Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump [2019] - Discussion and TOC Talk

[Chuck_Atlas]

Would of liked if Kurogane was also added, whatever we think of Ikezawa, that was a solid short series

 

[Halloween]

Would of liked if Kurogane was also added, whatever we think of Izekawa, that was a solid short series

I'm trying to keep the poll within six options, otherwise it ends up getting a bit too large and distracting.

I do understand, though. That's why the other option is available.

 

[MangAniMY]

if i can choose multiple i would choose sesuji wo pin as well , but Mx0 takes priority

 

[Jovan]

Sesuji wo Pin! to: Shikakou Kyougi Dance-bu e Youkoso is absolutely and by far my top choice for the poll, and the one that would have translated so well on anime. Such a pity.

I would be OK with Psyren anime, but I had a lot of issues with the manga and the anime would adapt the more boring part for me.
Yes. I am in the minority that liked the Tenju's Root arc soft reboot the manga did when they kicked out a lot of uninteresting side characters out of any focus and replaced them with more spotlight on Elmore Wood orphans.

 

[Leoat12]

Sorry for being anti-climatic, but it is useless daydreaming about something that will never happen, only remembering Magico cancellation makes me depressed, so I am not going to vote on this one.

 

[OtterBrigade]

Sorry for being anti-climatic, but it is useless daydreaming about something that will never happen, only remembering Magico cancellation makes me depressed, so I am not going to vote on this one.

it's also useless commenting on a forum yet here we all are

 

[vinceled]

I voted for Psyren because I feel like this was the most “complete” series in comparison to Magico and Enigma. While the latter were series I love and found really good I think that an anime in the state of how they ended would be pretty disappointing for the final arc. Magico introduced a rival to Shion after chapter 50 and then sunk in the ranking while Enigma was like TPN for it’s first 40 chapters but the author failed to find a good way to continue after the end of the first arc.

 

[Leoat12]

it's also useless commenting on a forum yet here we all are

Exchange of ideas is not useless no matter the subject. Japanese authors may not read what we are saying here specifically, but I'm sure they read comments about their series elsewhere. Everything is data today, here we have valuable information about how many people feel about many series. Aspirants authors can see something useful here, aspirant editors as well. Editors became editors discussing mangas, not silencing about them.
So I wouldn't underestimate the conversations we have here. Maybe people are not that serious about this than I am, but...

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Sorry for being anti-climatic, but it is useless daydreaming about something that will never happen...

Like Muhyo to Roji getting not only a anime 10 years after it ended but a second season too? you can argue with series like Magico or Enigma, but it's not really impossible for series like Psyren or Mx0 to get a anime, specially today with so many old series being revived out of the blue.

 

[MangAniMY]

what ushio & tora, karakuri circus thought us

a fan can grow up becoming a producer and make an anime of their favourite manga.

which might be the case for muhyo to roji, but that I can't be sure

 

[4Eyes]

A think a Soul Catcher(s) anime could be great, but I voted for Psyren because it seems more profitable and possible.

 

[TJQ15]

Sorry for being anti-climatic, but it is useless daydreaming about something that will never happen, only remembering Magico cancellation makes me depressed, so I am not going to vote on this one.

Hey Level E of all things got an anime adaption. And so did Buso Renkin, Hatsukoi Limited, and D•N•A^2.

 

[TyVip]

Level E is made by Togashi.

 

[SharkBait]

A think a Soul Catcher(s) anime could be great, but I voted for Psyren because it seems more profitable and possible.

Yes I want that and ST&RS as well.


Hopefully Astra Lost in Space performed so well that more space boys action manga series will be created, and adapted.

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

Level E is made by Togashi.

And it took 15 years to get a anime, you would think that being by Togashi would have more relevance :P

 

[TJQ15]

And it took 15 years to get a anime, you would think that being by Togashi would have more relevance :P

Imagine how Level E would’ve been treated if this forum existed back then.

 

[4Eyes]

Yes I want that and ST&RS as well.


Hopefully Astra Lost in Space performed so well that more space boys action manga series will be created, and adapted.

Did it? I didn't see any significant boost on manga sales, unfortunately.

Edit; It pains me how much it flopped: (Shoseki 17/09)
452 9784088808437 彼方のアストラ　１ 集英社 篠原健太 2016.7.4

 

[OtterBrigade]

Did it? I didn't see any significant boost on manga sales, unfortunately.

that's because you aren't looking on digital platforms where 98.745% of people buy manga now

 

[Shinuki no Reborn]

It's a complete adaptation of a short manga, i don't see much encouragement to go buy the manga

Imagine how Level E would’ve been treated if this forum existed back then.

Rain's thread on Twitter: Why Level E is a complete failure (in 3 chapters instead of 5 since it was a monthly manga...)

 

[Konja9]

that's because you aren't looking on digital platforms where 98.745% of people buy manga now

I guess that is sarcasm, right?