Emo Mel came and elbowed the DK's face to the ground, I knew that the chances of that battle being a great one to be remembered were zero.

Elizabeth, the deuteragonist of this series and the one that should have been more involved in all of this (since she was one of the main reasons for this war to happen in the first place) did absolutely nothing besides being a cheerleader (this also happened with the second battle against the DK, to add more salt into the injury). She could have tried the Grace absorption or done something else besides cheering, everything would have been fine. The AA did nothing either, despite being among the strongest characters of the series and despite the fact that much weaker characters like Diane were doing something. The DK's motives (besides destruction just for the sake of it) were never really fleshed out and there was great potential here for the DK to have had great motivations and for him to have been a great villain. For example, Nakaba could have had the DK being a humble, flexible and good ruler at first but at some point, something would have happened to him which made him realize that ruling like that won't give him any good result, resulting in his reign to be formed in the base of fear and overwhelming power. We could have had a great clash of ideologies between him and his son about that too.

No matter how you look at it, the amount of potential wasted here is enormous. This battle done right could have very well been one of the best to come out in shonen and a classic that could have been remembered for ages. I don't really know what happened to Nakaba with that massive drop in writing quality, but this ended up as a complete mess and it's such a shame.
 

Gladiolus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 24, 2019
Messages
507
Reaction score
1,376
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Spain
Judging what I liked and what I disliked from each saga:

Holy Knights Saga (first 100 chapters more or less)

Pros

• Since it was the first big saga, everything felt fresh and there wasn't much bullshit.

• The human characters had relevance.

• It had good animation when it was adapted to the anime.

• Vaizel Fighting Festival arc was fun.

• King's flashback of how he lost Helbram and met Diane.

• King vs Helbram battle.

• Whole final fight against Hendrickson + Hawk's fake death.


Cons

• Apart of Hendrickson and Gilthunder to a lesser extent, there were not many interesting antagonists.

• There wasn't much tension, since it was obvious that the Sins were holding back through the saga to not kill their enemies.

• Kinda rushed in the anime.


Ten Commandments Saga (everything covered in the second season of the anime)

Pros

• The 10 Commandments were the most entertaining villains of the series (even if they were handled horribly).

• Meliodas's training on Ishtar when he had to revive again and again the day Liz died.

• The battle of Meliodas against the 10 Commandments.

• Escanor's introduction.

• Galand's first battle against the Sins.

• The past of Ban with Zhivago.

• Jericho had some moments of awesome.

• Melascula <3


Cons

• Kinda rushed in the anime.

• Escanor's able to transform at night because Merlin is "his sun".

• Whole part of the raid of the Commandments on Liones.

• The introduction of power levels (those ones were a big mistake).

• Merlin's asspulls (this is a problem of the whole series, but everything started here).

• The Commandments were hyped as serious threats, only to take all the Ls at the end.

• Fraudrin's redemption felt awkward and forced.


Holy War Build-Up Saga (including the memories of the past Holy War, Corand and the Chandler/Cusack bits)

Pros

• The flashback of the Holy War was good for the most part.

• The first part of the fight against Melascula (up until Diane gets possessed by the vengeful spirits of Corand's inhabitants).

• The salt of the Meliodas fans/pride of Escanor fans during the battle of Escanor vs Meliodas.

• The memes of the animated version of the Escanor vs Meliodas.

• The memes of derp Meliodas.

• The battle of Chandler against the Sins.

• Estarossa planning to overthrow Meliodas.

• Estarossa in general.

• Ludoret <3

• The reveal of the curses of Meliodas/Elizabeth.

• Elizabeth was useful.


Cons

• It looked like shit in the anime.

• Pseudo romance between Rou and Gerheade (paralleling Ban/Elaine) was eh.

• The second part of the fight against Melascula (when she becomes a giant snake and gets clapped by everyone).

• Escanor vs Meliodas fight was just fanservice (but it's forgiven for all the salt it brought).

• Ban became the Yamcha of the series.

• The introduction of Chandler and Cusack didn't felt natural at all.

• Gowther became meh after recovering his heart.


Holy War Saga (everything from the Estarossa fight to the first Demon King fight)

Pros

• It started well, with all the hype of seeing a new Holy War at a great scale.

• Wild was a fun character.

• Estarossa being Mael all along was an interesting twist.

• Hendrickson didn’t turn out to be Ludociel’s personal bootlicker and was trying to save Margaret all along.

• We got to see the Goddess Clan fighting seriously (including Elizabeth).


Cons

• Will probably look like shit in the anime (and the beginning of the Estarossa fight kinda did).

• All the human characters except for Hendrickson and Howzer to a much lesser extend became completely worthless by this point.

• Awakened King’s Elvis hair.

• Awakened King defeating Mael with 4 Commandments.

• Merlin trashing Cusack and Chandler like if they were fodder.

• Ludociel being useless through the arc.

• Goddess Clan wasn't treated very well (to put it lightly).

• Mael became a pussy after his redemption.

• Just like Fraudrin’s one, the redemption of Monspeet and Derieri felt unnatural.

• Original Demon/The Sinner was a joke.

• It erased any credibility people could have towards the Demon King.

• The first fight against the Demon King was awful.

• Nakaba trolled us with the (first) fake epilogue.


Demon King Saga (whole second fight against the Demon King)

Pros

• It ended.

• Gave closure to the plotline of Zeldris/Gelda.

• Escanor’s death is emotional if you ignore how dumb it was in hindsight.

• Demon King Zeldris looked cool, I guess.


Cons

• Everything about the Demon King battle and the Demon King himself (too many things to list them all).

• Merlin pulling Ban’s Sacred Treasure almost literally out of her ass.

• "Bloody Ellie this, Bloody Ellie that..." *proceeds to do jackshit through the fight*

• It made Mael look unsympathetic by basically condemning Escanor to a sure death.

• Escanor’s death, if you think about it, ends being kinda stupid.

• Nakaba once again used a fake epilogue.


Chaos Saga (stuff with Cath, Arthur and the Chaos up to the last chapter)

Pros

• It tied everything regarding Arthur/Cath.


• Cath Palug’s design looked cool.


• The part where Cath mindrapes Meliodas.


• It finally ended the manga.


Cons

• It ruined Merlin’s character for good.


• The Sins felt unnecessary in the battle against Cath, and nothing would have changed if you would have removed them from the fight.


• Cath’s goal and defeat were pathetic.


• The powerscale of the manga (who was bad before) went to shit for good this time.


• Gowther’s reasoning about why they shouldn’t judge Merlin for her actions was... questionable.


• The epilogue didn’t give closure to certain characters (Zeldris, Gelda, Mael…)


• Tristan’s design.


I say that up until the 10 Commandments Saga the series was a solid 7. It wasn't the most original shounen of the world, but it was enjoyable and despite some eyebrow raising moments, it was passable. But after the last three sagas, everything went to Hell, so I drop my score to 4/5, depending on my mood. I say it is still better than Fairy Tail.
 
Last edited:

Samael Morningstar

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Dec 15, 2018
Messages
4,556
Reaction score
4,471
Age
25
Gender
Male
Country
India
First arc, ch 1-100 - 9/10
2nd Arc, ch 100-200 - 7/10
3rd arc, ch 200-250 - 6/10
Mini Maelstrossa arc - 9/10
3rd arc finale, ch 282-347 - 3/10

Overall for the whole series from good and bad together gets a 6.8 out of ten which let's make it a 7/10 for the whole
 
Top