- Joined
- Oct 15, 2007
- Messages
- 6,247
- Reaction score
- 2,771
- Gender
- Hidden
- Country
-
Happy Halloween!
Hello, everyone! If you had not already seen in GK's review for chapter 422, he is taking a two week vacation from reviewing. He, however, cares so much for you, his loyal following, that he has asked me to continue his reviews for the interim. I was quite honored and humbly accepted. So, although it says "Tsukisama's Ten Comments," please do not think I am trying to rip off GK or any such thing.
Just a few notes:
I shall refer to the various Pain bodies as the following bold terms:
- Deva Pain (a.k.a. Yahiko Pain, God Pain)
- Human Pain (a.k.a. Thin Pain, Shang Tsung)
- Asura Pain (a.k.a. Demon Pain, Mecha Pain, Goo Head Pain)
- Animal Pain (a.k.a Summoner Pain, Girl Pain)
- Preta Pain (a.k.a. Hungry Ghost Pain, Fat Pain)
- Hell Pain (a.k.a. Old Pain) [although I feel Naraka Pain sounds cooler]
For the manga pictures, I used the FrankyHouse Edited Manga with the exception of the first image. That image was done by DrChrissy of deviantArt. (To view the work, click here.)
This is my first review so I do hope you keep that in mind as reading.
¤¤¤Tsukisama's 10 Comments on Naruto Chapter 423: The Deva Path's Power¤¤¤
Good ol' Kakashi
Good ol' Kakashi
1. Reflections on Kakashi
Chapter 423 begins with some thoughts on Kakashi by Pain and Chouza. Pain takes note of Kakashi's level of mid-battle strategic ability by being able to set up such a flawless trap that even he himself was fooled, which made the supposed "god" look a lot less godly in many readers' eyes last week. I think that by showing Pain taking such serious regard of Kakashi, Kishimoto is trying to characterize Kakashi as a very impressive ninja, giving Kakashi some much deserved recognition.
Chouza also praises Kakashi's abilities. It also seems that Chouza has worked with Kakashi in the past. I would not have pictured Chouza having had a working relationship with Kakashi, but I also would not have expected to see Inoichi working with Ibiki (although Inoichi's skills make him a good candidate for the interrogation squad). Kishimoto is taking good advantage of this opportunity to characterize some of the lesser known characters in a way that does not really detract from the story or feel forced at all. Nicely done, Kishi!

From Chouza's experience with Kakashi, Chouza recognizes one of Kakashi's most glaring weak points: Kakashi's stamina. As Kakashi confirms, through his ordeal with Pain up to this point Kakashi has already used over half of his chakra, meaning that he does not have all that much left in him.
While I will return to this important fact in a moment, I just wanted to point out something. Kakashi is considered one of the greatest ninja Konoha has, the main candidate for the next Hokage as deemed by Tsunade and Jiraiya, and yet he is nearing the limit of his chakra. Perhaps that Raiton Kage Bushin was an extremely powerful, chakra-draining jutsu, but I wouldn't have expected him to have used so much of his chakra given what we have seen thus far. Why I bring this up is because I think this says a lot about Tsunade's awesomeness as a ninja.
If Kakashi has used so much of his chakra from what we have seen, Tsunade must have an insane amount of chakra to try to heal every injured villager and shinobi of Konoha. Even if doing this takes just about all of her chakra (which I doubt it will as I expect Tsunade to do some fighting before this is over), her chakra capacity seems to be much, much greater than Kakashi's, and I am filled with even more anticipation in seeing Tsunade's show more of her amazing skills. She definitely is worthy of the title Hokage, but I digress.
Kakashi is running low on chakra. He knows it, and Chouza knows it. Who probably doesn't know this? Pain. It does not bode well for Kakashi that Pain is finally considering him a serious issue and that Kakashi is just running low on chakra. What fate could this possibly spell for Kakashi? Stay tuned.

Send in the B team
2. The Power of a God
As Asura Pain seems to be out of the way and Deva Pain is now getting serious, what happens? The same thing always inevitably happens, more random fodder nin show up to show why Pain is badass. It never ceases to amuse me. They're like ants. You squash a few and more keep appearing. I think is nice at least that we got to meet another member of Akimichi clan, although he proves to be even more useless than Chouji, as he and his fellow fodder nin are blown away by Deva Pain's repulsion technique, apparently named "Shinra Tensei.
For all those questioning whether Deva Pain is an offensive type body, I think Deva Pain's display of Shinra Tensei answers that question. We see him use it take a fairly large portion of the village (at least a block). As Kakashi goes on
to explain after Deva Pain blocks all of his and Chouji's projectiles, Deva Pain can deflect all incoming attacks. Deva Pain is surely supporting the many theories that he is the most powerful body as would be predicted by Deva realm being the highest realm into which one can be reincarnated. There is more even explanation from Kakashi...
Newton would have a field day with this
3. Is GK really Kakashi?!?
Kakashi finally tells us what he has figured out about Deva Pain's ability from his observations. There has been much speculation about what Deva Pain's ability really is. Many, including myself, thought that Deva Pain had telekinesis. Some interpreted what he was doing as magnetism. Some other suggestions that I saw were air pressure and black holes, but a few people had a different idea.
GK in his review last week was the first person I saw on this forum to suggest that Deva Pain's ability is control of gravity. Whether or not this is the true mechanic behind Deva Pain's ability, gravity is Kakashi's theory. Given that Kakashi is a character of Kishimoto and that I don't see much plot-driven reason for Kakashi to be wrong on the issue, I would say that Deva Pain's Shinra Tensei like does indeed work on the principle of gravity.
As Kakashi explains it, the ability uses gravity to attract and repel objects. It would be really interesting if Kishimoto was much into physics and knew about dark energy and the history of the cosmological constant. For those without the necessary physics background, in summary Einstein introduced the cosmological constant as a repulsive, "anti-gravity"-esque term to allow for his theory based around a stationary universe. After the Hubble redshift showed that the universe is dynamic, he abandoned the constant, calling it his biggest blunder. Later, after observations showed the universe is expanding, a phenomenon currently attributed to the mysterious dark energy, the notion of the cosmological constant has made its way back into modern physical theory with this repulsive gravitational force being the next big mystery of astrophysics.
If Kishimoto was aware of all that and started to introduce the six element or the basis for Deva Pain's jutsu in a way revolving around dark energy or dark matter, I would be highly impressed. For now though, I think the mention of gravity is as much physics as we will likely get on the matter.
Anyway, though, kudos to Gold Knight for calling this and living up to his Kakashi avatar.

Pop goes the weasel
4. Kakashi's Big Plan
There was much speculation as to how much Kakashi actually figured out from his observations of Pain leading up to this chapter. Kakashi observes there to be a brief window of time between when Deva Pain can use his Shinra Tensei. (For those familiar with the game Pokémon, Shinra Tensei is basically Hyper Beam, and Kakashi plans to act during the resultant rest phase.) Kakashi believes this to be the key to defeating Pain. As Chouza points out, this window of opportunity is quite brief, but Kakashi still seems optimistic about the plan, thinking that through his combined efforts with the Akimichi pair they will be successful.
Many (myself included) thought he probably would not figure out that much given how hard Jiraiya had it to discover Pain's secret. Jiraiya had a handy prophecy and the experience of fighting all 6 Pain bodies only to unravel the great mystery of Pain in his dying moments. With his dying breaths, he etched the key to figuring out this secret on Fukasaku's back, the key which may or may not have been successfully decoded yet. (My theory is that the true key for Jiraiya's code lies within the book that Naruto has just recently begun to read and not one of the Icha Icha books.)
From what little information we have gleaned from Jiraiya's battle with Pain pertaining to the secret of Pain, I doubt this time gap has anything to Pain's secret. Since Deva Pain has up until now been made to seem like the lead body of the hive-mind sextet, I doubt he will be taken out without use of the big secret, spelling doom for Kakashi's plan. Plus, plot-wise, it would be a bit too optimistic to think that Kakashi could take out such a major villain. Silly Kakashi, who do you think you are: the titular character? You do realize you aren't

And now you die, Mr. Bond!
5. Pain's Killer Intents
Not really much to say here except just to underscore the importance of Pain's words. Pain has gone from being nonchalant about Kakashi to trying to get rid of him quickly then to taking him seriously and has now arrived at the next progression: viewing Kakashi as a dangerous threat. While I again am glad for Kakashi to get more recognition, I don't think Kakashi needed this much recognition from such a dangerous fellow. Unlike some of the villains we have seen in Naruto thus far, Pain means business, and when he goes to kill an important secondary character, he does it with an already proven track record.
A death threat from Pain is nothing to take lightly, folks. Pray for Kakashi. Please, O Pain-sama, spare this one!

Did I just get tied up by two giant man balls?
6. The Best-laid Plans of Mice and Men
Kakashi's plan starts nicely enough with Kakashi sprouting out of the ground to strike Deva Pain. Pain realizes Kakashi about to attack him and deflects the white-haired wonder.
Has the plan failed yet? No, because this is Kakashi with whom we are dealing, the man who always has an ace up his sleeve. Kakashi was merely using himself as a diversion to allow Chouza and Chouji to attack as the great balls of meat we know they are, but Deva Pain deflects them too.
Has the plan failed yet? No, because Kakashi has yet another ace up his sleeve in form of a chain lying in wait to be used by the Akimichi pair to bind Pain.
Now, Kakashi comes in to finish Pain off with a Raikiri. The Akimichi look confident. Pain seems nervous, and Kakashi looks victorious. Has Kakashi defied the odds in that his plan has actually succeeded?
Now is when your plan fails
7. Of Gods and Titans
As the caption reads, just as Kakashi is about to seize victory, Kishimoto snatches it away in the form of return of Asura Pain. Just when you thought you've seen his freaky face for the last time (at least until Hell Pain shows up), here he comes.
This begs the question of whether or not the Akimichi family or Kakashi actually checked to make sure he was out of commission. I know that in the midst of battle one cannot fault them for not being very thoughtful, but I would think that the least someone could do was make a quick check that the guy was actually dead before pronouncing him as such.
I expected Kakashi's plan to fail somehow, but I was hoping that it would be from some new, unexpected technique from Deva Pain. Asura Pain's interference being the weak link in the chain just makes it seem like the plan was ill-conceived, lowering slightly my opinion of Kakashi's analytical abilities, which were looking top-notch until now. (I guess Kakashi is no Shikamaru after all.)
This also lowered my recently raised opinions of Chouji and Chouza. Last chapter, they impressed me by "taking out" Asura Pain, but they didn't accomplish that. Instead, they overestimate their power and believe him to be out of commission.
I find it especially amusing how it is rendered in the FrankyHouse Edited Manga. "It's the other Pain! How can he still move? C'mon"

Well, I find it hard to empathize with Kakashi, Chouji, and Chouza at the moment. If you had doen a proper job of checking to verify that Asura Pain was incapacitated or at least (if you weren't going to bother to confirm his state) factor in the possibility that he might reappear into your plan, Kakashi, you wouldn't be in this mess.
Now we know what Naruto does when aren't looking...nothing
8. Checking in with Naruto
In the last chapter, we did get any new information on our young hero. When we do, it seems that he is having a rather uneventful day on the toad mountain. Given, though the last time we saw him (two chapters ago) having just used some new jutsu that was able to slice the tops of mountains and that the time of events is likely correlated between Konoha and Toad Mountain, Naruto is probably just taking a well-deserved rest after using his powerful yet unrevealed jutsu. When Fukasaku finds Naruto seemingly goofing off idly on a leaf somewhere, he seems to buy Naruto's cover story. I guess Fukasaku is still as clueless as we are as to waht Naruto is doing in secret. Hopefully, he and we find out soon.
Luke, don't trust your feelings. Just trust what I'm telling you, dummy
9. The Implications of Danzou's Decision
Before returning from our brief glimpse of Naruto to the main event in Konoha, we see Naruto showing even more example of why he will be an excellent Hokage in the village by wondering about the village's safety. Perhaps Naruto's Hokage sense is tingling, because he could not be more right, but Fukasaku in a large bit of dramatic irony assuages Naruto's concerns with the reassurance that Naruto would be contacted by the messenger frog if Konoha were truly in danger. (Froggy is still being mentioned and is now officially more relevent to the story than Tenten.
)Firstly, I just want to point out how so many people were against Tsunade sending Naruto that messenger frog. Although I did not place much value on it when Tsunade made the decision to contact him about Konoha's peril, I now think that another important reason that Tsunade wanted to contact Naruto is because he wants to Hokage some day and thus would want to be involved/made aware. Whether Naruto is capable of facing Pain currently is somewhat beside the point. To have kept the information of the attack from Naruto would have been extremely hurtful to Naruto, and it would have signified Tsunade not having the faith in Naruto to become Hokage that she has advocated since 3 years ago. In light of this scene, I wonder if anyone else's opinions on Tsunade's decision to contact Naruto has altered somewhat.
Well, Konoha's being attacked and Froggy isn't contacting Naruto. Someone is to blame for this, and it won't be Tsunade. (In fact, if Tsunade dies in this battle, I bet Naruto will make a big deal about avenging her and will completely forget any of the hurt feelings he had towards her for allowing Jiraiya to go into Amegakure alone.) The person who at some point need to take the blame for this is Danzou. When Naruto returns and questions arise as to why Naruto was not contacted as per Tsunade's orders, I wonder if Danzou will admit to being the culprit. He doesn't really have to do so. He already has the perfect scapegoats: the elders. They openly opposed Tsunade's decision in front of witnesses, while presumably no one saw Danzou murder the messenger frog. If Danzou is the cold-hearted bastard I think he is, he will allow the elders to take fall, escaping persecution and removing powerful figures out of his way (albeit powerful figures that were his patsies).
While Danzou's fate remains unclear, one thing is certain: Naruto will be pissed.
[Cue the dramatic crescendo]
10. First Jiraiya, Now Kakashi?
The scene returns to Kakashi and company having been utterly trounced the combined might of Asura and Deva Pain. (I like how Kishimoto takes advantage of this opportunity to show not only Chouza and Chouji but also the other unnamed Akimichi all lying unconscious on the same line. Family reunion time!
)As Deva Pain notes, Kakashi really does seem to be the one caught this time and not just a bunshin, supported by Kakashi's thought and speech bubbles. Deva Pain decides to take this opportunity to make good on his statements of killer intent towards Kakashi. How does Pain intend to kill the great Kakashi? In perhaps the most unceremonious fashion used in the manga up to this point: by fligning a random rusty nail off the ground at him. Thus we are left with a cliffhanger until next week.
I will now conclude my comments with the following haiku:
Kakashi's light shines
But Deva Pain's shines brighter
Will Kakashi die?
But Deva Pain's shines brighter
Will Kakashi die?
Rating:



(4 out of 5)While I enjoyed the action and drama, the fact that this chapter revolved around Kakashi's plan instead of offering much in the way of new developments and information leaves me somewhat unfilled. It was a great chapter nonetheless, doing well on what was covered.
Predictions
- We will find out Kakashi's fate, and he likely won't be dead (I expect some miraculous occurrence)
- Tsunade or some of the other ninja in Konoha will be shown
- We will see some brief moments of Naruto trying to learn to fuse with Fukasaku to bring some humor to an otherwise intense chapter
I hoped you enjoyed this review, and I hope you are having a happy Halloween. Please leave comments on where you agreed, where you disagreed, and where I need to improve. Please bear with me, as I will be doing another review for next week, after which GK will be back and fresh with more of his lovely review series.
Last edited: