Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[animeexpert]

- and of course the floppy five hiding in the back corners

Lmao I spat my drink out

 

[RafGL]

Peeps so the new groups cover is coming soon as mc's dressed as pirate, so HYPED.

who you guys think will be

1. On the front

2. On the middle

3. On the back

-One Piece, My Hero Academia & Haikyu.
-The Promised Neverland, Kimetsu no Yaiba & Black Clover.
-Dr. Stone, Jujutsu Kaisen & Act-Age.
-Yuuna, Samurai 8, We Never Learn & Chainsawman.
-Lastly, Saiyuuki, Yui Kamio, Double Taisei, Beast Children & Tokyo Shinobi Squad.

S8 positioning may vary, but Im pretty sure the whole cover would or should look like that.
And actually, TPN's positioning is also hard to determine since it's usually shown as something between that Big 3 in Jump right now and the other 3 Promising Ones (KnY, BC, and Dr. Stone also appears around there). Anyway, thinking about how the last cover was done, I'd bet for that.

 

[BaNChiGay]

Peeps so the new groups cover is coming soon as mc's dressed as pirate, so HYPED.

who you guys think will be

1. On the front

2. On the middle

3. On the back

According to ToC my guess is
OP
Dr Strone,TpN,Black Clover and KnY
HQ,MHA,JJK,CM and AA
everything else

 

[Tamil]

Part 5's finale is incredible, its the best adaptation from WSJ I've seen.

Kimetsu's BD/DVD are coming out at the end of the month. Any sales prediction? KnB has the highest BD/DVD sales for a jump adaptation which is like 25k sales. You think it'll surpass that? Ufo shows sell well iirc, maybe not as high as 25k but the anime is popular.

 

[Aeneas]

Good (and funny) chapter of Taisei.

LIVE, DAMN YOU.

 

[Mankichi Togawa]

Out the 5 ''newbie corpses'', Futari no Taisei has been the best this week for me.

 

[Stivie]

Did anyone notice that in kamio yui, kiito started to become more protagonist?

 

[Thores]

Out the 5 ''newbie corpses'', Futari no Taisei has been the best this week for me.

It certainly adds some interesting wrinkles this chapter. I have mixed feelings about that... Double Taisei is probably the Reiwa debut that I least want to see get a second wind. But it left a better impression than Beast Children this week, at the very least.

 

[Jovan]

And I dropped Tokyo Shinobi Squad now. At least Samurai 8 is finally getting somewhere.

 

[Thores]

My current plan is to commit to all of the Reiwa debuts until at least one of them gets cancelled. Like, I've gotten this far. If their conclusion is inevitable, I may as well see it through.

After I see which ones go, I'll decide whether it's worth it to stick with the ones that stay.

 

[Mr.Fujimaster]

Samurai 8, Beast Children and Double Taisei had great chapters this week.
Hope that Beast Children or Double Taisei survive.
About TSS, I dropped it in the last chapter.

 

[Jovan]

My friend (who still reads) Saiyuki just told me it is doing a rushed backstory infodump like Ne0lation and Higuma did? I think this one had huge potential, what a shame. Probably the most painful drop I had of Jump newbies since Noah's Notes.

 

[Stivie]

DT has a chance of surviving everything will depend on the coming weeks.
Beast children think it's going to flop bigger than Neolation, which is a shame.
TSS may survive as he will have a bangaihen just like yui kamio.

 

[OniluapL]

Saiyuki is infodumping right now, yeah, which is a shame, because it was a... really good infodump? It had plot revelations that would be amazing if they happened later in the series. It's also pretty good emotionally.

I... really disliked this week's Taisei? I don't know what you guys saw in it.

 

[RafGL]

My friend (who still reads) Saiyuki just told me it is doing a rushed backstory infodump like Ne0lation and Higuma did? I think this one had huge potential, what a shame. Probably the most painful drop I had of Jump newbies since Noah's Notes.

Yeah, it's just shouting 'Fuck I'm ending soon, here's the WHOLE STORY IN BASICALLY 10 PAGES'. Every other newbie is just doing whatever. I'm just hoping for them to end soon, it's sad to read such series and see how bad they're getting and how they're losing chances to survive.

 

[Jovan]

Saiyuki is infodumping right now, yeah, which is a shame, because it was a... really good infodump? It had plot revelations that would be amazing if they happened later in the series. It's also pretty good emotionally.

I... really disliked this week's Taisei? I don't know what you guys saw in it.

I am going to guess because it shifted focus in the chapter to comedy (judging by the comments here and on reddit). Sadly, I have dropped this a really while ago (after the disastrous certain twist that made not care about this one).

Yeah, it's just shouting 'Fuck I'm ending soon, here's the WHOLE STORY IN BASICALLY 10 PAGES'. Every other newbie is just doing whatever. I'm just hoping for them to end soon, it's sad to read such series and see how bad they're getting and how they're losing chances to survive.

Thanks to both Onilu and you for the confirmation. Not surprised, but still sad.

 

[Aeneas]

I... really disliked this week's Taisei? I don't know what you guys saw in it.

Comedy + more characters (finally).

 

[Stivie]

Yeah, it's just shouting 'Fuck I'm ending soon, here's the WHOLE STORY IN BASICALLY 10 PAGES'. Every other newbie is just doing whatever. I'm just hoping for them to end soon, it's sad to read such series and see how bad they're getting and how they're losing chances to survive.

but there is not much to do now that he has received the cancellation order, he has to close the loose ends, no way.

 

[RafGL]

but there is not much to do now that he has received the cancellation order, he has to close the loose ends, no way.

Im not saying its a bad decision, actually, I do prefer a rushed but closed ending rather than some random open ending after starting a new arc like what ne0 did.

 

[redon]

Or this one if you prefer Shonen Jump covers.