Discussion Wano - The arc with its roots in everything

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
There are times when I'm reading an arc in One Piece where I notice that I'm not enjoying the chapter to chapter experience as much as I think I could. With Wano (and Onigashima - for purposes of simplicity assume when I say Wano arc I mean both) it's been no exception. The pacing has felt off. I've had thoughts about how time has progressed two weeks in the OP world but over three years in real life, since the start of Wano. That said, sometimes I return to an arc and re-read it in one continuous sitting to see how it flows together when we're not all waiting week to week. This helped me enjoy the Whole Cake Island, Dressrosa, and Punk Hazard arcs a lot more (in hindsight). I managed to get some continuous reading of the arc in over the weekend and organize my thoughts on it and wanted to write something like a preliminary review, some thoughts, and speculations. This feels too broad for any one of the threads (and too specific / high effort to be a single post in the mega-discussion) so I ask to leave this up without collapsing it into another thread unless you truly feel the effort put forth belongs as a sub-piece of another thread. I'll collapse images into spoilers to make this post easier to scroll through, but just be aware that this post assumes you are up to date as far as chapter 1027. And I apologize - this is going to be long.

Firstly. The scale of One Piece has grown immensely. To paint that picture let's compare the trajectory that led to the fall of Crocodile to the one that will eventually lead to the fall of Kaido. Wano technically started in July of 2018. So we're about three years and some change into the arc now as we reach its peak. When did Wano really start? I would argue that the real path to Wano started in 2013. February of 2013 to be specific. This panel:
Similar to how Crocodile became the "goal" of the Straw Hats from the moment they left Whiskey Peak, Kaido became their goal from the moment they formed an alliance with the Heart Pirates. Everything between the alliance being formed, and Wano is purely there for the purpose of improving their chances of defeating the Yonko, Kaido. Caesar was the SMILE manufacturer, Joker was the broker to get the supply to the customer, Kaido. Punk Hazard, Dressrosa, and Zou were all directly related to the larger picture goal of defeating Kaido. Whole Cake Island provided necessary character growth for Luffy, as well as exploring Sanji's past, and giving him a reasonable power up so that he could perform in Wano (the RAID suit, obviously). While it may not be directly related to Wano in the sense that it was part of the overall plan to take down Kaido, it's more of a tangent in the way that Drum Island was for Arabasta - they needed to go there, and accomplish some goal so that they could hit their ultimate goal (defeating a tyrant).

So for the scale:
Arabasta over-all (End of Whiskey Peak to Crocodile's defeat) - Chapter 114 to chapter 217. Quite the trek especially considering it came fairly early in the overall story of OP. Similar questions hit my mind regarding how Luffy could defeat someone who shares the same status as Hawkeyes so quickly.
Wano over-all (Alliance forming to current) - chapter 697 - ongoing (currently chapter 1027 at time of writing). 330 chapters, or roughly 1/3 of the total chapters of One Piece have been dedicated to Kaido's defeat. This is a very significant number.


The reason I mention the scale is that I believe it's very important. As I mentioned I often read these chapters with less enjoyment than if I'm continuously reading them. It definitely feels slow to have Luffy in a "prison camp" for over 20 chapters, or to spend 10+ chapters exploring the past of a non-main character (Oden). When you look at the preparation that went into place to get to where we are, I think the pacing is more forgivable. It's been a long journey for Luffy to get to where he is now. It's included fighting Logia users, saving a princess (in Dressrosa), taking down a large portion of the black market of the OP world (Caesar and Joker), liberating a whole country from slavery (Tontattas and Toys), forming a powerful alliance (Straw Hat Grand Fleet), saving a species from Genocide (the Minks), taking out two Yonko Commanders, ruining said Yonko's plans of acquiring new technology, and even stealing a piece of her soul, to where we are today. Onto the "preliminary review" (I said it'd be long, right? I'm a wordy guy).

Part 1. Why are we even in Wano?
Let's start by getting to the point. Wano has had one goal stated ever since the Pirate Alliance formed; Defeating Kaido.
Why? Because he's a Yonko and that's what Pirate King candidates do - they lash out at the Yonko to establish their dominance. The reasons at the time were very simple. No complex plot points. Wano hadn't even been mentioned yet. We had some reason to believe Kaido was evil based on the stuff we saw on Punk Hazard, his association with Joker and Caesar, and his behavior (attempting to attack Whitebeard unprovoked in his moment of weakness). We had no idea how deep this would all run.

Kaido also did not get a fair shake before his proper introduction. Many of us assumed he was the weakest of the yonko based on the only context we had available to us at the time. What did we know about Kaido before Wano (and the end of Dressrosa, where he was introduced)?
  • Fought Moriah (who we perceive as weak)
  • "Held off" by Shanks (with very little context to what actually went down)
  • First Yonko that we will see Luffy fight
The above led many here to believe that Kaido would be something of a "diet Yonko". Like the Crocodile of the Yonko. Well, the simple fact of the matter is that Kaido is not the weakest Yonko, and he is not a "diet Yonko". He's probably the most real Yonko we will encounter in the story. This man:
People say if it's a one-on-one fight, Kaido will win. Land, sea, and air - out of every living thing in the world, this Pirate is said to be the strongest creature alive!
He has established one of the most strategic strong-holds in the world of One Piece. The weapons manufactured on Wano are powerful enough that even the darkest corners of the World Government seek the weapons he has produced in Wano. This is a man who can literally "fly" his base of operations, an Island itself, around on a whim. What were his word's when the Worst Generation started lashing out at him?
I think we can all agree that the initial purpose of Wano was to defeat Kaido.

Finally, we're in Wano. Now what? From a crazy landing to... more craziness?!
One Piece arcs are usually consistent. We dock at a new Island, form some new relationships, explore and eventually organically find our way to trouble. Wano was definitely an exception and not the norm. We were brought into Wano with a crash landing. Even Tottoland started with some basic espionage and exploring. They even met Pudding before taking off to Whole Cake Island to crash the wedding. Luffy's first moments on Wano were:
  • Save Tama from Beast Pirates
  • Rush Tama to get help after she drank polluted water
  • Run across Zoro who is also causing trouble
  • Face off with Hawkins
  • Save Tama (again) but also cause a huge ruckus summoning Kaido and Jack to Kuri
  • Get one-shot by Kaido and spend some time in a prison camp
We really didn't have much room to breath here. Wano has been a combination of slow pacing mixed with very up-beat moments strung together consistently. The situation has felt perilous ever since they landed and only ballooned since. Oh, your captain is in prison? How about we add Big Mom to the mix. Hell, let's send her to the prison! That'd be fun, right? Luffy showing a soft spot for the old man, Hyou? Let's bring on Queen, the Calamity, and have him force you to participate in a game where the loser gets decapitated. Oh, and your partner is a feeble old man. You want to sell some soba? I'm sorry, this is the capital sir. You must first defeat assassins to do that. Oh, you met a kind goofy old man who's always smiling? That old man is actually a very important Daimyo who mentored Oden, is Toko's (the world's sweetest assistant to the sexiest Courtesian) father, that smile is a curse on both him and his daughter, and he's going to get fucking crucified, and shot to death right before laying down the biggest string of low-key insults to the fucking Shogun that the country has seen. Needless to say or go on; Wano has been tense. I've never felt the situation was "comfortable". It's always felt a moment away from chaos and I think this is one aspect of the arc Oda has masterfully performed. We go from Luffy taking out Katakuri, the invincible superman of the Big Mom Pirates, to getting one shot and put in his place by the Yonko Kaido.

Oh and by the way. Kaido is a fucking Eastern Style Azure Dragon; "Seiryu" - who can "fly", change the weather, breath fire, and take an insane amount of physical punishment. Worthy of an image:


The first part of Wano served a clear purpose: Create the setting. We're shown that the alliance has clear objectives in gathering information, gathering allies, and gathering weapons. We're shown two contrasting scenes in Kuri and the Flower Capital. We get to see that a country run by a Yonko is no place for the weak. We're shown children in the Flower Capital being indoctrinated with Orochi's lies by Beast Pirate Gifters. We're shown girls in Kuri fall victim to the Beast Pirates' tyranny, and that a bowl of rice is a blessing one may only receive ever so rarely. We see the state of Kuri and that there are no guarantees. Even the beasts that wander about are not safe to eat due to their consumption of polluted waters. The combination of Orochi's rule with Kaido's brutish ways have snuffed out any possibility of a peaceful existence within Wano; Even the Flower Capital is only peaceful under a facade.

One of the most significant parts of this arc is we finally applied a timeline to events. We learn that Kinemon and crew actually jumped 20 years into the future by way of Lady Toki's power. We're introduced to Kyoushiro around the same time. This part personally was a bit of a mind-fuck for me. Momonosuke was.. born before Luffy?! We knew all along that the Samurai were secretive around the Pirates. After all, Momo was first paraded as Kinemon's son, and not Oden's son. Not only that but Oden died much earlier than we thought. The timelines never made much sense without this information - Oden traveled with Roger, Whitebeard, and was killed by Kaido. Wano is clearly already a weapon manufacturing island, but factories don't appear overnight without the likes of Perospero or someone like Pica who can materialize that type of thing.

Another aspect of Wano that we are shown is that Samurai are strong. This was definitely reinforced into our brains as we witnessed Ashura Doji. The man is nothing short of a literal comic-villain as we meet him. We know little about him at first other than that he runs the Atamyama Thieves, a band of ruffians. We're shown that he has no regard for the citizens of Wano as he steals fresh water and food from the desperate peasants of Kuri. Oda built Shutenmaru up in our minds as an evil, fat fool who would probably be stomped out by Luffy. It wasn't long before this "fool" is going toe-to-toe with Jack, the man who nearly genocide the Mink Race, and slashing Jack's chest open. We even see that he has been extended an offer to join the Beast Pirates by Kaido himself, a testament to the man's strength. Also a testament that he survived that chat with Kaido.

The first act and Wano's overall introduction come to a close in an epic exchange of blows between Luffy and Kaido. The latter receiving the blunt force of Luffy's strongest attacks, and the former being 1HKO's by a simple strike from Kaido's kanabo.

For the first part I have to say the pacing was there, the bad-guy lived up to his reputation as the world's strongest (he one-shot a guy who was able to survive being pursued by all three Admirals at once, pre-timeskip), and Wano's situation was very, very sympathetic to me. I loved the smaller moments in this part. It was chaotic but filled with great bits. Luffy taking a fire-y blow to the face from Holden and one-shotting him over his treatment of Tama, Luffy's minor PTSD when Tama mentioned Ace, and Luffy telling Tama that he'd turn Wano into a country where nobody starves. Part 1 on its own is a great part of One Piece which encapsulates almost everything I loved about the manga. Interesting new characters, a perilous situation that keeps getting worse, Luffy making promises, and a bad guy who seems unstoppable.

Part 2. Prison. What a great place for a montage!
As we all know the second act is arguably one of the slower parts of One Piece. A summary of events below:
  • Luffy and Kidd are imprisoned
  • Orochi is introduced officially
  • Big Mom is heading to Wano
  • Sanji fights Page One and explores using his RAID suit in various settings
  • Raizo is trying to free Luffy
  • The alliance is faced with tension over the fact that someone is obviously leaking information
  • Orochi is throwing a banquet and Komurasaki is attending
  • Komurasaki and Toko come across Zoro, who is fighting the Kitsune on the Bridge
  • Zoro saves Komurasaki and Toko from Killer
  • Law is captured at some point
  • Luffy practices Ryuo in the Sumo Ring
  • Komurasaki is revealed to be Hiyori, Oden's daughter and Momo's sister
  • Big Mom inadvertently saves the day, and is captured by Queen all at once
  • The prison mine is taken by the alliance, and Kawamatsu is freed
  • Zoro receives Enma
  • The situation becomes seemingly perilous - Nekomamushi is nowhere to be seen, they haven't come across Denjiro, the alliance did not show up as planned, the sea itself seems to be rejecting the Samurai, and it's becoming more and more obvious that a traitor is in the midst.
The reason I chose an unordered list for the above is that I find the second part of Wano to be an absolute (albeit necessary) mess. I wouldn't call it bad, or unentertaining. I just found this part hard to keep up with. The focus of part two cannot be summarized as easily as part one, or even part three. If I had to give it a short synopsis it'd go something like "Shit sucks, life sucks, Luffy isn't strong enough, Orochi is an asshole, Big Mom is petty and just doubled the Beast Pirate's strength, power ups are now itemized (Enma, RAID suit), and where the fuck is that cat and Denjiro, oh and Orochi is a crafty bastard too, and.. CP0?! Wtf mate?"

A lot of the "meat" of Wano is in this part. We see Orochi in his full form (which is objectively disgusting):
We see that just a mention of the name Kaido gives Orochi a chip to use in bargaining with the World Government and Tenryuubito. We never perceive Orochi as being a strong man, but he certainly is not lacking in confidence. The evil Shogun shoots one CP0 member in the face and demands they give him Vegapunk then name-drops his ally, Kaido, to intimidate them.

We witness Komurasaki's "death" just as quickly as her debut. We see Zoro doing Zoro stuff and taking out strong enemies, standing his ground, and nearly taking out Orochi himself. We learn about the cruel fate of those who eat the SMILE fruits but do not gain an ability. We see that Wano is hiding more than we first thought - the whole underground world of "Old Wano" work as slaves in the prisoner mines for Kaido, unwilling to relent or join forces with him. We're introduced to Old Man Hyou, a frail old man who can't even do the basic labor necessary to earn Kibi tokens in the Udon Mines, yet we witness him take out a SMILE user effortlessly. We're given some competitive bonding between Luffy and Kidd; Similar to Midoriya and Bakugo in BNHA. We're given the narrative of how previous rebellions against Kaido have ended by Ashura Doji. We're shown that Tama, the simple girl from part one is going to be a key player in the victory for the alliance. The part takes us from Beast Pirate cronies breaking into Women's bath houses, to gentle strolls across Wano with Olin, Boss Chopper and Crew, to Orochi's castle, to Udon, and has its utter peak in a battle between two Yonko who then form an alliance to take on the entire world. It's.. A lot. That said, if I had to summarize this arc more pointedly than my previous summary it would have to be:

There's a traitor in the midst.

The real theme to this part is that Orochi always seems a step or two ahead. Whether it's knowing to check the bath-house, to blowing the bridges which connect various parts of Wano and "destroying" the Thousand Sunny. One of the most memorable experiences in One Piece which I'll never forget is the more emotional part of part 2 - the death of Yasuei.


What a tragic character. Loyal to the people of Wano and dedicating his life to helping those in need. He's a victim of the evil SMILE fruit, and a brave man who took the entire burden of the Alliance's plan onto his own shoulders to ensure they would be able to follow through. He goes out in style after humiliating Orochi but if there was a tear-worthy part of Wano, this was it.

Orochi is not incompetent. It's clear he has a spy, and knows how to use them very well.

Not some no-name spy, either. It was very clear from the get-go (as early as Jack being able to find Zou) that the spy must be someone very close. A member of the Akazaya 9 themselves. All of the mess of the arc is on a solid trajectory - Oden's Nine Samurai heading to their destiny, the final battle, with Orochi, scheming atop the Flower Capital. We're shown Zoro's training with Enma, and Luffy's training with ryuo, and the Fire Festival begins as the curtains close:


Part 3. The war that started over 20 years ago...

The third act of Wano is more than just a mere part. This is the climax of the past eight years of One Piece chapters. Love or hate it, this is where chapter 697, from 2013, has lead us. We're finally here. Real life years of waiting to merely get a glimpse of Kaido, a few more real life years to land on his turf, and even a bit longer yet from landing on his turf to the climactic end of the war that was started decades ago in the manga.

To sum up the past 8.5 years in two images:


I am not going to lie. I love part three, and while it's not done yet I'd love to give a preliminary review, some conjecture, and throw some theory out there for fun.
We're thrown into act three with the most perilous, desperate situation yet: Orochi seemingly thwarted the plans of the Akazaya 9. We're at the promised port. We survived to this point. Where is everyone else? The entirety of the alliance including the pirates and recruited samurai are nowhere to be seen. We're at the peak of despair. No Nekomamushi in sight. No ships carrying Samurai. No Luffy. No help, whatsoever. Great time to slip into a necessary tale, the tale of Oden.

Oden's tale wouldn't be worth telling if it weren't a bit over the top. When Kaido enters the scene we hear about the attempts to execute, torture, capture, imprison and defeat him. What about Oden?


I found Oden's introduction.. perplexing. The man who we were told is so admirable, the rightful Shogun of Wano-Kuni, the man who charmed Whitebeard and Roger, the man who earned the respect of Ashura Doji, who put the only visible scar on the Beast, Kaido, is... someone to hide your wife and daughter from? Oh boy. This was one of the more emotional "pasts" we have received in the One Piece world, notably because it was also the most informative. We knew the end of the story, but we did not know how we would ultimately arrive there. From the second Oden was introduced in his own past we knew this would end in tragedy. The tragedy of the man who hates confinement and rules. The tragedy of the man who started the Brothel Wars with the Yakuza.

The scale of Oden's story is as massive as any side character can hope for. Oden is a very controversial and sometimes hated character. He's polarizing. I'd like to say I'm going to be objective and non-biased, but trigger-warning: if you hate Oden the next couple of paragraphs may read as fanboyism. Oden is a man exiled by his father from the country he would one day be the rightful leader of. He's portrayed as a ruffian with a soft heart. He's a conquerer who would ultimately be hard to wrangle in, and of all the people on Whitebeards ship I believe Oden is the only one who's not a son but a brother. He's like a protagonist taken straight out of a Kurosawa film.

In summary Oden was an adventurer, a Samurai, a Daimyo, a (debatable) Shogun, a pirate, one who could hear the Voice of All Things, a conquerer, and a warrior rivaled by few. He was the last heir to the Kozuki family capable of reading the Poneglyphs, and one of a handful of people who has traveled to Laugh's Tale. His story starts small and consists of him gathering followers, helping the poorer parts of Wano, being mentored by Yasuei, and even loaning money to Orochi. He's a carefree man similar to Luffy but with a few more personality flaws. He was able to earn the respect of the Yakuza, something that even Kaido couldn't pull off.

He potentially gave up his dream of sailing to save his wife, Toki - the woman who leapt continuously through time looking for Wano and the events predicted over 800 years ago. He was present when Whitebeard took on Teach. He was there for Whitebeard's famous battle against Roger. In a sense he must have been the envy of Newgate as the man envied family and desired those types of connections only to see Oden form a very real family on his own ship. Wano's future, in a sense, was literally born upon the Moby Dick, the ship we witnessed splash up on Marineford. Oden bore witness to the heavens splitting apart in the clash between Roger and Whitebeard. He was a meticulous log-keeper who documented every significant detail of his adventures.

We're finally shown how Oden ended up on the Pirate King's ship. Voluntarily. Oden was arguably selfish in these moments as he sent Toki to an unfamiliar land, sick and with two young children. To be fair, he did not want to go on without her and she forced his hand. I always found it odd that he left Toki on Wano when it was clearly in a precarious situation. At that moment I guess he knew if he didn't push along for at least one more year he'd be living in regret. Defeating Kaido wouldn't mean much if he didn't learn the significant history associated with the importance of opening Wano to Joyboy.

I like to think that Oden's past is a visualization of the 'best of' moments from his own log-book. The moment they arrived at Laugh's Tale and found One Piece was one of the best reading experiences in the manga for me. We finally had some Easter Eggs dropped. We learned more about the name of the island, and we even see a reasonable explanation for why Shanks hasn't achieved finding One Piece. We even witness Oden himself offering Franky the opportunity to join the fucking ROGER PIRATES. Franky, the oblivious, mischievous boy, is also the only current SHP we've known of who has interacted with Oden in any way, whatsoever.

Once we land back onto Wano things take a turn for the worst and thus begins the hatred of Oden as a character as we witness the most powerful Samurai be reduced to a laughing stock who dances naked for pennies. I don't want to go to deep into this part other than to say that it all had to happen for the story to progress as it has. There would be no Wano arc if Oden defeated Kaido. There would be no Yonko saga. It was definitely fate that Oden would not be the one to welcome Joyboy to Wano and assist him on his journey. All that said, the legendary hour exceeded my expectations. We knew the nature of Oden's death, that he was dead, and boiled alive. We were not told the extent of his awesomeness in any previous narration. They say a picture is worth a thousand words, so without elaborating:



Oden's final moments consist of telling Kaido to grow stronger and truly living up to his moniker. "Oden was made to boil" and then becoming a non-D character to die with a smile on his face.
We are slowly lead back to current events after the Legendary Hour. In a quick rollout of events we witness the birth of Komurasaki, what happened with Denjiro, and are shown that the earlier suspicion about a traitor is all but confirmed by Kaido.

The traitor is finally revealed. Traitor talk was something of a boon to these forums for the better part of a year. When it was ultimately revealed to be Kanjuro I would have to say that the overall reception was mixed. For anyone who thought Kanjuro being the traitor was unrealistic asspull, I strongly encourage you to watch this video, dated on September of 2019 (before the reveal happened in the manga). I hope it enlightens some of you to the fact that just because you didn't notice something, doesn't mean it wasn't apparent or didn't happen. I was one of the many who did not come close to predicting it was Kanjuro, but I have to say that youtube video showed me that Kanjuro was an obvious planned traitor from the moment we met Kinemon on PH.

Just as fast as we learn about Kanjuro being the traitor we learn that Denjiro has been hiding in plain sight all these years. I'm not a fan of the explanation behind his unrecognizable appearance, but I don't really want to derail the post with it. We're also quickly met with the fact that Denjiro and Kinemon's miscommunication literally saved the alliance as Denjiro shows up with all of the missing samurai. After all the despair leading up to this point we're finally met with some happy moments. In summary:
  • Oden's past becomes an explanation of what happened to Denjiro and Hiyori
  • Kanjuro reveals he's the traitor, and a huge asshole
  • Denjiro reveals himself to be the most competent of the 9RS and a Wano MVP candidate
  • Fleet of Samurai shows up
  • Luffy shows up
  • Jinbei shows up
  • Let the fun.. begin!
Where part two is all over the place I would argue that part three is compacted into one place. We're shown the Flying Six, the Big Mom Pirates being knocked down the waterfall (again), the alliance of Perospero and Marco ending as quickly as it started, Big Mom reclaiming Zeus and causing trouble, and introduced to a crazy new fact: Kaido has a fucking son.

A son you say? I take that son and raise you daughter. A daughter you say? I take that daughter and raise you transgender man. Transgender man you say? I take that transgender man and raise you Oden. Oden you say? I take that Oden and raise you daughter. Daughter you say? I take that ... you get the picture. Yamato has been an... interesting addition to say the least. One thing I have to admit? I fucking love it. I love the ambiguity in their gender identity. I love the fact that Kaido in all of his glorious badassery and power can't even control his one fucking offspring. I love that Kaido's offspring is a fucking Bartomoleo level Luffy fan-boy/girl/oden/whateveryouwanttocallthem. I love that this offspring of Kaido is sexy by any metric of measure.

Savvy? The dude can't even be located on a small island by the three calamities and flying six.
Intelligent? Yamato is teaching Momonosuke "HOW TO FUCKING DRAGON RIGHT". Oh, and Yamato is not a dragon.
Strong? Yamato smashed up multiple TF6 members, and held off Kaido for Luffy.
Beautiful? Don't even need to go into this. Yamato is gorgeous. Anime hair is great too.
Loyal? Yamato hasn't met Momo but is willing to stake their life on him.
Good hearted? Uh. Yes. See previous point. Also see that Yamato wants to protect those citizens of Wano who he has no direct connection to.
Tragic past? He was raised by Kaido. That's tragic in and of itself. He's probably had to tolerate being around Orochi more than your average person as well.

I've had a crush on Yamato since inception. It's a package deal. We know Ace came to Wano, but to hear that Yamato and Ace formed a direct relationship and that interaction planted the seed that leads to Yamato wanting to leave Onigashima on Luffy's ship? Sign me up for this one.

Yamato is all but a confirmed nakama at this point. Some of my favorite things Yamato has done / said:







I'm not.. going to laugh at him!
Upon hearing Ace's endless tales about Luffy, Yamato's response is simply doting. Yamato is a SHP at heart. Kind, empathetic, strong, caring, and would never laugh at someone's dreams. How anyone could debate Yamato joining at this point is beyond me. He's met several criteria:
  • Wants to join
  • Believes in / admires Luffy
  • Wants to join
  • Strong as fuck
  • Wants to join
  • Feels constrained on Onigashima
  • Wants to join
  • Literally freed from subjugation (explosive cuffs) by Luffy
  • Wants to join
  • Has critical information that only Oden's log book contains that could be helpful to Joyboy
  • Wants to join
  • Was literally waiting for Luffy on Onigashima
That's enough about Yamato.

The War
This war has been something else. We've had more story fed to us in this third part of Wano than anywhere else in the story.
We learned that the Gomu Gomu fruit was stolen from a CP9 agent named Who's Who, that Kaido chose Wano specifically, that Kaido is aware of Joyboy's existence, the existence of the Lunarians, about Queen's involvement with Caesar/Judge/Vegapunk in MAD, the application of COC in combat, the Sun God Nika, all but confirm Zoro came from Wano (with his resemblance to Ryuma and Ushimaru finally commented on in cannon literature), that Kaido considers himself an Oni, that Drake is an agent from a secret operation named Sword (we'll chalk this up to being in part three, but it's really outside of the Wano arc), and many other things.

The pacing in the war is much different than the rest of the arc. It starts as a simple bum-rush to Kaido and becomes more complex as we learn about the New Onigashima plan. We're given roughly 10 chapters of the Akazaya 9 "warming up" Kaido for the next generation before ultimately being defeated / brutalized by the Oni-man. Chapter 1000 gives us a throwback to Luffy's battle with Crocodile in an epic fashion:

Since the moment shown in chapter 1000 we've seen the fall of the Tobiroppo, the fall of Perospero and Jack, as well as the conversion of forces from the Beast Pirates to the Alliance. We've witnessed Tama and Usopp coordinating their efforts to convert Gifters over to their side, witnessed the growth of the SHP in seeing Robin and Franky take out Tobiroppo members, as well as Nami's power-up with "neo-Zeus". We've seen Luffy and Kaido split the sky, and Marco tango with King and Queen in a 2v1.

At the time of writing the unresolved pieces are:
  • King vs Zoro
  • Queen vs Sanji
  • Big Mom vs Law and Kidd
  • Hawkins vs Killer
  • Fukurokujo vs Raizo
  • Luffy vs Kaido
  • Onigashima's fate
While I feel like we're over the half-way point it still feels as though we have a long way to go and I hope Oda optimizes future chapters for enjoyment as I will be immensely disappointed if we get a solid chapter of Raizo's fight against Fukurokujo, but just a sliver of panels from Perospero and Jack's fights.

Some closing thoughts I have on the current state of things:

  • I was initially annoyed at the idea of Onigashima falling on Wano and the timer aspect of it. In hindsight I think I've had a revelation and believe this is the only way that the current arc could go. If we think about it what has Momonosuke done to earn the respect of Wano and the Samurai? Nothing. He's been through the same turmoil they have. He's been through more than your average eight year old but that's just One Piece. Momo pulling Onigashima away from Wano and lowering it into the sea, saving the entirety of the Flower Capital will be a symbolic way to transition him to a worthy Shogun.
  • I believe that Kaido comes from a race that is a less-mentioned part of the void century. Notably that he knows about Joyboy, but not from Oden's log-book or Oden himself. He knows of Wano's significance and chose Wano before he ever met Oden in the flesh. I believe that the Oni race must have been a third entity to clash with the world and the Ancient Kingdom, but was able to be snuffed out due to the ancient weapons. It would be very interesting if Kaido has a deeper connection to Joyboy than that of simply being a hurdle to opening Wano's borders.
  • Yamato will join the SHP after this, and we will get a more in depth look into Oden's log-book as it relates to their journey. I'm not expecting a solid information dump after the arc, but I imagine we will get quite a bit. Look forward to it.
  • I don't think the Road Poneglyph is on Onigashima. If it were they would have likely found it. I suspect this arc is going to segway into something where Kaido has stashed the poneglyph in a hiding spot. Perhaps the island that Scotch was guarding (and Drake confronted him).
  • The fallout here could be pretty crazy. The purpose of the pirate alliance will of been served. Law could very well be an enemy after this arc, and Kidd is likely to be as well. Big Mom Pirates are also nearby, and CP0 is on Onigashima. Kaido falling and The Flower Capital saved seem like they will just be the start of a whole new set of problems.
  • Orochi should be publicly executed or humiliated in some way. I hate that he keeps coming back like some kind of cockroach, but I would much rather see him meet actual justice than dying on a battlefield. I look forward to it.
I purposely didn't mention the transitional chapters as they don't really pertain to Wano. They were great and I'm sad it's been so long since we last saw one, but the reality is that we probably aren't getting any non-Wano information until Wano is complete.

Some thoughts I'd love to hear other opinions on:

Will Kaido acknowledge Luffy's strength after their battle?
Will Big Mom escape somehow, and be defeated later?
Will Queen become an involuntary SHP and be disassembled by Franky to be researched and used to help weaponize himself and the Thousand Sunny? Imagine having Queen in it for the long hall as some kind of weird laser-beam mounted on the Sunny. Oda could really have fun with the Cyborg Dino.
What is the relation between Noah, Poseidon, Joyboy, Kaido and Wano?
If you don't think Yamato is joining, what is your reasoning?

Sorry for the super long post. Thanks for reading.
 
Last edited:

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,007
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
On a minor not, the author had already planned the Wano arc way back in Thriller Bark. That's when the first heard of Wano, Kaido and Vegapunk.
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
On a minor not, the author had already planned the Wano arc way back in Thriller Bark. That's when the first heard of Wano, Kaido and Vegapunk.
Yeah definitely. Mostly meant that we didn't really know of Wano in the context of being a Yonko base. Kinda funny how all of that was related back then - Moriah stole Ryuma from Wano after getting his ass kicked by Kaido.

I think a lot of One Piece bullet points have been planned for years. I'm writing a book now and the method I use is to create a list of things I want to happen, a clear beginning, and an ideal end, and fill in the blanks to get there.
 

Fox666

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 28, 2008
Messages
7,007
Reaction score
4,650
Country
Galactic Empire
Yeah definitely. Mostly meant that we didn't really know of Wano in the context of being a Yonko base. Kinda funny how all of that was related back then - Moriah stole Ryuma from Wano after getting his ass kicked by Kaido.

I think a lot of One Piece bullet points have been planned for years. I'm writing a book now and the method I use is to create a list of things I want to happen, a clear beginning, and an ideal end, and fill in the blanks to get there.
The author himself admits he stretched the story too much, and wasn't meant to have so many things planned ahead.

For example, imagine if Jaya stayed the same, but Skypeia happened only in the New World. Everyone would be like "holy shit, he planned it for 500 chapters" when in reality it just took too long to finish the arc...
 

catagon87

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Jan 10, 2014
Messages
3,514
Reaction score
6,055
Age
39
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The author himself admits he stretched the story too much, and wasn't meant to have so many things planned ahead.

For example, imagine if Jaya stayed the same, but Skypeia happened only in the New World. Everyone would be like "holy shit, he planned it for 500 chapters" when in reality it just took too long to finish the arc...
Yeah, when you become the top selling manga I suppose it's in your best interest to milk it a bit and have fun with it. Part of why I mentioned the scale of OP growing so much. It's just insane atm. I don't think we're off-paneling fights because Oda is cruel. I think we're off-paneling fights because he has too many things going on at any given time lately. Though I maintain if we get a full chapter of Raizo vs Fukurokujo I will lose my fucking shit.

Also one thing I'd add is that even if something isn't planned 500 chapters in advance, it's a skill set to be able to use things you wrote 500 chapters ago in a relevant way. For instance, I'm not sure if Oda planned on Caribou to have such a long run at it, but it's been entertaining and I can't complain.

I imagine OP's "bullet points were something like:
  • Introduce main character
  • Build core crew
  • Go to grand line (first half) to build the world a bit more (CP, Shichibukai, Admirals)
  • Introduce an "ultimate villain" (Blackbeard)
  • Clear "half way point" with plot relevance - fishman island
  • Go to the New World
  • Find poneglyphs to lead to final island
  • Face off against ultimate bad guy
  • Become PK
  • Face off against the WG in some way
  • See everyone's dreams to fruition
It's just a LOT of potential blanks to fill. I mean, he said he came up with the Supernova as he was writing the chapter, and here we are. I think he has a tendency to want to reference other literary works (sometimes to his own detriment) too.
 
Top