I don't know, some variety might be nice. We have literally four demon/devil fighting series running concurrently in WSJ right now, all of which are popular in their own right. Does that make the magazine any more "oversatured"(sic)? And more importantly, what does it matter if the quality is high(the exact reason those four are running concurrently)?
You act like the genre has never existed in the magazine before, and that WSJ would be forever tainted by the existence of an Isekai.Because IsEkaI is too controversial. Demon & exorcism is now more refined and was always seen as something > interesting <. Jump is simply an tradition and noway they want to *bleach* that symbol for what it did for shonen. (Lel get it bleach)
I came here to see interesting comments about hori x kubo. But suddenly an ISeKai topic here in wsj, yeh I'm out for a bit. I cant take this srsly anymore
The thing about world trigger. It's not about an mc from human earth transported or reincarnated to an mmorpg and gets an harem for whatever reason and only focus on jesus mc saving the day. As long it doesnt follow the traditional blue print of today's isekai, (aka truck-kun). Jump will allow it, otherwise it would end up like that one manga that wanted to be an isekai too but got instant axed.
Okay, but the question isn’t “Would you want a stereotypical, by-the-books Isekai in WSJ?”The thing about world trigger. It's not about an mc from human earth transported or reincarnated to an mmorpg and gets an harem for whatever reason and only focus on jesus mc saving the day. As long it doesnt follow the traditional blue print of today's isekai, (aka truck-kun). Jump will allow it, otherwise it would end up like that one manga that wanted to be an isekai too but got instant axed.
As long the manga distinct itself from the typical. it's ok. Otherwise Nooooh
That's what the oversatured market exist in the genre now, and talking about it already give me an headache.
if we get an manga that can pull something like world trigger. im fine. but thats something only a couple can pull of, and a couple in jump is an super low success.
If well done means there's no harem of kawaii girls, then I'm in. If it means it has, then nope.
It was #1 for a few days like one or two weeks ago.10/26 漫画ランキング コミック売上BEST500【鬼滅の刃17】｜漫画・マンガ・コミック 売上ランキングBEST500
漫画・コミックの売上ランキングを日々更新！ 詳細はISBNコード（13ケタの数字）でご確認願います。文庫はhttp://shoseki500.blog.shinobi.jp/に移転しましたshosekiranking.blog.fc2.com
Is this the first time KNY 17 is #1 in the daily ranking? Wow...
didnt meant to bash you, i had a discussion earlier with isekai here but got debunked ofc how unrealistic it feels having it in the magazine. if its an well-done done isekai like WT,YYH, Bleach. not the junk food ones. also it should be limited for 1 isekai in the magazine, not more. im not reading jump to read an isekai anyway, so
Holy shit, this is blowing my mind. I never realized until THIS moment, but Bleach WAS an isekai, wasn't it?
Everyone want well done series regardless of genre.
I personelly prefer Bleach than SAO but 'well done' is subjective thing for another person SAO can be more 'well done' than Bleach.
well... i mean i dont want to praise sao much but sao is The ''isekai'' even tho its not an isekai that opened the door for the new gen, made the blue print and pretty much broke the web light novel industry. where publishers it finally took them seriously in the market. sao is pretty much the ''dragonball z'' of isekai. and also a few other that only populairize it such as Problem children from another world, overlord
hint hint
Hmm, this same poll has Spirited Away as number 1, so I think the definition of isekai they use is very broad.
