Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2015-2016] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[WyldViolet]

WithYouInSpirit99
I can install one of my customized templates for now and I can edit the headers and colours later today :]

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 9, 2016, Original Post Date: Nov 9, 2016 ---

Ok so I can't do it on my phone but I'll make sure to do it later

No worries! Take your time!

I think this is the 4th time I've seen someone create a Weekly Shonen Jump subreddit they usually end barren in a span of a year. I don't know if you will find the type of community you are hoping for in a place like reddit but you could easily end up with a bigger community there.

There are mature and intelligent communities capable of productive and civil discussion on Reddit. You just have to find communities tailored to it.
I feel like I'd contribute enough to the sub to keep other people contributing enough to the point that we'll at least have a small but dedicated community that will stem initially from the users in this thread who are crossed over with Reddit. But who knows, it could grow a lot larger just from Reddit users happening upon it.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 9, 2016 ---

It would make a change from having to go to r/manga. I'm not very eager to keep discussing WSJ or the industry in general over there.

Same, it's why I felt a need for this subreddit.
I love discussing thing on Reddit. I love discussing manga.
I want to be able to discuss manga on Reddit without ripping my hair out.

 

[Tamil]

Sales oricon
1,631,659 1,631,659 One Piece 83
*248,139 *248,139 Bleach
*203,825 *203,825 Hero
*162,169 *162,169 Shokugeki
*110,705 *110,705 Gintama
**26,879 *754,399 Hakyuu
**21,453 **21,453 Gintama DVD bundle
**21,210 **21,210 Hinomaru
**15,832 **15832 Karada Sagashi
**15,020 2,508,929 One Piece 82
**14781 **14781 Kochikame Scroll

Wow why is Gintama that low?!

Good for Bleach.

 

[Spirit]

Wow why is Gintama that low?!

Good for Bleach.

Mustn't have lost its Lustre for the JP Fans yet

 

[Varus]

A subreddit is more ambitious and it could benefit the manga community in general more if the right people and connections were set. Anyways good luck with your plans.

 

[Spirit]

@Rica_Patin I've updated the Subreddit theme

 

[Leoat12]

This whole train of thought is flawed. Did people think whats gonna happen to Deku after becoming a hero or Soma if he ever graduate, all this in the very first 14 chapters ? The manga is called The Promised Neverland which could easily be interpolated as the place they call home, its their journey toward finding that Promised Neverland. You just seem like grasping on straws, because we don’t know anything about that universe and saying you see no future when in reality we know nothing about it to begin with is a bit ignorant.

It is not flawed at all and completely different from the examples you gave. These are the final outcomes of the series you mentioned, leave the orphanage is not the final outcome of the The Promised Neverland at all, or at least I hope it is not. With this kind of final outcome in mind, the series will last an year at most, there is no way to stretch this arc any longer than that, I'm already bored right now and probably people with patience than me you also be bored by the end of the 30th chapter or so. They will get out of that place very soon, there is no way to stretch it any longer and what I meant is that with the series state right now, there is no chance of survival, the plot leads to this conclusion, unless they get superpowers in the next chapters. XD
I think you saw that monsters, right? Even their "mother" are just playing with them.
You cannot predict what will happen in the far future, but the series has to give you clues of what will happen in the next chapter at least, to make it plausible when you get there.

 

[Jaja]

"""You cannot predict what will happen in the far future, but the series has to give you clues of what will happen in the next chapter at least, to make it plausible when you get there."""

That's why I think the manga is amazing!


"""" I'm already bored right now and probably people with patience than me you also be bored by the end of the 30th chapter or so. """"

Say for yourself. I'm not even a little bored.

 

[Heiji]

 

[Jaja]

Whoa, a seinen magazine?

 

[Spirit]

"""You cannot predict what will happen in the far future, but the series has to give you clues of what will happen in the next chapter at least, to make it plausible when you get there."""

That's why I think the manga is amazing!


"""" I'm already bored right now and probably people with patience than me you also be bored by the end of the 30th chapter or so. """"

Say for yourself. I'm not even a little bored.

Yeah I think that YnN is fantastic! I like how many of the battles seem to be be based on cunning and wits, but I can see some sort of timeskip after an arc or two. They can't stay kids forever right?

 

[jagman1x3]

So if he's in Manga Goraku now, guess he's gonna try and make his next series longer than Minami no Teiou? Guess he's got the next few decades planned out.

 

[Leoat12]

"""You cannot predict what will happen in the far future, but the series has to give you clues of what will happen in the next chapter at least, to make it plausible when you get there."""

That's why I think the manga is amazing!


"""" I'm already bored right now and probably people with patience than me you also be bored by the end of the 30th chapter or so. """"

Say for yourself. I'm not even a little bored.

What? Did you understand what I said?

The TOC will tell who is right or wrong in this. I end here.

--- Double Post Merged, Nov 10, 2016, Original Post Date: Nov 10, 2016 ---

So if he's in Manga Goraku now, guess he's gonna try and make his next series longer than Minami no Teiou? Guess he's got the next few decades planned out.

People will claim that he is a vampire in no time. XD
But now I'm surprised, another series? What an active old geezer. XD

 

[Scruffy8642]

Geez, this dude must be insanely efficient at drawing. Going 40 years without a single week off is one thing, but starting a new series at his age!! Hes making writing manga look like childs play!

I wonder how long it actually takes him per chapter? It cant be nearly as long as what other artists have stated (~50hours) or he would have missed some weeks...

 

[G_I_A]

Galaxy gangs mangaka is starting a New serialization on jump next week.

 

[CuriousReborn]

It is not flawed at all and completely different from the examples you gave. These are the final outcomes of the series you mentioned, leave the orphanage is not the final outcome of the The Promised Neverland at all, or at least I hope it is not. With this kind of final outcome in mind, the series will last an year at most, there is no way to stretch this arc any longer than that, I'm already bored right now and probably people with patience than me you also be bored by the end of the 30th chapter or so. They will get out of that place very soon, there is no way to stretch it any longer and what I meant is that with the series state right now, there is no chance of survival, the plot leads to this conclusion, unless they get superpowers in the next chapters. XD
I think you saw that monsters, right? Even their "mother" are just playing with them.
You cannot predict what will happen in the far future, but the series has to give you clues of what will happen in the next chapter at least, to make it plausible when you get there.

" I dont like this manga, that means it has no future " is what you sound like at the moment. Please come out with actual arguments other than im bored therefore its bad. Im surprised you like Nisekoi even though you ran out of patience for Neverland, meanwhile Nisekoi was the most drawn out manga in recent years. Also have you not read what I said ? The manga is about finding that save haven, we already have know what they are looking for ( A place to call home) and the manga it self states multiple times how they have no knowledge of the outside world, yet they what to find out whats out there. If they tell us what behind the walls, that legitimately takes most of the suspense out of the manga.

 

[Heiji]

Sorry mistake.

 

[Ihore]

 

[vampire killer]

Demon's Plan still look like romantic comedy to me.

 

[Ihore]

Bleach volume 74 has a Second edition coming already.

12/31
REBORN! elDLIVE character's 365 740

 

[xAsum0x]

It just looks like a generic battle shonen