Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2018] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Tanzo]

Oh, they changed the design for the preview. It's much better now.

The next issue preview? No, that's just the style of Kimetsu's advert area thing in Jump.

What's the last color page?

Already listed all the color pages for next issue. The rest at the bottom are just there for advertisment, if that's what you're wondering.

--- Double Post Merged, May 25, 2018, Original Post Date: May 25, 2018 ---

A girl from Ziga is getting quite a bit of attention online
Search ジガ on twitter

 

[cody]

That's what concerns me with Kimetsu, they will have to clean it up for animation and the manga will lose its unique style as a result.


With the exception of stuff that needed redesigns for animation like Jojo and HxH its very very very rare for them to fuck them up since they're just rough drafts.

I'm really curious to see how they'll handle Kimetsu as an anime, assuming it won't be totally half-assed....

 

[ChocoBar9]

Too bad it's going to be cancelled soon.

 

[cody]

Too bad it's going to be cancelled soon.

Not if Jump+ can save it xD. Lycopene, anyone?

 

[Reigen]

There was nothing wrong with those character designs.

For you, they were nowhere good as the manga.

 

[Tamil]

4 month TS apparently.

 

[Chuck_Atlas]

isn't it basically a given the movie only chick will fall for Deku, remember how in every Naruto movie by the end the chick wanted him:

Spoiler

Spoiler

The last one died tho

 

[ChocoBar9]

For you, they were nowhere good as the manga.

Character designs are never going to be as good as the manga because detail has to be sacrificed for animation but there was nothing wrong with the designs in terms of faithfully capturing the style of the manga. They even gave each character a distinguished jawline that made them unique. There was nothing wrong with them at all.

 

[TyVip]

Why are they look younger???

 

[savethecat]

Tbh I think Jump+ should be utilized more for cancelled manga, or manga that have a fanbase in Jump, but see no growth in popularity for a significant amount of time. Or a decline in growth.
Not saying they should have a long life in Jump+.
Like say the Ziga team have some ideas they still want to try. Maybe send it to Jump+ and give it a trial run there as well, and if that doesn’t work out allow them to end it at their own pace, so they can get another chance in WSJ when they’re ready.
Or say Soma, which is on a decline. Instead of axing it, or letting it take up space in WSJ, move it to Jump+.

I know ppl say Jump+ is dead, but I feel like that’s largely due to Shueisha not utilizing it in the best way possible

 

[TyVip]

Tbh I think Jump+ should be utilized more for cancelled manga, or manga that have a fanbase in Jump, but see no growth in popularity for a significant amount of time. Or a decline in growth.
Not saying they should have a long life in Jump+.
Like say the Ziga team have some ideas they still want to try. Maybe send it to Jump+ and give it a trial run there as well, and if that doesn’t work out allow them to end it at their own pace, so they can get another chance in WSJ when they’re ready.
Or say Soma, which is on a decline. Instead of axing it, or letting it take up space in WSJ, move it to Jump+.

I know ppl say Jump+ is dead, but I feel like that’s largely due to Shueisha not utilizing it in the best way possible

that is a terrible idea
if a manga failed to find an audience in Jump, who would read it if it moves to Jump+?

 

[ChocoBar9]

Why are they look younger???

Do they?

 

[Reigen]

Character designs are never going to be as good as the manga because detail has to be sacrificed for animation but there was nothing wrong with the designs in terms of faithfully capturing the style of the manga. They even gave each character a distinguished jawline that made them unique. There was nothing wrong with them at all.

They didn't capture the manga's style at all and it had nothing to do with sacrificing details, if anything it was faithful to Haikyuu's anime style lol.
Anyway this is not the right place to discuss this so i'm just gonna leave these examples here

Spoiler

 

[shoyoboyo]

>character designs are slightly more angular
>"wow they didn't even capture the style at all"

 

[ChocoBar9]

They didn't capture the manga's style at all and it had nothing to do with sacrificing details, if anything it was faithful to Haikyuu's anime style lol.
Anyway this is not the right place to discuss this so i'm just gonna leave these examples here

Spoiler

Nothing you posted were detrimental to the mangas style at all. Not sure how you can praise Neverlands anime designs (which do look less stylized in comparison) but be anal about this? Also if they look similar to HQ is because they share the same character designer.

 

[TyVip]

Do they?

probably because of Souma eyes, compare to the 1 month timeskip

Spoiler

 

[ChocoBar9]

>character designs are slightly more angular
>"wow they didn't even capture the style at all"

Its even worse when he's comparing it to the first volume when the anime is clearly adaptating from the current artstyle.

--- Double Post Merged, May 25, 2018, Original Post Date: May 25, 2018 ---

probably because of Souma eyes, compare to the 1 month timeskip

Spoiler

I forgot how much of a deformed baby Souma looked in the beginning his post training look was a definite improvement even if he became more bishie. Erina just grew out her hair.

 

[savethecat]

that is a terrible idea
if a manga failed to find an audience in Jump, who would read it if it moves to Jump+?

If say Toriko, and Bleach was moved to Jump+ I 100% believe people would still read them

 

[iceemperor]

4 month TS apparently.

I'm worried they're going to run the whole thing into the ground at this rate. The spoilers seem like they're holding onto some sense but at the same time, they're just running full speed ahead.

 

[Reigen]

Nothing you posted were detrimental to the mangas style at all. Not sure how you can praise Neverlands anime designs (which do look less stylized in comparison) but be anal about this? Also if they look similar to HQ is because they share the same character designer.

Not my problem if you're blind.