- Joined
- May 20, 2018
- Messages
- 1,754
- Reaction score
- 5,158
- Gender
- Male
- Country
-
So, now that the series has officially ended, I believe it's time for a thread like this in which each and every one of us voices his/her opinion regarding the series as a whole. What did you think of it? What did you like and what did you dislike from it? If you had to give a mark out of 10, what would that mark be? I'll start:
- Holy Knights Saga (first 100 chapters)
Probably the best arc of the series overall, IMO. Most of the Sins except Escanor were introduced. Be it because of their abilities, background or personality, pretty much all of them were interesting. The fights during that arc were among the best of the series too. There was a decent amount of tension, the battle choreography was way better and each and every character used his/her own abilities accordingly. The villains were fine I guess, nothing spectacular from a character standpoint, but at least they were a threat, unlike the majority of the villains that will come later on. There were some plot twists here and there about Gil and Margaret, and some foreshadowing regarding the curse of the main couple of the series.
Overall Note: 7,5-8/10
- Ten Commandments Saga (100-200 chapters)
This arc was still fine for the vast majority of the time, however, it is also the arc in which the series introduced some concepts that were handled in a pretty bad way, like the PL system, a system that Nakaba barely even cared about and that IMO, it shouldn't have never been introduced in the first place. The overall PL differences between the characters didn't follow any logic at all, sometimes character A stomped character B with a measly 10K difference (see Escanor vs Galand) and other times this difference could have been way more than that and a character would still be able to keep up (though, this problem mainly affects the later parts of the series, in which for example Diane can force the DK out of the lake with her PL being 50K). The differences and the distribution of stats between magic, strength, and spirit were never explained in a proper way, but still, this arc still respected this system to some extent, the problem I'm saying is really severe in the next arcs.
The introduction of the Commandments was done pretty well. Galand showing up and massacring each and every one of the Sins to show the overwhelming difference between the two established them as a massive threat. Escanor (one of the best characters in the series, despite his whole sacrifice in the final fight being meaningless, IMO) was introduced with a pretty overpowered that power that brought an equally overpowered weakness. Even if some characters were stomped by him and Mel at that point, it was still fine, since we knew for a fact that the Commandments getting trashed were nowhere near the strongest of the bunch and we held (at least I held) on the idea that the upper echelon commandments would be able to tango with the Sins. The Second Vaizel festival arc was done pretty well and ended with a pretty high note with Mel's death. There were some BS moments though, just like Escanor transforming at night, but they were still passable. The real bullshit came at the end of the saga, more specifically in the Defense of Liones arc, that started really good with Escanor facing Estarossa, but went to shit afterward. The strongest Commandments were slapped around like flies mostly by Mel and Escanor (Merlin and her Infinity also had their own part in all of this) and all chances of potential danger, interactions between characters and good fights were thrown into the trash can. To add more salt into the injury, we got a panel saying that the Seven Deadly Sins were specifically formed to defeat the Ten Commandments, but none of them did anything noteworthy against them with the exception of Mel and Escanor.
Overall Note: 6/10
- Memories of the Holy War + Corand Battle + Prelude to the Second Holy War Saga (200- 280)
The reason I'm making this separation is that I consider those three to be the last decent arcs this series had to offer. In the flashback of the Holy War, we got to see Eli as a Goddess, as well as three of the four AA, and their clash with the Commandments. We also saw Gowther's origins (one of the best backstories of the series IMO). Other highlights were the Mel vs Escanor fight, that despite not being that much of a mindblowing fight when it came to choreography, the hype of seeing Mel in AM overpowering Escanor in his different day stages and seeing his peak for the first time brought massive levels of hype within me as a reader.
After that, we got to see the introduction of the masters, one that was kinda out of nowhere, to be honest. I think Nakaba made a serious mistake trashing and disposing of all the Commandments so quickly and since he realized that Zeldris alone was too little of a threat to the Sins, he had to pull this new demons way stronger than the Commandments (who were stated to be the best warriors of the clan previously) to fill the gap his bad execution had left previously. Even then, they didn't disappoint in this arc (at least not yet). Chandler vs Sins was among the best fights of the series. It didn't lack tension, each and everyone used their own abilities more or less accordingly and the teamwork of the Sins, as well as Chandler's massive arsenal of spells (somehow greater than his creator, lol) was a nice sight to see. Cusack teaching a lesson to Arthur on where he stood when it came to power and him seemingly killing him with his ability Resonant was a great moment too. Mel dissolving the Sins to become DK in order to break the curse, the AA forming an alliance with the Sins and the other Holy Knights, as well as the Mael reveal were pretty good too, especially the Mael reveal, a reveal that to this day and from my personal opinion, stands at the highest point of Nakaba's writing skills, along with chapter 224 featuring the cursed lovers' flashback. The amount of foreshadowing we got since the first appearance of Estarossa was really good, same for chapter 224.
Overall note: 7,5/10
- Final Saga (280-346)
I put all of these chapters in one final paragraph because, from this point onwards, Nakaba's writing exponentially decreased really fast, to the point that if you had told me that a novice had substituted Nakaba when writing, I wouldn't be surprised at all.
1. King's ridiculous power-up: We knew that the strongest Fairy King before him clocked at a max of 50K (since we don't anything of Dahlia, and likely we'll never know), but this guy suddenly grew up strong enough to treat 200K+ character like a complete and utter joke and could keep up to some extent with the DK. Don't get me wrong, we knew he was going to be the strongest Fairy King in history, and we have recently known that the Sacred Tree was a godly being and a direct offspring of Chaos just like the DK and the SD all along, but that doesn't change the fact that his power-up was still ridiculous. This really ruined the Mael arc for me, an arc that for the most part had been pretty good.
2. The massive inflation of the PLs that made absolutely no sense within the context of the story and was only made to make the numbers higher and hype that failed to deliver anything at the end, since like I said the PL system wasn't even well done before that point, and to that point onwards it became way worse.
3. The Sinner: We learned that the Masters were originally one being and that twist was pretty good since we were told that the DK gave his power to one certain servant that had Chandler's stick and Cusack's swords, however, what came after that was humiliation after humiliation for the poor guy. A massively weakened Escanor lasted a few chapters against him (this is again another proof that the PL system didn't matter at that point), Ludo humiliated him and Mael destroyed him with one attack. For a being that was hyped as the fusion of the two strongest demons besides the DK and Meliodas, he sure left a lot to desire at the very least.
4. The Demon King: The main villain of the series along with the Supreme Deity, the god of all demons, a being with an amazing design and the creator of really powerful curses and magic that had all the wisdom of the Underworld got reduced to a jobber that only swung his big sword upwards and downwards, someone that got disrespected in every battle he fought against the protagonists (to the point that some of them even talked about marriage in the middle of the final fight, lol) and someone who only desired destruction because he felt like it, with no real motives behind. To summarize, a total joke.
5. Mel's OG magic that basically destroyed the main core of this series' plot: the journey to break the curse. A magic that we don't know what it is, why he didn't even use it until now and that disappeared as fast as it appeared, without us learning anything from it. By far one of the worst things Nakaba has done. I won't talk about it too much since I already posted some walls of text explaining why I think like this in the Meliodas thread, but basically the problem here was that Nakaba failed to deliver a proper explanation as to why he couldn't use it until now ("I am afraid" is not a proper explanation). Nakaba's obsession with Mel got worse as the series went on, to the point that the spotlight of other characters got reduced considerably because of that and we were left with a lot of questions.
There are other really big problems with this final arc, like Wild's pointless death (and pointless revival too, but I guess dude deserved it), Escanor's pointless death, some characters actually forgetting that they have really strong abilities (like Merlin's Double Impact and Ban's Snatch and Hunter Fest that weren't really used at all like they never existed), fake tension and fake drama, but by far, the biggest one for me is the Supreme Deity. No matter how shit the DK's treatment was, he at least got one, unlike her. The Supreme Deity, the other main villain of this series that should've had the same relevance as the Demon King in the story, didn't utter a word until the very end and was left like she didn't even exist in the first place. Even if he were to introduce her in the sequel, what relevance could she have when we have Arthur around with the powers of the creator of the verse?
Not only the overall character of the Supreme Deity was left like it didn't even exist in the first place, but the whole Goddess Clan got left with very little development and screentime compared to the Demon Clan. Eli is perhaps, besides her mother, the worst victim of this. The deuteragonist of this series barely had any important moment at all, there are really few that come to mind, compared to the dozens and dozens that Mel had. She also got barely fleshed out and the overall writing about her felt inconsistent to say the least, sometimes she was a damsel in distress and some other times she was an incredible warrior. Now that I'm onto this, she isn't the only one victim of this, at this later part of the story it felt like the characters were as strong as Nakaba needed them to be, there was no power scaling and consistency with anything. The female characters got really left behind too and the Giants got the short end of the stick and a shit development, tbh.
Of course, there were some decent moments too, like the Assault Squad vs the top Demons, the development of some Sins (like Escanor's pride transforming into humility and Ban, the greed, sacrificing pretty much everything for his loved one, as well as other developments), but sadly they got completely overshadowed by the bad ones.
Overall note: 2-3/10
Overall, looking at the series as a whole, most of it was pretty decent (far from being perfect as flaws were still there like any other fictional work, but overall pretty enjoyable), the only chapters that suffered from a really bad writing quality IMO were the ones that featured the Defense of Liones Arc, as well as this whole final arc that I commented. However, those two, especially this finale, do great harm in the series as the end is really important and the quality drop was enormous. If the series had continued with the same quality as the previous arcs, this for me would have been easily a 7/10, perhaps even more, but sadly and thanks to this finale it stays as a 5/10 at best for me.
It's really sad because I think this series had a ton of potential, but in the end, I'm gonna have to leave it thinking of what it could have been instead of what we actually got.
PD: Sorry for the wall of text, I got a little too carried away, but I felt I had to do it.
- Holy Knights Saga (first 100 chapters)
Probably the best arc of the series overall, IMO. Most of the Sins except Escanor were introduced. Be it because of their abilities, background or personality, pretty much all of them were interesting. The fights during that arc were among the best of the series too. There was a decent amount of tension, the battle choreography was way better and each and every character used his/her own abilities accordingly. The villains were fine I guess, nothing spectacular from a character standpoint, but at least they were a threat, unlike the majority of the villains that will come later on. There were some plot twists here and there about Gil and Margaret, and some foreshadowing regarding the curse of the main couple of the series.
Overall Note: 7,5-8/10
- Ten Commandments Saga (100-200 chapters)
This arc was still fine for the vast majority of the time, however, it is also the arc in which the series introduced some concepts that were handled in a pretty bad way, like the PL system, a system that Nakaba barely even cared about and that IMO, it shouldn't have never been introduced in the first place. The overall PL differences between the characters didn't follow any logic at all, sometimes character A stomped character B with a measly 10K difference (see Escanor vs Galand) and other times this difference could have been way more than that and a character would still be able to keep up (though, this problem mainly affects the later parts of the series, in which for example Diane can force the DK out of the lake with her PL being 50K). The differences and the distribution of stats between magic, strength, and spirit were never explained in a proper way, but still, this arc still respected this system to some extent, the problem I'm saying is really severe in the next arcs.
The introduction of the Commandments was done pretty well. Galand showing up and massacring each and every one of the Sins to show the overwhelming difference between the two established them as a massive threat. Escanor (one of the best characters in the series, despite his whole sacrifice in the final fight being meaningless, IMO) was introduced with a pretty overpowered that power that brought an equally overpowered weakness. Even if some characters were stomped by him and Mel at that point, it was still fine, since we knew for a fact that the Commandments getting trashed were nowhere near the strongest of the bunch and we held (at least I held) on the idea that the upper echelon commandments would be able to tango with the Sins. The Second Vaizel festival arc was done pretty well and ended with a pretty high note with Mel's death. There were some BS moments though, just like Escanor transforming at night, but they were still passable. The real bullshit came at the end of the saga, more specifically in the Defense of Liones arc, that started really good with Escanor facing Estarossa, but went to shit afterward. The strongest Commandments were slapped around like flies mostly by Mel and Escanor (Merlin and her Infinity also had their own part in all of this) and all chances of potential danger, interactions between characters and good fights were thrown into the trash can. To add more salt into the injury, we got a panel saying that the Seven Deadly Sins were specifically formed to defeat the Ten Commandments, but none of them did anything noteworthy against them with the exception of Mel and Escanor.
Overall Note: 6/10
- Memories of the Holy War + Corand Battle + Prelude to the Second Holy War Saga (200- 280)
The reason I'm making this separation is that I consider those three to be the last decent arcs this series had to offer. In the flashback of the Holy War, we got to see Eli as a Goddess, as well as three of the four AA, and their clash with the Commandments. We also saw Gowther's origins (one of the best backstories of the series IMO). Other highlights were the Mel vs Escanor fight, that despite not being that much of a mindblowing fight when it came to choreography, the hype of seeing Mel in AM overpowering Escanor in his different day stages and seeing his peak for the first time brought massive levels of hype within me as a reader.
After that, we got to see the introduction of the masters, one that was kinda out of nowhere, to be honest. I think Nakaba made a serious mistake trashing and disposing of all the Commandments so quickly and since he realized that Zeldris alone was too little of a threat to the Sins, he had to pull this new demons way stronger than the Commandments (who were stated to be the best warriors of the clan previously) to fill the gap his bad execution had left previously. Even then, they didn't disappoint in this arc (at least not yet). Chandler vs Sins was among the best fights of the series. It didn't lack tension, each and everyone used their own abilities more or less accordingly and the teamwork of the Sins, as well as Chandler's massive arsenal of spells (somehow greater than his creator, lol) was a nice sight to see. Cusack teaching a lesson to Arthur on where he stood when it came to power and him seemingly killing him with his ability Resonant was a great moment too. Mel dissolving the Sins to become DK in order to break the curse, the AA forming an alliance with the Sins and the other Holy Knights, as well as the Mael reveal were pretty good too, especially the Mael reveal, a reveal that to this day and from my personal opinion, stands at the highest point of Nakaba's writing skills, along with chapter 224 featuring the cursed lovers' flashback. The amount of foreshadowing we got since the first appearance of Estarossa was really good, same for chapter 224.
Overall note: 7,5/10
- Final Saga (280-346)
I put all of these chapters in one final paragraph because, from this point onwards, Nakaba's writing exponentially decreased really fast, to the point that if you had told me that a novice had substituted Nakaba when writing, I wouldn't be surprised at all.
1. King's ridiculous power-up: We knew that the strongest Fairy King before him clocked at a max of 50K (since we don't anything of Dahlia, and likely we'll never know), but this guy suddenly grew up strong enough to treat 200K+ character like a complete and utter joke and could keep up to some extent with the DK. Don't get me wrong, we knew he was going to be the strongest Fairy King in history, and we have recently known that the Sacred Tree was a godly being and a direct offspring of Chaos just like the DK and the SD all along, but that doesn't change the fact that his power-up was still ridiculous. This really ruined the Mael arc for me, an arc that for the most part had been pretty good.
2. The massive inflation of the PLs that made absolutely no sense within the context of the story and was only made to make the numbers higher and hype that failed to deliver anything at the end, since like I said the PL system wasn't even well done before that point, and to that point onwards it became way worse.
3. The Sinner: We learned that the Masters were originally one being and that twist was pretty good since we were told that the DK gave his power to one certain servant that had Chandler's stick and Cusack's swords, however, what came after that was humiliation after humiliation for the poor guy. A massively weakened Escanor lasted a few chapters against him (this is again another proof that the PL system didn't matter at that point), Ludo humiliated him and Mael destroyed him with one attack. For a being that was hyped as the fusion of the two strongest demons besides the DK and Meliodas, he sure left a lot to desire at the very least.
4. The Demon King: The main villain of the series along with the Supreme Deity, the god of all demons, a being with an amazing design and the creator of really powerful curses and magic that had all the wisdom of the Underworld got reduced to a jobber that only swung his big sword upwards and downwards, someone that got disrespected in every battle he fought against the protagonists (to the point that some of them even talked about marriage in the middle of the final fight, lol) and someone who only desired destruction because he felt like it, with no real motives behind. To summarize, a total joke.
5. Mel's OG magic that basically destroyed the main core of this series' plot: the journey to break the curse. A magic that we don't know what it is, why he didn't even use it until now and that disappeared as fast as it appeared, without us learning anything from it. By far one of the worst things Nakaba has done. I won't talk about it too much since I already posted some walls of text explaining why I think like this in the Meliodas thread, but basically the problem here was that Nakaba failed to deliver a proper explanation as to why he couldn't use it until now ("I am afraid" is not a proper explanation). Nakaba's obsession with Mel got worse as the series went on, to the point that the spotlight of other characters got reduced considerably because of that and we were left with a lot of questions.
There are other really big problems with this final arc, like Wild's pointless death (and pointless revival too, but I guess dude deserved it), Escanor's pointless death, some characters actually forgetting that they have really strong abilities (like Merlin's Double Impact and Ban's Snatch and Hunter Fest that weren't really used at all like they never existed), fake tension and fake drama, but by far, the biggest one for me is the Supreme Deity. No matter how shit the DK's treatment was, he at least got one, unlike her. The Supreme Deity, the other main villain of this series that should've had the same relevance as the Demon King in the story, didn't utter a word until the very end and was left like she didn't even exist in the first place. Even if he were to introduce her in the sequel, what relevance could she have when we have Arthur around with the powers of the creator of the verse?
Not only the overall character of the Supreme Deity was left like it didn't even exist in the first place, but the whole Goddess Clan got left with very little development and screentime compared to the Demon Clan. Eli is perhaps, besides her mother, the worst victim of this. The deuteragonist of this series barely had any important moment at all, there are really few that come to mind, compared to the dozens and dozens that Mel had. She also got barely fleshed out and the overall writing about her felt inconsistent to say the least, sometimes she was a damsel in distress and some other times she was an incredible warrior. Now that I'm onto this, she isn't the only one victim of this, at this later part of the story it felt like the characters were as strong as Nakaba needed them to be, there was no power scaling and consistency with anything. The female characters got really left behind too and the Giants got the short end of the stick and a shit development, tbh.
Of course, there were some decent moments too, like the Assault Squad vs the top Demons, the development of some Sins (like Escanor's pride transforming into humility and Ban, the greed, sacrificing pretty much everything for his loved one, as well as other developments), but sadly they got completely overshadowed by the bad ones.
Overall note: 2-3/10
Overall, looking at the series as a whole, most of it was pretty decent (far from being perfect as flaws were still there like any other fictional work, but overall pretty enjoyable), the only chapters that suffered from a really bad writing quality IMO were the ones that featured the Defense of Liones Arc, as well as this whole final arc that I commented. However, those two, especially this finale, do great harm in the series as the end is really important and the quality drop was enormous. If the series had continued with the same quality as the previous arcs, this for me would have been easily a 7/10, perhaps even more, but sadly and thanks to this finale it stays as a 5/10 at best for me.
It's really sad because I think this series had a ton of potential, but in the end, I'm gonna have to leave it thinking of what it could have been instead of what we actually got.
PD: Sorry for the wall of text, I got a little too carried away, but I felt I had to do it.
Last edited:

)