Mag Talk Weekly Shonen Jump (2024) - News and Discussion!

Status
Not open for further replies.

KrenKren

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2024
Messages
1,493
Reaction score
3,901
Age
21
Country
United Kingdom
If we spend so much time on multiple girls (or guys) it will just stall and amount to nothing in the grand scheme of things.
Not trying to start an argument since obviously this is a matter of opinion, but you speak like someone who hasn't read a good harem. All that amounts to nothing, I'd say, is bad writing. Not a great author, but even a subpar one can make it so love interests and the interactions shared are meaningful and lead to an outcome equally interesting. A story can have multiple romantic threads all the while contributing meaningfully to the narrative and overall emotional journey. If anything, multiple threads can help enrich a narrative by not forcing all the themes into a single potential pairing. Allowing you to delve into the kind of relationships you couldn't with only one prospect.

I dunno. I think they can be incredibly kino in the right hands.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,102
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
Not trying to start an argument since obviously this is a matter of opinion, but you speak like someone who hasn't read a good harem. All that amounts to nothing, I'd say, is bad writing. Not a great author, but even a subpar one can make it so love interests and the interactions shared are meaningful and lead to an outcome equally interesting. A story can have multiple romantic threads all the while contributing meaningfully to the narrative and overall emotional journey. If anything, multiple threads can help enrich a narrative by not forcing all the themes into a single potential pairing. Allowing you to delve into the kind of relationships you couldn't with only one prospect.

I dunno. I think they can be incredibly kino in the right hands.
Is a good example being the Quintessential Quintuplets?
 

animeexpert

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2019
Messages
1,635
Reaction score
1,270
Age
30
Country
Norway
Are you saying that cause of seeing more of Hima exposed in this chapter?
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
Yes, couple in himaten is Basically a tone-down version. Plus i like the genuine push and pull in here, unlike most triangle romance that gives me massive brain dmg
--- Double Post Merged, ---

Not trying to start an argument since obviously this is a matter of opinion, but you speak like someone who hasn't read a good harem. All that amounts to nothing, I'd say, is bad writing. Not a great author, but even a subpar one can make it so love interests and the interactions shared are meaningful and lead to an outcome equally interesting. A story can have multiple romantic threads all the while contributing meaningfully to the narrative and overall emotional journey. If anything, multiple threads can help enrich a narrative by not forcing all the themes into a single potential pairing. Allowing you to delve into the kind of relationships you couldn't with only one prospect.

I dunno. I think they can be incredibly kino in the right hands.
Hmmm.. it will take alot of perfection to pull it off with this manga in WSJ. Who knows who knows, time will tell
 

TyVip

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Aug 30, 2015
Messages
2,721
Reaction score
2,814
Gender
Male
Country
Mariejoa
you guys remember about the end of the Kagurabachi Auction arc where there is a BIG ASS KANJI that translate to CURTAIN FALLS and the Viz Version didn't keep that kanji?

I now see why you guys are mad because Akane keep the Kanji and it is so much more impactful

Moue art is reaching Godhood status
 

Jhonathan

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2019
Messages
337
Reaction score
387
Age
25
Country
Brazil
Hima Tem? Currently it's just a triangle but I would be shocked if more girls don't get added
Doesn't have the same feel as old stuff, and o believe it will end like Blue Box a dramatic love triangle
 

Discomusic

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 20, 2020
Messages
629
Reaction score
1,711
Age
41
Country
Italy
1. Undead Unluck: Oh yeah, he is so cool! All Fuuko had to do is to let him do all the work, and he delivered. The series is no longer boring!
2. Akane-banashi: Was this an horror story or a story of people performing Rakugo? At a certain point I couldn't distinguish between the two. Amazing chapter and amazing Shiguma.
3. Mission: Yozakura Family: After Shion's debacle, the series is rising up again thanks to the often overlooked Nanao, probably never as cool as he is in this fight. He is also very mature for being the younger sibling.
4. The Elusive Samurai: Another very good chapter, the Mikado is a strong character after all. I can happily toss away my prejudices against him.
5. Astro Royale: It felt like the end of the introduction. By recognizing what happened in chapter 1 and correcting it, they recreated the good feeling from that time that was fading away little by little. Welcome back Astro Royale!
6. Ichi the Witch: It is a pretty standard first chapter as far as shonen tropes go, with the protagonist living alone, capable to pull off a miracle, the future supporting cast surprised by his feat etc. . But the setting elevates the base material a lot: first of all it's fantasy, we were craving for it so much that now feels refreshing. The hunt theme and the idea of the magic "choosing" their magician leave a lot of space for creativity in the future. So, chapter definitely promoted.
7. One Piece: Quite an eventful chapter for One Piece standards. In retrospect, for some of the things happened this week we should have seen them coming. I like the idea of them living in cloud, that can take double meaning if you think about it.
8. Sakamoto Days: Great return for a character protagonist of an iconic early splash page. Disappointed by the reveal of the medium, not the reveal itself but the fact that it hasn't been saved for when the main characters actually reach them.
9. Kagurabachi: This series has a strange characteristic: it makes me read the chapter twice for understanding it, but it is also the only one for which I am willing to do so. The author loves introducing a group of cool new characters only to have them killed off in the span of three chapters maximum.
10. Witch Watch: Nice and funny comedy chapter, that introduces Chamo to the wacky dynamics of the cast. Kan is always the funniest member of the group, unfortunately for him.
11. Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi: The very early exam arc that feels rushed as usual took an original twist with the point of view switched to a partecipant who is not the protagonist. And just when you thought it was a chapter without him, he appears without a warning: he also takes the test but he simply isn't the focus today. I found it a very brilliant idea.
12. Super Psychic Policeman Chojo: Of course there would have been a dog episode, why didn't I think of that. It was a nice episode too, I liked the parents-son dynamics that almost led to a figurative divorce.
13. Blue Box: The weird realization that Hina's lovestory has been demoted to third most relevant in the series. Remember when her importance was A tier?
14. Nue's Exorcist: In contrast to Kagurabachi, this is a series that I don't understand fully the first read but I don't bother with reading it a second time. Today, I had the TvTropes characters page reminding me who was this hostage named Hakutaku. I heard the name already, but I couldn't put the finger on it...
15. Hima-Ten!: The obvious harem route marches in. In the span of a day, the protagonist had two dates with two love interests, one official and one not, but the other one wasn't even acknowledged in this chapter. I would have liked more Himari as a simple shipper of other couples.
16. Psych House: The ending was disappointing. The final (and only) plot thread had to be resolved in this chapter and that is fine, but after that there was no effort to make the epilogue interesting, and multiple characters didn't even make an appearance. The series overall was a fine Slice of Life, probably not suited for Jump but it is also true that not every chapter was inspired.
17. Me & Roboco: Not a bad chapter (kind of average actually), but I am very disappointed because my theory that the dad makes an appearence at every hundredth chapter went down the drain right at the second opportunity.
18. Kill Blue: Simply not interested in this battle and in these cartoonish enemies of the arc. Hoping the evil class rep will be more worthy of my attention.
19. Yokai Buster Murakami: Simply not interested in this series in general, but if I really have to find a positive, the speed limit gag made me smirk a little.
 

LuckyLuke

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2021
Messages
75
Reaction score
70
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Italy
Ichi the Witch is really particular, however is the risk that it becomes just a harem and the rest becomes unimportant.
Also I hope the fighting will be interesting, as well as the powers etc...

And will he really be the only male with magic? I guess it depends on how long the series lasts.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,102
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
8. Sakamoto Days: Great return for a character protagonist of an iconic early splash page. Disappointed by the reveal of the medium, not the reveal itself but the fact that it hasn't been saved for when the main characters actually reach them.
So it lost the buildup and the surprise.
 

Teennitro

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Aug 16, 2019
Messages
611
Reaction score
879
Age
30
Country
Fire Nation
Speaking of haram's this brings back memories of the time people was jokingly calling black clover a harem
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,102
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
Speaking of haram's this brings back memories of the time people was jokingly calling black clover a harem
I truly missed that ship. But I know that was briefly mentioned on New World Review.
 

EnriqueR

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2023
Messages
158
Reaction score
170
Age
35
Country
Spain
I enjoyed the first chapter of Ichi, although I didn't really understand why only a man could defeat him. Anyways, I liked the main character personality, and if the story is half as good as the design, it will be a nice read. I also appreciated that, while hunting focused, it make sure to specify that it's only for eating or survival.

For the Akane fans, here is a video I found on reddit of the Shinigami story with English Subtitles:

 

Jhonathan

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2019
Messages
337
Reaction score
387
Age
25
Country
Brazil
I enjoyed the first chapter of Ichi, although I didn't really understand why only a man could defeat him. Anyways, I liked the main character personality, and if the story is half as good as the design, it will be a nice read. I also appreciated that, while hunting focused, it make sure to specify that it's only for eating or survival.

For the Akane fans, here is a video I found on reddit of the Shinigami story with English Subtitles:

Every Majick offers a challenge, it just happens that this one created a challenge that's impossible for Witches, something that benefits them
 

Wookitake

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2013
Messages
2,297
Reaction score
1,988
Gender
Male
Country
Brazil
I now see why you guys are mad because Akane keep the Kanji and it is so much more impactful
They couldn't. It's the art of subtraction taking form in Moue's art. The kanji being white. Perfection.
 

Dongus

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2023
Messages
1,530
Reaction score
4,985
Age
29
Country
Malaysia
I'm pretty sure I read Ichi The Witch before, but it was a very smutty eroge. That said, I'm not on the ball of expecting it to be an ero-- Sorry, a harem. I mean, the setting lends itself well to it, yes, but given the authors, I don't expect it to be a To Love-Ru type of harem with a lot of smut. Maybe something a lot more shojo-esque...?

Man. I can't put my chips down on the gamble yet. If it was made by Ken Akamatsu, I'd see the vision and I know what to expect. But when you say, written by Iruma's author, drawn by Act Age's artist, I just can't imagine it'd go that type of harem... Then again, the girl who won in Iruma was the hottest one, so maybe I should give myself to the bet cause I know I can believe in Iruma's author to have the best taste in women?

Anyway, there was one bit too much narration going on with this chapter, I'd say. I'd put it down as a negative, but fantasy settings necessitate these tangents to setup their world, it's unavoidable. Yes, there could be natural ways to introduce this exposition via dialogue, but it would be extremely forced. The things exposited are common knowledge for a witch, there is literally no reason for them to blabber about it besides the fact that the author needs the reader to know. That's why narrator has to step in and start running his mouth. Even Ichi's monologue was basically blabbering to himself, but it gives you a very keen sense of his character, his mindset and who and what he is.

Ichi's great for a lead. He's kind of like a wild animal that lives in the woods, someone who is probably the exact opposite of what the women in the witch society would be like. You can kind of get this picture of Tarzan going to Britain and getting weirded out by all their posh artistry. There's a lot of potential for a fish out of water sort of comedy they can do, and I know Iruma exceled brilliantly at telling those kinds of jokes. Ichi's handsome enough to catch female readers, but has a Luffy kind of dumb fun energy to make boys look up to him, and men want to be him. Good person to be a focal point.

It's... Red Hood but good. I think this is the best way to sum up my thoughts. If there's one thing that Red Hood lacked on the first chapter, it's a worldview and a hook. You finish the chapter and kind of get a few ideas of what to expect. A predominantly female cast, a neanderthal getting chucked into a magic society, solving trials to acquire Majik... Just from those three ideas, there's a lot to look forward to. Consider me sold.

Also art kinda makes me think of CLAMP. That witch Ichi frame was like, full Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle energy.

Hima-Ten-- UWOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAAAGGGGGGHHHHH HIMARI'S BARE ASS AND BOOB MOLE UWOOOOOOOOOGH HIMARI BEST GIRL UWOOOOOOOOOOGH FUCK OFF KANAI IT'S OVER UWOOOOOOOOOOOOOGH ALL MY STOCKS IN HIMARI UWOOOOOAAAAAAAAAGH

Centuria has been cooking for the past few chapters and really set up the current antagonist to be someone you really wanna see get put in his place. And put in his place he did, that Julian got his arm cut off and immediately used it as a bat to bludgeon the guy's face in. Absolute metal stuff. Centuria has just been spectacular from the word go.

Ultimate Exorcist Murakami is something I think I'll drop. I did say after a while, the usual talking the yokai down gag will get a bit stale, and now I'm feeling it more than ever. I did like it while it was fresh, but I can't see myself enjoying it for another twenty chapters after this. I will however say... Are we sure Kuin's a guy? He even uses the stardust filter for his selfies, that's girlier than any woman I know... At the very least, I know Kuin has zero testosterone in that femboy ass body of his. Geez. And-- Are Centaurs yokai? I thought they were European...

Phantom Buster Kiyoshi is getting into some kinda groove again. I always say I prefer it as an introvert comedy, but putting the lens off Kiyoshi for just a bit to focus on the rest of the world, only to chuck him in at the end to trivialize everything, is probably the best use of his character. Very One Punch Man, Mashle-esque. Kiyoshi is really best off as a gag manga with well-drawn action scenes. Also, that girl's dressed like Power.

Psych House... is peak.

Chojo did a marriage chapter, then followed it up with a divorce and child custody courtcase chapter. Wicked.

Astro Royale is starting to elaborate more on its power system and really leaning into those yakuza-isms with all that talk, I do like that Ken Wakui's finally elaborating more on these abilities, since it's part and parcel of what makes a shonen. Oh, and Hibaru's super punching arm having three generators... Three bullets... Scryed...

Nue's Exorcist kind of irritates me with how it just snaps right back into the school setting so quickly without really giving the events that transpired the sort of weight it deserved. Like, the village arc had a whole chapter of Gakuro being a little bitch about how he performed, it would've been right for him to introspect a little more about Nue's true nature and the world he lives in. After all, the shit that he just witnessed would NOT make anyone normal. Like in Chainsawman, when they went to hell, Aki just had a huge breakdown and decided he wanted to run away from it all. It was great piece of character writing that really sets the tone of how otherworldly and beyond humanity that his experience in hell was. In this case, the entire cast just went through the most lopsided uphill battles, witnessed Godzilla Nue fighting a Cthulhu UFO that resulted in seven nukes utterly devastating the entire schoolgrounds, then, on literally the same chapter, they go to school the next day and are like, okay! I don't mind if the characters get off on zero casualties, but man, let Cthulhu UFO lady really mess with their psyches a bit, she deserves that sort of gravitas given the nonsense she's showing off. I feel like this return to the status quo hurts the series whenever it wants to be a battle shonen.

>Hakutaku joins the cast, probably joins the harem too
>Hakutaku is that evil woman reformed trope
>Hakutaku fronts as a gym teacher


Nue's ExorcistTM is a generational manga that is a turning point for Jump, which redefines shonen manga at its core. Taking inspiration from a lost generation of Light Novels, Nue's ExorcistTM blends nostalgia with innovation, to craft a one-of-a-kind experience that has never been seen before on Jump. With charming characters that take on tropes and archetypes, but given a progressive spin that breaks the formula, featuring distinct designs from which you can recognize every character from their silhouette, the world of Nue's ExorcistTM comes alive before its very pages. Every chapter of Nue's ExorcistTM features a perfect blend of comedy, intrigue and drama, that sucks you into its world of exorcists and spirits. With a distinct artstyle that lends itself to horror elements akin to Junji Ito's works, but powerful and stark shading that pays tribute to Masami Obari's animation escapades, the story of Nue's ExorcistTM is further realized with stylish paneling, distinctive shapes and cinematic paneling. A hidden gem for this generation of manga, a cult classic in the making, once its anime airs, it will be on par with the greats such as One Piece and Naruto.
 

BelTL

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2024
Messages
1,567
Reaction score
1,498
Country
Gotei 13
It's really extremely easy to mix up Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi and Phantom Buster Murakami for some reason
 

shonenblue

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2022
Messages
202
Reaction score
262
Country
Mariejoa
Yeah, Ichi had a solid first chapter. I wouldn’t say it blew me away or anything, but it definitely was a good start and has lots of potential. As usual, the next few chapters will define what kind of direction it will take, but I’d say there’s a lot to be excited for with it. Interested to see what the response will be in JP.
 

JBC008

Registered User
MH中毒 / MH Chuudoku / MH Addicted
Joined
Apr 17, 2023
Messages
6,102
Reaction score
2,514
Age
35
Country
Avatar
It's really extremely easy to mix up Ultimate Exorcist Kiyoshi and Phantom Buster Murakami for some reason
It does. If anything, we need to ask Nakano why he made that choice to release both simultaneously. You know when you compare them, it just props up Kiyoshi more and sinks Murakami down so many rungs. At least this is a stark contrast with Mashle and Guardian of the Witch when you have both fantasy adventure battle manga and one is better in more ways than the other. Well one was more simple and easy to understand (and has a group of funny likable characters) while the other was poorly put together with bland characters.
 

pennycryman

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2023
Messages
1,213
Reaction score
3,497
Age
26
Country
United States
I enjoyed Ichi, but it's the type of thing I need to see the second and third chapters to see what comedic direction it's going for. The most likely thing to happen is a mountain boy getting chucked in a covenant, an idea which has decent comedic potential and having read Iruma, I expect Nishi to take full advantage of.

It's still pretty easily the best debut of the year, though that isn't a high bar.
 

MugiwaraPatrick

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2016
Messages
151
Reaction score
159
Age
31
Country
United States
I loved the new manga a lot. I hope it does well
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top